Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Job Share response to hol request

409 replies

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:01

I'm fairly new to my jobshare with another lady (I've been there 1 year). She's older, single and no DC.
She loves her cruises and goes on around 3 a year, I cover the days she is absent.

As yet, she hasn't booked any days off this year, but as I have a husband, grandchild, elderly Mum etc, occasionally I book things in advance as have a busy life outside of work.

The other day I asked my jobshare if she could please cover 2 days for me in September as I would like to book annual leave.

She went all red in the face and said 'I just don't know if I'll be available, I don't know when I'm going on my cruises yet'. I could tell she was very annoyed at me asking! She asked if I needed to actually book something such as travel or accommodation etc? I don't personally think its any of her business what I plan to do on annual leave and I think 7 months notice is pretty decent. In the end, in a huff, she just said 'well, you may as well go ahead and book then and I'll let you know closer to'.

My DH needs to book his annual leave to coincide - and we were hoping to visit friends in London who would also book annual leave, but obviously if she changes her mind closer to it will mess everything up 😬

I guess she's pretty much saying 'I'll cover if I don't book a cruise' in effect saying her holiday plans trump mine (unless I'm getting it wrong)

I put my holiday form in to HR, but how would you address this going forward?

I'm not just going to sit back each year, wait for her to book the days she wants, then have the crumbs that are left.

Anyone else jobshare and how do you navigate?

OP posts:
Guttedme · 24/02/2024 19:19

I’m guilty of not reading all the thread, sorry but perhaps this person is getting ratty because they don’t expect to be in the company come 7 months notice time and are contemplating handing their notice in.

I know when people talk to me about beyond April I find it hard as my contract expires end of March gladly and to be honest I’d rather be out of any organisation who quibbles over 2 days needed as surgery time but can afford to give a direct colleague 3 and a bit weeks off in the lead up to Christmas and did they worry about the workload for me then at busiest time of year with donators. Err no.

Stargazer75 · 24/02/2024 18:29

Propertylover · 24/02/2024 11:14

@Stargazer75 you are entitled to plan ahead and request the leave.

You have followed the correct process and neither of the other job shares have commitments. So you have submitted your form to HR.

For this absence I suggest you put it in your calendar and cc in both colleagues so it is their calendars.

Going forward just follow the same process, if she gets huffy ignore her. All 3 of you have the right to request and take leave.

The only time I would expect more consideration are key holiday periods e.g. Christmas/New Year, Easter etc.

I know you may not have meant to but judging her lifestyle is not a nice or fair thing to do. Just because you have DC does not give you a right to school holidays etc. You do however have the right to book leave in advance.

I don't have DC
I'm just a woman who wants to book 2 days annual leave mid September.
I have my DH to factor in obviously as he'll need to tie in his leave too. We want to visit friends in London.
I have no DC for clarity.
I have 2 GC from step daughter

OP posts:
Magicmama92 · 24/02/2024 18:01

Personally I would put my foot down.
Say I am booking this off and I won't be told by you when I'm allowed to. Say she will have to book her time off different since she has Seven months notice of this. Also let your manager know.
Neither of you trump each other but first come first serve. You've planned this and told her and that's it. She doesnt get to dictate to you when you can have time off.
Personally I'd ask to have a phone or in person meeting with your manager so that holidays can be discussed and a proper plan in place. My husband his work have it online and in January you can book all your holidays and the planber shows it so no one books the same time off. That way it's fair and on record.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 17:58

Rosscameasdoody · 24/02/2024 17:31

It’s clearly escaped your notice that OP has accommodated the jobshare colleague and expects the same courtesy from her - especially since she has given seven months notice of her plans. I can’t see how that’s unreasonable.

It's unreasonable because neither of them should have to accommodate the other.

OP should be able to take annual leave without her colleague working extra shifts to cover her, and vice versa when the colleague wants time off.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 24/02/2024 17:56

Carpediemmakeitcount · 24/02/2024 15:07

The op has covered her shifts when her job share was on holiday. The job share doesn't want to plan around op that's what I understood?

She did the decent thing and made plans in advance so the job share and the op doesn't lose money when making plans. The op did say that her job share will let her know closer to the time if she can do it. How nice of her?

It shouldn't be up to the job share to work extra days so OP can go on annual leave.

That's not OP's fault, of course, but the entire system sounds fucked to me.

ZiriForGood · 24/02/2024 17:53

Rosscameasdoody · 24/02/2024 17:31

It’s clearly escaped your notice that OP has accommodated the jobshare colleague and expects the same courtesy from her - especially since she has given seven months notice of her plans. I can’t see how that’s unreasonable.

It's clearly escaped your notice, that "covering" is additional overtime on non-working days.

It is absurd to frame it as each of them doing a favour to the other one, they are doing a massive favour to their employer working like that.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/02/2024 17:31

ZiriForGood · 24/02/2024 14:50

There is a difference between general keeping a staff level from a bigger pool and commanding a coworker that they have to come to work on their non-working days on a specific date.
The OP is effectively doing the second thing now.

Yes, it is mostly the system/employer to blame here.

One OP's sentence caught my attention - due to her mum's appointments, she can't possibly plan her leave around share's cruises. It sounds that if the share went ahead and planned her leave first, the OP wouldn't be happy about it either.

It’s clearly escaped your notice that OP has accommodated the jobshare colleague and expects the same courtesy from her - especially since she has given seven months notice of her plans. I can’t see how that’s unreasonable.

Simplelobsterhat · 24/02/2024 16:45

Lifetooshort23 · 24/02/2024 16:15

I don’t understand? Surely if you put in your holiday request first and she then decides she wants to book the same time off, hers won’t be approved?! So tough to her?! Most places I’ve worked they wouldn’t allow multiple members of teams to be off at the same time, so you each just put in your holiday requests and hope it doesn’t clash? Maybe just don’t mention it to her next time, just add it to the holiday calendar when it’s approved and tough to her??!

If I understand the OP correctly, it's not an issue of the colleague wanting to book leave the same days as the OP. They don't work the same days so she wouldn't need to book those days as leave to have them off. The issue is that the OP only seems to be allowed leave at all if her one colleague is willing to do overtime on days she doesn't usually work, which seems ridiculous.

Branwells77 · 24/02/2024 16:16

I am on a project with another person although we have our own calendars appointments we are not allowed to take holidays at the same time our manager came to us when we returned from Christmas break and mentioned we both have holidays to take before the end of March I spoke to my Dh and we worked out a week we can both take together (rare occurrence) so I submitted my request and it was authorised my project partner approached me last week and mentioned that I’m off on week commencing X I said yes I am “oooh but I wanted to take that week” my response was you could speak to our manager about taking that week but I won’t be available as I’m going away.
Me and my project partner both have teenage children she is single and as said above I have a DH but I find that irrelevant if you want to take a certain day/week off then why not I never discuss with her if she would mind me taking a certain week off I only need approval from my manager.

Lifetooshort23 · 24/02/2024 16:15

I don’t understand? Surely if you put in your holiday request first and she then decides she wants to book the same time off, hers won’t be approved?! So tough to her?! Most places I’ve worked they wouldn’t allow multiple members of teams to be off at the same time, so you each just put in your holiday requests and hope it doesn’t clash? Maybe just don’t mention it to her next time, just add it to the holiday calendar when it’s approved and tough to her??!

AboutYouTalk · 24/02/2024 15:54

Surely if HR authorise your leave your colleague can’t then book those 2 days? Tough for her, she needs to book if she needs it. Sounds selfish.

Blossomclouds · 24/02/2024 15:53

As an older widowed lady with no kids, I used to get really pissed off when first choice was sometimes given to young women with kids. But I must say she is being completely unreasonable and has got used to her position and having her own way. You will have to find a tactful way round this, but maybe have a quick word with HR so they know the situation. PS I would probably be the same as her .... no not so horrible ... but this has to be negotiated and you can't really blame either side. Your older colleague IS being unreasonable, fight your corner!

PopandFizz · 24/02/2024 15:42

Bit odd for job share to be required to cover, not usually how a job share works with annual leave.

Either way it's unfortunately first come first served. With things like Christmas then discussion and compromise is normal but the rest of the year its tough. I've worked on teams of 8 where only 1 was allowed off at once 🤣 this is just a normal annual leave problem but with much less chance of a clash.

Not her responsibility to sign up to work your days though, as its not the other way around. But I can understand eg if you booked off Mon to weds them not allowing the other to book off the Thurs and Friday so someone is in

Carpediemmakeitcount · 24/02/2024 15:07

ZiriForGood · 24/02/2024 14:50

There is a difference between general keeping a staff level from a bigger pool and commanding a coworker that they have to come to work on their non-working days on a specific date.
The OP is effectively doing the second thing now.

Yes, it is mostly the system/employer to blame here.

One OP's sentence caught my attention - due to her mum's appointments, she can't possibly plan her leave around share's cruises. It sounds that if the share went ahead and planned her leave first, the OP wouldn't be happy about it either.

The op has covered her shifts when her job share was on holiday. The job share doesn't want to plan around op that's what I understood?

She did the decent thing and made plans in advance so the job share and the op doesn't lose money when making plans. The op did say that her job share will let her know closer to the time if she can do it. How nice of her?

BardRelic · 24/02/2024 14:58

You've got an employer problem, not a colleague problem. It doesn't sound like a job share. It sounds like there is a particular role within the organisation that needs to be covered throughout business hours. Your employer has taken on three of you to fulfill this role and is calling it a job share but in fact it isn't - as PP have said, a job share would be one whole time equivalent split between you. What they want is more than one whole time equivalent, because they haven't factored in illness and leave.

All the rest is flimflam. It doesn't matter who has children or not, or who has more flexibility or not. You all need to agree a fair process with HR and stick to it. And if the company need more employees to cover for you, they do. Or they need to train existing employees in that role so that they can cover. But it isn't the OP's fault or her colleague's that the employer is taking the piss. That's on the employer.

ZiriForGood · 24/02/2024 14:50

LaurenMichelleFx · 24/02/2024 14:35

This is not what the OP is suggesting, I can’t quite see how you have interpreted it this way but here we are.

YANBU - you are more than entitled to book your leave in advance. There are 365 days in a year and you are asking she covers 2 of them in 7 months time.

In most jobs, not just a job share, there must be a certain level of staff in at a time, if you leave it until last minute to book your leave you run the risk of it being booked by others.

There is a difference between general keeping a staff level from a bigger pool and commanding a coworker that they have to come to work on their non-working days on a specific date.
The OP is effectively doing the second thing now.

Yes, it is mostly the system/employer to blame here.

One OP's sentence caught my attention - due to her mum's appointments, she can't possibly plan her leave around share's cruises. It sounds that if the share went ahead and planned her leave first, the OP wouldn't be happy about it either.

Italiangreyhound · 24/02/2024 14:48

"I put my holiday form in to HR, but how would you address this going forward?"

I'd clarify whose responsibility it is to cover your work when on holiday. Presumably it is the HR department have the final say.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 24/02/2024 14:36

"The OP is getting a really hard time. You do obviously see that her job share is effectively saying no you cannot plan any leave until I say so. Is the OP supposed to wait months just to fit around another's plans."

I agree with this, and think the OP is simply showing professional courtesy by running this by her colleague 7 months ahead of when she wants to take 2 days off. If the colleague has absolutely nothing planned for then, the OP is quite entitled to put in for those dates for her annual leave, she shouldn't have to wait for her colleague to decide whether or not she wants to go on a cruise at the same time, that's ridiculous. The OP could equally well just have put in for the leave without mentioning it to her colleague, but that would really have been cause to create bad blood between them.

LaurenMichelleFx · 24/02/2024 14:35

SausageRollsWithMustard · 22/02/2024 12:15

Her being single with no children is completely irrelevant.

It's not only parents who deserve holidays.

This is not what the OP is suggesting, I can’t quite see how you have interpreted it this way but here we are.

YANBU - you are more than entitled to book your leave in advance. There are 365 days in a year and you are asking she covers 2 of them in 7 months time.

In most jobs, not just a job share, there must be a certain level of staff in at a time, if you leave it until last minute to book your leave you run the risk of it being booked by others.

Abbimae · 24/02/2024 14:27

So if she decides to go away you couldn’t be off? Makes no sense

Lobberto · 24/02/2024 14:22

Think you’re going about this all wrong. You don’t need to run your leave passed her in the first place. Pick your dates, submit to management, take your leave. It’s your manager’s responsibility to then tell Job Share A that the time she requests 5 months down the line is already booked, or arrange cover if you’re both to be off.

Merryhobnobs · 24/02/2024 14:20

LookItsMeAgain · 24/02/2024 14:02

This poster has it.

I agree to an extent but it depends on the workplace, are HR likely to bend the jobshares whim or complaints and override the OP later. Not fair but it does happen .

Merryhobnobs · 24/02/2024 14:19

My job share is also older than me with no children. We work together and absolutely respect each others right to leave. If I had said hi X do you have plans 8 months from now because I would like to book a week off then. She would either say well actually I was also planning to do something but let's work around each others dates or no I don't have anything booked so go for it.

The OP is getting a really hard time. You do obviously see that her job share is effectively saying no you cannot plan any leave until I say so. Is the OP supposed to wait months just to fit around another's plans.

It's not about being entitled because of the kids. The OP gave a picture, if she hadn't there would have been endless questions about the jobshares life. Better a full picture than a bunch of repeating same things again and again.

LookItsMeAgain · 24/02/2024 14:02

PrueRamsay · 22/02/2024 12:44

You’re over complicating this.

You apply for annual leave and your manager approves it. If she subsequently requests the same dates, manager either rejects her request, or approves it and arranges cover.

Take a step back. You need to change the narrative to “informing her” rather than “requesting”.

This poster has it.

Dillydollydingdong · 24/02/2024 13:59

First come, first served.