Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is fantastic, of course. Now can we sort out women’s rights wrt women’s spaces, and stop this 1%Of women have penises nonsense?

134 replies

Lion400 · 22/02/2024 11:33

Respect biological women’s spaces or be sued, that kind of thing?

To think this is fantastic, of course. Now can we sort out women’s rights wrt women’s spaces, and stop this 1%Of women have penises nonsense?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cazpar · 23/02/2024 20:45

AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 16:05

Thank you :) Apologies for misinterpreting your post.
I think in this case the OP often starts threads in the same vein and some of us are a bit bruised by it.

Nothing to apologise for! I'm not as prolific on the FWR forums as I used to be and have NC several times over the years. But you and I are definitely in agreement on almost everything I think!

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 17:06

What's a DIDS?

Yes, it won't be long before the DIDs decide they are being discriminated against because they don't go through the menopause

Although going by this at a guess it's a derogatory term for a trans person going by this comment and a wild theorist "I bet this is what they're gonna do next!" which'll get thrown out as fact when nothing of the sort happened and they didn't try to claim menopause at all?

blacksax · 23/02/2024 17:01

HermioneWeasley · 22/02/2024 12:02

That article is about employers failing to make adjustments for the menopause might be sued for sexual or disability discrimination. It is nothing to do with women’s spaces.

but the point is that it’s potential sex discrimination because only women experience menopause and women are a sex not an identity

Yes, it won't be long before the DIDs decide they are being discriminated against because they don't go through the menopause (while conveniently forgetting that a lot of other people in the workplace don't either).

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 17:01

If it happens to be relevant, as it is in this case, there is no reason why not
How is it relevant to the menopause?

twingiraffes · 23/02/2024 16:57

Universalsnail · 22/02/2024 11:36

Do you have to shoehorn your opinion about trans people into every subject you talk about?

If it happens to be relevant, as it is in this case, there is no reason why not.

TheKeatingFive · 23/02/2024 16:54

AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 16:50

Those are single sex spaces. Womens rights are a lot more than that.

Sure, but they won't be specifically women's rights.

Granted, biology will make a nonsense of some of these rights being granted to men, but the concept will be eroded.

AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 16:50

Those are single sex spaces. Womens rights are a lot more than that.

TheKeatingFive · 23/02/2024 16:48

Look, I am strongly GC. But this argument that "womens rights cease to exist if a man can identify as a woman" is just plain wrong. Womens rights to single sex spaces, yes.

I think we have been over all this before and I think you're being very naive.

We now have the concept of 'legal sex' which can be different to 'biological sex' and no clear mechanism in the law to prioritise biological sex. How can women secure their rights to single sex spaces, shortlists, care, etc, etc, when men with GRCs can pitch up with a legal document (birth cert) that now states their sex as female?

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 16:46

Your rights won't be. How can you have women's rights if they apply to any man who wants them?

How will my women's rights not exist if they properly implemented the buffer zones outside anti abortion clinics?
Why would trans people have any bearing on that?
How would my rights not exist if they sorted out the extortionate childcare costs which would have helped me get back into work so much sooner?
There is so much more than "women v trans" which some seem to think.
Half the time we're wanting the same thing, we should be standing up for it altogether in my view - bodily autonomy (right to an abortion, right for trans men to have control over their body)
Right to be able to access medication (eg birth control)
Etc etc

AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 16:38

TheKeatingFive · 23/02/2024 16:15

Nope, I'm still here

Did you actually read my comment? Your rights won't be. How can you have women's rights if they apply to any man who wants them?

Because human sexed bodies still exist, with all the implications of that.
Discrimination against women doesn't happen because of our identity. It happens because of our sex. Therefore changing definitions doesn't magically get rid of the issues. And any actions taken will still benefit women, even if we've started calling them something else.

Look, I am strongly GC. But this argument that "womens rights cease to exist if a man can identify as a woman" is just plain wrong. Womens rights to single sex spaces, yes. Womens rights to live free from violence and poverty, to be able to access appropriate medical treatment for womens conditions, to be protected from discrimination due to menstruation, breastfeeding, menopause or childbirth can all be protected regardless of definitions.
You are being overly simplistic.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 16:15

The government could take action to address violence against women and girls now, today, without needing any extra definition of what a woman is

Exactly

TheKeatingFive · 23/02/2024 16:15

Nope, I'm still here

Did you actually read my comment? Your rights won't be. How can you have women's rights if they apply to any man who wants them?

BIossomtoes · 23/02/2024 16:14

Arguably this crazy focus on "what is a woman" is deflecting from the actual real life harms women live with every day.

I think you could dispense with the arguably.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 16:13

They cease to exist

Nope, I'm still here....
Or am I
"Help I've disappeared!"
"Who said that?!" 👀

AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 16:13

Lion400 · 23/02/2024 16:06

All women’s rights are impacted if ‘men can be women’. It’s not hard to understand.

No they aren't. To go to the list of "Human Rights" - Right go Remedy by Competent Tribunal is arguably one of the biggest rights women don't have today, because rape is effectively decriminalised, as is stalking by a previous partner, as is living free from flashers or harassers.
The government could take action to address violence against women and girls now, today, without needing any extra definition of what a woman is.

That's just one example, I can think of plenty more "womens rights" issues where the definition of woman is irrelevant. Tackling maternal death rates would be another. Dealing with poverty, which disproportionately affects women.

Arguably this crazy focus on "what is a woman" is deflecting from the actual real life harms women live with every day.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 16:11

Womens rights are not just one issue and so it's madness to me that people would vote on one single issue ..’

This doesn’t make any sense

How does it not make any sense?
I couldn't have been clearer, did you read my post properly? (Genuine question)
There's other women's issues that are important (I mentioned just a few) as it's just not a single issue but you get people voting on just one - trans /women's issues.
Even if that's to the detriment of other women's rights.

Lion400 · 23/02/2024 16:11

TheKeatingFive · 23/02/2024 16:07

If men can be women there is no such thing as women's rights. They cease to exist.

Exactly. Thank you for being so succinct 😂🤗

OP posts:
Lion400 · 23/02/2024 16:09

ilovesooty · 23/02/2024 12:42

As it stands no vote for him

Your vote stands entirely on that single issue. You have to accept that other people make their decision on a range of issues and that's a perfectly valid viewpoint.

‘You have to accept that other people make their decision on a range of issues and that's a perfectly valid viewpoint’

Absolutely. People make their own decisions based on the information they have and the way they interpret / use / analyse that information. That is the great thing about living in a free country.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 23/02/2024 16:07

If men can be women there is no such thing as women's rights. They cease to exist.

Lion400 · 23/02/2024 16:06

All women’s rights are impacted if ‘men can be women’. It’s not hard to understand.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 16:05

Cazpar · 23/02/2024 15:39

Not particularly. It happens to anyone who goes even slightly against the grain in any topic. But to continue in the GC vein, I've noticed it happening to you an awful lot on FWR, even though I think you've made some excellent points. You're just not quite in line with the majority view, therefore your posts must be policed (except it's not policing when the right posters are doing it of course, only the wrong ones).

Thank you :) Apologies for misinterpreting your post.
I think in this case the OP often starts threads in the same vein and some of us are a bit bruised by it.

Lion400 · 23/02/2024 16:03

@NoMoreFalafelsForYou

‘Womens rights are not just one issue and so it's madness to me that people would vote on one single issue ..’

This doesn’t make any sense.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 23/02/2024 15:40

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 23/02/2024 15:26

Women’s rights are not ‘a single issue’
No, they're not, that's the point!
Yet still you get people voting on just this issue, or dismissing other important things like menopause (can't be discussed without conflating a thread with yet another trans one)
Or childcare costs etc, making it easier for women to go out to work
Or anti abortion protesters harassing women outside clinics despite being promised buffer zones so they feel safer.
Or Sure start centres closing which were so good when mine were small, toddler groups and a community hub, somewhere you could go and get yourself out of the house and feel more human some days.
Etc
Womens rights are not just one issue and so it's madness to me that people would vote on one single issue even if it means maybe threatening several other rights for women.

Well said.

Cazpar · 23/02/2024 15:39

AdamRyan · 23/02/2024 15:26

I assume you mean "ultra GC" by the right side.
😴

Not particularly. It happens to anyone who goes even slightly against the grain in any topic. But to continue in the GC vein, I've noticed it happening to you an awful lot on FWR, even though I think you've made some excellent points. You're just not quite in line with the majority view, therefore your posts must be policed (except it's not policing when the right posters are doing it of course, only the wrong ones).

ilovesooty · 23/02/2024 15:38

Lion400 · 23/02/2024 15:13

Women’s rights are not ‘a single issue’.

If males are unquestionably allowed to enter any and all female spaces (spaces used as defined earlier, for ease of ref), this has a potential impact on all of the females in all of those areas. Be it schools, hospitals, prisons, sports, sports centres, any competition that has a female category, domestic violence facilities, work places, any public facility, any literature referring to women, the list is endless.

That is the way we would be heading with that ‘single issue’. And that is why it is important to me. And that is why it is important to many other women.

That's the way you feel. Other women might come to their decision differently.