Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To draw your attention to this absolutely shocking medical scandal...

34 replies

Tenegrief · 22/02/2024 10:34

I heard about this because I know someone who has been affected. Posting here for traffic.

All the terrible details are in this Guardian article:
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/feb/22/the-mothers-fighting-a-scandal-bigger-than-thalidomide-we-were-told-the-medication-was-safe
But, in summary, pregnant women with Epilepsy have been prescribed a drug which was known to cause harm to babies in the womb. Despite the drugs company, NHS and government knowing about it for a very long time, and regardless of the tireless campaigning of the people affected, the drug has continued to be prescribed with often devastating consequences. The article above states that an average of 3 babies a month are born affected... So, if you know an epileptic woman who is TTC or pregnant please make them aware.

The mothers fighting a scandal bigger than thalidomide: ‘We were told the medication was safe’

Since the 1970s, it has been known that sodium valproate can harm babies in the womb. So why was it prescribed to pregnant women?

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/feb/22/the-mothers-fighting-a-scandal-bigger-than-thalidomide-we-were-told-the-medication-was-safe

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rarewaxwing · 22/02/2024 23:23

@innerdesign - thanks, that makes sense. I did wonder about the impact on males at the time Epilim was prescribed to DS, but pushed it to the back of my mind because getting his epilepsy under control was a priority. I'm glad I'm aware of the possible risk factors now, however.

MargaretThursday · 22/02/2024 16:22

I remember my Mum's friend talking about this in the 80s. She was epileptic and had been told that if she wanted to conceive she'd have to come off the medication for at least 6 months beforehand.
She had come to ask Mum if she would check on her because her husband was going to be away for a couple of nights and she was scared about fitting on her own.

innerdesign · 22/02/2024 16:13

@PauliesWalnuts @Rarewaxwing please note the dates on the articles. That warning was issued in 2023. Lots of information on medicines comes to light in the post-marketing period, clinicians don't (generally) set out to cause harm but it's impossible to do trials in pregnant women due to ethics, and difficult to do trials on paternal exposure due to numbers/timing of conception/follow up period needed to identify developmental difficulties.

ThePure · 22/02/2024 15:48

Yea guidance for males is new this year
This risk (for males) was not known about 10 or even 5 years ago.

Rarewaxwing · 22/02/2024 15:46

Patchworksack · 22/02/2024 15:05

It now has to have the agreement of two consultants to prescribe to anyone under 50 because of concerns it may affect offspring of males on SV too.

Is this a very new requirement? My son was prescribed Epilim by a single consultant two or three years ago.

Rarewaxwing · 22/02/2024 15:44

I had no idea this could possibly affect children through males as well. I don't think my son was given any warning about this.

Ratherstandonacliffandsetfiretomyself · 22/02/2024 15:16

I also work in mental health, not in prescribing or even clinical but I do deal with patient safety alerts and can confirm the guidance around contraception/not being given to women of childbearing potential has been around for years (and been followed to the letter in my area at least)

Not SV but I was prescribed topiramate (another epilepsy drug) for alleged EUPD - turns out I’m autistic so it didn’t help but regardless I was told absolutely not to get pregnant under any circumstances and if an accident did happen I would have to terminate the pregnancy.

PauliesWalnuts · 22/02/2024 15:08

God this makes me angry. The decision my brother and his partner had to make was utterly heartbreaking.

notreadyandable · 22/02/2024 15:05

My eldest is 25. I was on epilim from the age of 17 to 43. All through my child bearing years. Neither my GP, my neurologist, my midwife or the obstetrician warned me about that medication that I was taking. They took me off it at 43 'just in case you get pregnant'.

Patchworksack · 22/02/2024 15:05

It now has to have the agreement of two consultants to prescribe to anyone under 50 because of concerns it may affect offspring of males on SV too.

KnowledgeableMomma · 22/02/2024 14:59

I'm not in the UK but I've worked in a sub-unit of Neurology since 2011 and that medication has always had a black box warning since at least then. If a female was not on at least 2 contraceptive/preventatives, then they tried different meds. Not everyone can switch however, so they were definitely warned of the consequences should they become pregnant while on that drug.

Mydustymonstera · 22/02/2024 14:43

I was on this from 2002-4 as a chaotic 20 something, I don’t remember a single warning about or discussion of pregnancy and it’s only by sheer luck I’m not in the position of the women in this article.

CheesecakeandCrackers · 22/02/2024 14:31

Back in 2004 I was given a really clear warning and then had additional consultation appts when I decided to try and get pregnant. I was told to stop taking meds for a period before and duration of my pregnancy so I was interested to see that may have been down to a few particularly engaged consultants over the years rather than standard

TigerRag · 22/02/2024 14:19

Ohnoohohhoohh · 22/02/2024 11:23

There are a lot of drugs where if you're a woman of child bearing age you are put on birth control at the same time. They simply will not prescribe it if you're sexually active without birth control. I believe this is one of those medications

I've been on a few where this is the case. The first thing the GP checked was whether I was thinking about having children.

PauliesWalnuts · 22/02/2024 14:16

I'm not sure if I'm being a bit stupid, but is there any chance medication can pass through the father's sperm? My brother had severe epilepsy and took Epilim for a very long time before being moved to Tegretol - his partner became pregnant and their scan showed that the foetus had spina bifida and hydrocephalus. They ended up terminating the pregnancy as they wouldn't have been able to cope.

My brother also wasn't informed about the impact of epilepsy medication on bone density, and ended up with terrible osteoporosis. He died of SUDEP.

CurbsideProphet · 22/02/2024 14:16

I was diagnosed in 2004 and explicitly told I wouldn't be prescribed SV in case I became pregnant. It's been shocking to me how many Consultants continued to prescribe it to women.

I wish the newspapers would start reporting on the current difficulty in getting prescriptions for certain epilepsy medications filled.

DailyEnergyCrisis · 22/02/2024 14:10

Definitely included as part of my pharmacy degree from 2001-2005 and the medication boxes clearly labelled too.

NotanotherboxofFrogs · 22/02/2024 14:06

Valporate is a major factor in my choosing not to have children. When I got together with my partner, we discussed having children after a while together, we were both on depakote as mood stabilizers. I'd been on it for 14 years at that point, he was around the 10 year mark.

Our own research informed us that any potential baby would most likely have the odds stacked against them even before they were born especially with both of us taking it. We both tried to discuss with the consultant psychiatrist who felt we were "reading too much into it" and you "can't believe things you read online".

We have both been moved off it in recent years, the decision to wean off it was taken out of my hands and was taken off it over a matter of weeks which threw my mental health off out of control completely. Partner was moved slowly to lithium, I'm now on carbmazapine. It showed us the massive chasm between men's and women's mental health care.

But obviously we were reading too much into info sourced from online but when we asked for the option to change medication, it was a straight no way.

HoppingPavlova · 22/02/2024 13:54

So, it seems it was a lottery - if your GP/midwife/pharmacist was aware of the risks with this drug, you may have been told but, if not, you wouldn't have been. Which is a tragic scandal.

Nope. I can’t speak for midwives but all Dr’s and pharmacists have had this information for donkeys years. The problem has been some patients are not really in the space to absorb the information they are given for various reasons; or it fell through the gaps with GP’s thinking the specialties who initiate will take care of that aspect and the GP’s thinking the initiating specialties will have gone through it; or in some cases decisions were basically unilaterally made for patients that taking it was the lessor of two evils (not endorsing it or saying it was right but I definitely observed this in situations decades ago.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/02/2024 13:43

If you use the brand name, a lot of people who were prescribed it fir bipolar won't realise it concerned them.

Mind you, when I picked up a first prescription for somebody, I asked if the patient information leaflet was in the not original box and the pharmacist said she didn't need it and if it went in the boxes, the person won't take their meds. 2008, that was.

Theredjellybean · 22/02/2024 13:36

As said up thread the advice that women use two contraceptive methods while on SV has been in use for a long time.
MHRA warning to doctors went out years ago.
GP are supposed to keep a register of patients with epilepsy, and these patients are supposed to have yearly review with their consultant.
It falls through the gap who of these two groups are responsible for reminding the patient about contraceptive needs...plus there is the personal responsibility of you have been told and you choose to ignore the advice

PoppingCandles · 22/02/2024 13:26

My friend with epilepsy has 2 children with asd/adhd. Ages 12/10
Both slow to walk and talk. I would say one may have the features.
I know she said the paed thought maybe the epilepsy meds (though i dont know which one she was on)
But even with the speech delay there was no early intervention.
There was no quick referral for asd etc abd this is pre covid...

So it is not JUST that government or nhs have allowed people to continue to be prescribed meds but that there is little support.
And really no wonder kids are waiting so long for asd diagnoses when kt doesnt even get rushed through when the chances might be up to 46%. And obviously higher for younger sibling of asd child.
So the costs to the families, nhs and education.
Where children may need sen schools. Plus mums unable to work full time.

Also the obvious if it was said after dc1 then many would have come off the meds for dc2. Or not had a second child.

And when children are young the parents think the dc will perhaps grow out of issues. (Which could still happen) but easier to prepare if you know if its likely or not.

My dc have some sen. It would be easier to have known. And also less blame on parenting.

Also we know the pill goes into our water supply. What is the likelihood of drugs like this being in our drinking water. Men will still be prescribed.

If as in the article a mum had 5? Kids while on the meds, what would the costs have been. But also the impacts on the possibly small primary or secondary school.

People take risks havong kids but decisions would iffer for most if such high risks were known

ThePure · 22/02/2024 12:51

Currently there are very strict controls in place on prescribing valproate to women of child bearing age. Similar to Roaccutane.

In the early 2000s when I was a junior Dr it was certainly known that these medications were teratogenic and should not be prescribed to pregnant women but there was not the statutory regulatory framework in place to stop Drs doing it/ ensure patients were warned. It was clear they ought to be warned but not really clear that they actually were warned or whether patients really understood the seriousness. No-one would have prescribed it to anyone who was pregnant or planning a pregnancy but there was a lack of appreciation of how many pregnancies are not planned.

I remember that as a registrar after one of our patients had a baby who was affected I went on a bit of a crusade to get women off valproate or at least get them on long acting contraception but my (largely male) consultants thought I had a bit of a silly bee in my bonnet about it. They knew the risks but they just didn't think it was so important vs controlling seizures or mania or they thought the women should be more personally responsible about not getting pregnant and did not see it as the prescribing Drs issue. The people we were seeing were often vulnerable learning disabled (association with seizures) or chronically mentally ill (mood stabiliser) and I felt it was unrealistic to think they would always protect themselves even if they were informed. It's a good drug for what it's good for but there was a period where it was overprescribed for the wrong indications as well. I am so glad it is properly regulated now.

Tenegrief · 22/02/2024 12:31

Interesting responses. The article seems to suggest that there was no warning on the drugs (intentionally, because it might cause 'needless anxiety'), hence the government agreeing to a programme of compensation for those affected. The person I know, for example, who's 14 year old son is profoundly affected, was not warned or told not to take the drug when pregnant. So, it seems it was a lottery - if your GP/midwife/pharmacist was aware of the risks with this drug, you may have been told but, if not, you wouldn't have been. Which is a tragic scandal.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread