Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there have to be some clearer reasons for the rise in school attendance problems?

257 replies

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 07:52

Inspired by this article https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers/

How specifically has the pandemic affected things? Why is the environment so inhospitable to the neurodivergent?

The plight of Britain's school-refusers

https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 22/02/2024 10:10

@ShareTheDuvet with respect, what you're talking about is a million miles from EBSA. A child who would sooner be elsewhere but "doesn't mind going" is like the holy grail for parents dealing with EBSA.

I teach secondary. It's actually the work of a moment to pop the PowerPoint I'm using in class onto a chat message for an absent pupil, or upload everything to the Team, which I often do anyway so all have access to materials. Flexible teaching like that is not so unachievable and actually, were there the funding and the will, a member of admin staff could be used to collate resources each week for each pupil identified as persistently absent but wanting to learn, like my own child was, and have them available for collection at reception if internet access was an issue. I was told anything like this was "normalising and encouraging" absence. They'd rather she sat at home staring into space...because this came alongside the advice to remove all screens, pets, heating and nice food. 🙄

Newtonianmechanics · 22/02/2024 09:53

JackieO22 · 22/02/2024 08:28

I feel the effect of the pandemic has been hugely underestimated when it comes to kids mental health. I don't feel the same, can completely understand why many kids don't. Imagine going from everyday life to suddenly being at home, separated from friends, people talking about covid, hospitals, dying - hard enough for adults let alone kids. My teen DS has never been the same. Actually said to me 'why worry about school because we will all just get old and die' - he was never like this before. He tells me many of the kids have been really disruptive and lots of teachers left and are still leaving - covid turned the world upside down. Plus DH and me both had covid in 2020, DH had life threatening side effects. And we expect kids to go back to school as if nothing happened.... I wish I knew how we could help. I fear for DS future, I don't know if he'll ever hold down a job
..

I agree imagine thinking your grandparents may die or even your parents. The stress on the psych of some kids is horrendous. Yes a lot coped but at a young age age your world turned upside down hearing people dying course it will have an affect. That's without the effect of covid itself and lockdowns.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 09:51

@HeBeaverandSheBeaver its not a question for some parents of “choosing” it. There are a small but not insignificant number of children who come from very chaotic and dysfunctional backgrounds where parents have a very challenging relationship with schools and these children are also swept up in the school absence stats. It’s not solely about ND children being badly failed sadly 🙁.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 09:48

@Antsinmypantsneedtodance but that would be a logistical nightmare to manage 1500 kids doing that and also delivering meaningful education in school.

Whst is needed are far smaller schools but this has a huge resource implication. And no one wants their taxes raised 🙁.

alloalloallo · 22/02/2024 09:47

We had major issues with my younger daughter and school avoidance.

She had a mental health breakdown in the first lockdown so Covid certainly exacerbated it, but she was having issues pre-covid.

IMO, mainly down to unmet needs and horrendous (diagnosed) social anxiety. She is autistic, severely dyslexic and has some other stuff going on as well.

  • Her pupil passport/reasonable adjustments being ignored/not followed
  • GCSEs being wholly unsuited to her style of learning - she’s doing a level 3 Diploma at college now and is thriving
  • Sensory issues - strict adherence to an uncomfortable school uniform with no consideration for pupils like DD with sensory needs. Not being allowed to use ear plugs/ear defenders, despite them being included in her pupil passport and reasonable adjustments. Having fidget toys/stress balls confiscated, again, despite them being included in her pupil passport and reasonable adjustments.
  • Over the top rules and strict adherence to the rules. DD thrives on rules and routine, however, some of the rules introduced by the school were quite mad and contradictory- for example, if you followed rule X, you inadvertently broke rule Y. She found it impossible to cope with. She hates getting into trouble and just couldn’t brush off a behaviour point - it would keep her awake half the night worrying about it.

Covid came along and she had a mental health breakdown, once school re-opened getting her back in for her final year was nigh-on impossible.

Shes now at college, it’s more relaxed, she can dress comfortably, she can wear her earplugs, after a bit of a bumpy start they follow her reasonable adjustments, she’s doing a different type of qualification (level 3 diploma) that’s more suited to her style of learning and she’s thriving - distinctions in all her work.

VickyEadieofThigh · 22/02/2024 09:47

Everydayimhuffling · 22/02/2024 08:17

It's the money. There's fewer teachers, and even fewer experienced teachers, so there's bigger and more chaotic classes. Fewer TAs and other support staff, so less support in school and fewer staff available to work with families to get kids in. Parental disengagement with higher stress levels in struggling families. Less social services and community support for families. Basically a bunch of bad policies coming home to roost.

Good summary, I think.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 22/02/2024 09:44

@BibbleandSqwauk

Has it right on the nose

No one chooses this. Or if they do it's a tiny tiny minority.
Most parents want their child to be able to do well and have a friendship group and get out in the world. Why would we choose this????

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 22/02/2024 09:42

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 09:15

@Antsinmypantsneedtodance how would flexi schooling work in reality for every child? I agree with the principle for those struggling but for the entire school it would be unworkable. My younger DS is in Y10, sees school as an interruption to his social life but doesn’t mind going, but if you offered him the chance to pick and choose when he went I guarantee you he wouldn’t go at all! How would that work? Not trying to be difficult - genuinely interested as I totally agree our schools don’t work anymore but without massive investment in staff and resources I don’t know how an alternative would either 🙁.

Flexischooling isn't an unofficial arrangement whereby a child goes in and out of school as they please. Its formalised with the school and agreed days. Some schools also require evidence of what's covered on those days. Or ask certain things to be covered. It allows a more holistic approach to education and learning. For some pupils, it may mean spending 1 day a week playing football to a high level, or painting or music. For others it may be taking time away from the hussle and bussle of school to focus on an area they've struggled to grasp in the classroom, taking time to learn it in a way that works for them. It won't work for all pupils for sure. But for quite a few it would. It needs to be an option.

The issue is at the moment schools just decline these requests. Even when faced with pupils with school refusal, SEN, neurodiversity or other challenges who are clearly struggling in the classroom 5 days a week. Flexi allows these pupils a balance. It also has so many benefits in teaching young people how to learn for themselves prior to further and higher education. Its not an extra day off school for a jolly.

Bobbybobbins · 22/02/2024 09:40

There are lots of intersecting reasons-

poor support for neurodivergent children, stricter behaviour rules in lots of schools, a more academic curriculum with fewer vocational options, pandemic with online learning and being told to stay home with any symptoms of illness, increase in home educating.

Iscreamtea · 22/02/2024 09:39

WishIwasElsa · 22/02/2024 08:52

Schools particularly high schools don't sound like a nice environment to be in. No wonder some children just can't deal with it. So many rules for no reason particularly uniform, no access to bathrooms, and nothing done about bullying.

I think people assume there are rules for no reason. I know my school crack down on uniform because it turns out that those children persistently not in correct uniform often have other issues going on that were flying under the radar. It has been a way to identify children that need more support.

The issues with bathrooms are never ending. Some teens choose to hang out in the toilets and intimidate others that try to come in. There just aren't enough staff to constantly monitor all the toilets. The children want to go to the toilet in lesson time because it feels safer, but that disrupts the lessons. One child going occasionally may not be a big deal but 20 going out of a lesson one after the other gets very disruptive. Also, some say they need the toilet just so that they can join the hordes truanting round the corridors. I'm not saying schools that close the bathrooms have got the right answer but I can see where it is coming from.

Tiny2018 · 22/02/2024 09:38

To the OP who asked if they even care, interesting you should mention this. As in my pp, my son's attendance hasn't been great. I received an email around December asking me to come in for a meeting regarding his attendance, I responded with convenient dates and times and never heard back.

I called him in sick on Tuesday and again today, though this morning asked the receptionist to please put me through to someone I could discuss his attendance with, she said nobody available.

So I am well on board with liaising with the school in relation to his poor attendance as there is valid reason but they don't appear to have the resources to see/hear from me regarding the poor attendance.

itsfinallytime · 22/02/2024 09:37

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 22/02/2024 08:38

It really is this. I have a school refuser, started with a breakdown self harm and lead to an ASD and ADHA diagnosis. But once we understood we were able to intervene. She is currently doing well in mainstream school again. ( it goes up and down sometimes for months at a time) the school have been fantastic.

but there are people who can’t be arsed to argue and do everything their children say.

Sometimes it used to take almost 2 hours to get her into school and sometimes we didn’t even make it out the door, but I never stopped trying and now her mental health is better , she is better. If I had allowed her to stop going to school completely during her bad times , she never would have gone again I don’t suppose and her future would look very different.

That's not the answer for all kids.

We kept going until our child started seriously trying to kill himself. The time he tried to throw himself in front of a gritter truck having jumped out of his bedroom window was the last time I tried to force him in to a harmful environment.

It did the opposite of building resilience.

He took several years to recover and missed out on all of high school because he was traumatised.

He now has 100% attendance at a mainstream 6th form and is doing well in his A levels and plans to go away to university in September.

Mainstream schools are not set up for neurodiverse children.

Many suitable schools / provisions were closed in the name of 'inclusion'.

GremlinsTwo12 · 22/02/2024 09:37

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 09:15

@Antsinmypantsneedtodance how would flexi schooling work in reality for every child? I agree with the principle for those struggling but for the entire school it would be unworkable. My younger DS is in Y10, sees school as an interruption to his social life but doesn’t mind going, but if you offered him the chance to pick and choose when he went I guarantee you he wouldn’t go at all! How would that work? Not trying to be difficult - genuinely interested as I totally agree our schools don’t work anymore but without massive investment in staff and resources I don’t know how an alternative would either 🙁.

It can't. When you have a third to 2/3 of year groups in some schools being identified as SEN it's impossible to make the adjustments required to meet every individual need.

I see many sides to this, having been a very anxious child in the late 80s who struggled with the transition to secondary and cried every day for the 1st term, had poor attendance as I'd fake illness to not go. Had I been given the option of homeschooling or just not going to school full stop, I would have taken it and then likely not ever returned. As it was, I did settle in after several months of being extremely distressed.

In adulthood I work in a field which is tied in to education and have seen the education system fail many but also seen in some cases, it make such adjustments and concessions that in my opinion the child/adolescent given such control over what they would or wouldn't do that the approach ultimately failed anyway because they were never able to become more resilient because they quickly opted out of any situation which caused uncomfortable feelings.

And there will always be some children/adolescents who just don't want to be in education regardless of how it is adjusted for them or they have such unreasonable expectations that it is unworkable.

There are no easy answers and in the meantime, teachers and schools are on their knees with ever increasing numbers of SEN children and not able to meet everyone's needs.

Flatpackedboxes · 22/02/2024 09:30

for my family the start of secondary coincided with Covid. Both children are now awaiting to be assessed for adhd/autism. (I was diagnosed last year, their dad is autistic). Looking back, the school we thought was best just...wasn't. Too big, too many strict rules, no flexibility, poor communication, sen department underfunded and overworked. We've had a suicide attempt, school avoidance, self harm, anorexia, CAMHS involvement. I withdrew one child for six months but kept the other on roll despite her not going for six months. I managed to find a smaller school and whilst there are some issues, they tend to work with us, not against us.

smaller, more flexible and well funded schools are the answer. (I think) however that isn't what the government want to hear.

Echobelly · 22/02/2024 09:28

I think because Covid inadvertantly show there was a way (albeit very imperfect) to do things without schools, those kids for whom school never 'worked' were left finding the thought they had to go back pretty untenable, and I understand that. I also know that their parents are really trying to help, they are not 'enabling' their kids to avoid school - I have 4 or 5 friends stuck in what seems like an endless battle trying to either get their kids into school or find some sort of alternative provision they can manage. And all of these kids are neurodiverse.

StormHawk · 22/02/2024 09:28

Are schools even bothered? DS hasn’t been to school for over two months. School doesn’t even ask where he is anymore and no effort is being made to get him back. I can only assume it’s easier for school him not being there.

purplepandas · 22/02/2024 09:27

Unmet need. It's impossible and soul destroying for all experiencing this. We are now funding an online school (wk 1) which is better for DD but so tricky with work. MH in tatters. Schools cannot manage. It's not bloody wishy washy parents, those articles that suggest this should spend a day (or more) in our shoes.

Iscreamtea · 22/02/2024 09:27

I don't think there is any one answer. It's a combination of a multitude of issues coming together, most of which come down to the decimation of public services which, it turns out, actually do benefit society as a whole when they are working properly. My, not exhaustive, list includes...

  1. Health: long covid will be having an impact. Also, I don't know what other people are finding, but in my experience with my children and work colleagues people just seem to be getting ill a lot more post covid. Of course you can't see a doctor very easily now so probably some illnesses that would have been quickly treated are now being left to rumble on. Also, long term health conditions that are not being properly treated due to waiting lists.
  1. Mental health: I work in a secondary school and the number of children really struggling with anxiety is horrifying. Getting help seems to be a bit of a lottery but the situation has to be pretty dire to get any.
  1. Behaviour: behaviour in schools is a huge issue. The parents don't care/blame the school/are trying their best but there's little support. The kids are undiagnosed ND (waiting lists, gatekeeping)/struggling with mental health/feral.
  1. Underfunded schools: schools are pulling off miracles with insufficient funding but even that isn't enough any more. Teachers are leaving in droves and it's become very difficult to recruit new ones. Many lessons are being covered by supply. The children run wild in those lessons and do no work. It becomes an extremely unpleasant environment for children (apart from the few causing chaos) and staff.
  1. Underfunded social services: anyone who works with children will tell you that many children are neglected but they get left with their families until the situation is catastrophic. It does so much damage.
  1. COL: stressed parents make the best decisions they can. Sometimes that means going to work to keep the roof over their heads and food on the table rather than spending time getting reluctant teens to school.
  1. Covid: everything changed after covid.
Bluevelvetsofa · 22/02/2024 09:25

@DrRuthGalloway is right.

The ridiculous and constantly changing hoops that Ofsted insists upon have developed an anxious and stressed workforce. Inevitably that translates to a results focused regime and nurturing environments fall by the wayside.

That, coupled with everything previous posters have mentioned, has created a perfect storm.

GoldDuster · 22/02/2024 09:18

Because the education system is no longer fit for purpose, and if you spent a few days as a fly on the wall of many schools you'd have the answer to your question.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 09:16

@DrRuthGalloway totally agree. Covid is part of a much bigger more complex problem sadly.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 09:15

@Antsinmypantsneedtodance how would flexi schooling work in reality for every child? I agree with the principle for those struggling but for the entire school it would be unworkable. My younger DS is in Y10, sees school as an interruption to his social life but doesn’t mind going, but if you offered him the chance to pick and choose when he went I guarantee you he wouldn’t go at all! How would that work? Not trying to be difficult - genuinely interested as I totally agree our schools don’t work anymore but without massive investment in staff and resources I don’t know how an alternative would either 🙁.

DrRuthGalloway · 22/02/2024 09:15

Noicant · 22/02/2024 09:12

I often think research lags behind practitioner exoerience in these areas.

It would need to be UK based to be fully pertinent anyway

We were already in a MH crisis that began picking up around 2017. Camhs referrals for anxiety skyrocketed between '17 and '19, then again post covid. Gove curriculum is fundamental in my opinion.

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 09:12

Very sorry for everyone going through this.

OP posts:
Noicant · 22/02/2024 09:12

There is some research out there about school refusal

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10071931/

https://utdanningsforskning.no/contentassets/fea98fafada94781b1946096acae60f7/1-s2.0-s1077722918300427-main.pdf

Theres more out there to look at.