Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there have to be some clearer reasons for the rise in school attendance problems?

257 replies

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 07:52

Inspired by this article https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers/

How specifically has the pandemic affected things? Why is the environment so inhospitable to the neurodivergent?

The plight of Britain's school-refusers

https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 22/02/2024 11:04

@ShareTheDuvet apologies if I misread but I'm not sure why you would reference your son's situation on a thread like this if not to compare and say "look, all kids would rather not go really but most do so it must be the parents being weak". If I was wrong I apologise but I hope you can understand it comes from a place of such frustration at being constantly told that the issue lies with the parenting, or lack of and whilst in some case that's true, it's not at all the case for EBSA. I think any discussion of school absence in the media or anywhere else should focus very clearly on what kind of absence they are talking about.

leccybill · 22/02/2024 11:04

Money - we're 14 years into a govt that does not care about state education.

Unmet needs - SEND schools are full.

Pandemic - the genue is out of the bottle now, won't ever go back in. The govt said home schooling was an acceptable alternative so now it is.

taxguru · 22/02/2024 11:00

Lots of factors over the past 50 years have contributed to the perfect storm we see today:-

1- School sizes - we have fewer and bigger secondary schools making it harder for those who struggle with noise, crowds, etc. It also makes it more likely to need transport to schools further away, making kids suffer the often awful conditions of noise, disruption and bullying on school buses.

2- Comps - we used to have different types of school for different (broadly) types of children, i.e. grammar for academic and technical/sec mod for non academic. That meant kids could, generally, go to a school more suited to them. With comps, you're fitting square pegs in round holes - no academic kids are forced to do academic stuff they're not interested in and incapable of, at a young age, and only allowed to choose subjects they are interested in for GCSE years, by which time, many have lost interest and become disenfranchised.

3-Subjects havn't changed with the times. We're still teaching things to memorise, facts to learn, which is bad enough for those academically able, but painful for those who aren't. In Maths, there's no point trying to teach pythagoras or simultaneous equations to kids who havn't mastered the basics. Same with English trying to teach Shakespeare to kids who can barely read or write. Kids who struggle to learn will soon become bored and disruptive.

4-Lack of discipline - teachers seem frightened to discipline kids, so some classrooms become warzones with disruption, noise, etc., which are obviously harder for "quiet" children to cope with.

5-Classroom layout. Quiet kids are generally happier working on their own, on a single desk, all facing the same way, and not in the clusters/groups of modern classroom design.

Quite simply, it's mostly down to bad behaviour which affects "quiet" children the most, who need a quiet and calm environment, whether in the classroom or the school bus. A few decades ago, poor behaviour wasn't tolerated and was nipped in the bud, maybe helped by smaller schools, so the noise/disruption wasn't so bad.

Newtonianmechanics · 22/02/2024 10:59

stevebheadteacher.wordpress.com/2023/08/29/school-on-fire/

gamerchick · 22/02/2024 10:58

For one it's not 'school refusal ' it's barriers to attendance. Wording is important. Modern schools aren't set up for ND kids, back in my day is was individual desks all facing forward. Much more suited to ND kids rather than round a table facing and being close to each other. COVID brought things to a head when kids were shown that going into school isn't the only thing available and education is falling apart at the seams due to underfunding and shit government.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 10:57

hiredandsqueak · 22/02/2024 10:54

@SleepWhenAmDead Alderwasley Hall possibly High Grange both in Derbyshire and Brantwood Specialist School in Sheffield teach to ability as well.

I ave a friend who works at Brentwood. They don’t do much academic stuff.

MariaVT65 · 22/02/2024 10:56

Will be interesting to see if attendance goes back up with children too young or not born before lockdown.

CoffeeWithCheese · 22/02/2024 10:55

We also have it happening in adult learning disabilities - people who lost their routine of going out to the day service centres with lockdowns and then just couldn't cope with going back into that routine as things reopened.

hiredandsqueak · 22/02/2024 10:54

@SleepWhenAmDead Alderwasley Hall possibly High Grange both in Derbyshire and Brantwood Specialist School in Sheffield teach to ability as well.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 10:54

SleepWhenAmDead · 22/02/2024 10:42

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Sorry for detailing the thread.

Please could you let me know school where academically able ASD/ADHD can do A levels? Happy for dm. Have been looking nationally with no luck. Desperate. Will move anywhere.

Hi, it’s Sheffield.

Kenwood academy. It was just amazing.

l cried when l came out from looking round. The child who won’t speak to teachers chatted freely with the deputy head😮

So quiet and calm. They have a meltdown room, where they can just go if the get overwhelmed, they can leave class to make a drink. They take them to a local educational farm for animal therapy. But they all have to take a turn in the cafe and in serving customers ( with support if needed)

https://www.kenwoodacademy.co.uk/page/?title=KS5+Courses+%28Sixth+Form%29&pid=36

Icannoteven · 22/02/2024 10:53

I genuinely think that lockdown traumatised our children - at least for those of us in areas that were locked down for a long time and who didn’t qualify for school places under the key worker exemption.

They were pulled out of school with no warning. Their daily routine and learning was disrupted. They had their entire social network taken away without warning (like being grounded but for a REALLY long time) and an awful lot of their support network taken away too. I know in my children’s case they were also cut off from their family (for almost two years for us due to us living in areas which seemed to take turns being locked down - if it wasn’t us it was them) and had to cope with being ignored most of the day by their parents (because we were working from home, not eligible for furlough due to public sector status). I don’t know about anyone else’s kids but mine also had to deal with two very stressed parents who suddenly had more pressure in their life but no access to their usual support networks or outlets. I was on the verge of a mental breakdown.

For the youngest kids, their development was hugely affected. My smallest was 2 when we went into lockdown and was also in the shielding list. When shielding ended, it took her a long time to adjust to normal situations - she had never experienced a shopping centre or a party - she is still scared of situations where there are lots of kids and noise. She didn’t know what an escalator was.

Kids have been given no time to reflect, grieve and process what they experienced. Their trauma (and the parts of normal development and education they skipped) have not been addressed - they have been expected to act and perform as if they never went through any of this and the pandemic never existed.

Then we have all of the kids who are ill frequently because they are stuck in NHS waiting lists and missed out in routine care for their chronic conditions during the pandemic.

In addition, a lot of schools are implementing this bullshit slant nonsense (usually badly implemented). This is definitely a factor in school refusal.

It is a shitstorm. Locking down schools was the stupidest decision this government ever made. Backed by a population who let themselves be manipulated by fear and social control rather than use their brains.

mindutopia · 22/02/2024 10:52

I still think a bit part of it is down to parents who are struggling - with physical and mental health, with work and cost of living pressures, just being completely overwhelmed. It's not laziness, it's not being able to cope. A 16 year old in walking distance to school is one thing, but a 6 year old is something different. They need a parent to get them up, get them ready for school, and get them there.

I work in higher education, but we have staff crashing and burning left and right. People are off on long term sickness or working reduced hours (myself included) due to poor physical and mental health, burnout, stress. If parents aren't able to get themselves to work, they are equally going to struggle to get their children to school.

I had a parent who was like this - my mum's burnout/stress/poor mental health/general overwhelm really impacted my school attendance. She wasn't lazy. She was working like 50-60 hours a week, but the school run was just one thing too far after a point. She still managed to work and to get out the door on time and into the office on time and run the household, but she literally couldn't cope with getting me up and ready for school, so she just stopped doing it. I missed nearly a whole year of school (god only knows were SS was or why no one checked on me!). She would just get up and go to work and I'd wake up later alone having missed going to school (school was a good 20 minute drive away, no public transport, so I needed her to drive me there).

I think for some parents who are unwell and overwhelmed, just getting through the day means avoiding the aggro of a battle over getting to school. It may even be necessary if they are to get to work and keep their jobs.

TheWildWest · 22/02/2024 10:47

What parent in their own mind, apart from those who genuinely chose to HE, want their kids at home?
Most parents need to be at work.
There was a post recently on one of the school attendance forums from a parent who was having to section herself literally, because of the stress of her child not being able to attend school. Like others she had exhausted all avenues. It was heart breaking to read. She was crying out for help, asking how other parents managed having a child out of school, how they dealt with the stress of it all.
To read some of the lazy and ignorant replies on here, people should be ashamed and thank God they haven't had it inflicted on them.
These attitudes are exactly why the attendance figures are what they are. There is no help, understanding or support. It tears families apart, the stress of it all.

hiredandsqueak · 22/02/2024 10:43

For dd who was unable to attend before covid (hate the term school refuser) I'd say a complete disinterest in her needs and lack of care contributed greatly. She had an EHCP and had thrived in Primary, in Secondary they weren't interested in her need for support as academically she was high achieving and they felt others were more deserving of support despite the EHCP detailing specifically what support they must give.
Pre empting an Ofsted inspection school started enforcing multiple petty rules that dd never broke but the anxiety they induced became unbearable. Until dd was missing lots of days school were unwilling to make even minor adjustments that would have made it easier and were in keeping with the EHCP. When they finally decided they could help it was too late and dd never went back.
She started at an independent specialist just before lockdown and thrived.The school stayed open throughout so she had far less disruption to her schooling than the majority.

SleepWhenAmDead · 22/02/2024 10:42

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Sorry for detailing the thread.

Please could you let me know school where academically able ASD/ADHD can do A levels? Happy for dm. Have been looking nationally with no luck. Desperate. Will move anywhere.

Alwaysgiraffe · 22/02/2024 10:42

I think that adult sickness absences should also be no surprise. We were at one point told to isolate for up to 10 days at the possibility (due to close contact) of covid. I had to do this several times once schools returned due to pupils I teach testing positive, and this was despite a negative test from me.
I actually think it’s not a bad thing and perhaps in the long run we will all benefit from people actually staying off for a day or two when sick rather than dragging themselves in to work and coughing/sneezing over everyone and spreading their bug around.

Riverlee · 22/02/2024 10:41

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 08:08

The Ed pysc who reviewed my EBSA for an EHCP said that it broke the routine rather than it being ‘optional’

That they’d spent years getting up and going to school, and then stopped. And some couldn’t get back in the saddle again.

Its not casualness, it’s things being broken. He was rushed off his feet. Seeing 1000’s of kids. He probably knows more than you with your ‘casual’ comment.

My Ebsa was desperate to go to school. But couldn’t. She couldn’t cope with the stress. She’s ND. Conditions in schools are appalling. Students are just under so much pressure.

l was a secondary school teacher for 25 years. I hated seeing the stress of the kids.

Edited

Yes, ‘broken routine’ is probably a better way of describing it (and I never claimed to be an expert).

MariaVT65 · 22/02/2024 10:39

A couple of things spring out to me.

The article also refers to general attendance, not just ‘refusers’. My best friend has had an issue with her son’s primary school, where they send him home for every little thing, including claiming he had a rash that looked like chickenpox, even though he had already had it. The school also doesn’t record the difference between days when the parents have kept him off and when they have sent him home. I also had a childminder who sent my son home for every little thing, and I have to wonder if this has become worse since covid.

Something else I consider is actions taken regarding bullying. When I was at school, I was still made to attend school when I was being physically bullied. If my children are ever physically bullied once they start school, I wouldn’t hesitate to keep them off school until the issue is properly dealt with.

Hoplolly · 22/02/2024 10:33

My comment was wishy-washy and I stand by it! Not the majority but there are some feckless parents out there and there's no point pretending there isn't. There must be teachers on here that see it all the time. I have a friend who is a Head of Year in a school in a deprived area and getting the kids to actually attend school is a daily battle because of parental support (or lack of). Hence they pick their battles and behaviour gets ignored and they don't care if they're not in the right uniform because they're just glad they're in school at all.

I'm certainly not saying that it's the majority, and definitely not some of the parents on here who (as I said in my first post) have genuine needs. One of my best friends has a school refuser, and that's not her being wishy-washy, she's had to give up her job as she couldn't work due to it. Her son needed a different school and the LEA were no help so he spent 7 months out of school until they could get him in a suitable school. It was a super stressful time for all of them.

There was an article in a newspaper (Guardian maybe?) that cited some reasons and talked about "ghost children" who vanished from schools and education during the pandemic and are at risk of falling into crime or abuse. However stats also say this isn't a problem just with schools and children as adults also have more sickness absence now since the pandemic.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 10:31

@lollipoprainbow totally agree - it is regularly covered on our local news as we have one particular LA constantly in trouble for it, but I don’t think the vast majority of people who have no experience of the SEN issues around education really understand the complexities of it 🙁. The lack of specialist schools is a nightmare - but I also worry about the variable quality of some of the schools already in existence who think providing for SEN kids is a cash cow and it very much isn’t 😬.

Alwaysgiraffe · 22/02/2024 10:28

I’m not sure why school attendance dropping is a surprise to anyone. Yes the classrooms are more chaotic with fewer teachers and much less supports but you just need to read this forums to see that it’s not just children who have had this change in attitude. Prior to covid probably 90% of workers worked out of the home and now every week there are threads on here, articles in the news about people being incensed they are asked to return to the office x number of days a week.
Adults as well as children have had their attitudes changed to having to attend somewhere. Adults are willing to leave their jobs over being asked to go in 2-3 days a week, not even a full week. It should be no surprise that after the better part of 2 years being schooled at home is acceptable that both children and adults are not seeing in person school attendance as the gold standard any more.

CoffeeWithCheese · 22/02/2024 10:20

The break in the routine when we were in and out of restrictions cannot be understated. The power that "this is what happens on X day" has is massive. You lose that routine and it can be really difficult to get that impetus back - especially for families where school is a difficult place anyway, or people living more chaotic lives, or also the "wishy-washy" ones who can't face the argument (there - happy I included the wishy-washy very very very small sub quota?!)

The current thing that seems to have started with Michaela and Gove and all that shit to aspire to schools being silent Victorian-style bootcamps where all uniformity and slight resistance is stamped down on... HARD. If you're a kid like DD2 is, with various diagnoses explaining high anxiety and organisational difficulties - and you end up in a school where it's an automatic 30 minute detention for forgetting a ruler... you're completely fucked. You have the anxiety of wanting to follow all the rules, combined with the anxiety of not coping well with changes to your routine and random detentions being landed on you, and then you're wired for it to be incredibly incredibly difficult to meet those standards anyway... you are being set up to fail on multiple different fronts (and bloody hell I hope DD2 gets the school we've listed first on offers day where their solution is a locker provided, mentors from staff to support with building organisational skills, and the approach where she can leave multiple rulers in all her different classrooms)!

And there is an element of respect for teachers being at an all-time low, again, this is largely because of the behaviour of some very obnoxious loud voices during the pandemic. People haven't forgotten the way some rogue branches of teachers' unions referred to kids when schools reopening was being discussed... or the way some individual teachers behaved (such as one that one of my kids had - who literally carried a portable perspex screen around the classroom if she had to go in any proximity to a child). I'll freely admit that that was the point where I decided that I was no longer going to pay the price premium to avoid term-time holidays if required and that since society had viewed my kids' education as something they could stop and start on a whim - I was going to fuck off with them to Centerparcs for a few days mid-May without feeling bad about it (they're still among the highest percentage attenders in the school - so my rebellion was incredibly small!)

And there is the issue with access to diagnostic services for conditions such as ASD and ADHD... and access to child mental health services as a result. DD1 was self-harming briefly and school attempted to refer her for low-level mental health support - rejected because her difficulties may be indicative of ASD... but the waiting list for ASD is 2 1/2 years, and then CAMHS won't touch you in some areas if you're autistic - so where do the neurodivergent kids who are struggling go to access any help? We really seem to have moved to one step short of kicking any kids who don't fit the mould out of the system completely.

lollipoprainbow · 22/02/2024 10:18

It's a huge problem, I'm going through it with my autistic dd and the school unable to meet her needs and lack of specialist schools. The Facebook page 'not fine in school' with £50k members and growing highlights this. It needs to publicised in the mainstream media. We need a post office style drama on tv to highlight the problem.

DorothyZ · 22/02/2024 10:14

Terminology has changed too

I would consider myself to be a school refuser. I was labelled a bad kid who bunked off back in the 90s

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 10:14

@BibbleandSqwauk apologies, I’m confused about which point you’re talking about? It was my own son who I said doesn’t mind going to school - I wasn’t beginning to compare that to EBSA! That would be ridiculous.

The flexi schooling the PP was talking about was far more than “sticking a PowerPoint on an email”, much more complex. But please don’t pretend I was saying that not liking school is the same as EBSA - that’s so far from what I said and quite offensive.