Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Job Share response to hol request

409 replies

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:01

I'm fairly new to my jobshare with another lady (I've been there 1 year). She's older, single and no DC.
She loves her cruises and goes on around 3 a year, I cover the days she is absent.

As yet, she hasn't booked any days off this year, but as I have a husband, grandchild, elderly Mum etc, occasionally I book things in advance as have a busy life outside of work.

The other day I asked my jobshare if she could please cover 2 days for me in September as I would like to book annual leave.

She went all red in the face and said 'I just don't know if I'll be available, I don't know when I'm going on my cruises yet'. I could tell she was very annoyed at me asking! She asked if I needed to actually book something such as travel or accommodation etc? I don't personally think its any of her business what I plan to do on annual leave and I think 7 months notice is pretty decent. In the end, in a huff, she just said 'well, you may as well go ahead and book then and I'll let you know closer to'.

My DH needs to book his annual leave to coincide - and we were hoping to visit friends in London who would also book annual leave, but obviously if she changes her mind closer to it will mess everything up 😬

I guess she's pretty much saying 'I'll cover if I don't book a cruise' in effect saying her holiday plans trump mine (unless I'm getting it wrong)

I put my holiday form in to HR, but how would you address this going forward?

I'm not just going to sit back each year, wait for her to book the days she wants, then have the crumbs that are left.

Anyone else jobshare and how do you navigate?

OP posts:
FlissyPaps · 22/02/2024 17:59

Out of interest, OP, and apologies if it’s been said, but what is your job role? I’m really struggling to understand a role that only 2/3 people do and has to be covered at all times.

What if you both were ill/suddenly passed away? How would the organisation cope?

C8H10N4O2 · 22/02/2024 17:57

CatrionaCat · 22/02/2024 17:35

Some people seem just determined to have a go at OP without actually addressing her problem. OP is not saying that her wishes should trump her colleague's, she's asking if it's reasonable that her colleagues should trump hers. The single/married/kids/no kids situation is totally irrelevant to the situation and should probably not have been mentioned - although no doubt then the same people would be all "oh maybe she has to plan around her children/spouse so of course she should get priority."

No OP, it's not reasonable that you can't book A/L until your job share has decided if/when she wants to take hers. YANBU for thinking you should be able to book yours for any time when she hasn't booked any. If she had previously given you a heads-up along the lines of "I'd like to go away in September but I'm not sure of the exact dates yet, but probably the first half of the month" then that would be different, but she has no concrete plans and not even any soft plans yet, so you are not doing anything wrong.

Yes exactly. PPs are so keen to bash the OP for mentioning the child free status of her job sharer that they are missing the point.

OP is it actually a requirement that the three of you have to coordinate cover for hols within the job share? Or is it just a request that you do this as a courtesy where possible?

If its a requirement then your employers are taking the piss (or ignorant about job shares). If its a courtesy then you book the leave you need to book and let your cruising job sharer book hers when she is ready. You can then cover each other if its mutually convenient, otherwise employer needs to sort cover.

Its not reasonable for anyone to block their job sharer from booking leave but its a problem created by the employer if this situation is mandated.

Basilandmandarin · 22/02/2024 17:48

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:35

As explained previously. This wasn't meant in a derogatory way, I was just trying to explain that she doesn't have other people to consider. For eg, If I book annual leave my DH will also need to book to coincide. We may arrange then to take the Grandchild - this all takes planning and so I need to book annual leave in advance.
But...she won't commit to covering incase she decides to go away, which has a knock on effect for me and I'm finding it hard to make plans.

I wouldn’t commit either. Just because she doesn’t have children and is single doesn’t mean she doesn’t have other people to consider. She may have friends she travels with or just quite simply she may prefer a certain time of year to cruise.

This is not your colleagues issue. It’s your employers.

TerfTalking · 22/02/2024 17:41

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 22/02/2024 16:05

Maybe it’s a job where you have to be there - like reception or something. So they need to cover each other on leave.

OP, I think you have given more than enough notice! I’d email your manager with your holiday request and say to jobshare lady that once it is booked you won’t be able to change it.

But if it was a full timer on reception would that mean they couldn’t ever have leave as they have no job sharer to cover?

in most places you have x number of employees, at any given time only x can be off at once. Whether the individual is part time, full time or job share is irrelevant, x off at any one time.

if there’s no one else trained in the role, what happens if half the job share goes off sick, the other half has to work full time?

the Job sharers leave should be dependent upon the wider team not just each other.

ThePerfectDog · 22/02/2024 17:39

I guess she's pretty much saying 'I'll cover if I don't book a cruise' in effect saying her holiday plans trump mine (unless I'm getting it wrong)

I don’t think is what she’s saying at all. She hasn’t booked any holiday this year but you have booked a fair amount (because you have to plan ahead), she’s worried that she’s going to miss out because you’re top trumping the holiday booking.

CatrionaCat · 22/02/2024 17:35

Some people seem just determined to have a go at OP without actually addressing her problem. OP is not saying that her wishes should trump her colleague's, she's asking if it's reasonable that her colleagues should trump hers. The single/married/kids/no kids situation is totally irrelevant to the situation and should probably not have been mentioned - although no doubt then the same people would be all "oh maybe she has to plan around her children/spouse so of course she should get priority."

No OP, it's not reasonable that you can't book A/L until your job share has decided if/when she wants to take hers. YANBU for thinking you should be able to book yours for any time when she hasn't booked any. If she had previously given you a heads-up along the lines of "I'd like to go away in September but I'm not sure of the exact dates yet, but probably the first half of the month" then that would be different, but she has no concrete plans and not even any soft plans yet, so you are not doing anything wrong.

TerfTalking · 22/02/2024 17:33

TheDefiant · 22/02/2024 12:11

Thing is if the post wasn't a job share then there'd be no one to cover if one person off.

If held by one person and they took leave...there'd need to be other arrangements. So do that.

Exactly this.

I worked for a large well known corporate and job sharing has been offered since the mid 80s, there has never been an expectation that you covered for each other, that’s ridiculous, in the same way as a full timer wouldn’t usually have a full time buddy that they had to cover leave for.

you need to speak to HR and your line manager and put these questions to them.

DillDanding · 22/02/2024 17:26

Sounds like a usual job share if you’re expected to cover each other when off. I used to job share when my children were small. I worked 2 days, the other person 3. We did not cover each other’s leave - that would mean working ft in those weeks? And we certainly didn’t do each other’s work.

Anyway, her personal status has nothing to do with the time she takes off. Hers is equally valid. You just need a more equable system.

Sageyboots · 22/02/2024 17:25

There are two things though

  1. the person may have plans and not be able to cover those two days when she wouldn’t normally work.
  2. the person may be reluctant to commit because they might want that week off for a holiday themselves.

I think it’s reasonable in case 1) for the person to take a bit of time to check about commitments they might have on their non work days before letting you know (and potentially saying no if there is a clash).

case 2 is cheekier - keeping her options open for a more last minute holiday and keeping you dangling while she decides is a bit off (and she shouldn’t use withholding holiday cover for you as a way of reserving the weeks she might want off at your expense.)

7 months is neither short notice nor booking something at the beginning of the leave calendar and not giving anyone else the chance. I don’t see what you have done wrong.

If give and take has always worked before then hopefully she can give you an answer in a short time frame, but if not, you may have to speak to your manager for firmer guidance about when holiday can be booked/blocked by colleagues or look at alternative cover systems if this keeps cropping up.

Milkmani · 22/02/2024 17:20

Seems like a strange arrangement for annual leave. Book all yours well in advance as you have quite a lot going on and she can book her dates in when she’s decided on the cruises. If it’s not possible for her to book later on as there’s not sufficient cover then that’s up to her. HR and management can’t then turn around and ask you to amend your dates if already approved in advance. You were trying to be polite and she’s being a bit awkward.

Vgbeat · 22/02/2024 17:20

Your mistake is asking. It surely is first come, first served. Why are you running past her first. I would just mention in passing oh I've booked holidays in September as its already a done deal. Same the other way, I'm sure she's not running past you when she wants to book a holiday.

GinandGingerBeer · 22/02/2024 17:18

Besides if you work extra to cover someone's shifts then you accrue additional annual leave for those shifts.
And if they fall On a bank holiday... 🤯🤯🤯

ClaudiaWankleman · 22/02/2024 17:10

BeyondMyWits · 22/02/2024 16:46

We seem to have the same sort of arrangement... I do 3 mornings, one does 2 mornings and an afternoon, the other does 4 afternoons... the way it works with us is that you cover on days you don't already work, so you only do half days.... so if I work Tue, I don't cover Tue pm lady, the other one covers. Unless there is an issue for her, then I'd cover if I could.

The way it works out here is if you don't cover others leave, good luck getting cover for your leave.

It really is common in small retail places to do it this way. I worked in 4 different ones and the boss has always said "sort it out between you, someone needs to be in..." so basically if you don't sort your own cover, you don't get to take that time off.

The annual leave is your legal entitlement. If you don’t arrange cover for your leave, your just has to deal with it. You’re being ripped off.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 22/02/2024 17:06

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:35

As explained previously. This wasn't meant in a derogatory way, I was just trying to explain that she doesn't have other people to consider. For eg, If I book annual leave my DH will also need to book to coincide. We may arrange then to take the Grandchild - this all takes planning and so I need to book annual leave in advance.
But...she won't commit to covering incase she decides to go away, which has a knock on effect for me and I'm finding it hard to make plans.

You Have no idea who she has to consider. People may have caring responsibilities or siblings the have additional needs etc.

You can't claim she has no one else to consider. You have no bloody idea and it is very offensive.

I'm unmarried (have a partner) and have no children. I have 5 people to consider in most of my annual real due to other family member's difficult circumstances. You have no idea who people are responsibilities for or what caring responsibilities people may have. Even if they don't, it does mean your need are higher ranking.

MiniCooperLover · 22/02/2024 17:03

I would expect your line manager to arrange the cover not your job share. Assuming you have your specific days then she may have commitments on those other days that are none of your business.

TunnocksOrDeath · 22/02/2024 16:57

Justifiedcheese · 22/02/2024 15:00

Perfectly obvious why OP is busier, but okay then 🙄

Not at all obvious. One of my older single colleagues who worked part time joined us direct from a great full time job in the States, which was an odd decision in our industry. Some months later we discovered the move was to support her oldest friend through terminal cancer, which she was too distressed to mention at work untill after the lady sadly passed away. We often have NO IDEA what's going on in people's lives and have no business making assumptions about their commitments, or lack of them.

Mostlyoblivious · 22/02/2024 16:56

I don’t think arranging cover is your responsibility here..

BeyondMyWits · 22/02/2024 16:46

We seem to have the same sort of arrangement... I do 3 mornings, one does 2 mornings and an afternoon, the other does 4 afternoons... the way it works with us is that you cover on days you don't already work, so you only do half days.... so if I work Tue, I don't cover Tue pm lady, the other one covers. Unless there is an issue for her, then I'd cover if I could.

The way it works out here is if you don't cover others leave, good luck getting cover for your leave.

It really is common in small retail places to do it this way. I worked in 4 different ones and the boss has always said "sort it out between you, someone needs to be in..." so basically if you don't sort your own cover, you don't get to take that time off.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 22/02/2024 16:28

alltoomuchrightnow · 22/02/2024 12:30

'Older single and no DC'.. that sounds like me
Also why I loathe working with entitled people like you

Bitter much. You are not entitled OP take your holiday when you want. Fuck her, she should be faster off the mark.

Everythinggreen · 22/02/2024 16:24

BigFluffyHoodie · 22/02/2024 16:11

I am older, married, with DC and an aged parent 😂🙄

And I still think it is crass to mention and consider a person's "private lifestyle" choices as somehow lesser than my commitments.

She's not saying that though. She's saying she has to think ahead more because of specific reasons.
Would I have taken offence to being told I was younger, single with no DC so had more freedom with my AL? No. Did I feel like my AL meant less? No.
Will I be offended when my DC are older, my partner will be lucky enough to have retired and I again have more freedom, and someone who is in the position I've been in for years needs more time to plan? Nope. Will I think my AL means less? Nope.

It's offence over nothing 🤣

BigFluffyHoodie · 22/02/2024 16:11

Everythinggreen · 22/02/2024 16:08

Some of the replies on here 🤣 Tell me you're older, single and have no DC without telling me you're older, single and have no DC.

When I was younger, single and with no DC I absolutely had more freedom to book things more last minute or be spontaneous, which I often did, whether that be alone or with a friend who was also available. I didn't have a partners AL to consider, didn't have school holidays and pricing ranges surrounding that to consider, didn't have to think about childcare and any leave childminders have advised of well in advance, or family who are providing child care and their upcoming plans. Add to it if you're caring for a relative that you need cover for, it means 99% of the time you CANNOT be spontaneous.

Back then, all I had was me, myself and I to please. Didn't mean I didn't deserve my leave, just meant I had a ton more freedom with my leave.

If you fail to grasp the difference, you've not been on both sides of it.

Edited

I am older, married, with DC and an aged parent 😂🙄

And I still think it is crass to mention and consider a person's "private lifestyle" choices as somehow lesser than my commitments.

Everythinggreen · 22/02/2024 16:08

Some of the replies on here 🤣 Tell me you're older, single and have no DC without telling me you're older, single and have no DC.

When I was younger, single and with no DC I absolutely had more freedom to book things more last minute or be spontaneous, which I often did, whether that be alone or with a friend who was also available. I didn't have a partners AL to consider, didn't have school holidays and pricing ranges surrounding that to consider, didn't have to think about childcare and any leave childminders have advised of well in advance, or family who are providing child care and their upcoming plans. Add to it if you're caring for a relative that you need cover for, it means 99% of the time you CANNOT be spontaneous.

Back then, all I had was me, myself and I to please. Didn't mean I didn't deserve my leave, just meant I had a ton more freedom with my leave.

If you fail to grasp the difference, you've not been on both sides of it.

PansyOatZebra · 22/02/2024 16:07

Yanbu in that you’ve given enough notice and she’s acted so put out by it but… the fact she has no kids, grandchildren, is single etc. isn’t relevant here and I hate it when people try out make out that because someone has no kids or immediately obvious responsibilities that they should somehow be more available to work than someone else.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 22/02/2024 16:05

TheDefiant · 22/02/2024 12:11

Thing is if the post wasn't a job share then there'd be no one to cover if one person off.

If held by one person and they took leave...there'd need to be other arrangements. So do that.

Maybe it’s a job where you have to be there - like reception or something. So they need to cover each other on leave.

OP, I think you have given more than enough notice! I’d email your manager with your holiday request and say to jobshare lady that once it is booked you won’t be able to change it.

wronginalltherightways · 22/02/2024 16:05

Stargazer75 · 22/02/2024 12:24

Unfortunately one of us needs to be in and holidays worked between us. At a push they could provide alternative cover for the odd occasion but generally speaking we are expected to cover the others annual leave.

If that's truly the case, and you always cover her holidays, I would make it VERY clear that you will never agree to any future holiday dates she proposes if she doesn't cover your very reasonable 7 month notice for your own holiday dates.

Swipe left for the next trending thread