Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you know this reason why strangers may be hanging about outside your home?

107 replies

ATadShocked · 21/02/2024 21:40

NC as I have spoken to people about this IRL.

I didn't know until very recently that our home broadband hub in our hallway is also being used as a public wi-fi hotspot by other passing BT/EE customers - did you?!

If, like me, you didn't know that and have noticed strangers hanging about outside your home with their phones then this may be the reason. I had assumed all the hotspots were in businesses or via masts, so I was a bit perturbed when I found out by accident that our hub was a hotspot. I would have liked to have been asked first. You can opt out, but only if you don't want to use other BT/EE hotspots yourself.

YABU: Yes, I knew my hub was also a public wi-fi hotspot and I don't mind

YANBU: No, I didn't know and I don't like the idea or I should at least have been asked to opt in

OP posts:
HiveSentinelApis · 22/02/2024 19:30

as far as im aware the general publics wifi are not hotspots unless you set the settings to a hotspot, as for people most would be using their own data,

ATadShocked · 22/02/2024 19:07

Just to answer a few points and questions:

There isn't really another explanation here for why strangers are loitering outside or sitting in their cars and vans for ages on their phones. It is concerning as it's not the norm around here, they are usually men, and people do worry about burglaries and car thefts. Sometimes they sit there with their engines running and polluting the air for an hour or more.

We live in the countryside in a fairly quiet place. Neighbours may stop for a chat with each other when walking the dog or on their way to the little shop, school or whatever. We get some walkers passing by who sometimes briefly stop to tie their shoelaces or consult a map. We get a few tourists who sometimes sit on the bench nearby for a while. Other than that it is people driving through down on the main road, visiting the pub down there or diverting in to come up to the little shop or small primary school.

I'm told that there's a map of local hotspots and our hub will be on that. I think a pp said that she has the BT app and so her phone picks up any local hotspots too.

I understand that some pps may not notice if they also have a lot of people around in their street waiting for buses or taxis or visiting businesses and so on.

OP posts:
HappiestSleeping · 22/02/2024 16:41

Fitzbillie · 22/02/2024 14:55

Thanks, @ColleenDonaghy and @HappiestSleeping. I understood the concept that my usage is prioritised but do you know how that works in practice? For example, is there a limit to how much of my bandwidth is allocated to me if the hotspot is in use by multiple users, how is the bandwidth divided up, what happens if more devices are connected to my router than it can handle (it’s quite old and the limit on device numbers is a lot lower than newer routers), is it instantaneous?

I do indeed live by a tourist hotspot in Central London 😂 And there is hotel that charges for Wi-Fi next door. I would guess that is exactly the kind of scenario where people might use a free hotspot rather than their own data to watch Netflix…

I shall try switching the hotspot off to see if that solves my bandwidth issues.

It doesn't work in the way you might think. Let's say you are looking at a website. You will type in the URL, say bbc.co.uk, your computer will send a request message (very small), and the server the other end will send back the raw code to your browser which contains all the information for your browser to build the Web page you requested. This is also a relatively small amount of data. The browser you are using then constructs the page using the code it has been sent. You could have many users doing this over your connection and you'd probably never even notice. How the prioritisation works is this: you essentially have two networks, your own, and the public one. Let's say you request a Web page on your own private network at the exact same instant that someone on the public one does. The router sends your request first, and queues the other one for however many microseconds it needs to. Ditto the response.

Doesn't matter how many users there are this will be the same principle so you would never really even know.

This system worked fine when it was originally conceived as the majority of Internet traffic was Web pages. Problem now though is that more people stream video, which in turn is more bandwidth intensive, so there would need to be fewer people all on at the same time in order that it becomes noticeable.

To counter this, there are fair use policies which prevent streaming from those public connections, and additionally the prioritisation of your traffic over anyone on the public part would probably make streaming untenable as there would be too much buffering. It's unlikely that anyone is standing outside your house watching a film, but they could conceivably be in the hotel next door attempting to. Most hotels these days have their own free WiFi though.

So the entire bandwidth is essentially shared, but your traffic is prioritised over anyone else. I can explain further if you would like?

ZetuianRose · 22/02/2024 16:35

This is old, old news, and yes - it was very much made clear in the documentation when I was with BT. You can choose to be part of (I think it is or was called Openzone?) or choose not to. If you opt out, then you don’t get the benefit of using other hotspots.

I believe there is a way around it by saying you’ll do it but then using your own router which then doesn’t allow it… but not sure how! Either way, it doesn’t affect your usage or security so it doesn’t really matter. I certainly never had anyone loitering outside my house 😂

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 22/02/2024 16:34

LakeTiticaca · 22/02/2024 08:55

I didn't know this was a thing and I certainly wouldn't want to pay for something that strangers can obtain for free. I would be worried about someone being able to hack into my data.
And no way I would want a bunch of strangers loitering out side my house!!

They can't get it for free Confused

ColleenDonaghy · 22/02/2024 16:25

Fitzbillie · 22/02/2024 14:55

Thanks, @ColleenDonaghy and @HappiestSleeping. I understood the concept that my usage is prioritised but do you know how that works in practice? For example, is there a limit to how much of my bandwidth is allocated to me if the hotspot is in use by multiple users, how is the bandwidth divided up, what happens if more devices are connected to my router than it can handle (it’s quite old and the limit on device numbers is a lot lower than newer routers), is it instantaneous?

I do indeed live by a tourist hotspot in Central London 😂 And there is hotel that charges for Wi-Fi next door. I would guess that is exactly the kind of scenario where people might use a free hotspot rather than their own data to watch Netflix…

I shall try switching the hotspot off to see if that solves my bandwidth issues.

Ah, next door to a hotel I'd definitely try turning it off! Not sure it'll work but if you don't depend on it yourself when out and about there's no downside to trying.

Fitzbillie · 22/02/2024 14:55

Thanks, @ColleenDonaghy and @HappiestSleeping. I understood the concept that my usage is prioritised but do you know how that works in practice? For example, is there a limit to how much of my bandwidth is allocated to me if the hotspot is in use by multiple users, how is the bandwidth divided up, what happens if more devices are connected to my router than it can handle (it’s quite old and the limit on device numbers is a lot lower than newer routers), is it instantaneous?

I do indeed live by a tourist hotspot in Central London 😂 And there is hotel that charges for Wi-Fi next door. I would guess that is exactly the kind of scenario where people might use a free hotspot rather than their own data to watch Netflix…

I shall try switching the hotspot off to see if that solves my bandwidth issues.

QueenCamilla · 22/02/2024 14:31

Andthereyougo · 21/02/2024 23:23

I didn’t know this existed. Just checked my list and yes there’s an unlocked BT/EE hotspot, think it must be ndn. I wonder if that’s why there’s a van parked in the road each weekday? I assume collects a child from the village school but turns up about an hour before school ends.

Van you say? Working days?
That'll be a tradie, who had to rush off the job at 2pm to "collect his child" or visit a "dying relative" or a "quick run to pick up supplies". He was then never seen again and left the job unfinished and the roof botched.

Whole of Mumsnet could do with your address @Andthereyougo !

That's much more likely ⬆️ 😆

coureur · 22/02/2024 14:12

If you replace the BT router with your own router (Netgear and D-Link are good) you'll stop providing the hotspot but still be able to use free EE Wifi.

Apple's Find My Phone and Airtag work in an analogous way - by using the iPhones of passers-by. Again, you can opt out of it, but then you won't be able to use Find My Phone or Airtags.

Giggorata · 22/02/2024 14:07

I have been grateful to use the open network when I've been away in my van and want to use the iPad.
I don't mind returning the favour either.

mindutopia · 22/02/2024 14:04

Yes, I have known this was a thing for ages. But we live in the middle of bloody nowhere. Like even the Amazon guy refuses to drive to our house some days and leaves parcels in the hedge somewhere down the lane. We have never been worried about foot traffic going by. But yes, I think we disabled it when we set it up. We have PlusNet now anyway.

Borborygmus · 22/02/2024 14:01

As has been said, BT have been doing this for years. I find it very handy. I much prefer to use WiFi than my meagre mobile data allowance.

Windy23 · 22/02/2024 13:49

Does this just apply to BT/EE or do any of the other ISPs do it? Sky for example?

HappiestSleeping · 22/02/2024 13:36

Morewineplease10 · 22/02/2024 13:31

@HappiestSleeping

So can he literally see everything that I'm doing? All my Internet history and what apps I'm on?

And is that whether I'm on my phone or a laptop?

I'm an absolute muppet with tech. I've asked friends in the past who work in tech and cyber security, they've assured me I've nothing to worry about.

He definitely has the ability and is horrible enough that he would do this. Is there anyway I could find out if he has?

Each of those questions requires a slightly different answer, but yes, if he has access to your network, it is possible that he could have complete access to all devices that are connected to that same network.

This takes quite a bit of specialist knowledge, and is unlikely, but it is definitely possible.

Morewineplease10 · 22/02/2024 13:31

@HappiestSleeping

So can he literally see everything that I'm doing? All my Internet history and what apps I'm on?

And is that whether I'm on my phone or a laptop?

I'm an absolute muppet with tech. I've asked friends in the past who work in tech and cyber security, they've assured me I've nothing to worry about.

He definitely has the ability and is horrible enough that he would do this. Is there anyway I could find out if he has?

InnocentAndDeranged · 22/02/2024 10:15

If it didn't take away my bandwidth, and their searches/sites they visit didn't go on my router or whatever, I wouldn't care. People can stand in the street for any reason.

If their sites DO go on your history or whatever then that isn't on, they could be accessing all sorts.

ColleenDonaghy · 22/02/2024 09:23

LakeTiticaca · 22/02/2024 08:55

I didn't know this was a thing and I certainly wouldn't want to pay for something that strangers can obtain for free. I would be worried about someone being able to hack into my data.
And no way I would want a bunch of strangers loitering out side my house!!

You pay for the ability to access BT WiFi pretty much wherever you go.

It doesn't increase the risk of someone accessing your data.

Vanishingly unlikely to result in strangers loitering outside your house.

lljkk · 22/02/2024 09:18

Cheap home wifi wasn't easily available 27 years ago.

We worked from home reliant on Ethernet cables until... 2004?

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 22/02/2024 09:05

Gosh. It's only 9am and I've learnt something! I'm with BT and had no idea.

artfuldodgerjack · 22/02/2024 08:58

If you changed the router would that solve the problem?

LakeTiticaca · 22/02/2024 08:55

I didn't know this was a thing and I certainly wouldn't want to pay for something that strangers can obtain for free. I would be worried about someone being able to hack into my data.
And no way I would want a bunch of strangers loitering out side my house!!

Theraffarian · 22/02/2024 08:16

@Chasingsquirrels this is going to sound so outdated , but I’m on a PAYG , so I top it up with £10 every few months , which covers the odd occasion I might have needed to pop the data on . My in built car GPS does all my navigating and lets me know about traffic queues and diversions I can take. Make calls via WhatsApp, message via it , rarely text . I’m guessing it sometimes takes 30 seconds to log into a restaurants WIFI etc that people can’t be bothered with .

2mummies1baby · 22/02/2024 08:14

Oh wow! That's longer than I thought.

LivingRoomTiger · 22/02/2024 08:13

Also, I live in a main road in London near a bus stop and shops. No idea if anyone is there for the wi-if, but I’ve never noticed it in particular. Not have I ever returned to the same hot spot over and over! It’s cold and dark outside most the time, seems an odd way to access the Internet when cafes, shopping centres and libraries etc are warm with wi-if

I’d out money on you having a pokestop near the house if there are genuinely groups with their phones out

Chasingsquirrels · 22/02/2024 08:11

2mummies1baby · 22/02/2024 08:09

Has Wi-Fi even been around for decades?!

1997, so a couple.
We got it around 20 years ago.

Swipe left for the next trending thread