Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there have to be some clearer reasons for the rise in school attendance problems?

257 replies

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 07:52

Inspired by this article https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers/

How specifically has the pandemic affected things? Why is the environment so inhospitable to the neurodivergent?

The plight of Britain's school-refusers

https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers

OP posts:
BallaiLuimni · 22/02/2024 15:30

If you demonstrate to a whole generation of children that the things they need in order to have fun, develop socially and thrive - friends, activities, visits to relatives, holidays, celebrations etc - can just be taken away for months on end by a bunch of feckless idiots who give no thought to the horrendous impact, then of course you create a generation of anxious, unwell, poorly socialised people. The fact that this was all done under the guise of 'staying safe' (with the accompanying cries of 'granny killer' to anyone who dares question it) makes it all the more horrendous

Anyone who supported lockdowns have no business moaning about this totally predictable fallout. My generation completely and utterly let the next generation down. It's shameful and it will never be fully repaired.

NImumconfused · 22/02/2024 15:18

The lack of mental health support is a massive issue, without doubt, especially for ND kids. Until we came into the system I would never have believed how awful it is.

We went through a term of trying and failing to get DD into school, got turned down by CAMHS first time round, eventually got accepted after submissions from her counsellor and educational welfare, it took 14 months from then till she was seen by anyone. Two years on from there, she has been diagnosed with autism, anxiety, OCD and PTSD, and still all she gets from them is a medication review every two or three months, and that's really only for the OCD. No therapy, nothing, even after an overdose all we got was a single phonecall from the crisis team.

What chance have you got of getting a child back into education if you can't even get help for that level of mental health distress?

honeylulu · 22/02/2024 15:18

Lots of kids dislike school especially if they are naturally anxious and/or neurodivergent. But before covid school was compulsory and that was that. A lot of kids didn't know refusing school was an option.

Then covid, no school for months. Starts looking optional. Plus anxiety rises. Plus many more parents wfh now so "you have to go to school because I have to go to work" doesn't have a much resonance. Plus schools are stretched to the limit in every way. Committment to addressing absence and massive increase in pupil MH issues means its just not possible to tackle it all effectively.

I think that covers the main reasons.

cansu · 22/02/2024 15:04

BrambleyHedge
There will be others who only go to some lessons. Others whose attendance is low and others who spend most of their time in the pastoral base. As a parent you will not necessarily be aware of the number of children whose parents have reported their child has anxiety issues and who are struggling with attendance. I have definitely seen friendship groups where there are several students all presenting in similar ways who are trying to support each other but are potentially making each other's attendance worse as they all spend hours together on the pastoral base or truanting lessons .

Dostadning · 22/02/2024 15:02

Christ, some of the comments under that article.

StaunchMomma · 22/02/2024 14:54

There has been a rise in mental health issues in kids, possibly sparked by Lockdown, potentially exacerbated by too much time on screens (both of which have been proved to cause depression in some kids - not judging, mine has too much time gaming, as do most, it seems).

Add to that the squeezing of funds to education under Tory rule, which has resulted in losing a huge number of TAs, SEN provision, never mind an increasing number of children being taught solely by insufficiently trained level 2 TAs because some schools either cannot recruit teachers or cannot afford to pay them, and the picture is not at all bright!

ND kids are routinely failed in schools and many parents saw that their ND kids were happier at home during lockdown. Under those circumstances, I would definitely consider home schooling.

It's not one thing, it's many things.

DyslexicPoster · 22/02/2024 14:38

OP to answer your questions. Covid both stopped socialisation of kids. Giving rise to the new chorus having issues. Which in turn raised a bug in SEN assessments. Plus some parents never their kids back to school, some couldn't handle going back.

See above as to why school is hostile to the ND. There are not enough professionals to assess, camhs is a two year wait. You get no help while you wait. It is a massive cist to LAs.

My eldest was a school refused pre covid. Attendance at 60%. Why? Undiagnosed SEN. We had a urgent referal to camhs that took 6 months wait and discharged at triage.

Camhs damages kids. There is no sweet spot in which they help. They are a chocolate teapot. I waited two years to get help gor my son with ASD strangling his little sister. He grew out of it before we got to the top of the list ( or he killed her).

hiredandsqueak · 22/02/2024 14:00

You would have to be inhuman to have forced dd in when EBSA was at its worst. I wouldn't despite being told by SENCo and called into multiple 9am meetings (I think they thought we stayed in bed) Dd was vomiting,hyperventilating, couldn't speak etc. I ignored all their "advice" to force her in,take her phone,switch off the internet, make home life uncomfortable and followed my instincts and nurtured her, formally complained to CAMHS to get ASD specific support and went to SENDIST to get the school that best met her needs. Strangely enough once in an environment that met her needs dd attended every day happily with no sign of EBSA.

Julen7 · 22/02/2024 13:58

AmyandPhilipfan · 22/02/2024 13:25

Also, and I respect everyone's right to strike, but last year's strikes didn't do schools any favours when it came to parents thinking about when to take holidays. I think it was about 8 school days last year that some schools were shut for. Almost two full weeks. So it does make parents laugh when they get letters explaining how important it is for children to be in school every school day - but it didn't matter them missing almost two weeks due to the strikes. I was very thankful my kids' school only closed for the first two strike days and then managed to keep open for the rest. And even then, even though for years I've done my best to have my two oldest kids in school as much as possible, never taking term time holidays, never getting appointments during the school day where possible, always making sure homework was done, we had a family member visiting on the second strike day so I let my boys not do some of the assigned work so that we could all go out for lunch. So I can well imagine some parents now thinking, sod it, let's go on a cheaper term time holiday.

Absolutely this. The teachers strikes were the “sod it” moment for me and many other people I know

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 13:58

Katypp · 22/02/2024 13:55

Mine did this too. She also tried to wrestle the steering wheel from my hands. I had to call the police on a few occasions.
However, I still think the starting point should be children are expected to go to school.

I think that’s a really personal decision and entirely down to the individual needs/abilities of the child and the family involved. I couldn’t judge as I’m not in that place.

DrRuthGalloway · 22/02/2024 13:56

justcallmebettty · 22/02/2024 13:29

Agree with this. I can only imagine my (very loving and kind) parents’ reaction if I had refused to go to school.

safe to say I’d have been frog marched in.

This is a very simplistic view.
Do you think all of us with children with EBSA haven't frog marched our children in, 40 or 50 times? Haven't shouted and threatened? Haven't cried ourselves? Haven't dreaded every bad day? Haven't spent 4 hours a day for months on end supporting our youngsters getting up and dressed and driven them in to facilitate their attendance, only to find the school can't get them in to lessons? Haven't lost jobs or had to cut down hours?

At their worst, my child lay in a foetal position on the bathroom floor for an hour after I had run the bath, laid out clothes and towel etc. Couldn't take their hands away from their face as they were so disgusting that no one must be allowed to look at them. Shook like a leaf crying and clinging on to me at aged 17 when I managed to get them in to school for a planned meeting. Tbh by that point my main concern was whether they would survive at all, not whether or not this might impact GCSE results.

If it were as simple as frog marching a child in and wahey, problem solved, wouldn't that be wonderful? Spoiler - it isn't.

Katypp · 22/02/2024 13:55

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 13:50

Oh and to those posters saying “frog march them in”, I’ve worked with families where their kids have tried to throw themselves from a moving car to avoid school so yer, frog marching isn’t really where they are 🙄😬.

Mine did this too. She also tried to wrestle the steering wheel from my hands. I had to call the police on a few occasions.
However, I still think the starting point should be children are expected to go to school.

SearchingForSolitude · 22/02/2024 13:53

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 13:44

I knew nothing about this.

So I’m not sure how it was a narrow view. I only knew what l knew which was nothing, despite endless research.

It is a narrow view of EOTAS to think EOTAS equals no friends. You obviously disagree, which is obviously fine. But I stand by EOTAS does not have to equal no friends and to think that does is a narrow view of what EOTAS can be.

Some with EOTAS don’t have friends. That’s more about the child’s needs and wouldn’t change whether they attended a setting or not. But many with EOTAS do have friends.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 13:50

Oh and to those posters saying “frog march them in”, I’ve worked with families where their kids have tried to throw themselves from a moving car to avoid school so yer, frog marching isn’t really where they are 🙄😬.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 13:48

@BibbleandSqwauk thank you for the apology - you did misread my post but I was referencing another poster wanting flexi schooling as a right for every child and I was making the point that kids like my DS would use that in a way it isn’t meant for unfortunately.

i’m not sure I’m expressing myself clearly because I totally agree our school system isn’t fit for purpose (I work in it) but I don’t see how, with current resources, we could make flexi schooling a right. I think at the moment our resources should be spent on helping those with ND and other needs to access education that works for them.

My DS is not ND and doesn’t have needs - he’s just a kid who’s rather be doing anything but school. And I see his point - there are so many more useful things he could be doing with his time than learning to regurgitate pointless facts that he can google in a second. But we are where we are 🤷‍♀️.

lavenderlou · 22/02/2024 13:46

justcallmebettty · 22/02/2024 13:29

Agree with this. I can only imagine my (very loving and kind) parents’ reaction if I had refused to go to school.

safe to say I’d have been frog marched in.

Have you ever been in a situation where your child is incredibly, incredibly distressed about going into school?

I used to think the same as you until I'd experienced it myself.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 13:44

SearchingForSolitude · 22/02/2024 13:34

EOTAS doesn’t have to be at home or can include a mixture of provision at home and away from the home. Packages are bespoke to individual needs, whatever is suitable and meets DC’s needs.

I suspect the things you are talking about are aimed at under 16.

You suspect wrong. EOTAS packages, including provision away from the home, can be for all age groups, including in your LA.

It would also be up to us to take her to these places as she won’t travel alone.

Parents can not be compelled to deliver, facilitate or organise any provision in an EOTAS package. Transport and an escort can be provided.

It is irrelevant to your DD anyway, because it is obviously not inappropriate for provision to be made in a school for her, therefore she doesn’t meet the LA threshold for EOTAS. I was just highlighting it is incorrect to think EOTAS = no friends.

I knew nothing about this.

So I’m not sure how it was a narrow view. I only knew what l knew which was nothing, despite endless research.

shearwater2 · 22/02/2024 13:40

Katypp · 22/02/2024 13:32

I have an autistic daugher who was a chronic school refuser and I have a very anxious son who is also not keen (partly, I think, because skipping school was 'normalised' by his older sister).
However I really don't understand why threads like this are hijacked by parents of children with ASD etc with a chip on their shoulder and brushing aside the fact that some children do not have a good reason for skipping school and are just doing it because they can.
Parents of children with a good justification for missing school (which is usually mental-health or ASD based) are not being criticised as far as I can see, but they always appear telling others not to criticise them because they don't know what they are talking about.
I moved heaven and earth to get my daughter into school and I often failed. My view was at some point in the future, she would have to do something she didn't want to and found difficult, so making school officially optional for her was not a good foundation for the future.

However I really don't understand why threads like this are hijacked by parents of children with ASD etc with a chip on their shoulder and brushing aside the fact that some children do not have a good reason for skipping school and are just doing it because they can.

Yes they fucking well ARE being criticised as everyone gets tarred with the same brush and so many parents are fined when their kids and they are really struggling, for a penalty which was meant to prevent term time holidays or parents who don't know or care where their kids are if not in school, who are very, very few.

Even in the latter case - how does the fine help the child? It doesn't.

shearwater2 · 22/02/2024 13:34

safe to say I’d have been frog marched in.

Thanks for that understanding response, @justcallmebettty 🙄

Most parents have tried frog marching their kids in. Clearly you know bugger all about it.

In our case it got to her getting out of the car and running away from school or running away from home as she was so fearful of it. Once it got to that stage, and then she got a bit bigger - 5'10" and ten stone+, no frogmarching was possible and everything I read advised that it was entirely counterproductive (as I had felt in my bones all along).

SearchingForSolitude · 22/02/2024 13:34

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 13:25

No l don’t know. But she wouldn’t be able to cope with all that.

She wants to go to the same place every day. And I suspect the things you are talking about are aimed at under 16. It would also be up to us to take her to these places as she won’t travel alone.

EOTAS doesn’t have to be at home or can include a mixture of provision at home and away from the home. Packages are bespoke to individual needs, whatever is suitable and meets DC’s needs.

I suspect the things you are talking about are aimed at under 16.

You suspect wrong. EOTAS packages, including provision away from the home, can be for all age groups, including in your LA.

It would also be up to us to take her to these places as she won’t travel alone.

Parents can not be compelled to deliver, facilitate or organise any provision in an EOTAS package. Transport and an escort can be provided.

It is irrelevant to your DD anyway, because it is obviously not inappropriate for provision to be made in a school for her, therefore she doesn’t meet the LA threshold for EOTAS. I was just highlighting it is incorrect to think EOTAS = no friends.

Katypp · 22/02/2024 13:32

I have an autistic daugher who was a chronic school refuser and I have a very anxious son who is also not keen (partly, I think, because skipping school was 'normalised' by his older sister).
However I really don't understand why threads like this are hijacked by parents of children with ASD etc with a chip on their shoulder and brushing aside the fact that some children do not have a good reason for skipping school and are just doing it because they can.
Parents of children with a good justification for missing school (which is usually mental-health or ASD based) are not being criticised as far as I can see, but they always appear telling others not to criticise them because they don't know what they are talking about.
I moved heaven and earth to get my daughter into school and I often failed. My view was at some point in the future, she would have to do something she didn't want to and found difficult, so making school officially optional for her was not a good foundation for the future.

Katemax82 · 22/02/2024 13:31

shellyleppard · 22/02/2024 08:08

Op.... school refusal is not always down to laziness from the child or parents. Maybe the child is struggling mentally with the pressure of the school work??? Maybe school aren't helping with the problem and have an attitude of you either come in full time or nothing?? Two sides to every coin

This. My son is being assessed for asd and is almost impossible to get into school.

shearwater2 · 22/02/2024 13:30

BrambleyHedge · 22/02/2024 13:09

If it were a contagion then my son would be in school as that is where all his friends are. He is the only one EBSA.

Indeed. DD2 wants to go to school and be with her friends, but can't manage it at the moment.

No social contagion at home either, DD1 was not school avoidant and did really well, as did DH and I. And we used to really believe in state education, DH was a school governor until recently for about ten years.

justcallmebettty · 22/02/2024 13:29

Hoplolly · 22/02/2024 08:00

I do agree with what you are saying but kids have never been taught as individuals so that still doesn't explain a rise.

I think it's down to a combination of things...like a PP school refusal is contagious, gentle parenting (I know some genuine school refusers, I also know some friends who "can't get them to go in"), parental apathy since covid and teacher strikes - government and schools didn't mind my kids not going in...so they don't force the issue. We also seem to have developed a fear as parents of doing anything that might upset our children.

I believe there are very genuine school refusers for very genuine reasons but I also think there are some very wishy washy parents who don't try hard enough to get their kids into school.

Agree with this. I can only imagine my (very loving and kind) parents’ reaction if I had refused to go to school.

safe to say I’d have been frog marched in.

AmyandPhilipfan · 22/02/2024 13:25

Also, and I respect everyone's right to strike, but last year's strikes didn't do schools any favours when it came to parents thinking about when to take holidays. I think it was about 8 school days last year that some schools were shut for. Almost two full weeks. So it does make parents laugh when they get letters explaining how important it is for children to be in school every school day - but it didn't matter them missing almost two weeks due to the strikes. I was very thankful my kids' school only closed for the first two strike days and then managed to keep open for the rest. And even then, even though for years I've done my best to have my two oldest kids in school as much as possible, never taking term time holidays, never getting appointments during the school day where possible, always making sure homework was done, we had a family member visiting on the second strike day so I let my boys not do some of the assigned work so that we could all go out for lunch. So I can well imagine some parents now thinking, sod it, let's go on a cheaper term time holiday.