Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask a parent to drop out of a trip?

236 replies

RadicalRadishes · 21/02/2024 13:52

My DD’s class goes on school trips quite frequently and it’s pretty much the same ~4 parents every time. I’m usually not available, but the one time I was it was full by the time I messaged the office to volunteer.

I just found out there is a school trip on DD’s birthday. DH checked he could rearrange his schedule to attend but now is being told all the parent slots are full.

Would it be reasonable in the class WhatsApp group to ask if one of the regular attendees would be willing to give up their spot for him?

OP posts:
budgiegirl · 22/02/2024 13:55

Politely asking if anyone is willing to give up their space so the DH can go instead isn't complaining

As long as the DH is polite, and he words it carefully, then I guess it's ok, as long as he understands that the answer may be no.

Suggesting an alternative way of picking helpers so it's more varied is not complaining.

As a cub leader, if someone asked me to change the way I picked helpers, I would definitely take this as a complaint - no matter how polite they were! Not really anyone else's business how I pick helpers - although usually we take any help that's offered, as we get very few volunteers. Except of course, when we go on a big trip to a fun place, when we are inundated with volunteers! You can bet your bottom dollar I'm prioritising the parents that have been helpful at less exciting activities, and if anyone take issue with this, that's tough.

Highfivemum · 22/02/2024 12:42

I would politely ask but not expect anyone to pull out. Some parents are always first but then without these parents are DC couldn’t go on trips as a lot of parent work now.
I am a primary school teacher and we have a group who do not work and always help so yes are the first to ask. Not because we are excluding but we rely on them and appreciate them. I wouldn’t ask the teacher as To be honest she probably has enough in with 30 children in her class. Put a polite request out and see what happens

TimeForTeaAndG · 22/02/2024 12:35

Unitedthebest · 22/02/2024 12:13

To anybody on this thread contemplating ever doing this…please do not. I am a teacher and this would not in any way be helpful. Let us plan and arrange a lovely school trip for your children (which are very difficult anyway) without the completely unnecessary stress of dealing with parents complaining they can’t come.
Dont be THAT parent-reputations linger forever 😂

They're not complaining though.
Politely asking if anyone is willing to give up their space so the DH can go instead isn't complaining.
Suggesting an alternative way of picking helpers so it's more varied is not complaining.

Unitedthebest · 22/02/2024 12:13

Thelightis · 21/02/2024 15:27

Talk to the teacher and get them to pull parents names out of a hat next time who put their names forward as wanting to go and stress how ridiculous it is to always have the same people going to the exclusion of everyone else

First come first serve just doesn't cut it as an excuse

And they should bloody well know that

To anybody on this thread contemplating ever doing this…please do not. I am a teacher and this would not in any way be helpful. Let us plan and arrange a lovely school trip for your children (which are very difficult anyway) without the completely unnecessary stress of dealing with parents complaining they can’t come.
Dont be THAT parent-reputations linger forever 😂

Beautiful3 · 22/02/2024 11:57

It's first come, first served. If I've gone away thinking about it, it gets filled by the next day! I don't think asking a volunteer to drop out, is the right thing to do.

NightIbble · 22/02/2024 10:36

I don't think my school insists on being DSB checked but when I went I went as a 1to1 for my autistic child so maybe it was just me.

TheNumberfaker · 22/02/2024 10:23

Sk8erboi · 21/02/2024 19:56

I volunteer weekly in my child's class (only parent who does) and I've been on some trips, recently there was an amazing trip I was desperate to go on and they said they would do a name out of a hat situation to choose who could go as so many people had offered.

I was silently seething and although I volunteer out of kindness I did think it would be a liberty if I couldn't go when I give a lot of time to the school, thankfully I got chosen 😅.

Also a volunteer DBS check is free and costs the schools nothing, obviously there's some admin involved so our school only want classroom volunteers who can commit regularly.

As for asking to go, that would get my back up that your husbands come out the woodwork as it's a birthday and wanted me to give up my place and Id tell him that too.

Thankfully??? I expect the teacher made sure you were on it!

2mummies1baby · 22/02/2024 10:17

pokebowls · 21/02/2024 22:49

@Tiredforfive45 schools and teachers should be creating community and a safe and harmonious environment not creating division and a sense of favouritism. If you don't think that's important I'm not sure teaching is the right job for you.

Oh do give it a rest! School is for children, not parents. What's best for all the children trumps what individual parents want, every time.

budgiegirl · 22/02/2024 10:11

Willwetalk · 22/02/2024 10:04

I disagree. I was always far more twitchy about other people's children.

That's good. But believe me, not everyone is like you.

Willwetalk · 22/02/2024 10:04

90yomakeuproom · 21/02/2024 14:46

It's bad practice to have parents in their own child's group. They will be too bothered about their own child to look after the rest and its unfair. You don't volunteer for a trio to be with your child, it's to help the school with ratios so the whole trip can go ahead.

I disagree. I was always far more twitchy about other people's children.

budgiegirl · 22/02/2024 09:45

yes I have absolutely organised a large trip and I go on every school trip with my own.

Then I don't understand your some of your comments, because you surely understand the importance of reliable, trusted adult help.

A person who can't usually get on one, but makes a special effort on their kids birthday doesn't automatically make them incompetent

Of course it automatically doesn't, but it would make me a bit suspicious that their motivation to come on the trip is to spend time with their child on the child's birthday, rather than to help, which would worry me. So if I was organising, I'd be more inclined to stick with the adults I know, rather than swapping out for one I didn't. Nothing to say that the dad can't volunteer again at another time.

bnotts · 22/02/2024 09:23

Our school will try and use parents across the year but you need to be DBS checked - and it has to be via the school can't use one done by another employer.

It's the same for the PTA (I am on the committee and spend my life begging poeple to volunteer alongside my full time job).

Our school grabs the first x that volunteers as frankly it's a nightmare trying to get volunteers and good to know it's someone who won't drop out and if they have done it before knows the kids. They aren't going to wait around to see who else is before confimring with those who have volunteered and need to get the dates in diaries wait too long we often aren't sitting around doing nothing.

It's not political to use the same volunteers- they will be the ones that volunteer time and time again because they can.

Going on trips with the kids is not desperately fun dealing with vomiting, whingy, or overexcited kids on coaches , keeping up with straggling walkers.
You aren't inclined to volunteer , though it sounds like you havent before - please please please say a massive thank you to those who do who enable your child to go on "lots of trips" instead of feeling they have been favourited in some way.

IncognitoUsername · 22/02/2024 09:14

School absolutely need to have the final say in who helps on trips. We used to allow any parent to come on the Reception ‘walking round town’ trip but after I had to ask a grandmother to stop taking and posting selfies whilst walking along with her grandson walking in the road we had to become more selective!

Barrenfieldoffucks · 22/02/2024 09:03

Well, never before have I seen so much clamouring to assist at school! Certainly never replicated in real life.

Lovemyones · 22/02/2024 09:00

Budgiegirlbob · 22/02/2024 08:51

What a load of nonsense. I assume you’ve never organised a trip for a large group of children? You do need reliable, helpful parents on board, who you can trust not to prioritise their child. The fact that this parent has volunteered for the first time on his child’s birthday would ring alarm bells for me.

The trip can still be a “jolly” for the kids, but this shouldn’t be the sole reason that adults volunteer. And how in the world does a teacher making sure that a trip is properly supervised by picking suitable adult supervision stop kids wanting to go to school? Surely it would be exactly the opposite!

🤣 well you know what assume did.
yes I have absolutely organised a large trip and I go on every school trip with my own. A person who can't usually get on one, but makes a special effort on their kids birthday doesn't automatically make them incompetent.
Admittedly I replied a little quick because it's ridiculous to suggest thats the case.
I understand that some parents aren't going to be as great as others but there are plenty of adults to make sure the kids are supervised and again there's nothing to suggest this person, a loving parent wanting more time on their child's birthday with them, is anything other than a genuine competent person.
And no, neurodiverse often enjoy things that aren't boring. The way that the word jolly has been thrown about on this thread as if it can't be classed as so because it's a school trip is ludicrous.

YenSon · 22/02/2024 08:59

I think it’s completely unreasonable to ask someone to do that. You could ask to be added to a reserve list in case someone can’t make it. At our school, any volunteers have had to attend a 30-45 minute safeguarding briefing by the DSL and all have dbs checks. These run termly and are refreshed for volunteers in a yearly basis. We cannot use any volunteers that have not done this so it does require some forward planning from both parents and school if parents think they might like to help at some point.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/02/2024 08:55

RadicalRadishes · 21/02/2024 20:49

The school says that DH is on the waiting list. He is not DBS checked but they’ve never said that’s required? The school have said it’s a first come, first serve, but based on these responses I guess it’s completely possible they’re lying to our faces!

We are new to the school and have not volunteered for anything before so I don’t know how they would have written us off already, but who knows. DH has a very demanding job and I’m at home but chronically ill, so we’re not really regularly available. I volunteered for the one low-energy half day trip they did, but didn’t get it.

This isn’t a particularly interesting trip. It’s a half day and walkable. No coaches and nothing terribly exciting or terrible.

I legitimately thought we could ask to switch and that would be that, but according to this thread that certainly does not seem to be the case.

As far as I know from my DC, children are placed in groups with their parents.

Based on these responses, I will certainly not have my DH ask, nor will I be inclined to volunteer myself in the future. This seems to be way more political than I realised and it seems like no matter what — unless I’m regularly volunteering for everything at the school, which I physically cannot do — other parents and the school won’t be pleased with me showing up just occasionally. Too bad!

I don’t understand the final paragraph here.

Based on the answers here, I’d have thought you’d say “my dh has said he’ll volunteer more” or “I’ll try to help with low energy stuff such as hearing kids reading”

Not “we can’t get on the trip that her birthday so won’t be offering for anything that’s needed”

Tiredforfive45 · 22/02/2024 08:54

pokebowls · 21/02/2024 22:49

@Tiredforfive45 schools and teachers should be creating community and a safe and harmonious environment not creating division and a sense of favouritism. If you don't think that's important I'm not sure teaching is the right job for you.

Oh my goodness. You’re so right. Thank you for enlightening me. I will hang my head in shame and write my resignation letter immediately.

Budgiegirlbob · 22/02/2024 08:51

Lovemyones · 22/02/2024 08:36

Wow you sound like a regular fun sponge. You're one of the reasons some neurodiverse (and probably some neurotypical) don't want to go to school. Learning doesn't have to be boring and if a school trip can made to be as fun as a "jolly" then it should be. Stopping a kid from being with their parents on their birthday when it's a possibility just because you want to sounds like great morals. That said, it is admirable that you prioritise the disabled children. I get It if it was a case of the children wouldn't be supervised properly, but if it was just a case of this person has only volunteered because it's their kids birthday, but they are capable then surely compassion can be shown.

OP all you can do is ask and check with the school. No harm in that at all.

Edited

What a load of nonsense. I assume you’ve never organised a trip for a large group of children? You do need reliable, helpful parents on board, who you can trust not to prioritise their child. The fact that this parent has volunteered for the first time on his child’s birthday would ring alarm bells for me.

The trip can still be a “jolly” for the kids, but this shouldn’t be the sole reason that adults volunteer. And how in the world does a teacher making sure that a trip is properly supervised by picking suitable adult supervision stop kids wanting to go to school? Surely it would be exactly the opposite!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/02/2024 08:51

Probably redundant now but it’s also the case at our school that no parent helper is ever placed with their own child.

Lovemyones · 22/02/2024 08:36

Tiredforfive45 · 21/02/2024 15:52

Reasons I select parent helpers for
trips:

  1. they have attended previous trips and were helpful, followed my instructions well, were good with the children (not just their own).
  2. their child has additional needs and they are the best person to support them.
  3. they are not a PITA/ looking for things to criticise/ thinking it will be a nice little jolly.

Reasons I do not select parent helpers for trips:

  1. it is their child’s birthday and they want a nice day out with them.
  2. they have organised it themselves with the other pre-selected parents.

FYI when it comes to parents, there will be some that I tell ‘the slots are filled’ even if not one other person has volunteered.

Wow you sound like a regular fun sponge. You're one of the reasons some neurodiverse (and probably some neurotypical) don't want to go to school. Learning doesn't have to be boring and if a school trip can made to be as fun as a "jolly" then it should be. Stopping a kid from being with their parents on their birthday when it's a possibility just because you want to sounds like great morals. That said, it is admirable that you prioritise the disabled children. I get It if it was a case of the children wouldn't be supervised properly, but if it was just a case of this person has only volunteered because it's their kids birthday, but they are capable then surely compassion can be shown.

OP all you can do is ask and check with the school. No harm in that at all.

Budgiegirlbob · 22/02/2024 08:30

I think you don't understand about work. I can't schedule bits of time out of work twice a week for reading, because I can't control what days there will be important meetings. I can arrange an afternoon off sometimes for a trip. Scheduling is not easy for l people who have responsibilities outside the home

What a rude, patronising and self-important post. If you can schedule an afternoon off for a trip, then you can do the same for reading if you choose to. You just don’t want to. You sound like the school governor we had who couldn’t possibly attend governor meetings because he was a “professional” don’t you know? Insinuating he had a job far more important than anyone else (he didn’t).

glusky · 22/02/2024 08:08

GRex · 22/02/2024 07:24

I think you don't understand about work. I can't schedule bits of time out of work twice a week for reading, because I can't control what days there will be important meetings. I can arrange an afternoon off sometimes for a trip. Scheduling is not easy for l people who have responsibilities outside the home.

That's extremely rude. Working mums were the backbone of reading helpers in our school. A SAHM with no toddlers at home is pretty unusual round here.

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 22/02/2024 08:00

There might be reasons why the school choose these particular parents.
As has been stated schools are well aware of the parents who help out with all the less glamorous stuff and those who appear only for the good trips.
I used to run the PTA.
The same volunteers showed up.
Even when parents were at an event many would refuse point blank to help so much as sell a raffle ticket, or put chairs out.
Then we organised a treat for the children and suddenly lots of parents were available and asked if they could go along. No, the regulars were chosen. Those few parents who did the boring stuff and had actually offered to sell a few raffle tickets whilst the others just enjoyed the events.
I certainly wouldn’t be speaking for your dh if you do ask. He should be capable of speaking for himself.
Maybe he could tell school he is available if anyone else drops out.

flea101 · 22/02/2024 07:48

I always had to go to school trips with my son in mainstream as he has Sen. I hated it!!! I was basically one half of his 2:1 and he would refuse to engage with anyone else, due to attachment to me! I found it stressful but it meant he could actually go. Now he is in specialist school I am not expected to go (or even allowed to!) and I know he is enjoying activities without me being there. Plus I get a day off!

Swipe left for the next trending thread