Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be embarrassed by our politicians?

118 replies

domineastronomy · 21/02/2024 20:45

What an absolute shambles in the Commons this evening.
Voting on Gaza was secondary to pathetic game playing and point scoring.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 21/02/2024 22:13

Agnes12 · 21/02/2024 22:07

However they vote will make absolutely no difference to the situation on the ground. I don’t think it symbolises anything. It’s performative. The only country in a position to realistically influence events is the US.

Yes and even then only just

WTF on the whole thing and the speaker bending to Labour

ChihuahuasREvil · 21/02/2024 22:10

Fiddling while Rome burns. There’s a whole country deep in the shit here and they’re pissing about playing student politics.

BarelyLiterate · 21/02/2024 22:09

Spectre8 · 21/02/2024 22:07

If it's meaningless why the duck arr they wasting time over it when it should be time spent on local issues

🙄

Good question. Don’t expect any MPs to answer it, though.

namechangefornow123 · 21/02/2024 22:08

@Spectre8 well quite. Because of the make up of the Labour Party / wanting to win votes / being scared of pro Palestinian supporters smashing up their offices or family homes

Spectre8 · 21/02/2024 22:07

If it's meaningless why the duck arr they wasting time over it when it should be time spent on local issues

🙄

Agnes12 · 21/02/2024 22:07

However they vote will make absolutely no difference to the situation on the ground. I don’t think it symbolises anything. It’s performative. The only country in a position to realistically influence events is the US.

BarelyLiterate · 21/02/2024 22:06

percypal · 21/02/2024 21:46

Don’t come at me but how can uk politicians decide to call a ceasefire in another country? I’m obviously missing something here.

No, you’re not missing anything. Nobody in either Israel or Gaza gives a toss what the British parliament says about anything. It’s all just pointless, empty posturing.

namechangefornow123 · 21/02/2024 22:05

HRTQueen · 21/02/2024 21:25

It was shameful

On such an important vote. Point scoring and playing political games

How is it an important vote?

It's entirely meaningless. Hamas / Israel won't be watching and thinking "oh shit yeah, better return the hostages and stop bombing, the SNP said so"

GreyBlackLove · 21/02/2024 21:54

That's my frustration too Fangisnotacoward, as a symbol or statement it's powerful but carries no true weight or consequence as far as I can tell. Would love to be corrected if that isn't the case though

Fangisnotacoward · 21/02/2024 21:54

percypal · 21/02/2024 21:46

Don’t come at me but how can uk politicians decide to call a ceasefire in another country? I’m obviously missing something here.

It's not just you, I've just asked a similar question.

I'm honestly confused by all the fighting for or against motions which as far as I understand isn't going to make any actual difference to the situation.

Fangisnotacoward · 21/02/2024 21:51

What would the various motions actually achieve in realistic terms, if one was agreed?

Genuine question. Then what? Hamas and Isreal say "oh UK government has agreed there should be a complete ceasefire, so let's all put ours guns down"?

I'm clearly missing something, because what will it DO? Does it do something tangible?

GreyBlackLove · 21/02/2024 21:51

It's to call for a ceasefire, rather than to call a ceasefire directly. So more like a formal call from one government to another to stop what they are doing than being able to enforce it.

RafaistheKingofClay · 21/02/2024 21:50

percypal · 21/02/2024 21:46

Don’t come at me but how can uk politicians decide to call a ceasefire in another country? I’m obviously missing something here.

They can’t. And as an opposition day motion the government aren’t legally bound by it.

It’s more about the British Parliament letting its will be known. Or not as it turned out.

percypal · 21/02/2024 21:46

Don’t come at me but how can uk politicians decide to call a ceasefire in another country? I’m obviously missing something here.

RafaistheKingofClay · 21/02/2024 21:43

BarelyLiterate · 21/02/2024 21:23

The allegation against the speaker is that he has today shown clear bias in favour of Labour on an issue (Israel / Gaza) on which there are major divisions in the party. By doing so, he very probably averted a major rebellion by left wing Labour MPs against the leadership.

That’s what he has apologised for, and that’s the reason why he is likely to face a vote of no confidence instigated by the Tories & the SNP. If that does happen, it’s very likely he will resign rather than being humiliated by losing the vote. It’s very unusual to see those parties on the same side of an issue.

Except that there are major divisions in the Tory party on this issue too. And part of the reason that the whole thing fell apart is that the Tories couldn’t get their MPs to either vote down the labour amendment or get the government amendment voted through. So they pulled it and tried various tactics to get the whole SNP motion and Labour amendment thrown out.

virtually every party could and perhaps should have done things differently. Including the speaker. But what Hoyle did was unusual but not unprecedented. It could have ended differently if the parties had reacted to it differently rather than politicking.

domineastronomy · 21/02/2024 21:39

There was so much aggressive shouting that most of them didn't notice that voting was taking place. Shocking scenes.

OP posts:
gannett · 21/02/2024 21:37

Being embarrassed by our politicians has been my default position for most of the past decade but I felt quite repulsed today. People dying and a humanitarian disaster unfolding, yet to them it's just a parlour game of semantics and procedure.

domineastronomy · 21/02/2024 21:35

A growing list of 'no confidence ' votes from SNP and Tories.
Don't think the Speaker will survive this.

OP posts:
rwalker · 21/02/2024 21:34

Not really the point of the tread but never understood why there allowed to behave how they do in the house shouting and jeering like there at a panto

if I behaved like that in a meeting at work I’d be asked to leave

Jumpitha · 21/02/2024 21:29

GreyBlackLove · 21/02/2024 21:27

  • Today is one of those days allocated to parties not in power, this time SNP

  • SNP wanted to vote on a motion calling for a ceasefire in Gaza and Israel, for Hamas to release all hostages and for an end to the collective punishment of the palestinian people

  • Labour wanted to vote on an amendment to call for a humanitarian ceasefire, removing the collective punishment wording and acknowledge Israel's right to self defence

  • The government wanted a similar amendment, but using "pause" rather than permanent ceasefire terminology among other things and echoing Labour's desire for a two state solution

  • Starmer was in a difficult position with the original motion, which would likely see a labour split

  • If the speaker accepted the labour amendment, they'd vote on that, and in doing so take SNPs motion off the table on what we might think of as "their" agenda day, if the speaker accepted the government motion it was unlikely labour would get their vote

  • No absolute rules, but generally you proceed with the option that allows the original motion to be voted on since the day is about giving smaller parties a chance to drive their agendas

  • speaker chose to vote on the labour under accusations of pressure from senior Labour members

  • chaos reigns and SNP/Conservative walk out

This is an excellent round-up. Thank you

GreyBlackLove · 21/02/2024 21:28

Sorry, that was my attempt at a summary for Jumpitha

Mischance · 21/02/2024 21:28

It is very sad. Some MPs start out trying to make serious points on behalf of their constituents, but within a year or two they join the point-scoring brigade. It is pitiful and, yes, embarrassing.

GreyBlackLove · 21/02/2024 21:27
  • Today is one of those days allocated to parties not in power, this time SNP

  • SNP wanted to vote on a motion calling for a ceasefire in Gaza and Israel, for Hamas to release all hostages and for an end to the collective punishment of the palestinian people

  • Labour wanted to vote on an amendment to call for a humanitarian ceasefire, removing the collective punishment wording and acknowledge Israel's right to self defence

  • The government wanted a similar amendment, but using "pause" rather than permanent ceasefire terminology among other things and echoing Labour's desire for a two state solution

  • Starmer was in a difficult position with the original motion, which would likely see a labour split

  • If the speaker accepted the labour amendment, they'd vote on that, and in doing so take SNPs motion off the table on what we might think of as "their" agenda day, if the speaker accepted the government motion it was unlikely labour would get their vote

  • No absolute rules, but generally you proceed with the option that allows the original motion to be voted on since the day is about giving smaller parties a chance to drive their agendas

  • speaker chose to vote on the labour under accusations of pressure from senior Labour members

  • chaos reigns and SNP/Conservative walk out

Jumpitha · 21/02/2024 21:27

NewName24 · 21/02/2024 21:22

I haven't seen any coverage today, but I totally agree we should be immensely embarrassed at the pantomime that is the House of Commons.

Every week PMQT is just a farce being acted out.

So many debates are just about posturing, point scoring, and trying to insult the opposing parties or politicians rather than actually using the time and energy to try to work out solutions to any problem.

I'm not suggesting a solution to the mess in the Middle East could be solved in the House of Commons in the UK, but so many awful domestic situations could be much improved if anyone were interested in trying to work towards that rather than just trying to insult other politicians.

It was always going to be a disaster from when they invited the TV cameras in in the first place, but the whole system needs to be radically overhauled.

Agreed. I believe before you were deemed honourable (hence the debacle over calling someone a liar was seen as more punishable than an actual liar lying in parliament) so this is now redundant.

it’s a joke, it’s not reality TV and needs burning to the ground and rebuilt foundations up.

HRTQueen · 21/02/2024 21:25

It was shameful

On such an important vote. Point scoring and playing political games

Swipe left for the next trending thread