Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask a parent to drop out of a trip?

236 replies

RadicalRadishes · 21/02/2024 13:52

My DD’s class goes on school trips quite frequently and it’s pretty much the same ~4 parents every time. I’m usually not available, but the one time I was it was full by the time I messaged the office to volunteer.

I just found out there is a school trip on DD’s birthday. DH checked he could rearrange his schedule to attend but now is being told all the parent slots are full.

Would it be reasonable in the class WhatsApp group to ask if one of the regular attendees would be willing to give up their spot for him?

OP posts:
GRex · 21/02/2024 19:08

So much angst! Ask the teacher, ours has taken one or two extra parents on each trip as the kids are little so extras on the road crossings help. I doubt teachers are picking useful parents at our school, they just ask who wants to go and we always got a spot so far. How would they know who isn't useful if they haven't been before with that teacher? I can't think of any parents in our year group who would be so useless they would ignore kids in their group, nor run about getting ice cream, nor knowingly leave coats etc.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 21/02/2024 19:06

Shoutinglagerlagerlager · 21/02/2024 14:14

It doesn’t hurt to ask. Definitely explain about the birthday in your request.

Don’t explain about the birthday, it is irrelevant. Just say you can’t normally make it but am able to this time is there anyone signed up who would like to change.

6pence · 21/02/2024 19:02

If you don’t ask you don’t get.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 21/02/2024 19:00

I agree you need to talk to the school.
Its not a case of the parents deciding who volunteers. The school may choose regular parent volunteers for their own reasons.
And as a parent I would be concerned that his reason for volunteering means the other children in his group will be neglected as he focuses only on his daughter.

weefella · 21/02/2024 18:57

If one of the parents did drop out as requested, there is no guarantee that the DH would be picked to be the replacement. It would be the school's decision -not something for the parents to decide on between themselves.

I've been on a lot of school trips over the years. For some it was as part of my job, and others as a volunteer. There were definitely a few parents who seemed to think it was just a day out with their own child.

I remember coming across one group of Yr1 children who were standing around by themselves. The parent in charge had gone off to take photos of her child next to the exhibits and had left the remainder of the group behind. On another trip, someone decided to be 'fun parent' and had led their group off to the play area rather than the actual place where they were meant to be.

Schools don't know which type of volunteer a parent will turn out to be, so they tend to pick the ones that have a proven track record.

TheNoodlesIncident · 21/02/2024 18:56

I used to go with DS's class on trips to supervise him, as it meant his 1:1 could look after four other kids. If I didn't go, the TA would have to just watch him so they would need more helpers.

As he got older I had a few to look after as well as him, it did get more interesting then. But even when I was responsible for just DS I did keep an eye on other kids and pick up forgotten jumpers etc. It's not a jolly at all, the responsibility and having to have eyes on the back of your head is exhausting!

Rosesarere · 21/02/2024 18:55

In the school my daughters attend it's the parents that regularly help out with other events get first choice to go on the trips, rightly so. I wouldn't want to give up my place tbh

LadeOde · 21/02/2024 18:53

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 21/02/2024 15:55

It literally says in the OP the trip is on her birthday

The trip is on her birthday, that I get, but what have the two got to do with each other other than they clash? why is OP's DH trying to go on the 'school' trip?

Surely what parents do for b'days is they organise some kind of celebration and invite school friends to the event or they take they b'day dc on a nice day out with friends. I've NEVER heard of parents trying to piggyback on a school trip and pretend it's some kind of pseudo birthday celebration which is why i asked if there is some other link between the two events that I've missed?

viques · 21/02/2024 18:52

HeddaGarbled · 21/02/2024 15:03

The teachers would probably prefer to keep their regulars. Keeping all the children safe and behaving whilst out and about can be a bit of a nightmare, so old-hands who are known to be reliable and know the individual children, are more useful than newbies who may need a fair bit of supervision and guidance themselves.

I agree, especially people who apparently fancy volunteering because it will be their child’s birthday. Is he planning on pulling a birthday cake and candles out of a bag on the coach home? The whole thing sounds more about him playing superdad than understanding that school trips take a lot of organisation and planning, are bloody hard work , very stressful ,and are there to enhance classroom learning not provide an opportunity for performance parenting.

DillDanding · 21/02/2024 18:52

I went on a lot of school trips and would’ve bitten someone’s arm off to get an excuse to stand down!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 21/02/2024 18:49

Swanhilde · 21/02/2024 18:05

Really? Things have changed since my kids were at primary school then, not that long ago. That's quite concerning really. How do they get around being left alone with the children? Surely having DBS is still best practice?

No one off parent helper should be left alone with a child, and issuing DBS checks excessively just leads to complacency because people assume that clear DBS = safe and the two are not the same.

Schools (amongst other places) have had to massively cut down on the number of dbs checks they were getting both for costs and because there is a better understanding of when they’re actually entitled to use them

arethereanyleftatall · 21/02/2024 18:45

Of course parents don't choose and swap volunteers!!

It's up to the teachers.

They choose the ones who are capable of doing it!

Capable of actually looking after a group of children rather than going on a jolly birthday trip with their own child.

And that's why parent volunteers should be praised and everyone else should be very very grateful for them doing an unpaid role to help all children.

BusyMummy001 · 21/02/2024 18:40

Assuming he has a current dbs, ie satisfies the criteria to attend, I think there is no issue with asking on the WhatsApp.

Syppox2000 · 21/02/2024 18:31

Drives me nuts when parents who don’t help with anything else want to come on school trips as they think it’s a ‘jolly ‘!
I’ve helped with swimming lessons in a year my children are not in as there is no volunteers ever for that or school fairs etc. No problems with school trips .

Also had parents handing out chocolate biscuits and taking their group into the shop to buy them souvenirs . As a teacher you just want to take the most helpful parents as trips are certainly not just a fun day out !

AnneElliott · 21/02/2024 18:31

I'm a beaver leader and we definitely pick the parents we want to come on trips - even if we tell them it's names in a hat! Some parents are a massive PITA so we refuse to have them with us.

At DSs school we used to be in the group with our child. I always used to get the naughty twins though Smile.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 21/02/2024 18:30

I volunteer quite a bit and volunteer for the more boring ones harvest festival) and hard work ones (full days out) so I can help too with the more interesting ones (theatre trips) so I wouldn't want to swap if it was a fun one or if I'd already told my children but would happily swap a harder work one!! I get put with my children and don't ignore the others!!

Squirrelsbite · 21/02/2024 18:26

Sorry but why should your Dh ‘need’ to go on a trip that has been arranged and volunteers sorted just because you/he wants to be with your DD on her birthday

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2024 18:24

90yomakeuproom · 21/02/2024 14:46

It's bad practice to have parents in their own child's group. They will be too bothered about their own child to look after the rest and its unfair. You don't volunteer for a trio to be with your child, it's to help the school with ratios so the whole trip can go ahead.

So have you never looked after other kids alongside of your own? Occasionally we walk each others kids home etc. I'm MORE vigilant with other people's kids. I've never seen a parent ignore the other kids in their groups or let them get lost etc because they're so focused on their own kid. Obv it happens but I don't think it's the norm and we've ALWAYS had our own kid and then usually a couple of kids they're close to

HollaHolla · 21/02/2024 18:21

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 21/02/2024 17:16

@HollaHolla

three trips in a week?!?!

My god woman, there's not enough gin the world to get me through that! Respect!! ✊

I was young. I think my Dad promised me £20 for each one. All things which would not be the case nowadays. 😂
But, I did learn about some prehistoric cave paintings, a medieval castle, and an animal park, all in the same week. Even if I was stopping children yeeting themselves off battlements (to see the William Wallace/Mel Gibson statue), climbing in beside the monkeys, and being left behind in a cave which is only accessible at low tide.
(That combo might give away where I grew up!!)

SleepingStandingUp · 21/02/2024 18:17

LilacStork · 21/02/2024 17:51

I'm a teacher.
I take the same 4 parents on every trip.
Parent 1: Child is a flight risk, if mum doesn't come he can't.
Parent 2: Child has physical disabilities and needs to be accompanied in toilet and PEG fed.
Parent 3: Child has epilepsy, whilst this could be managed by staff, it would need to be in addition to numbers in case of hospital trip being needed.
Parent 4: Child has severe anxiety, will not enter unfamiliar place without parent.

I still send a general message to everyone requesting volunteers but I know who I will take regardless of response.

How are those parents not 121s tho? If you give Parent 3 four kids and her kid has a fit, the ratios will be out unless she's there purely for him. Who would have the other three? Etc.

In our school I always go as DS' 121 although will help out with general coralling, loo duties etc. one child with autism always has one of their adults with them, 121. Another child has epilepsy, Mom comes 121. None of us have other kids. THEN they divide the kids left into groups and work out how many EXTRA parents they need

LilacStork · 21/02/2024 18:12

CharlotteBog · 21/02/2024 18:06

This isn't quite the same as regular parent helpers, is it?
It sounds like these parents are needed as more one-to-ones for specific children and thus not readily available for the herding cats element of a school trip.

Why can't you be open and honest about why you need to take these 4 parents? I'd be a bit miffed to organise potential time off only to find out that I had 0% chance of being asked.
Can those children still go if their parents don't accompany them?

My point was you don't know why those volunteers are regular volunteers. Yes they are supernumerary, there are however no rules on how many adults are required only guidance and in reality the herding cats is done by school staff.

We do not share the reasons as the children have a right to privacy. Some things are confidential.

The email we send out as a school says something like, we will need volunteers, if you would potentially be available please contact us, should we get more volunteers than required parents with experience and DBS will be considered first followed by parents with DBS. Parents without DBS will be considered if necessary.
If you wish to get DBS checked by school to be considered in future please contact the office.

90yomakeuproom · 21/02/2024 18:10

Woodyandbuzz1 · 21/02/2024 16:35

I've never seen anyone behave like that before

I have 🤣

CharlotteBog · 21/02/2024 18:09

Swanhilde · 21/02/2024 18:05

Really? Things have changed since my kids were at primary school then, not that long ago. That's quite concerning really. How do they get around being left alone with the children? Surely having DBS is still best practice?

I think they are NEVER actually alone with any child.
My youngest in 14 and when I helped on trips I was never, ever alone with any of the children.
Helped with swimming, but wasn't allowed to help the girls with long hair get their hats on, told that if a kid fell in I wasn't allowed to jump in and save them (I would have, and taken the consequences).

APART FROM......
The most ridiculous thing was that they were happy for me to drive kids to sport events in my car though.

Godwindar · 21/02/2024 18:07

SooticaTheWitchesCat · 21/02/2024 14:40

I always had my girls in my group when doing school trips, all the parents did. The teaches would put parents and children together. I don't think as many parents would want to go if they couldn't actually be with their child

Me too. And on one memorable trip, as she was seen as one of the sensible ones, she was paired up with a less sensible child and I was called to stop them disrobing in the sandpit. So don't assume you will be spending quality bonding time with your child!

CharlotteBog · 21/02/2024 18:06

LilacStork · 21/02/2024 17:51

I'm a teacher.
I take the same 4 parents on every trip.
Parent 1: Child is a flight risk, if mum doesn't come he can't.
Parent 2: Child has physical disabilities and needs to be accompanied in toilet and PEG fed.
Parent 3: Child has epilepsy, whilst this could be managed by staff, it would need to be in addition to numbers in case of hospital trip being needed.
Parent 4: Child has severe anxiety, will not enter unfamiliar place without parent.

I still send a general message to everyone requesting volunteers but I know who I will take regardless of response.

This isn't quite the same as regular parent helpers, is it?
It sounds like these parents are needed as more one-to-ones for specific children and thus not readily available for the herding cats element of a school trip.

Why can't you be open and honest about why you need to take these 4 parents? I'd be a bit miffed to organise potential time off only to find out that I had 0% chance of being asked.
Can those children still go if their parents don't accompany them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread