Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Job Share response to hol request

409 replies

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:01

I'm fairly new to my jobshare with another lady (I've been there 1 year). She's older, single and no DC.
She loves her cruises and goes on around 3 a year, I cover the days she is absent.

As yet, she hasn't booked any days off this year, but as I have a husband, grandchild, elderly Mum etc, occasionally I book things in advance as have a busy life outside of work.

The other day I asked my jobshare if she could please cover 2 days for me in September as I would like to book annual leave.

She went all red in the face and said 'I just don't know if I'll be available, I don't know when I'm going on my cruises yet'. I could tell she was very annoyed at me asking! She asked if I needed to actually book something such as travel or accommodation etc? I don't personally think its any of her business what I plan to do on annual leave and I think 7 months notice is pretty decent. In the end, in a huff, she just said 'well, you may as well go ahead and book then and I'll let you know closer to'.

My DH needs to book his annual leave to coincide - and we were hoping to visit friends in London who would also book annual leave, but obviously if she changes her mind closer to it will mess everything up 😬

I guess she's pretty much saying 'I'll cover if I don't book a cruise' in effect saying her holiday plans trump mine (unless I'm getting it wrong)

I put my holiday form in to HR, but how would you address this going forward?

I'm not just going to sit back each year, wait for her to book the days she wants, then have the crumbs that are left.

Anyone else jobshare and how do you navigate?

OP posts:
ZiriForGood · 24/02/2024 10:54

I totally understand why she is annoyed.
Not everyone wants to plan holidays 7 months in advance and be bounded by co-workers odd 2 days blocking a range of two weeks options.
I suppose she took the job share position to get more flexibility and now is getting less.

I understand that you want to plan your holidays in advance and there is nothing wrong with that either. However, your "she could plan her cruises around" sounds very unpleasant.

The issue here is your job share setup, which holds your two preferences against each other. If the agreement would allow 1 week a year with both of you away, it wouldn't be an issue.

Crayfishforyou · 24/02/2024 10:52

‘ 'I just don't know if I'll be available, I don't know when I'm going on my cruises yet'. ‘

  • *Your response: OK, well avoid those dates because I’m sending my holiday days to HR. Let me know when you do decide on holiday days and I shall cover for you. I’ve had this sort of issue with a colleague before, she was a budding actor and toom days off for auditions. She got very shirty when I booked time off as she acted as though I was potentially taking her big break away from her. The only way to deal is to be direct, calm and clear.
Lassiata · 24/02/2024 10:49

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/02/2024 20:33

Had OP's post not been dripping with contempt for this older, childless woman with no life outside cruises - in contrast with OP and her fecund vibrant busy life - I would have said YANBU...

You're really reaching there and sound insecure. Makes me wonder if you've ever encountered real contempt if you think OP's post is "dripping with it." "Fecund and vibrant..." Come on. Resilience is a useful life skill.

Lassiata · 24/02/2024 10:45

SausageRollsWithMustard · 22/02/2024 12:15

Her being single with no children is completely irrelevant.

It's not only parents who deserve holidays.

They're not less entitled to them than someone who loves cruises though.

Havinganamechange · 24/02/2024 10:31

I think you need to formally confirm the expectations with your line manager, if you are on leave then is the expectation that she doesn’t book the same week/covers the extra days. Given you have now booked the week, she can’t now decide she wants it and it’s unreasonable to have to wait around until someone finally decides when they are taking their cruise. You are being a bit judgy judgy about the fact she is single, doesn’t have DC etc. that’s irrelevant and she has the right to ask for school holidays or she we she wants. However she is rude to grill you for details, all you need to know is can I have that week or is she taking it. If the rules are clear then it’s first come first served surely.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 24/02/2024 10:26

You wanting to book days well in advance is not unreasonable, your colleague wanting to wait until nearer the time before agreeing to overtime is not unreasonable. What is unreasonable is the system of booking holidays that means you can only book days off if one of your colleagues agrees to cover your shifts.
Where I work only one person from the department can be off at any one time. We can book holiday up until 12 months ahead on a first come first serve basis. The manager sorts our work rota out 4 weeks ahead, if he can see someone is on holiday he will ask other colleagues if they can come in and work those days at that point, if no-one agrees we work on short staff numbers which can be a struggle so sometimes the manager will help out too.
I think you need to highlight this problem with your line manager or HR department. If they refuse to alter the system I would start considering looking for a change of job.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 10:07

Don't think that was the point. She had only herself to consider. She doesn't have children or a husband to work around.

It doesn't matter. Maybe she has elderly parents to consider, or friends she wants to co-ordinate leave with, or animals she needs to find care for.

Babydaddy1978 · 24/02/2024 10:06

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:01

I'm fairly new to my jobshare with another lady (I've been there 1 year). She's older, single and no DC.
She loves her cruises and goes on around 3 a year, I cover the days she is absent.

As yet, she hasn't booked any days off this year, but as I have a husband, grandchild, elderly Mum etc, occasionally I book things in advance as have a busy life outside of work.

The other day I asked my jobshare if she could please cover 2 days for me in September as I would like to book annual leave.

She went all red in the face and said 'I just don't know if I'll be available, I don't know when I'm going on my cruises yet'. I could tell she was very annoyed at me asking! She asked if I needed to actually book something such as travel or accommodation etc? I don't personally think its any of her business what I plan to do on annual leave and I think 7 months notice is pretty decent. In the end, in a huff, she just said 'well, you may as well go ahead and book then and I'll let you know closer to'.

My DH needs to book his annual leave to coincide - and we were hoping to visit friends in London who would also book annual leave, but obviously if she changes her mind closer to it will mess everything up 😬

I guess she's pretty much saying 'I'll cover if I don't book a cruise' in effect saying her holiday plans trump mine (unless I'm getting it wrong)

I put my holiday form in to HR, but how would you address this going forward?

I'm not just going to sit back each year, wait for her to book the days she wants, then have the crumbs that are left.

Anyone else jobshare and how do you navigate?

Very simple. You book the leave before she does.

qualitychat · 24/02/2024 09:59

SausageRollsWithMustard · 22/02/2024 12:15

Her being single with no children is completely irrelevant.

It's not only parents who deserve holidays.

Don't think that was the point. She had only herself to consider. She doesn't have children or a husband to work around.

MrsB74 · 24/02/2024 09:59

Picklestop · 22/02/2024 12:21

And there you go again! Because she lives alone she can’t have as much going on as you! Listen to yourself.

It’s a fact of life that some people’s commitments are more complicated/fixed than others. That’s just life. The OP knows her better than you.

I can currently book leave any time I like: it‘a one of the reasons I’m reluctant to change jobs. I hate having to coordinate leave with other people.It’s especially hard when you have to factor in school holidays, partner’s leave, other family member’s leave etc.

All you can do OP is discuss with this lady what dates you’d like and then request them. If she hasn’t booked yet, I’d get in there before she does as her reaction makes me think she’s considering going away at the same time. There has to be some give and take and you are giving her plenty of notice.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 09:57

I don't think it's illegal - it's effectively compulsory overtime which is allowed

It is allowed, but if you're part-time then extra overtime has to be reflected in your annual leave allowance.

If Jane only contracted three days a week (or whatever) then her annual leave will be reduced to reflect that.

If she then works all her annual leave back because she has to cover all of Sue's holidays, that's illegal because she'll effectively be losing her paid time off.

If Jane is expected to work 5.6 weeks extra each year to cover Sue, that needs to be reflected in her annual leave as well as in her pay packet.

But if they're always having to cover each other's time off, it effectively becomes a vicious circle where nobody actually gets any paid annual leave.

Bishbashbosh9 · 24/02/2024 09:49

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:35

As explained previously. This wasn't meant in a derogatory way, I was just trying to explain that she doesn't have other people to consider. For eg, If I book annual leave my DH will also need to book to coincide. We may arrange then to take the Grandchild - this all takes planning and so I need to book annual leave in advance.
But...she won't commit to covering incase she decides to go away, which has a knock on effect for me and I'm finding it hard to make plans.

Of course she has other people to consider! She has to be able to get the same dates off work as all the friends she wants to go with. It doesn't stop you putting your request in to HR though. That's all you need to consider really, and they will tell you if it's viable or not.

MummyJ36 · 24/02/2024 09:31

Sorry but this is an insane set up for a job share. As plenty others have said, you effectively don’t get any annual leave!

I’ve done a job share before and I was given the option to cover my job share if I wanted overtime pay or if not we’d get a temp in to cover. I’m not sure what job you do OP, but my job share was a reception job so we had to have cover. However I had external commitments so couldn’t always cover (no DC at this point) and my job share had kids.

Jaxhog · 24/02/2024 09:28

Wow, there's some vitriol on here! Op, I think it is perfectly ok to book in advance regardless of whether you have children or not. It would only be unreasonable if you block booked several weeks; a couple of days doesn't seem like a lot to ask.

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 24/02/2024 09:27

I don’t think it should be your job to check others can cover your annual leave! You should book it through HR and if someone else has booked a holiday at the time they come back and say ‘sorry X has booked those days off, you can’t have them’ or ‘yes, that’s fine’. They should then arrange the cover as required. That’s how it works in most places, that way one person doesn’t get to over ride another.

DH has to book his well in advance to make sure he gets the times we want as we have a school age DC and I teach so he can only take holidays in school holidays if we are all going to do stuff together.

Niallig32839 · 24/02/2024 09:07

You have given her the heads up, she has nothing booked and didn’t say that overlaps with when I’m off and it’s approved by your manager or hr it’s an absolute non issue. First come first serve for annual leave

SapphireOpal · 24/02/2024 08:53

Figgygal · 24/02/2024 08:34

Honestly there's nothing wrong with this job share arrangement what are people like??? Op was never getting no holidays or any other nonsense being spouted. They cover for each other and get paid, leave dates known in advance all works for those involved so no idea what people are projecting??????

Honestly op I'd have a word with your manager to tell them about your exchange in case it happens again. You need to plan leave as much as she does.

Clearly it doesn't work for all involved though does it.

I don't think it's illegal - it's effectively compulsory overtime which is allowed if it's in OP's contract - but it's not a working pattern that would work for lots and lots of people who job share.

Amireallyhere · 24/02/2024 08:52

I do a jobshare and would be really put out if I had to cover other people's holiday on my days off, irrespective of how well we got on. I work part time by choice because of other life commitments. It is no one's business what these are (could be another job, children, caring responsibilities, mental health reasons). I get where this woman is coming from. The employer is at fault putting you in this position.

Clarinet1 · 24/02/2024 08:50

Haven’t RTFT but I think all the details about
job sharing and family circumstances don’t really come into it - the colleague is just being a CF saying the OP can’t book the time just in case she wants it herself when she hasn’t booked the cruises at all yet.

Greenkindness · 24/02/2024 08:38

There doesn’t seem a lot of spare capacity to cover a long term illness. But again that’s not your problem it’s the manager's.

I would definitely frame it in future oh by the way I’m booking xx off especially if it’s months in advance. If colleague has a problem they need to speak to the manager, as that’s what they get paid for.

Oblomov24 · 24/02/2024 08:37

This whole thread is wierd. The job share bit is irrelevant. Any company that can't cope with an employee taking AL has got issues.

Readytoevolve · 24/02/2024 08:37

Tell her you’re taking it, don’t ask. You’re not asking her permission. She sounds very selfish “I might”.

Shefliesonherownwings · 24/02/2024 08:36

People need to get over the OP mentioning her job share was single with no kids. It was clearly just context not meant in a derogatory way, jeez.

Just book your days OP, if it’s only 2 days it’s hardly like you’re taking the whole of September off. Surely when she comes to booking her holiday she either has to avoid those days or your managers have to make a decision about whether she can also have the time off. You can’t hang about waiting to see when she might possibly take time off, that’s ridiculous. You know when you want to go away so book it off, it’s not that hard.

SapphireOpal · 24/02/2024 08:34

Stargazer75 · 23/02/2024 13:09

All checked with acas. Perfectly legal. In all the job shares I've had we cover if the other is off and received overtime pay. This is my 4th job share and we have always done it this way, so pretty normal.

This is really not a normal way to operate a job share. Most people I've job shared with have small kids in childcare and need their days/mornings/afternoons off because that's when their kid is NOT at childcare. I'd be able to work an extra day as an exception if there was something super crucial (DP could book leave, grandparents could come to stay, etc) but I couldn't cover every single time my job share partner went on leave, that's batshit.

Figgygal · 24/02/2024 08:34

Honestly there's nothing wrong with this job share arrangement what are people like??? Op was never getting no holidays or any other nonsense being spouted. They cover for each other and get paid, leave dates known in advance all works for those involved so no idea what people are projecting??????

Honestly op I'd have a word with your manager to tell them about your exchange in case it happens again. You need to plan leave as much as she does.

Swipe left for the next trending thread