Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks I ask him to do things I can just do myself! AIBU?

116 replies

LetsStartWithAir · 21/02/2024 20:38

Today, one of our DC has D&V. I spent the day cleaning up the aftermath and when DH arrived home, there were two nappy bags at the front door I hadn’t taken out to the bins yet. He walked into the house and I asked if he wouldn’t mind putting them in the bin outside. The reason I asked is that I was in my dressing gown and I don’t like going out the front unless I’m dressed. Not judgemental of others that do go out in dressing gowns. I’m just very self conscious and don’t want to be seen by neighbours because of my own insecurities.

Anyway, this somehow triggered DH into a big rant about why I always leave jobs like that to him.

This made me really upset. I don’t want to be too graphic, but let’s just say that clearing up the D&V was far more offensive than placing 2 nappy bags in a bin. In the end, I put the bags in the bin (dressing gown and all), as they needed to go out asap.

DH has since apologised but said that he is fed up of me asking him to do things that I could do myself. For instance, I don’t like going out to our garage once it’s dark outside. There is a bat that flies right by our back door and I’m petrified. Another example he gave is when I’ll ask him if he’ll go to the shops to pick something up in the evening. This might be on an occasion when I’m in my pyjamas. I have issues going out without having makeup on etc so once I take that off, I would have to re-do it to pop to the shops. This isn’t really frequent. Maybe once or twice in a month that I might ask him if he could go in the evening for that kind of reason.

I also want to caveat this by saying I have struggled with eating disorders and anxiety for many years due to being emotionally and verbally abused by my mum when I was a child. Although I’ve been to counselling because of this, I still struggle with having to look my best in public. I’m not trying to impress anyone. It’s just because on some level, I’m afraid for people to see me without this “mask”.

I said to my husband that I will try not to lean on him so much, but that I didn’t really feel sorry. I explained that he literally got so upset with me when I simply asked him a favour and that even though he has now apologised, he’s using my issues as the reason and I don’t think that’s really fair. I know I’m not perfect, and if he had come to me and told me how he felt, I’d have understood. But after the day I’ve had, a drama over something so small was really the last thing I needed. He’s upset by this and said that he can’t believe I won’t apologise for my role in it all.

Im finding it hard to figure out if I’m the one who’s just being stubborn here and would really appreciate honest replies, even if it’s deemed to be me that’s the problem.

So AIBU?

YABU - just say sorry for asking him favours.
YANBU - he shouldn’t have got mad at you and then should have apologised without passing the blame to you.

OP posts:
stayathomer · 21/02/2024 23:22

The only thing is it only once or twice a month for everything? See if dh decided something should go out to the shed and I was in the house, or it’s raining and I’m the one who’s been asked to go out, or it’s early in the morning etc etc, it would kind of get a bit annoying. If it really only is the odd time he’s being ridiculous or just had a bad day. Hope the d and v goes quickly

pizzaHeart · 21/02/2024 23:21

DelphiniumBlue · 21/02/2024 20:52

My DH does stuff that I don't like doing because he wants me to be happy, and actually likes to do things for me. In the same way that I do things for him. We are married and both consider that we are there to support each other.
There's a lot of stuff I wish he'd be more proactive about, but things like taking the rubbish out at night or doing a corner shop run are ways he can make my life easier with very little effort, and he recognises that.
I'd be wondering why your DH doesn't want to be nice to you, you're not asking for a lot.

This ^
And I don’t think he apologised sincerely. He didn’t understand that he was in the wrong. I’m sure you do a lot for him which he could have done himself. He is on a very dangerous territory with this approach.
His strop was pure nonsense. It was much more efficient for him to take the bag out as he was in the outdoor clothes rather than for you to make a specific trip.

JaneLawrence · 21/02/2024 23:19

I do things for DH that he can do himself, just as he does things for me that I can do myself.
That’s pretty normal in a relationship IMO.

Although the bit about not wanting to go outside if you’ve took your makeup off or you’re wearing pyjamas / dressing gown seems extreme.

Fourecks · 21/02/2024 23:17

I voted YABU in regards to the general situation - he should have taken out the nappy bags. It's interesting though that he was willing to apologise for that but you aren't prepared to reflect on your own behaviour.

Yes, a good partner should want to do things for each other. But when those favours are just expected then it does become frustrating.

My husband does this - will change into his pyjamas ridiculously early, then expect me to answer the door or go to the shops.

In essence, he makes a decision without consulting me that then results in more work for me. If he said something like, 'Hey, I'm really tired and I've had a big week but we need something from the shops so I'd really appreciate if you went', then that would be different.

That's where your husband's frustration is coming from. You are making a decision to get into your dressing gown and take off your makeup and just expecting he will pick up anything that needs to be done.

Mnetcurious · 21/02/2024 23:09

I’m assuming you do him little favours that he’s perfectly capable of doing himself, from time to time? Marriage is about give and take, helping each other out, not keeping score. He sounds very petty and I don’t think it was unreasonable of you.

JCLV · 21/02/2024 23:06

He sounds immature and childish.

mathanxiety · 21/02/2024 23:02

There's a part of me that hopes he catches the D&V bug and you can demonstrate to him what smallness and pettiness feel like when he's on the receiving end.

mathanxiety · 21/02/2024 23:00

YANBU.

Where does kindness figure in his response to you?

This is not a kind man.

BookishFran · 21/02/2024 22:59

Perhaps my long term partner (10 years) panders to me but if I mention something I am fancying he will often then offer to go to the shop and get it for me. It's a nice thing to do for someone you're in a relationship with... (and as I now work with a long commute and he is fully WFH he does many of the daily chores like laundry, dishes and hoovering. I grocery shop and cook and then we tackle other bits at the weekend so we are firmly in the equal share/arguably he does more camp).

I think if you ask and he says no, then the matter is left, that's fine. Obviously hassling him when you could expend the energy getting ready and then going is a different matter but that didn't seem the case from your post.

I think the nappy bags were probably a case of feeling put upon immediately through the door. When my partner worked outside the home and I was freelance I'd let him come in, change and get sorted before trying to then discuss things like dinner or weekend plans so it wasn't a barrage of information.

honeylulu · 21/02/2024 22:48

I thought he sounded unreasonable about the nappy bags but after hearing the rest it sounds like he snapped following a long history of you expecting him to baby you.

I know someone like that and her husband willingly babies her. She seems to have become more incapable as a result.

Pushing yourself out of your comfort zone will do you good. Get some comfy lounge wear for the evenings and don't put on pyjamas or flannel off your make up until you go to bed.

Comtesse · 21/02/2024 22:33

Both me and my husband go to the shop in the evening to buy milk etc. It’s not ridiculous to ask him to go once every 2-4 weeks, that’s pretty normal.

Pretty stupid of him to make a huge fuss about the nappy bags.

Not going out without makeup? Mate, this is quite extreme.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/02/2024 22:25

I think when you have an anxiety disorder it is really hard to understand how it impacts the people around you. Almost everyone I have met like this either does not understand it at all or doesnt understand the magnitude of the impact it has on their loved ones. Are you working on not needing him to prop you up like this? If you did those things yourself sometimes, or he could see you were working on not letting your anxiety run your life, he may be less fed up with you at other times.

PuppyMonkey · 21/02/2024 22:15

This bloke occasionally “helps” doing stuff that needs doing. He’s a bloody hero, no question. Hmm

Ilovelurchers · 21/02/2024 22:08

I think if I was in your husband's position, while I would be willing to help, I would want to feel you were working on the issues (the make-up ones and the fear of the dark preventing you from accessing parts of your own property in the evening). Both of these are dehibilitatiing phobias for an adult to have - admittedly not totally ruining your life, but preventing you from doing things most adults can happily do. Plus they are impacting on him too on a small way.

I think you need to address them for your own sake and his, and going forwards for your kids too - what if they need you to take them out at night to a firework display or to fetch a toy in they have left out in the garden when your husband is away or... I don't know, countless examples.....

You can get help with phobias - they can be tackled. It's a loving act to do so. Good luck.

Jingleballs2 · 21/02/2024 22:07

I agree I think today has been the straw that broke the camels back, and it's not about not wanting to help put out the nappy bags. Of course he should help after the day you've had, but the other things just sound ridiculous tbh and I'm not surprised it's annoying for him.

Lampslights · 21/02/2024 22:01

MiltonNorthern · 21/02/2024 21:23

He shouldn't have got cross about the nappy bags but the other examples you gave must be really annoying. I'd have no patience with being asked to go to the shops after I got back from work because my partner had already taken her makeup off. Just no.

If my husband said to me, I’ve got my pjs on can you go to the shops for me, in the evening, regularly, I’d tell him to jog on. Or if he sent me regularly to thr garage as he was scared of the dark or bats. Or told me he can’t go out In public without looking a certain way then deliberately got changed and then asked me to go do it for him, I’d consider kicking him in the nuts.

TadpolesInPool · 21/02/2024 22:00

The once or twice a month when you're in your pjs and ask him to go to the shop: is he already home? Is it for family things (key ingredient for evening meal) or is it a snack you've suddenly fancied?

Can't you plan things better so you don't suddenly need things in the evening twice a month?

Nappy bag = fair enough he should do it. But it sounds like its the straw that broke the camel's back.

Fionaville · 21/02/2024 21:57

I'm a SAHM. My DH works full time. I would think nothing of asking him to run the shop or doing anything else that needed doing. No way I'd go out to the garage of a night or in my dressing gown to put something in the bin. Your DH was prepared to walk past the nappy bags! It wasn't like you got him out of bed to put them out. He's being ridiculous and very unhelpful and I'd tell him as much. You've had a bad day too. Partners are supposed to look after each other.

LoveSkaMusic · 21/02/2024 21:53

I would really like to know how many times per week you ask him to do something like make you drinks, make snacks, or run to the shop of an evening. How much running around is he doing after work outside of sharing the household load?

It would drive me barmy if I had to run around after my partner constantly when I've earned some evening time.

I'm not saying that's the case here, but is there the possibility that it's all one-sided and he's annoyed with that in general?

IslayAnn · 21/02/2024 21:49

To be honest it sounds like the thing with the nappy bag was part of a bigger issue, of course he should have just put the nappies in the bin seeing as you had been coping with a sick child all day. But the other things sound like your issues that you need to work on and by the sounds of it you know that, not going to the garage in the dark because of a bat? Really???

rainyskylight · 21/02/2024 21:47

The nappy thing YANBU but it may be that to him it’s not really about that, it’s about all the other things.

It’s not exactly fair on your husband that he has to trek back out of the house when he’s tired and wants to sit down because you’ve decided to put your pjs on early. If you’ve put them on at a reasonable pj hour (10pm) then it’s pretty shoddy of you to ask him to go out then.

Maybe you should think about whether you need to go out again before you settle down for the night, rather than relying on your husband to go out in the cold.

NewName24 · 21/02/2024 21:37

I can't vote as per your instructions, as of course you shouldn't apologise for asking a favour, but OTOH

This might be on an occasion when I’m in my pyjamas. I have issues going out without having makeup on etc so once I take that off, I would have to re-do it to pop to the shops.
If it is really an issue for you to nip out without being smartly dressed and made up, then why do you get into your PJs and take your make up off so early ? I wouldn't be impressed if my dh decided he couldn't go out anywhere unless dressed for work, (for whatever reason) if he changed out of his work clothes early in the evening. You can't really have it both ways.

The nappy bags incident sounds like you both had a really bad day. Logically of course he should have done them, but I kind of get the "have a bad day at work / bad commute then being given a job before you've even shut the front door" annoyance much as I also see from your perspective you'd had an awful day too - although presumably he didn't know that at the time, same as you didn't know anything about his day at the time.
He has apologised for that though, but you think you have a 'right' to make him go out whenever it is needed that one of you needs to. In that, I think YABU.

MrsKintner · 21/02/2024 21:34

Do you things, 'favours' for him too?

I do things for my DH that he could do himself, he does things for me. That's a normal relationship.

MamaGhina · 21/02/2024 21:27

You won’t apologise for your “role” in all this? What role?! You asked him to put the nappy bags in the bin FGS, it was hardly a big ask.
YANBU OP. You have nothing to apologise for.

Rialoulou · 21/02/2024 21:27

It sounds like he's struggling because of the pressure added to him because of your insecurities. He's not wrong. Sounds like today was the final straw. You not nipping out to the bin for needing a full face of make up, that's so limiting and I can understand why it would drive him mad. Obviously as a single issue without the back story then he is being unreasonable, but with the story, I get it.