Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Overheard nanny speaking to DS

93 replies

AlmostCutMyHairToday · 22/02/2024 09:08

Our 2.5yr DS had a meltdown this morning after we did the handover with a new-ish nanny (it's her third day). I was upstairs and could overhear her saying, sternly, not to cry and that mummy/daddy won't come unless he stops crying, mummy/daddy said they don't like it when he cries as it's too loud.

It makes me really sad and uncomfortable, and that's not the way we parent. During the interview we were clear about our parenting approach, and how we never say 'stop crying', etc. We accept all feelings and set boundaries around actions - eg being sad/angry is ok, but hitting is not, etc. We give him space to feel, let the meltdown run its course, and comfort him when he asks to be comforted. If it's a really bad meltdown we use distraction techniques. We don't threaten, we don't abandon, etc.

I'll be speaking to her later when I'm home, and things have calmed down, but I was wondering if anyone has tips on how best to approach this with her. I have had issues in the past with nannies saying they understand the gentle parenting approach, but then reverting to what they normally do/the parenting style they grew up with.

Am I being deluded to think it's possible to change someone's approach? Or has anyone had success with this? She's quite a bit older, and very experienced.

It's complicated by the fact that it's hard to find a nanny that speaks my native language (which we're trying to teach to DS), so would be tricky to replace her, but we will if she doesn't change.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 22/02/2024 17:49

Forget the language bit. Find someone else.

I agree with a pp who says the entire ethos of this nanny is clear, and unacceptable.

If she would speak sharply and in those terms to the child when she thought you might be within earshot, what would she do when she knows you're nowhere near?

I have worked as a nanny - the handover is always tricky and the level of crying and general misery is unpredictable from one day to the next. Someone who is frustrated by crying, wailing, or screaming for mummy at handover time isn't as experienced as she says she is, takes the crying personally (interprets it as personal rejection), doesnt have confidence in her own ability to manage the situation and end up with a peaceful, happy, child (she panics, in other words), and doesn't appreciate that small children are doing the absolute best they can every minute of the day.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 22/02/2024 17:42

TunnocksOrDeath · 22/02/2024 17:38

This person outright lied to a child about what the parents" response to that child's distress would be. And they did it in order to make their own working day a tiny bit easier. This person has no business working with children.

Well said

Infinity234 · 22/02/2024 17:41

Lassiata · 22/02/2024 10:00

I would fire anyone who told my child that I wouldn't come to them because they were crying. Or that he wasn't allowed to be upset. Total dealbreaker.

Same. I work with young children and would never do this, we would comfort and reassure that mummy will be back later for them and has just gone to do some jobs etc.

mathanxiety · 22/02/2024 17:39

You should fire her.

This is all kinds of wrong.

TunnocksOrDeath · 22/02/2024 17:38

This person outright lied to a child about what the parents" response to that child's distress would be. And they did it in order to make their own working day a tiny bit easier. This person has no business working with children.

Birdsworth · 22/02/2024 17:18

I'm not a 'gentle parent' and there is absolutely no way I would say those things to any child.

I would have asked her to leave straight away.

CroccyWoccy · 22/02/2024 16:42

Not the right fit for you.

As well as hqving a completely different approach to dealing with behaviour, invoking you as part of threat would have got my back up.

It’s one thing if she’d said that e.g. she doesn’t like the loud noise, but it’s particularly out of order to cast you as the bad guy.

And as an experienced nanny with a particular style she should have flagged this before you took her on.

Ariona · 22/02/2024 16:33

I wouldn't have liked that either! Finding a good nanny is like gold dust. I'm a sahm now because I've had quite a few and tbh if they are in sole charge you never know what really happens. Not all, but a lot. I worked PT so I could also hear what's going on at home and even the nicest and best nannies just had something an issue too. My very best nanny who absolutely adored my children thought it very normal to test whether food was hot or not by taking a lick of the baby's spoon and then putting it in her mouth 🤮. Never thought I needed to ask someone not to do that but apparently it was. The fact that your nanny did this loudly not bothered that you were home, makes me think that this is normal to her. It really makes you consider what may be normal to some and not acceptable to you, and what you don't know goes on while you weren't there. I wouldn't keep her just because she knows your native language.

TheSquareMile · 22/02/2024 16:31

@AlmostCutMyHairToday

Which language are you teaching to your son, OP?

Caffeineislife · 22/02/2024 16:28

I would say the nanny is not a good fit for your family and your parenting approach and look for a new one.

The fact you have had so many nanny's possibly means you will need to compromise either with the language or the discipline approach.

I'm wondering if speakers of your native language typically have a more authoritarian approach to discipline and therefore finding someone who speaks the language and has the same approach to discipline may be tricky.

Somuchgoo · 22/02/2024 16:13

Fundays12 · 22/02/2024 16:07

She probably isn't a good fit for your parenting style and does sound like she isn't a great nanny. Just as a side note unless your ds is autistic they did not have a meltdown they had a tantrum. Please don't confuse the 2. They are very different things and need dealt with differently.

Whilst I agree that meltdowns are different to tantrums, and it was likely a tantrum here, autism doesn't have a monopoly on meltdowns.

My eldest has many tantrums and one meltdown. They were very different. No autism.

My youngest has meltdowns frequently. Not autistic. She does however have a brain injury.

This is a side point though that maybe should be discussed elsewhere.

HelpMebeok · 22/02/2024 16:09

I think it will be hard for her to change but I would be very clear about what is acceptable to you and not acceptable and let her know it's a deal breaker and see what she says.

ArchetypalBusyMum · 22/02/2024 16:09

Lassiata · 22/02/2024 10:00

I would fire anyone who told my child that I wouldn't come to them because they were crying. Or that he wasn't allowed to be upset. Total dealbreaker.

Couldn't agree more.

Demanding a child stifles their upset by making them feel ashamed and fearful mummy or daddy won't come because they don't approve. 😡 How dare she.

Making yourself not appear upset doesn't not mean you are not upset, it just means you've learnt to put out an acceptable front... Utterly useless for the child, might make the adults more comfortable because they don't have to see it.

For a 2 yo that's a big ask as well as a damaging response to upset. There is nothing constructive about it.
All you need to do is help them through the upset, and then, if needed, reflect on it in an age appropriate way. Be their safe harbour while the emotions pass through. It's not difficult.

BurbageBrook · 22/02/2024 16:08

It would put my right off the nanny and think she's not the right fit for the family. Saying 'stop crying' is really poor. Doesn't sound like she put much effort into helping him with his emotions.

Fundays12 · 22/02/2024 16:07

She probably isn't a good fit for your parenting style and does sound like she isn't a great nanny. Just as a side note unless your ds is autistic they did not have a meltdown they had a tantrum. Please don't confuse the 2. They are very different things and need dealt with differently.

TheSquareMile · 22/02/2024 16:03

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 22/02/2024 16:00

Norland nannies are pretty old fashioned. OP is not looking for an old fashioned approach.

That's true. I was trying to think of a reputable agency which might be able to offer a nanny meeting the specific language requirement.

Which agency would you suggest?

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 22/02/2024 16:00

Norland nannies are pretty old fashioned. OP is not looking for an old fashioned approach.

TheSquareMile · 22/02/2024 16:00

Could you approach Norland to ask whether they have a nanny on their books who could meet your particular needs?

https://www.norland.ac.uk/norland-agency/

Josette77 · 22/02/2024 14:37

Former nanny and I would never speak to a child that way. It would be a red flag to me as a mom.

That said if you've had 3+ nannies, that would be a red flag to me as a nanny.

MaverickBoon · 22/02/2024 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well, presumably yes, hence the post!

I agree with everyone saying this sounds like not the right fit for your family, OP. FWIW I also agree with posters noting that it's rare that a nanny will completely reproduce your exact parenting style, and that's not always a bad thing, but the shouting and telling a 2.5yr old that they can't cry is a definite red flag for me!

Seagrassbasket · 22/02/2024 13:49

I think that was a really quite cruel thing to say and I would be furious and sacking her.

I am interested however as are some other posters - is this the third nanny you’ve had for the 2.5 yr old? If so while I don’t think you’re unreasonable here then I assume there are other aspects of working with you that are difficult. And a constant merry go round of carers really isn’t good for your son’s well-being.

I also think you’d be far better not focusing on the language - the child won’t learn English if all he hears is your native tongue. Surely it’s better to grow up bilingual? And easier to find a nanny that meets all other requirements…..

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 22/02/2024 13:46

It is the native language that is an issue in finding a nanny with your parenting style.
Finding someone with the same parenting style as you is not easy, and by insisting they have to know your native language you are majorly restricting the pool of candidates.

Frangipanyoul8r · 22/02/2024 13:45

If she’s threatening a 2.5 year old in order for them to stop crying it sounds like she absolutely doesn’t know what she’s doing. What threats does she have in store for your child not eating… for toilet accidents etc…

Get rid now.

Herewegoagain84 · 22/02/2024 13:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Doesn’t matter if she’s a gentle parent or not. The nanny’s behaviour was cruel and unacceptable for any child.

Herewegoagain84 · 22/02/2024 13:39

Irisrosedaisy · 22/02/2024 10:20

My personal view is that gentle parenting is gentle parenting: it isn’t gentle nannying or gentle teachers or gentle nursery workers.

Nannies can be more personal of course but I do think it does children good to have a range of approaches to behaviour (bar abusive of course.)

I think it’s fine to ask her not to but I’m unsure if you and DH were in the house and working at this point. Working from home with a young child there is very difficult for everybody I think.

Yes but this isn’t whatever the alternative to gentle parenting is either. It’s vile to speak to a child that way - telling them mummy won’t come if you cry because she doesn’t like it. There’s firm and then there’s just fear-mongering.

Swipe left for the next trending thread