Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there have to be some clearer reasons for the rise in school attendance problems?

257 replies

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 07:52

Inspired by this article https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers/

How specifically has the pandemic affected things? Why is the environment so inhospitable to the neurodivergent?

The plight of Britain's school-refusers

https://unherd.com/2024/02/the-tragedy-of-britains-school-refusers

OP posts:
MotherofChaosandDestruction · 22/02/2024 23:17

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:12

I have massive sympathy for this but I’m racking my brains trying to think what the difference is between schools only 15 years ago or so, and schools now, that means this is a sudden and widespread problem.

I can only conclude it’s smartphones because I can’t think of anything else that is that different from the school environment in the early 2000s when I was there.

Personally I think it’s time for responsible parents to bring their children up tablet and phone free.

EDIT: sorry the last paragraph was NOT aimed at the poster I quoted, and I acknowledge this would mean time travelling for a lot of parents whose kids currently have EBSA

Edited

That's great but schools expect you to do your learning on a tablet nowadays from primary school.

itsalwaysthesame · 22/02/2024 23:12

In my case it's because my daughter who's academically excellent but diagnosed ASD and quiet as a mouse cannot cope being in such a large, nosey environment with so many people, different classrooms, teachers, rules that are pointless but that she strictly adheres to, it's all so overwhelming for her. Secondary has broken her and she's only in year 7. Surprisingly she had exceptional attendance throughout covid as I was a key worker and she enjoyed going to school

6 months into secondary and she's borderline anorexic and self harming.

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 22/02/2024 23:12

I've just posted on the thread about getting a detention for forgetting a ruler. I was always forgetting things at school and never got a detention for it, I was engaged and loved school (this was 20 years ago). If I had been in school now and getting detention everyday or isolation for a small infraction I would have definitely been a school refuser as I suffered terribly with anxiety and depression.

Underfunding, COVID, poor mental health services, stressed parents, cost of living and getting ND diagnosis is taking 2+ years and then you have to fight for any support - it's a shit show out there and it's no wonder kids mental health is bad.

Roseyposeypie · 22/02/2024 23:11

My (almost certainly) NT but sensitive, intelligent DS is struggling with secondary school. His attendance dropped to about 60% in year 7. We tried but there’s very little you can safely do to get your child into school when they’re in the midst of a panic attack and trying to harm themselves. For him it’s too big and too crowded. There are too many rules you can accidentally break, too many exams and too much pressure. We’ve made it to year 9 with support from CAMHS and a private therapist. He’s in a reasonable place right now but I’m already worried about what GCSEs will bring.

Dogdilemma2000 · 22/02/2024 23:09

“How specifically has the pandemic affected things?”

Massive increase in general anxiety amongst my 9 year olds cohort if nothing else.

We told them to hide inside for 6 months. Why is anyone surprised when they are scared not to do that now?

MrsKintner · 22/02/2024 23:05

TheWildEyeBoyfromafreecloud · 22/02/2024 22:22

@MrsKintner there are plenty of free courses that take very little time to gen up about sen

If I was a teacher I would do a few and learn more about my pupils needs.

Cool, but I'm not sure what problem you think that's solving?

So the class teacher working 50+ hours a week who is already on antidepressants, a performance plan and dreads waking up every morning uses some of her free time to do some online courses about SEN.
Is that going to help the child in her class who is waiting for a diagnosis but the waiting list is 3+ years?
Or the child who has a diagnosis but their EHCP application has been batted back again due to not enough evidence and the SENCO isn't being very helpful as honestly they know the school doesn't have the capacity to fulfil another EHCP anyway
Or the child that does have an EHCP, but isn't getting the 25 hours of 1:1 TA support they're legally entitled to because the school can't recruit anyone to do a skilled and stressful role for less money than working part time in Lidl.
Oh and SATS are coming up so the children are all expected in for before and after school revision sessions and there's no art, music or drama available until after May half term.

No wait, don't worry - the class teacher is on long term sick now so there's two new supply teachers who can do the free online courses and fix the education system.

WaitingforSpring24 · 22/02/2024 22:58

It would be really interesting to see if this is a problem elsewhere.

In Ireland for example, I don’t think there has been a similar rise in non attendance at school. (But I haven’t fact checked this!)

solsticelove · 22/02/2024 22:45

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:12

I have massive sympathy for this but I’m racking my brains trying to think what the difference is between schools only 15 years ago or so, and schools now, that means this is a sudden and widespread problem.

I can only conclude it’s smartphones because I can’t think of anything else that is that different from the school environment in the early 2000s when I was there.

Personally I think it’s time for responsible parents to bring their children up tablet and phone free.

EDIT: sorry the last paragraph was NOT aimed at the poster I quoted, and I acknowledge this would mean time travelling for a lot of parents whose kids currently have EBSA

Edited

You having to wrack your brains to figure out what has changed in the last 15 years says so much about how you know nothing about the current education system. Ask any teacher what major changes occurred in 2014 under Gove and there’s your answer.

Smart phones it is not….

bottomlypots · 22/02/2024 22:23

MrsKintner · 22/02/2024 22:17

The main reasons are:
Gove Curriculum
Academisation
Cuts in SEN funding
Cuts in education funding
Cuts in mental health services
Covid
Zero tolerance behaviour policies with a focus on shame, punishment and isolation
Poverty and inequality in society

100% this and I’m not sure how it’s going to change.

TheWildEyeBoyfromafreecloud · 22/02/2024 22:22

@MrsKintner there are plenty of free courses that take very little time to gen up about sen

If I was a teacher I would do a few and learn more about my pupils needs.

TheWildEyeBoyfromafreecloud · 22/02/2024 22:20

Too boring and unkind.
Adults with absolutely no compassion or kindness for our children often born in of sheer ignorance.

Because they don't get taught about what being dyslexic means, what having autism means etc.

MrsKintner · 22/02/2024 22:17

The main reasons are:
Gove Curriculum
Academisation
Cuts in SEN funding
Cuts in education funding
Cuts in mental health services
Covid
Zero tolerance behaviour policies with a focus on shame, punishment and isolation
Poverty and inequality in society

MrsKintner · 22/02/2024 22:10

Schools are often horrible places to be now.

Teachers are stressed, overworked, don't want to be there.
Why would children?

Don't we think a high-stress environment with bonkers behavioural policies, boring and over stuffed curriculums and being overseen by adults who hate their jobs is going to put children off going?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 22:07

cherish123 · 22/02/2024 22:05

Rise in parent mental health issues,
more parents working from home and laziness about leaving the house, rise in behavioural problems at school so a lot of children unhappy and don't want to come to school, more permissive attitudes in parenting, more permissive attitudes in schools which makes the classroom quite chaotic.

Schools are the opposite of permissive. They are like Victorian prisons.

cherish123 · 22/02/2024 22:05

Rise in parent mental health issues,
more parents working from home and laziness about leaving the house, rise in behavioural problems at school so a lot of children unhappy and don't want to come to school, more permissive attitudes in parenting, more permissive attitudes in schools which makes the classroom quite chaotic.

wellington77 · 22/02/2024 22:00

As a teacher, we have seen it at my school as parents and children not viewing school as so important anymore in terms of missing a day or more since covid lockdowns when they were away- a rather apathetic attitude unfortunately has crept in.

DrRuthGalloway · 22/02/2024 21:57

Naptrappedmummy · 22/02/2024 19:12

I have massive sympathy for this but I’m racking my brains trying to think what the difference is between schools only 15 years ago or so, and schools now, that means this is a sudden and widespread problem.

I can only conclude it’s smartphones because I can’t think of anything else that is that different from the school environment in the early 2000s when I was there.

Personally I think it’s time for responsible parents to bring their children up tablet and phone free.

EDIT: sorry the last paragraph was NOT aimed at the poster I quoted, and I acknowledge this would mean time travelling for a lot of parents whose kids currently have EBSA

Edited

Not in my child's case. He uses no social media. Refuses to have a smart phone at all. Not on FB, Insta, Twitter, or anything. Not even on our family Whatsapp.

NeelyOHara1 · 22/02/2024 21:47

Differentiating between 'I don't want to, because I don't want to, and now I've got a label to hang it off' from the genuine cases is a problem for society as a whole.

FloorWipes · 22/02/2024 21:45

This is such an interesting discussion.

Hard not to relate it all to one's own experience. I struggled to go to school and was in CAMHS as a child. I spent time in the principal's office and matron's room, as well as hiding in the corridor. There was no pastoral room. But I loved rote learning, rules, single desks and to an extent even exams (as opposed to long projects or team projects). So luckily despite serious difficulties, in the end I did well once the set up suited me a bit later on in school (not without continued psychiatric problems but still I was in school and achieving). But applying those things that suited me to everyone clearly wouldn't work and would be absolutely awful for some.

But tailoring the experience seems really important. In my school I was able to stay away from the loud dining hall. I avoided sport with support from my mum, and some other activities that didn't suit me. This was also all tolerated by the school because I was "clever" and academically engaged. And I think I knew that.

If my differences weren't tolerated and accepted, if I couldn't avoid the activities that were too distressing...it could have been very different.

What I am getting is that under resourced schools cannot provide much tailoring of the experience. That means only a narrow band of people will thrive.

I'm also wondering if although we pay a lot of lip service to celebrating difference, in some ways we are actually not doing well at this attitude wise? Some of the attitudes people are describing of staff seem more towards a Victorian sort of approach that what you'd expect in 2024. Almost seems to have gone backwards.

OP posts:
NotMeNoNo · 22/02/2024 21:41

Another issue is that maybe a quarter of schoolchildren are now living in significant poverty/substandard housing with all the stress and emotional difficulties that brings. Children who are hungry dirty or behind on homework due to home circumstances can either get bullied, (or become bullies themselves to avoid being victims ) or spiral down the behaviour system and understandably disengage from school.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2024 21:34

I was teaching from 1996. I think a really important thing is the intensity of the school day. It’s horrible now there’s absolutely no down time. Every one needs this. I think it was one of the things that drove me out of teaching.

1996, kids moseyed in, did the register, they settled down after 6 or 7 minutes. End of lesson they packed up, took about 5 minutes. Hour and 10 minute lunch, 25 min morning break

2020 kids has to be in within 4 minutes of beginning. Even if coming from another part of the school.Tatgets on the board to add to stress, and an activity to do during register. Different activities, questioning everyone, long conclusion right up to last minute. Pack away as soon as bell rings and rush to other side of school.Frantic activity all lesson to stop them getting bored. 35 mins lunch, 15 mins break. No chatting in registration. More ‘activities’ to do. No adult could cope with that.

I hated it, it used to over stimulate me as an experienced teacher. Displays everywhere for learning, but just add to over stimulation. Rush rush rush rush. l just wanted a room with pale blue walls and restful pictures on it. Instead every inch of wall was cluttered with horrible garish colours and type faces . All over. I feel stressed again just thinking about it.

Ita awful now. My nd dd would have been fine in the 90’s. It blew her mind in 2022.

11NigelTufnel · 22/02/2024 21:30

If there was more suitable provision early on then kids wouldn't have to get to this level of crisis. The funding was cut to the bone and specialist schools and units have closed down, with kids forced into mainstream. Funding there is also cut and lessons were designed by Gove to be as dull as possible.

If we had got more help when my year 4 child first showed signs of distress, it never would have got to this point. Now he is self harming, asking us to kill him, has lost friends because he can't cope and verbally lashes out (not physically) or avoids them. He is fully aware that he is different and can't do as well as his classmates as he has autism, adhd, motor skills disorder and hypermobility. Even now, we are still being told by the school that the ehcp is almost certain to be refused. This is all taking time and resources away from the regular kids in the class, so they will be losing out too. It's a bloody joke!

But hey, it's all wishy washy parenting to blame isn't it.

PullUpTheDrawbridge · 22/02/2024 21:24

bottomlypots · 22/02/2024 20:04

Gove started the rot. If you came into a year 1 class now it would be unrecognisable from one 15 years ago. The Singapore style of rote teaching is everywhere. Children have to sit on the carpet for hours. In KS1 and 2 they learn grammar concepts which are irrelevant and outdated (Gove again). Children in year 1 are doing daily dictation.

Read that again…

5 year olds are doing daily sentence dictation. They are sent away to rewrite it if it’s wrong. This is a state school in 2024.

Everything is about data. Rote learning gets results. It breaks children and squeezes every bit of creativity out of them, but the results on how well they decode “Alien Words”is great.

Gove destroyed GCSEs. My degree didn’t rely on one exam, nor did my MEd. Why did we push the kids back to O-level days? One slip and you’re done.

Money to support the children struggling/ to make the curriculum more accessible (for NT and ND children) has gone. I’m doing a pastoral care role. I support the exact children we are talking about. My job pays 22k a year before tax. I am a trained educator, with many years experience and I’m good at what I do. But look at the pay! There’s no money to pay more. The pastoral care was better funded in the early 00s.

There’s a few reasons and not one has even started to considerthe COVID issues.

All of this has changed in the last 15 years. Not just tech.

This. Plus greater awareness re the damage school is doing to self esteem. Greater awareness of alternatives. Greater awareness of how shit school is on so many levels. How useless the learning is, how awful the behaviour is, how socially cruel it is. We'd never expect an adult in a workplace to put up with these issues. We'd just say leave. Do something else. Its a perfect storm for attendance issues.

TeaWithASplashOfMilk · 22/02/2024 21:16

There's a 50 per cent rise in teacher absence too.

CammyChameleon · 22/02/2024 20:56

Well you keep hearing how bad behaviour is in schools - other kids are having to cope with that bad behaviour.

I went to a school with appalling behaviour and I became a "school refuser" because of the violent little fucks I was forced to be around. It's quite scary when people throw chairs around a room and beat you or someone else up. I got spat on once.

The scariest incident was when a boy cornered me in our empty form room and started talking dirty to me and groping me while two other boys blocked the door. I don't know how far it would have gone if a teacher hadn't heard me shouting.

The deputy head told me off for being in the form room in the first place (I'd been there alone, reading a book during lunch as I had no friends - the patrolling teachers would usually turn a blind eye), refused to call my parents to come and get me, and sent me to my next lesson with the same boy who had groped me.

My parents weren't slack, they just couldn't make me go to school any more. Going to court and being told to go to school by a judge didn't make me go either.

They eventually managed to get me to an out of catchment school, but while the kids there were nice enough I was woefully behind by that point and stressed out by any sort of loud or rowdy behaviour - stressed out by other teenagers, basically. My attendance was still poor, and I left as soon as I legally could (15 back then).