Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask a parent to drop out of a trip?

236 replies

RadicalRadishes · 21/02/2024 13:52

My DD’s class goes on school trips quite frequently and it’s pretty much the same ~4 parents every time. I’m usually not available, but the one time I was it was full by the time I messaged the office to volunteer.

I just found out there is a school trip on DD’s birthday. DH checked he could rearrange his schedule to attend but now is being told all the parent slots are full.

Would it be reasonable in the class WhatsApp group to ask if one of the regular attendees would be willing to give up their spot for him?

OP posts:
UnderTheMidnightMoon · 22/02/2024 07:45

UnderTheMidnightMoon · 22/02/2024 07:41

Yes, but why then is it that people can rearrange things for a school trip but not for other things is the point that poster was making. I'm sure you knew that

Edited

And also, how incredibly patronising to say "you don't understand work". Most people on here work. You don't need to come every week for reading and could go on a day without an important meeting. No-one is saying you have to do that though - but getting shitty with someone because they couldn't possibly understand your terribly important job and meetings is rude as hell

MissMelanieH · 22/02/2024 07:43

I'm guessing that it won't be "first come first served" if the same few go every time it's probably because the staff in school know that they're reliable and will genuinely get stuck in with helping with the kids including doing the boring bits like the toilet run and clearing up after lunch.

The fact that your dh was asking for a swap because it's dd's birthday would fill me with fear (from a teacher perspective) because I'd imagine losing a reliable helper and gaining somebody who's going to swan around having "quality 1-1 time" rather than helping properly.

I'm not sure how you'd make it onto the genuinely helpful list for the future? Maybe start volunteering at in-school events and show you're a good worker.

School trips can be hard work and a lot of responsibility for those in charge so you can't blame them really for wanting reliable people.

UnderTheMidnightMoon · 22/02/2024 07:41

GRex · 22/02/2024 07:24

I think you don't understand about work. I can't schedule bits of time out of work twice a week for reading, because I can't control what days there will be important meetings. I can arrange an afternoon off sometimes for a trip. Scheduling is not easy for l people who have responsibilities outside the home.

Yes, but why then is it that people can rearrange things for a school trip but not for other things is the point that poster was making. I'm sure you knew that

EarringsandLipstick · 22/02/2024 07:29

OP what a strange reaction to the suggestions here! That you'll never volunteer again, and that it's all political.

Volunteer when you can.

Don't make a big deal about DH going but no harm to ask if anyone would like to swap.

GRex · 22/02/2024 07:24

Thursa · 21/02/2024 23:40

I volunteered a lot when my boys were young. For about 5 years I was at the school at least twice a week. Parents didn’t want to help with the day to day stuff like helping with reading or maths, or running the book club, or the school play rehearsals. I got asked a lot. As soon as a fun thing came up suddenly there were loads of volunteers, people you rarely ever saw.

I think you don't understand about work. I can't schedule bits of time out of work twice a week for reading, because I can't control what days there will be important meetings. I can arrange an afternoon off sometimes for a trip. Scheduling is not easy for l people who have responsibilities outside the home.

Tamuchly · 22/02/2024 04:45

Unfortunately parent helpers can’t always be trusted!

A parent helper on a Y4 trip to a nearby city vanished after arrival leaving the staff and volunteers out of ratio and having to get someone to drive out to meet them so the trip could continue. When asked later she said it all seemed to be under control so she thought she’d go shopping! Needless to say but she won’t be allowed to volunteer again.

Edited to add the parent on a YR trip to the zoo who dumped her group with the teachers to go and eat at the cafe instead of bringing a packed lunch and eating with the children in the picnic area.

I did lots of volunteering before I worked in the school, was only with one of my children on one trip due to personal care needs otherwise I was always placed with other groups. Trips are hard work, often fun and quite rewarding - not really an opportunity to spend quality time with your own child though.

CrappyBarbara · 22/02/2024 01:01

Woodyandbuzz1 · 21/02/2024 16:35

I've never seen anyone behave like that before

Me neither and I’ve been on many private and state school trips as well as a fair few scout trips.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/02/2024 00:51

HelloMiss · 21/02/2024 22:02

So glad to hear DBS checks are done these days!

Depends on the school. Ours don't.

wandawaves · 22/02/2024 00:44

LadeOde · 21/02/2024 18:53

The trip is on her birthday, that I get, but what have the two got to do with each other other than they clash? why is OP's DH trying to go on the 'school' trip?

Surely what parents do for b'days is they organise some kind of celebration and invite school friends to the event or they take they b'day dc on a nice day out with friends. I've NEVER heard of parents trying to piggyback on a school trip and pretend it's some kind of pseudo birthday celebration which is why i asked if there is some other link between the two events that I've missed?

Your continued faux confusion is cringeworthy.

SE13Mummy · 22/02/2024 00:13

Get your husband to contact the teacher himself, explain it's DD's birthday on the day of the trip and that he's been able to arrange to have the day off. Say he'd love to come and help out on the trip that day, even if DD isn't in his group but also acknowledge that regular helpers are all in place as he'd not realised how quickly parent helpers volunteered at this school. He could offer his services as an extra helper if appropriate or ask if the teacher thinks any of the regulars would take pity on him and swap...

I'm a primary teacher and when at schools that made use of parent helpers, I would ask parents to let me know if they were able to help and would then work out who I needed for that particular trip. I didn't do first come, first served and nor did I do names out of a hat. I tried to use a range of parents across the year. Sometimes the parent had their own child in the group, sometimes they didn't. It depended on the dynamics of the groups and the nature of the trip.

When my DC were in primary school, I had one day off per week so would volunteer to help on any trip that fell on that day. I used to teach at the school they attended so was often used by my ex-colleagues as an extra adult on trips and given the same 'perks' as the other teachers e.g. larger group, more lively children etc.

Thursa · 21/02/2024 23:40

I volunteered a lot when my boys were young. For about 5 years I was at the school at least twice a week. Parents didn’t want to help with the day to day stuff like helping with reading or maths, or running the book club, or the school play rehearsals. I got asked a lot. As soon as a fun thing came up suddenly there were loads of volunteers, people you rarely ever saw.

pokebowls · 21/02/2024 23:32

@UnderTheMidnightMoon who said anything about caring for parents? I said building community and a harmonious environment. Not create one of division and disappointment. You can't do that whilst pissing off parents.

Dancingontheedge · 21/02/2024 23:32

Over thirty years, I’ve had some amazing parent helpers. And some incompetent ones. And some nightmares. Most are…fine.
The children are the priority, so if I’ve had to deal with careless, inappropriate or otherwise useless adults on a trip, I never invited them again. My reasons and concerns were shared with other teachers who may have to deal with them in the future.

UnderTheMidnightMoon · 21/02/2024 23:25

pokebowls · 21/02/2024 22:49

@Tiredforfive45 schools and teachers should be creating community and a safe and harmonious environment not creating division and a sense of favouritism. If you don't think that's important I'm not sure teaching is the right job for you.

It isn't a school's job to care for parents at all I'm afraid. I think you've got the wrong end of the stick about what schools actually do. The children's safety comes first at all times. It's the first thing you learn when you work in a school tbh. Creating harmony among parents by making sure they all get a turn at school trips? No, not the school's job at all. I'm sure you know all this since you were ready to tell someone "teaching isn't for them" Shock. Christ.

FuckityFuckBollocks · 21/02/2024 23:25

Hmmm…how useful is your DH realistically going to be with the other kids? The regular helpers will be used to school trip routines etc and have got to know the children.

Yes it would be lovely for your DD but what about the rest of the class? He’d be there to support the whole class, not just your DD.

SpringSparrow · 21/02/2024 23:19

I used to help with the trips at my children’s school but I also used to go in and hear all the class read at least one morning a week for four plus years. The teachers knew that I knew all the children in the class. I also had a dbs check and worked with children and families in a professional capacity previously. They always asked me rather than me asking them.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 21/02/2024 23:03

Barleysugar86 · 21/02/2024 23:02

For what its worth my sons primary isn't like this at all- they ask for volunteer parents, take first come first served, never ask about DBS checks and put children with their parents group. My husband had our son and two others on their recent museum trip.

I hope I’m reading that wrong and your husband wasn’t left solo with 3 children on a trip.

Barleysugar86 · 21/02/2024 23:02

For what its worth my sons primary isn't like this at all- they ask for volunteer parents, take first come first served, never ask about DBS checks and put children with their parents group. My husband had our son and two others on their recent museum trip.

pokebowls · 21/02/2024 22:49

@Tiredforfive45 schools and teachers should be creating community and a safe and harmonious environment not creating division and a sense of favouritism. If you don't think that's important I'm not sure teaching is the right job for you.

Tiredforfive45 · 21/02/2024 22:04

pokebowls · 21/02/2024 21:17

Then it would be good for you to know that it created an awful lot of bitterness and resentment amongst parents when the same 4 or 5 parents are 'selected' as
A) how does anyone else get the experience you so value if you keep using the same few who volunteered at the very beginning of their time at the school?
B) the volunteers dc get to see their parents again and again but others never get that experience
C) it creates a sense of favouritism (which you've confirmed you do have)
D) it creates a sense that there are parents who are in the inner circle. This is a TERRIBLE dynamic to create. The complete opposite of what a school should be aiming to create. 👏🏼......👏🏼.......👏🏼

Schools should be aiming to educate children and keep them safe…whether the parents think I have favourites or not makes no difference whatsoever to either of those things.

HelloMiss · 21/02/2024 22:02

Swanhilde · 21/02/2024 17:26

This is all academic until you tell us if he has a DBS certificate. He won't be going anywhere without one I'm afraid.

So glad to hear DBS checks are done these days!

Starlightstarbright3 · 21/02/2024 21:52

When my Ds was in primary school . I was never with my Ds . He was always in his teachers group.🫣.

I had a child in my group once birthday . I made sure she was picked when they asked for volunteers . I wouldn’t do that for my own Ds because of favouritism

viques · 21/02/2024 21:41

@RadicalRadishes

A father has to go on a school trip ”to show his face and show he cares” !!!!

Show who?

your child - does a father really have to go on a school trip to see his child and let them know he cares.

the school - I don’t think they need attendance on a school trip to assess this.

As I said before, sounds like he wants a performance parenting opportunity and the trip fits the bill.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 21/02/2024 21:35

I would guess your dh will be given a small group of boys, and your dc will be placed in a different group.

Is dh happy to volunteer in that situation, or is he only wanting to go because it is your child's birthday.

I have been on many school trips in the last few years, I do not have a child at the school. As a result I know all of the children, and their names. I don't get given loud ones or ones that may play up / get over excited or the shy / quiet ones.
I do not lead the walking crocodile nor am I at the end.

I also do not take any child to the toilet - that is only done by the staff. ( and quite rightly too )

claretblue79 · 21/02/2024 21:29

I think a school and teachers have to make a decision based on parents who are reliable and follow instructions well. Having helped with a few in my son's school , I am placed with different year groups to my son and I think that's probably for the best as it might be embarrassing for him to have his dad walking round with him. It's probably different at other schools but I don't think there is massive competition for helpers at ours. Ultimately, it's what works best for the children and staff and not always what the parent would like.