Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery worker telling DD her behaviour…

213 replies

Ohwhatsthatnoise · 21/02/2024 21:23

…will make mummy sad.

And this just isn’t sitting well with me. Wondered what others would think? For context, DD is 2 and the most beautiful, headstrong little girl in the world. I hope to raise her be strong, to be kind, and to be brave. I don’t think I’d ever tell her that her behaviour makes me sad. I’d rather she understood the consequences of her actions. Today, she didn’t show good listening skills when she was asked not to do something, and she kept doing it and her key worker told her this would make me sad. I’d rather it was explained to her why she needed to listen.

If I were to say something to her key worker, would this come across as fluffy parenting with no discipline? It’s an eternal worry of mine because she is the love of my life and I worry I’ll be too soft on her.

OP posts:
WaitingfortheTardis · 22/02/2024 05:50

I agree with @Doingmybest12 , understanding the natural consequences of the way she behaves will help your dd learn. The nursery worker pointing this out is actually a kind and sensitive way to help your dd make the right choices.

HAF1119 · 22/02/2024 05:47

I think I would find it a bit peculiar myself to say 'mummy will be sad' about behaviours at nursery - given I'm not there and not a part of the consequence. I don't disagree with talking feelings - 'you're not listening to me and it's making me sad' or 'X is asking you to do Y, if you don't listen she may be sad' - but mummy isn't there or part of the feelings in my opinion!

Unless of course it was in the context of them doing a craft for mummy and she's not listening/doing what is asked at all, then it could be 'if you don't listen and do this for mummy, she won't get this Mother's Day craft and will be sad'

Feelings are great to discuss, but mummy feelings as a threat for behaviours which have absolutely nothing to do with mummy, I think is weird personally - them telling you at end of day if it continued and you asking child to please listen today before you drop off next day would be enough.

Doingmybest12 · 22/02/2024 05:45

I hope your child learns that how she behaves might make you sad at times. As well as you being happy, proud, frustrated , excited for her etc it's all part of learning about other people's emotions and ger own and how her interactions impact others , empathy.

GreenyBluePaint · 22/02/2024 05:39

You can’t micromanage how everyone speaks to your child. If your child is ok at nursery and seems happy, and they are otherwise kind to her, just let them get on with it. None of this stuff matters quite as much as you think it does.

Doingmybest12 · 22/02/2024 05:34

Maybe they tried the rest of the repertoire to manage what ever it was and got to the point of , 'I will need to talk to mummy about this'. Maybe you wouldn't be 'sad' but hopefully you might wish for your child to follow what is asked of them or be learning about the need to do this. If you delegate parenting especially to a group situation there is a natural consequence of that decision for you and your child , ie that somethings may not centre your child's every wish or need and that things are not done exactly as you would prefer, also that you'll get feedback about your child.

itsgettingweird · 22/02/2024 04:20

Well it should make you sad or cross or disappointed in her.

She refused to listen.

Learning how your actions affect riggers is an important lesson. You can see the affect of this not being apparent with older age groups currently.

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 22/02/2024 04:16

neonjumper · 21/02/2024 21:56

You are being unreasonable ... I'm not even going to explain why ... and as for the poster suggesting a 2 year old would understand the word 'frustrated ' ... well !!!!!

I presume @neonjumper that you know how children learn to talk the same language as their parents,and the society they are brought up in?

Simply put, if a baby was brought up where no language was ever spoken, only gestures, and actually doing things were the method of communication, it would mean that that baby couldn't learn to speak anything but it's own personal language.

So if we never say certain words to our babies or young children, then they could never learn the words that they never heard. My own - very naturally to me - language, that I spoke to my babies in (even from the time I first knew I was pregnant) was the normal one that I use when talking to people I love.

Therefore my baby will have first heard words like love, beautiful, wonderful, frustrated, excited, exemplary, fantastic, and potentially any other word in an English dictionary, whilst they were still in my womb. Once born, and over time, a baby will repeatedly hear certain words, and will unconsciously notice the moods, and reactions etc to those words, and that is how we all learn how to talk, and how to use the the most appropriate word for any particular occasion.

bradpittsbathwater · 22/02/2024 02:30

Headstrong and brave Confused

Snugglemonkey · 22/02/2024 02:22

Hollyhocksandlarkspur · 21/02/2024 21:41

I don’t think the nursery worker should speakfor you or use your emotions i. This loaded way. She should be managing DD’s two year old behaviour within the nursery framework and keep emotions out of it, way too intense.

I agree. I would have an issue if a child so wee was experiencing guilt or shame.

momonpurpose · 22/02/2024 02:05

PoisonMaple · 21/02/2024 21:40

'Headstrong'

😂

Right headstrong...

mathanxiety · 22/02/2024 02:00

Tumbleweed101 · 21/02/2024 22:09

There are very few ways you can make a child know there are consequences these days for persistent 'naughty' behaviour.

You can't say they are naughty, you can't do times out etc. I will sometimes tell a child their behaviour is making me sad - as opposed to 'just stop, you are being naughty! - because we have to be careful on what terminology is used. Some behaviour is simply naughty defiance and they know exactly what they are doing. I'd have handled it very differently with my own children than I have to with other people's children (not disputing this as there has to be a consistent way within care settings).

Maybe your child is simply not responding to.any other attempts at guiding their behaviour.and the nursery need a degree of support from you.

There are ways to tell a child their behaviour needs to change without using the word naughty, which is very abstract.

You can certainly avoid labeling the child - "You are naughty"/ "You are being naughty".

You can say, "I won't let you..." (hit Tommy, take the toy from Lucy, throw the blocks, etc).
Or, "Friends don't hit/ throw/ take toys."

You can say, "We listen to our teacher", or, "We use our words", or, "We wait our turn", or, "We must not throw things".

It's best to be concrete, and avoid abstracts like "be good", "that's naughty", etc.

Explicit, concrete instructions are best.
"Look up and listen to Miss Jane."
"Stop throwing the books."
"Walk in the hallway."
"Wait til Lucy is finished. Then it will be your turn."
And you can redirect.

For praise:
"Good co-operating."
"Good listening"
Etc.
(as opposed to "Good girl/ boy.")

Saytheyhear · 22/02/2024 01:51

It's manipulative. Paints you as the bad one.
Why does it not make the key worker sad?
Why mummy who isn't there and enjoys her as she is. Next it will be "that makes Santa sad. And that means no presents at Christmas."
I would challenge the key worker about presenting you so negatively. Just tell her no, we don't do that here. And if she asks why, say because I said no, it hurts etc and move on.

mathanxiety · 22/02/2024 01:42

Leonarda89 · 21/02/2024 22:51

I despair at some of the comments on here, a 2 year old not listening is not being naughty, they are being 2. Shaming them for that won't make them magically be able to behave in ways that their brain hasn't developed to yet. A 2 year old is not responsible for an adults emotions and shouldn't be told that their actions (which most of the time they can't control) make someone sad. This creates shame which leads to so many problems and doesn't teach them anything because they aren't old enough to have true empathy. These approaches hugely contribute to the social/emotional/behavioural difficulties which are increasing at an alarming rate.

Amen to all of that.

mathanxiety · 22/02/2024 01:41

MrsKintner · 21/02/2024 23:01

Don't think you can micromanage the nursery staff to this extent.

It might not be the way you would talk to your daughter, but you can't tell the nursery staff what words to use.

You can though.
If you heard that the nursery worker was calling your child a little shit, or even saying, "You're a naughty girl", you could absolutely 'micromanage'.

KevinKostnerOfferedMeACremeEggOnce · 22/02/2024 01:07

QuietBear · 21/02/2024 22:13

You need to support the nursery in correcting your child's behaviour.

We all love our children. Your DD isn't anymore loved, beautiful, headstrong or special than any other 2yo and I'm not sure how this relates to your complaint with the key worker?

I thought this too

Your child isn't the most beautiful in the world. She is to you, but not to the nursery worker, or other mums.

Not sure why it's relevant anyway.

Justfinking · 22/02/2024 01:07

PrincessOfPreschool · 22/02/2024 00:13

I have a very good grasp of child development, thank you (more than minimum wage deserves). It doesn't stretch to thinking that someone saying "mummy will be sad" is going to psychologically damage that child. In my opinion, the level of parental introspection, indulgence and entitlement going on here are likely to be far more damaging to the child long term than a random person who is in a child's life for a year or so making a rare comment.

And long term, for those working in childcare and teaching, the attitudes parents have are not making it easier to recruit. There are huge shortages of staff - which is also damaging to children's development and education. I'm grateful my children are just exiting all that because it's got a lot worse quite quickly.

👏👏👏

RightMoaningHilda · 22/02/2024 01:07

For “headstrong” read “precocious little shit”

PrincessOfPreschool · 22/02/2024 00:13

fourelementary · 21/02/2024 22:58

Even on minimum wage you should have a basic grasp of child development and child psychology surely though? And shaming and manipulation shouldn’t be seen as acceptable methods regardless of your pay packet.

I have a very good grasp of child development, thank you (more than minimum wage deserves). It doesn't stretch to thinking that someone saying "mummy will be sad" is going to psychologically damage that child. In my opinion, the level of parental introspection, indulgence and entitlement going on here are likely to be far more damaging to the child long term than a random person who is in a child's life for a year or so making a rare comment.

And long term, for those working in childcare and teaching, the attitudes parents have are not making it easier to recruit. There are huge shortages of staff - which is also damaging to children's development and education. I'm grateful my children are just exiting all that because it's got a lot worse quite quickly.

fourelementary · 21/02/2024 23:03

QuietBear · 21/02/2024 22:56

Does it really make you a terrible parent to be disappointed when your children misbehave?

I mean we are talking about a 2yo not listening (hardly the crime of the century!), but generally speaking I have high expectations of my children and they know it.

I'm not talking about guilt and shame, but yes I expect them to listen and be respectful to the person looking after them.

For example:

"I was sad to hear that you weren't listening to Aunty Jo when she took you to the park today. She won't want to take you again, and I won't let her, if you can't listen because she won't be able to keep you safe."

I said similar to my DS when he was 5yo and had spent the day being an absolute horror for my sister. He didn't do it again.

But why not just use the actual consequence of if you can’t listen you might not be safe rather than bringing your feelings into it? It’s a slipperly
slope making a toddler or child responsible for your feelings… and not fair to give them that power. That’s on you as an adult to be reflecting on your parenting skills and techniques if your child regularly misbehaves or doesn’t listen to be honest. Or on “Aunty Jo” for not having a better discipline technique when taking kids out for the day. Respect works two ways and far too many people fail to respect their child first and then wonder why they grow up to not respect you…

Tatonka · 21/02/2024 23:02

It's also probably developmentally accurate as around this age children start to learn different emotions etc my 2.5 year old is often using words like sad, happy etc and asking me the same "are you happy mummy" and I actually find it useful to say that's making me sad or angry if he's misbehaving. Give your children credit for not being stupid, they are much smarter than you realise

MrsKintner · 21/02/2024 23:01

Don't think you can micromanage the nursery staff to this extent.

It might not be the way you would talk to your daughter, but you can't tell the nursery staff what words to use.

Tatonka · 21/02/2024 22:59

PrincessOfPreschool · 21/02/2024 22:52

You will be on here desperately asking for advice when your beautiful, headstrong teenager has zero respect for you or anyone else because you've undermined all forms of authority in her life.

Ps. Newsflash! Nursery workers/ teachers etc. are not parenting everyone's child according to their individual parenting preferences. Seriously, we are paid minimum wage. You're lucky they are safe and learning something!

Agree with this. Unless it's particularly offensive to you, then I'd let this slide (what word would you use instead/ can they not mention you of that makes you feel better, and does it really matter on the great scheme of things). Of course, there is an alternative that you look after your own child yourself. The way you describe your child is not great, it's all very waffly for what sounds like a badly behaved child. Perhaps let the nursery do what they are doing, sounds like your child would benefit from it

fourelementary · 21/02/2024 22:58

PrincessOfPreschool · 21/02/2024 22:52

You will be on here desperately asking for advice when your beautiful, headstrong teenager has zero respect for you or anyone else because you've undermined all forms of authority in her life.

Ps. Newsflash! Nursery workers/ teachers etc. are not parenting everyone's child according to their individual parenting preferences. Seriously, we are paid minimum wage. You're lucky they are safe and learning something!

Even on minimum wage you should have a basic grasp of child development and child psychology surely though? And shaming and manipulation shouldn’t be seen as acceptable methods regardless of your pay packet.

ColleenDonaghy · 21/02/2024 22:57

I wouldn't have a problem with this. When my DC misbehave at nursery (as they all do at times), I feel frustrated and disappointed - or in a two year old's language, "sad".

It's important that they learn their actions have consequences, including causing sadness or anger in others.

Agree with other posters that you do sound a little precious - all two year olds are beautiful and headstrong! They're gorgeous, chaotic little sociopaths. Grin It's our job to temper that headstrongness with a decent dash of empathy and respect.

Moveoverdarlin · 21/02/2024 22:57

She’s talking to a 2 year old. Have a day off.