Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU it's nearly impossible to break into IT industry if you don't have previous experience?

61 replies

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 12:20

I'm a project manager working in engineering/manufacturing. I want to switch to IT as it's easier to commute to London where most of the IT sector jobs are offered and would appreciate flexible hybrid working hours which is very common in IT.

But since I started looking at the job boards on several websites, nearly every single job post in IT requires:

  • either experiences in software development
  • or certain particular technology/software/platform, some specific skills

I just don't see how it's possible even to be considered for a chance. Am I wrong?

I'm very capable in what I'm doing in my current industry. But even with the experience to manage technical (engineering) contents, I can't see how I could even go through the first stage screening just by key words and the lack of those particular skills.

Thinking back previous job hunting experiences, I often had similar impression. The particular "basic requirements" are very specific to meet unless you are already at that level within that environment. It seems more so in the IT.

My understanding is that maybe the talent pool in IT is vast and people constantly move around. So maybe because of this, the employers are always able to find enough right candidates who meet those criteria?

Stretching the truth can be an option to reach the interview stage. But then what? If I don't have the experience, then I don't. I feel very uncomfortable to bend the truth. But then for all those jobs out there, are all viable applicants good matches?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LoveSkaMusic · 23/02/2024 22:58

Ok, 25 years in IT here.

Here's the brief version of my advice, as I'm on my phone and it's not practical to type a massive reply!

  1. Forget Agile. Nobody ever gets the methodology right. Some companies add unnecessary nonsense, others treat it like a religion. Both are wrong.
  2. Forget Product Management. You don't have the skills or experience for that.
  3. Project Management for software development is super repetitive. You may like that, you may not. For me, endless sprint cycles are really boring.

I have an idea for you that has a lower barrier to entry. Why not look at Project Management in the cyber security industry. There are loads of MSSP's (Managed Security Service Providers), who have to implement their software and services into customer environments. This is IT-adjacent, but will allow you to flex your more traditional PM muscles.

Also, the cyber security industry is where IT was 15 years ago. It's a goldmine - you can make serious money and make a name for yourself quite quickly.

I'm happy to answer any questions you have, having made the jump to cyber last February.

ThisOpalCritic · 23/02/2024 20:30

EBearhug · 23/02/2024 02:29

I'd say roles like programmer, DBA, sysadmin, networks, storage, cyber security, application support, even desktops* are IT. Then related roles - business analysis, project management, data analysis, UX, testing... it's a very wide field these days.

  • I'm a Unix sys admin. I have to look down on Windows support. It's a key part of the role. 😉

Currently in the middle of daily unix vs windows tiffs (working on automatic server patching and backups) , it's hilarious!

@r0sep3tal I don't think people in the field consider PM's or programmers 'IT',
https://www.teamblind.com/post/IT-vs-Tech-tDrBnVhO
Many people I know would bristle at being referred to as 'IT' employees they use the word 'tech' instead. Developing software for business operations is their erm 'superior' role as opposed to the base infrastructure that allows the org to function such as networks, servers, email, etc.

To the general public however this is all 'IT'.

EBearhug · 23/02/2024 02:29

r0sep3tal · 22/02/2024 21:44

forgive my ignorance but what actually is an "IT" role? I'm a programmer but wouldn't necessarily say I work in IT.

I'd say roles like programmer, DBA, sysadmin, networks, storage, cyber security, application support, even desktops* are IT. Then related roles - business analysis, project management, data analysis, UX, testing... it's a very wide field these days.

  • I'm a Unix sys admin. I have to look down on Windows support. It's a key part of the role. 😉
Yazo · 22/02/2024 22:13

Try and apply but I think it would be deathly full, agiles is boring and endless, most IT development also both as nothing ever gets done it would seem! You could try working for university or something like that, salary may be lower but techy projects to get involved with.

r0sep3tal · 22/02/2024 21:44

forgive my ignorance but what actually is an "IT" role? I'm a programmer but wouldn't necessarily say I work in IT.

sofasofa42 · 22/02/2024 21:06

Sometimes to shift to a different industry you need to go down 10k in salary and then find a job that you know if you perform you will then go up quickly. I have done this three times. You only know your worth, you need to prove it.
Or get a decent recruiter.

Cheescake3303 · 22/02/2024 21:00

I'm an IT PM and where I work IT experience isn't needed, most IT projects are not very technical in my experience so maybe it's a case of finding the right company? Good luck!

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 20:50

Thanks again to everyone. All good advices and sharing. I took notes and will give the whole idea a proper thought tomorrow.

OP posts:
jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 20:47

@ThisOpalCritic , it's very interesting to hear all this. Thank you.

The fast pace in IT could easily result in what you said. And the market/the customers are not always sure or even have an vague clue what they really NEED. Lots of hype in the field.

It's hard to keep principle these days. Even in manufacturing/engineering. Company performance is measured monthly/quarterly/annually, but rarely enough focus on beyond 2 years. That drives a completely set of behaviours not in favour of "principles".

I learned it in the hard way to be modest with what I express and I am still trying to find the balance.

OP posts:
jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 20:36

@forgotmyname1000times Funny, that's pretty much how I got my first job working in an engineering company without any technical background. 😉

OP posts:
forgotmyname1000times · 22/02/2024 20:29

I know someone who did. At the interview they said, ‘we only called you to interview as you have no IT experience at all and we wondered why you applied’. He said, ‘because what I do have is extensive customer service experience which I bet you are lacking, and I reckon you can teach me the IT side.’
And they gave him the job.

ThisOpalCritic · 22/02/2024 20:25

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 16:11

I also agree many technical folk don't like PMs

I would like to be a different one (and I think I did manage), as I believe good PM relies on their team - their individual knowledge, intelligence and motivation.

Is it a different case for scrum masters? They are supposed to be in a more "servant" roles, at least that's how it's been portrayed.

Disclaimer: Only ask this out of curiosity, not that I want to apply for that role. 🙃

The thing is OP very often the engineers aren't your team. They're just one of many other stakeholders. Your career progression and visibility depends on delivering a particular project that aligns with the incentives of a few groups, e.g. upper management.

You won't get any kudos for taking the time to build it right the first time. You progress much quicker getting things done, on time/under budget/whatever and then moving on to the next project. Any mess created rears its head when you're long gone, and you'll never get the blame anyway . That's why technical people often speak up but get pushed aside.

It's made much worse by the lack of regulatory standards. Although such things can happen in other industries (e.g. Grenfell Tower).
Companies can get fined for data breaches, there can be an investigation etc etc but unlike, say needing a chartered engineer to sign off on something, or an actual doctor to sign off on a prescription nobody's really accountable. Despite rising awareness on the cost of IT outages, cybersecurity companies make all the right noises but still don't really think they should be paying for any sort of quality.

A good PM with a strong backbone is worth their weight in gold, but again, it's not really their fault if they're not incentivised to take the long-term view.

@Createausername1970 I sort of agree with your DH but people are switching to IT in droves thanks to the pay and flexible working. Particularly people in public facing professions teachers, nurses, social workers, etc.

I was earning double the median national salary 5 years out of university, based in the North West. I like the challenge of my job, the posturing . lack of transparency etc annoys me but I get paid well for it. Many others have to put up with so much worse, for much less. I have put my foot down on many occasions and while it's not made me the most popular at least I retain some sense of being principled.

IT is also cyclical the market is dead right now, but looks like it will pick up.

BadgersArses · 22/02/2024 17:04

You can switch to a different sector but it takes time and as PP have said some steps down/sideways. I've been in PM for 30 years. Mostly IT. I wouldn't expect to get an interview for an engineering role or in drug development. I didn't have any IT qualifications when I started but I was young enough to get away with it.

If you are still keen after all the scary posts above, I'd see if you can wheedle your way into running a tech project in your current role. (Could be implementing a new tool for the firm, for example.)

I'd definitely also consider some IT but qualifications to get a sense of how IT systems work. Consider TOGAF, maybe? It's for technical architects but will give an overview of how things work.

I'd steer clear of scrum master roles initially - if you don't have any IT experience the team will run rings round you. And agile done badly is dreadful. Incredibly stressful and inefficient. Maybe look for roles that are implementing systems built by others - change managers for example. Or infrastructure IT project management - it is more similar to engineering work. E.g. Putting the IT into new building fit out.

IT work can be rewarding, interesting and well paid. And it can have all the problems listed above. I love it. And I'm definitely NOT Jen from the IT crowd.

Isanyonereallyanonymous · 22/02/2024 16:46

Scrum master / delivery lead or manager would be other options if you want to cast the net further. More about using agile principles to deliver on time and involved in the day to day delivery a little more than a traditional PM I would say.
I’m a BA in tech, we do get non-techy IT PM’s. Actually they don’t necessarily need to be techy, if they can handle difficult stakeholders (including grumpy devs who are unhappy they have a non-techy PM 😂 ) and are organised and can front business cases, manage comms etc they’re all good AS long as they have enough interest to gain enough knowledge to get them by.
It helps to know the tech speak so you better understand impact to timescales, asks of stakeholders etc.
Delivery will (I imagine) be very different to engineering/mechanical project delivery!
If you are a project manager I’d be inclined to disagree with the PP who suggested PMO (think it will be too much of a step down unless you are happy to do that as a stepping stone) and product management (you need to know and, ideally, care about your product which in IT means IT knowledge/experience) Edit - actually on reflection, not necessarily. Eg we have product manager for our events system. Based on a tech product but with a business focus/roadmap. Tech knowledge helpful though in defining/achieving that roadmap but probably not as essential as I initially worded.
Transformation manager might be a better fit for you - tends to be more strategic work and based around business change. An ability to pick up tech stuff would be helpful though as you may need to understand the tech landscape and change impact (and seemingly possible for you to do if you can pick up engineering)
Honestly, there’s a lot of opportunities but I’d say if your heart isn’t in it like it sounds, I’m not sure I’d be fighting to find a job here. Suppose it depends what you want out of your job though, we’re all different.

IWFH · 22/02/2024 16:33

I work alongside a technical delivery lead but I'm "the face" of the IT team to the business.

Are you Jen from The IT Crowd? 🤣

norfy · 22/02/2024 16:27

ancienticecream · 22/02/2024 15:04

What about a product manager? You'll still be within IT and working with software engineers. IT experience is a bonus, not an essential.

Requirements aren't always requirements, don't let it put you off. Why not approach a recruiter for a company and have a chat?

Yes this too

norfy · 22/02/2024 16:26

Consider a delivery lead role. Your PM background would really help. I work in an in-house IT team in professional services. My background is compliance, project management and other things years before but never IT.

I work alongside a technical delivery lead but I'm "the face" of the IT team to the business.

EBearhug · 22/02/2024 16:23

arejcenencehche3uh9f3 · 22/02/2024 15:31

I do agree with @ThisOpalCritic that if you're in IT, particularly if you're a woman in a technical role, you do need a thick skin. You have to put up with a LOT of shit, which is one of the reasons I'm not doing it any more. Not everywhere is awful by any means though.

I also agree many technical folk don't like PMs.

Oh, this... so much this!

Not everyone in IT is blessed with excellent with excellent interpersonal skills. This doesn't matter for men, but guess who was the only one in the department who got sent to HR about it, despite not being as charmless as most colleagues? And how many women were in the department?

However, PM probably isn't as bad as really techy departments.

But I have seen a number of IT job specs go out, and thought, if the person with that skills mix actually exists, we probably can't afford them. And when I showed a couple of friends in IT in other companies, they also thought it was a bit of a tall order. Person who was recruited was good, but didn't have all the apparently essential requirements.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 16:11

I also agree many technical folk don't like PMs

I would like to be a different one (and I think I did manage), as I believe good PM relies on their team - their individual knowledge, intelligence and motivation.

Is it a different case for scrum masters? They are supposed to be in a more "servant" roles, at least that's how it's been portrayed.

Disclaimer: Only ask this out of curiosity, not that I want to apply for that role. 🙃

OP posts:
IWFH · 22/02/2024 16:09

I don't agree with most of the generalisations about IT staff above however. Like any working environment you get good and bad people.

IWFH · 22/02/2024 16:06

I've worked as an IT PM for years. I'm currently recruiting for contract PMs and while I'm not looking for specific technical skills, I am looking for people who have delivered similar IT projects (end to end delivery from proposal/business case all the way through design, delivery, testing, acceptance into service, and deployment). I'm sorry OP but I wouldn't consider a PM without similar IT experience.

In the same way, I wouldn't trust myself to project manage (for example) building my own house.

jobsearching2024 · 22/02/2024 16:06

@Createausername1970

He active tells people to avoid a job in IT if you have any sense of integrity as it will grind you down.

unfortunately, it's a bit everywhere. The amount of jaw dropping events in the companies I worked are shocking - They were all portrayed as "advancements" for the business at the time. All about money and self importance, very little pride in the true result, don't even mention about integrity.

We are in a materialised world. Some are just very material driven than others who are more principles driven.

OP posts:
Createausername1970 · 22/02/2024 15:41

My DH works in IT and has done for about 30 years. He would say most of the IT people he encounters dont know their arse from their elbow, have a small amount of knowledge about one aspect and think they know everything.

He specifically doesn't like contractors and/or project managers who waft in, make recommendations without understanding how this will impact all areas of operation, then waft off to the next job and leave the in-house IT staff to sort out the resultant chaos.

He active tells people to avoid a job in IT if you have any sense of integrity as it will grind you down.

arejcenencehche3uh9f3 · 22/02/2024 15:31

I do agree with @ThisOpalCritic that if you're in IT, particularly if you're a woman in a technical role, you do need a thick skin. You have to put up with a LOT of shit, which is one of the reasons I'm not doing it any more. Not everywhere is awful by any means though.

I also agree many technical folk don't like PMs.

GanninHyem · 22/02/2024 15:12

Well if all the people working in IT are are rude and obnoxious as our little friend here I can see why one needs a "thick skin". It's a wonder people like that even get a job tbh, people skills seriously lacking.