Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not "get" the requirement for alcohol to have a proper celebration

186 replies

MrsCulpepper · 21/02/2024 10:05

I'm in the process of organising a meal for my birthday and considering a nice restaurant that's around 15 minutes drive away. I suggested it to others and was met without enthusiasm and "but some people won't be able to drink then".

I've never really felt that I "needed" a glass of wine or something else alcoholic after a tough day. I like it, and have a glass of wine or a beer or a gin and tonic when I'm out or visiting someone if they offer, but we don't generally have alcohol at home (perhaps in part because the expense).

When I was pregnant, I didn't miss drinking at all. It seemed to make people very uncomfortable though that I was "only" drinking water and they would fall over themselves to think of options they could offer. One friend of my husband's was really pushy about a small glass of wine, assuring me that it was absolutely fine to have while pregnant and his wife is a gynecologist so he knows what he's talking about. I had to say no 5 or 6 times!

I admire the PR that sparkling wine companies have done on their product so prosecco at the very least has to be budgeted for my party. And a taxi will be required too I suppose.

AIBU to consider a restaurant that would require a short drive? Is alcohol such a necessity for a party to be good?

OP posts:
cauliflowerqueen · 21/02/2024 16:05

If it's your own birthday celebration, surely the others should go along with what you want, even if it means they can't have alcohol this time. Would they complain if you wanted Italian food on your birthday, and they preferred French?

Creatureofhabit87 · 21/02/2024 16:02

I’d come, drink but get a taxi. 15 mins is nothing! Do people expect you to arrange something two mins walk from each of their doors?!
I don’t like going out without a drink or two, for me it makes it more fun!

OhNoWhatIf · 21/02/2024 16:02

@purplehotdogs that sounds good fun with the tractor and trailer.

purplehotdogs · 21/02/2024 15:59

YANBU, no idea why people would make a big deal out of this, surely if you want to go you do, and if you don't you make your excuses? I live in a rural area so if you want to out and enjoy a drink you either car pool, arrange a taxi or get the local farmer's trailer that seems to run every weekend (one designated driver on the tractor and as many drinkers as they can fit in the open trailer on the back, it's an entertaining sight in the summer months). If nobody drove anywhere to go out, nobody would go...well, anywhere. It's really not an insurmountable problem.

OhNoWhatIf · 21/02/2024 15:58

@OpieMo you do realise there is a difference between being a raging alcoholic and wanting a couple of glasses of wine with your dinner when you are out?

Perhaps these people don't go out much so when they do they like to have a drink.

None of them were enthusiastic and surely not all of OP's friends are problem drinkers.

OpieMo · 21/02/2024 15:52

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 21/02/2024 15:42

Because there’s a cost of living crisis?!? So for some people it might be a choice between the meal and a cab?!? They might not be able to afford both?!? Maybe they spent all their money on superfluous punctuation marks?!?

They can spend the amount they would have spent on alcohol on the cab.

Seriously though, if the deciding factor when it comes to whether to attend a friend's birthday celebrations or not because money is tight is whether or not you can drink then you have bigger problems.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 21/02/2024 15:42

Starlight1979 · 21/02/2024 12:04

Why can people not just get a taxi?! We live at least 10-15 miles away from all our family and friends so for any meal or celebration we either drive if we're not bothered about drinking or get a taxi.. It's only 15 mins away FFS?! Do they all want to go somewhere in walking distance or something?! I can't understand why the options are drive or not go?!

Because there’s a cost of living crisis?!? So for some people it might be a choice between the meal and a cab?!? They might not be able to afford both?!? Maybe they spent all their money on superfluous punctuation marks?!?

skyeisthelimit · 21/02/2024 15:36

YANBU. It's your birthday so you should choose the venue that you want. If they want to drink then it is up to them to arrange transport for themselves not you.

I live in a rural area so people are used to either

a - driver doesn't drink
b - get a minibus for whole group
c - go to the Indian or pub where we live

as a social group we have done all 3 options as people like to do different things and not always go to the 2 places that we can walk to

Zimunya · 21/02/2024 15:27

@MrsCulpepper - I hear you! I was shocked by the alcohol abuse / dependency that seems rampant in the UK when we moved here. I too like a glass of wine or a G&T now and then. But I certainly wouldn't avoid a restaurant just because they don't serve alcohol. There really is more to life. I regularly give up alcohol for Lent, and my wider family are always a bit distraught about it - "But how can we celebrate your birthday if you aren't drinking?" they cry. Every celebration doesn't require alcohol, and some of the best times I've had have been alcohol free.

It's your birthday - do it the way YOU want. Those who love you will come anyway. Happy birthday in advance!

bakewellbride · 21/02/2024 15:26

Surely the people who insist on drinking can just get a taxi? So what's the issue? I don't get it.

Sufac · 21/02/2024 15:26

Yogatoga1 · 21/02/2024 14:30

If it were a good friend who really wanted to go to mcd’s though, what would you do?

suck it up for the sake of seeing her on her birthday? Or tell her that no, you don’t like her enough to tolerate mcd’s on the one day a year that’s about her?

i can’t stand mcd’s. I’d go though, have a catch up and a coffee. I’d maybe find I’d eaten not so long ago so I wouldn’t need to eat, but I’d go,

same as when I went to a birthday at a vegan restaurant, or anything else that’s not my thing. I go because I like the person whose birthday it is, and it’s their day so they choose.

if my friend were pregnant or alcoholic, and wanted to do somewhere with no drinking, I’d go. I wouldn’t say oh but I need to drink and I’m more bothered about that than seeing you…

Edited

Of course I would go! I just don’t believe she can’t ‘understand’ why some people like to have a drink and dinner, or champagne for a celebration.

There is so much of this faux incomprehension on here that often is trying to mask the writer’s belief of their own superiority.

Many people like a drink with food or to celebrate, it really can’t be that difficult to understand.

Millions of people like McDonalds, F1 racing, beards on men, and homemade chutneys. I don’t, but I can certainly understand why people do.

Diamondcurtains · 21/02/2024 15:24

I never drink at hime but definitely like a glass or two when going out.

Trinity65 · 21/02/2024 15:20

CloudPop · 21/02/2024 12:19

You're out of control. EVERY New Year's Eve? You urgently need to seek help with your binge drinking.

😄😄

To be honest, OP, I think YABU

I used to drink, too much when I look back in hindsight, but now I tend to drink at family meals or parties only. I do go to the pub a few times a month and will have a few vodka and lemonades, but I am happy enough with a pure orange juice or a Orange juice and bitter lemon after my alcoholic ones

I would want to have a drink at your Birthday Meal and don't see what is wrong with that.

CatamaranViper · 21/02/2024 14:50

I like to drink. I like the taste. I like how I feel when I drink. It enhances celebrations and feels like such a treat along with good food. Can properly relax too as no cooking needed, no cleaning up or dishes to wash etc.
Do I need it to have fun? No. Do I have to have it? No.

We live in a small town so when we socialise with friends of family outside of our town, one of us drinks and one drives. We swap every other time (or depending on who we're seeing). It's absolutely not a big deal.

Resilience · 21/02/2024 14:36

I'm on the fence with this.

I live in the middle of nowhere so going out usually means having to stay sober and drive. Although I like a drink (regularly used to get drunk in younger years), I just accept it. If it's a particularly special event where I'd like to drink I might arrange a taxi or sleep over somewhere.

I can't imagine not going to a friend's party because I couldn't drink.

Used to be a police officer BTW and was absolutely amazed at the amount some people can drink before they fail a breathalyser. I could drink 3.5 pints. In no universe was I fit to drive and I felt pissed, but breathalyser said I was under the limit. On the same amount of alcohol DH barely affected. Limits are stupid and best to avoid alcohol and driving completely IMO.

Yogatoga1 · 21/02/2024 14:30

Sufac · 21/02/2024 14:09

Can you really not understand why people like different things? Do you lack empathy in other areas of life?

If you were to have your birthday meal at McDonalds I would probably not be that interested as I don’t enjoy the food. I would think of it as a treat.

Wine and food pairing is as old as time, a lot of people enjoy treating themselves to a steak and glass of wine. I think thy go hand in hand and if I was spending all that money of a good steak, I would be a bit put out if I had to have a water or coke instead.

There is absolutely no need to have cake at a birthday or wedding, but a lot of people get put out when there isn’t one. Doesn’t mean they’re all sugar addicts.

If it were a good friend who really wanted to go to mcd’s though, what would you do?

suck it up for the sake of seeing her on her birthday? Or tell her that no, you don’t like her enough to tolerate mcd’s on the one day a year that’s about her?

i can’t stand mcd’s. I’d go though, have a catch up and a coffee. I’d maybe find I’d eaten not so long ago so I wouldn’t need to eat, but I’d go,

same as when I went to a birthday at a vegan restaurant, or anything else that’s not my thing. I go because I like the person whose birthday it is, and it’s their day so they choose.

if my friend were pregnant or alcoholic, and wanted to do somewhere with no drinking, I’d go. I wouldn’t say oh but I need to drink and I’m more bothered about that than seeing you…

LemonRedwood · 21/02/2024 14:27

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 21/02/2024 11:15

I can't believe you are encouraging drink driving.

It is best to have none.

I don't want to pay for dinner and not have a glass of wine. That's not getting drunk, it is having a glass with a meal. But I will not drive.

You could say why bother going somewhere nice for dinner, let's just go to pizza hut, after all why would someone enjoy a meal in a restaurant, it is all food.

Where am I encouraging it? I've pointed out the difference between the law and the advice.

OhNoWhatIf · 21/02/2024 14:26

OpieMo · 21/02/2024 14:04

YANBU. It's honestly bonkers the idea that people would need alcohol with a celebratory meal to such an extent that they'd be unhappy with a restaurant a 15m drive away. If they're that desperate they can just get a taxi? Do people genuinely only book restaurants they can walk to or something?

Really glad my social circle aren't drinkers

I'm really glad mine are. I love sharing a bottle of wine when we go out to eat.

I've got a group of friends that live in town so lots of nice restaurants. They pick us up and we get a taxi home. Same if they come our way. I wouldn't mind being the driver though if I needed to.

OP's friends didn't sound very enthusiastic about going so I wondered if they were good friends.

gannett · 21/02/2024 14:25

I like a drink or several and 99% of the time I would prefer to have a drink with a meal in a restaurant, especially if celebrating. But if I was celebrating someone I loved I would certainly be able to get through the evening and have a good time without alcohol, if I had to. I think it's pretty rude of the OP's guests to complain to her. Have a moan to your partner, maybe, but if you really want to celebrate with someone, the point is them, not the alcohol. I'd go along with good grace, or at least sort myself out a taxi.

Sufac · 21/02/2024 14:11

Also alcohol and celebrations have been around a lot longer than PR companies!!

Sufac · 21/02/2024 14:09

Can you really not understand why people like different things? Do you lack empathy in other areas of life?

If you were to have your birthday meal at McDonalds I would probably not be that interested as I don’t enjoy the food. I would think of it as a treat.

Wine and food pairing is as old as time, a lot of people enjoy treating themselves to a steak and glass of wine. I think thy go hand in hand and if I was spending all that money of a good steak, I would be a bit put out if I had to have a water or coke instead.

There is absolutely no need to have cake at a birthday or wedding, but a lot of people get put out when there isn’t one. Doesn’t mean they’re all sugar addicts.

OpieMo · 21/02/2024 14:04

YANBU. It's honestly bonkers the idea that people would need alcohol with a celebratory meal to such an extent that they'd be unhappy with a restaurant a 15m drive away. If they're that desperate they can just get a taxi? Do people genuinely only book restaurants they can walk to or something?

Really glad my social circle aren't drinkers

AdriftAbroad1 · 21/02/2024 14:03

Absolutely no chance of me paying 60 quid to go for your meal and pay for that too.

Unless you are paying for the meal?

I say that having been wealthy in London and poor elsewhere. Regardless it is a lot.

Mintyfreshtulips · 21/02/2024 14:01

That is exceptionally rude as I imagine they probably know you arent much of drinker? Its wild that for ONE occasion people cant sit through a dinner without an alcoholic drink.

gmgnts · 21/02/2024 14:00

Bit of a drip feed here, OP. If there are no walkable options available, then you don't really have a dilemma. Just go ahead and book. I don't drink much these days, but I must say I really hate being the designated driver, which I often end up as. I still enjoy the food and the company, but a glass or two of wine would make it so much better!

Swipe left for the next trending thread