Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there have to be some clearer reasons for the rise in school attendance problems?

257 replies

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 07:52

Inspired by this article https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers/

How specifically has the pandemic affected things? Why is the environment so inhospitable to the neurodivergent?

The plight of Britain's school-refusers

https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers

OP posts:
ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 20:51

@bottomlypots absolutely - he sucked all the joy out of teaching and learning!

Mumma2024 · 22/02/2024 20:24

I work in SEND, I love my job and my families.

School expectations are overwhelming children. As is social media and tech. Before, you would have a bad day at school, go home and escape. Now it follows you everywhere. If you are struggling socially, social media is there and in your face. If you are overwhelmed with work, all the school apps are there and in your face.

Behaviour is a huge issue in schools. Lots of Children can't cope with the unruly behaviour. So schools try and tackle it. Lots of other children can't cope with the zero tolerance approaches. Schools seem truly damned if they do, damned if they don't.

Children aren't able to access support before little problems become huge problems. The health system in particular is just not there for them.

Parents are seeking out support anywhere they can. I do think there's now an extra issue that if you post on social media that your child is anxious or struggling about school, you get lots of replies which all bet tell you you are an awful parent for sending them in anyway. I've seen parents called abusive for doing so. The responses often aren't to try and tackle problems before that action is taken.

A small minority (I'd say maybe 2%) of the families I see I look at it and think they just can't be bothered. I think these are the demographic of families who always have had poor attitudes towards education, it's just a new way to justify it. This is just a tiny minority though.

It is a hugely complex issue, impacted by poor services, huge demand, limited resources and a huge behaviour problem.

I often go into my old schools as a professional now. I walk through the halls and remember so many lovely memories. The senco at one now is someone who I went to school with throughout our entire schooling, she says they get none of the stuff we used to get. It's just fighting for survival.

shellyleppard · 22/02/2024 20:21

Sprigato....my sons school changed to an academy and it really went down hill. Before if there was a problem we could talk to them. Now it takes weeks of emails and phone calls before you can speak to anyone. I've withdrawn my son from school completely as he was having a nervous breakdown with the pressure. I asked school if he could go part time or drop some GCSE subjects..... they said he had to attend full time and do all the GCSE subjects. No help or support for him. He was getting in trouble for the slightest little thing.....and soo unhappy.

shearwater2 · 22/02/2024 20:14

bottomlypots · 22/02/2024 20:04

Gove started the rot. If you came into a year 1 class now it would be unrecognisable from one 15 years ago. The Singapore style of rote teaching is everywhere. Children have to sit on the carpet for hours. In KS1 and 2 they learn grammar concepts which are irrelevant and outdated (Gove again). Children in year 1 are doing daily dictation.

Read that again…

5 year olds are doing daily sentence dictation. They are sent away to rewrite it if it’s wrong. This is a state school in 2024.

Everything is about data. Rote learning gets results. It breaks children and squeezes every bit of creativity out of them, but the results on how well they decode “Alien Words”is great.

Gove destroyed GCSEs. My degree didn’t rely on one exam, nor did my MEd. Why did we push the kids back to O-level days? One slip and you’re done.

Money to support the children struggling/ to make the curriculum more accessible (for NT and ND children) has gone. I’m doing a pastoral care role. I support the exact children we are talking about. My job pays 22k a year before tax. I am a trained educator, with many years experience and I’m good at what I do. But look at the pay! There’s no money to pay more. The pastoral care was better funded in the early 00s.

There’s a few reasons and not one has even started to considerthe COVID issues.

All of this has changed in the last 15 years. Not just tech.

Hear hear. Having two daughters four years apart, the eldest who started school in 2010 there was a real difference once the Gove changes kicked in, and not for the better.

bottomlypots · 22/02/2024 20:04

Gove started the rot. If you came into a year 1 class now it would be unrecognisable from one 15 years ago. The Singapore style of rote teaching is everywhere. Children have to sit on the carpet for hours. In KS1 and 2 they learn grammar concepts which are irrelevant and outdated (Gove again). Children in year 1 are doing daily dictation.

Read that again…

5 year olds are doing daily sentence dictation. They are sent away to rewrite it if it’s wrong. This is a state school in 2024.

Everything is about data. Rote learning gets results. It breaks children and squeezes every bit of creativity out of them, but the results on how well they decode “Alien Words”is great.

Gove destroyed GCSEs. My degree didn’t rely on one exam, nor did my MEd. Why did we push the kids back to O-level days? One slip and you’re done.

Money to support the children struggling/ to make the curriculum more accessible (for NT and ND children) has gone. I’m doing a pastoral care role. I support the exact children we are talking about. My job pays 22k a year before tax. I am a trained educator, with many years experience and I’m good at what I do. But look at the pay! There’s no money to pay more. The pastoral care was better funded in the early 00s.

There’s a few reasons and not one has even started to considerthe COVID issues.

All of this has changed in the last 15 years. Not just tech.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 20:01

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 19:57

It was group work that finished my dd off. And the pouncing on them to answer questions.

Edited

And this is what is so wrong with the one size fits all method of teaching sadly 😢.

taxguru · 22/02/2024 20:01

BibbleandSqwauk · 22/02/2024 19:43

I think that aspect of it is really interesting. I've been a teacher for 25 years and was trained in the 90s to be all about group work, different kinds of learning styles etc. I think there's some truth that for some ND kids, the older fashioned, more regimented and individual desks etc would suit them better..more predictable, "safer". This is an incredibly complex issue and there simply isn't a straightforward answer to any of that.

I just see it from my own perspective. I really hated any kind of group work and lessons where the class was sat in clusters, such as science labs where we had 8 sat around large tables - wonderful for bullying and disruption! My exam results speak volumes - my "best" results were English and we'd had our last three years' of English lessons with an "old school" teacher who had his own classroom (a "cow shed" portacabin) with single desks in rows, all facing forward. It was literally the only lesson I looked forward to because there was never any group work, and very little disruption/noise. When I say "best" results, I still didn't pass, but the grades weren't as ridiculously poor as my other subjects, all of which were in modern classrooms in clusters which I absolutely detested. Even my historically "best" subject being Maths, I failed miserably with a U, and then went on to get an A at A level with self study after leaving my hell hole comp, and then got over 90% in my chartered accountancy "maths" exam called "quantitative analysis" which was heavy on statistics and probability - all by lone/self study in my own environment. English was the only subject I didn't want to truant from - in a way it was my "safe space" because the teacher and classroom didn't lend itself to bullying and disruption.

ShareTheDuvet · 22/02/2024 20:00

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:33

So it’s a parenting issue? Poorly brought up children being so disruptive that others don’t want to go in?

There’s certainly an element of this. The behaviour my DC describe is close to feral but my kids just roll with it as they’re don’t have to contend with any kind of anxiety/ND. I can’t imagine how terrifying some of this behaviour is to more vulnerable kids - not to mention some of that behaviour is targeted at them. A few months ago one kid was made to get on his knees and beg for mercy while a gang filmed it and uploaded it to social media for shits and giggles 🤬. I’d be fucking terrified to go to school if I thought that was going to happen to me 😢.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 19:57

It was group work that finished my dd off. And the pouncing on them to answer questions.

1dayatatime · 22/02/2024 19:55

Absence rates had been falling since a previous high in 2008 / 2010 then something happened in 2020 that caused them to sharply increase again.

To think there have to be some clearer reasons for the rise in school attendance problems?
BibbleandSqwauk · 22/02/2024 19:43

I think that aspect of it is really interesting. I've been a teacher for 25 years and was trained in the 90s to be all about group work, different kinds of learning styles etc. I think there's some truth that for some ND kids, the older fashioned, more regimented and individual desks etc would suit them better..more predictable, "safer". This is an incredibly complex issue and there simply isn't a straightforward answer to any of that.

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:33

So it’s a parenting issue? Poorly brought up children being so disruptive that others don’t want to go in?

taxguru · 22/02/2024 19:31

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:19

Not intended as a goady question but has the huge focus on introspection and feelings resulted in teens ‘hyping up’ their emotions and focussing on them to the exclusion of regulating themselves and being able to stay calm?

Edited

That assumes that behaviour, disruption, etc in schools hasn't changed.

In reality, it's changed massively for the worse.

When schools were relatively calm, controlled, with generally well behaved children, the shy, anxious, stressed, ND, children could mostly function. Even moreso when a lot of the education was done on single desks, individual "quiet" work, etc.

Now many schools are more like a warzone with out of control kids, loud, shouty, disruptive, etc., the anxious/ND/shy/stressed kids find it harder to cope. Added into that, most classrooms now have clusters of desks or pupils sat around a big table, plus ever more groupwork, meaning less opportunities for pupils who prefer to study quietly on their own.

The ND and other "special" needs kids have always been there, it's just that previously schools were better managed, kids were better controlled, etc., so they could cope. It's not the struggling kids who have changed, it's the entire environment in which they are forced to work within that's changed.

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:19

Not intended as a goady question but has the huge focus on introspection and feelings resulted in teens ‘hyping up’ their emotions and focussing on them to the exclusion of regulating themselves and being able to stay calm?

BibbleandSqwauk · 22/02/2024 19:16

coxesorangepippin · 22/02/2024 19:06

Honestly if I'd have had the option to not go to school when I was a teenager, I'd have taken it.

Was I allowed?

No.

Have you read literally ANY of this thread? Please do explain how you deal with a 12 yo who desperately wants to go to school and is sobbing in the car because she CAN'T. Idiotic comment.

mitogoshi · 22/02/2024 19:14

Wasn't great before, the difference is that it is not just the "poor" people not sending them to school now. DD's school (pre pandemic) had many students below 80%

sprigatito · 22/02/2024 19:13

I think academy trusts have a good deal to answer for here. Many of them have a corporate business leadership model not based in good pedagogical practice; various aspects of school culture are increasingly hostile to students who need a more nuanced approach (ND, SEND, mental health challenges etc) and off-the-shelf behaviour policies (such as Ready To Learn) lead to these students spending a lot of time anxious, frustrated and in isolation. Bought-in policies on homework and other aspects of curriculum delivery (look-cover-write-check, tech alternatives to direct teaching) can be dehumanising and uninspiring. Toilet policies add to anxiety and poor wellbeing, especially for girls. Constant surveillance and punishment for things like violating the one-way system to avoid punishment for being late, insufficient time at lunch to enable all students to eat, loos only available at break and not enough time for all students to use them...most adults would struggle to function at that pitch all day every day. All of these things undermine (or prevent) healthy relationships between students and staff and make school untenable for a growing number of students. I hear a lot on MN about kids lacking resilience and their lives not being tough enough, and I wonder whether those posters have any idea what is actually going on in state secondary schools.

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:12

DrRuthGalloway · 22/02/2024 17:19

Indeed. Mine had EBSA pre-covid - actually the respite of no longer having to go to school in covid was the long slow start of some semblance of recovery. It was a total autistic burnout in our case, precipitated by school expectations at A level. Kid is incredibly able and the most knowledgeable person I know, but doesn't think like the qualifications and education system expect, and simply couldn't cope with it.

Mine didn't go to uni. Is on highest pip and LCWRA benefits 4 years later and now goes out with carer once a week to a climbing wall. We are quite pleased because we are seeing clothes on probably 3 days a week now, rather than one of the giant hoodies. The previous 5 years have been spent, literally in bed 23+ hours a day.

I think the education system, unknowingly, quite destroyed my child. I don't know if they will ever work; at one point we were wondering about Oxbridge. Seems bizarre now.

I have massive sympathy for this but I’m racking my brains trying to think what the difference is between schools only 15 years ago or so, and schools now, that means this is a sudden and widespread problem.

I can only conclude it’s smartphones because I can’t think of anything else that is that different from the school environment in the early 2000s when I was there.

Personally I think it’s time for responsible parents to bring their children up tablet and phone free.

EDIT: sorry the last paragraph was NOT aimed at the poster I quoted, and I acknowledge this would mean time travelling for a lot of parents whose kids currently have EBSA

sheflieswithherownwings · 22/02/2024 19:11

As I've said on a previous thread about this, so many teachers apparently do not want to be working in a school anymore - why are we so surprised that so many kids also don't want to be in a very oppressive, barely functioning education system?

Yes, there is very likely to be contagion.

But if children's needs were being met (including SEND but also NT kids who find school stressful and de-motivating) then I think fewer kids would be persistently absent.

At my DS's school recently, there were so many teachers absent in one week, that they ended up having a large number of kids, across year groups, watching films in the hall. Yes, maybe many of those teachers were sick, but the impact on the kids and perhaps what they perceive from that can't be minimised.

I think it's incredibly easy (and dare I say lazy) to just blame the child or the parents. Because that way you don't have to look at the much larger problem of why schools have become such difficult and stifling environments for both kids and teachers.

PullUpTheDrawbridge · 22/02/2024 19:08

shellyleppard · 22/02/2024 08:08

Op.... school refusal is not always down to laziness from the child or parents. Maybe the child is struggling mentally with the pressure of the school work??? Maybe school aren't helping with the problem and have an attitude of you either come in full time or nothing?? Two sides to every coin

Not always? I'd say hardly, hardly, ever. What's lazy about taking on 100% responsibility for your child's education, like home schoolers do? Like ferrying your kids around between many disparate home ed activities all week? About having to entertain them 24/7 with no help?

We had 2 years of home Ed/ EBSR and it was exhausting. Back in system now and it feels like the 'lazy' option. At least 50% of the motivation to get in everyday despite massive stressful push back from my kids is I need a break!

coxesorangepippin · 22/02/2024 19:06

Honestly if I'd have had the option to not go to school when I was a teenager, I'd have taken it.

Was I allowed?

No.

SearchingForSolitude · 22/02/2024 19:01

@DrRuthGalloway excellent post.

Persistent absence is described as missing 10% or more of available sessions.

DrRuthGalloway · 22/02/2024 18:55

Hoplolly · 22/02/2024 18:39

This thread is so heavily skewed by people with SEN children when I don't even think that's the key issue with school attendance figures. It's certainly not one of the biggest areas of concerns for school attendance officers.

It would be nice if we could talk about or debate the other reasons (or at least people accept that there are other reasons) than children with SEN.

Actually you are wrong. A heavy majority of EBSA is of neurodivergent children.

There are also "truant" children , many of whom have SEND needs that school is not meeting one way or another, so they vote with their feet, but perhaps aren't as distressed and overwhelmed by life as the EBSA population.

Of course it depends on what persistently absent means. If 20 percent are now persistently absent, as per recent press releases, that might mean all those with less than 95 percent attendance - which would include my child with a chronic illness who loves school, attends whenever possible, but has frequent hospital appointments (3 in the next month, for example). That just can't be helped and is not really symptomatic of anything but bad luck on the genetic inheritance front.

Has there been a change in people's attitudes to things like taking holidays in term time? Almost certainly, for some people. That could drop people below 95 percent too, a week's holiday and a childhood illness in the same year. Again, not really a giant problem.

It's a very different problem though from the burgeoning mental health crisis of EBSA.

SearchingForSolitude · 22/02/2024 18:50

Hoplolly · 22/02/2024 18:39

This thread is so heavily skewed by people with SEN children when I don't even think that's the key issue with school attendance figures. It's certainly not one of the biggest areas of concerns for school attendance officers.

It would be nice if we could talk about or debate the other reasons (or at least people accept that there are other reasons) than children with SEN.

EBSA is classed as an SEN. SEN includes SEMH needs.

The link in the OP also focuses on SEN.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 18:46

Hoplolly · 22/02/2024 18:39

This thread is so heavily skewed by people with SEN children when I don't even think that's the key issue with school attendance figures. It's certainly not one of the biggest areas of concerns for school attendance officers.

It would be nice if we could talk about or debate the other reasons (or at least people accept that there are other reasons) than children with SEN.

It is the biggest area. I left secondary teaching in 2021, the majority of long term absence was SEND.

Swipe left for the next trending thread