Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with partner over this?

283 replies

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:26

Partner is adamant he doesn't want another baby (for context we have a 2 year old). I'd love another. We are on different pages about this.

However, I am not on any form of contraception because hormonal contraceptives cause awful side effects for me and I've never found one that suited. So after the birth of our child I wanted a break from the pill, and partner was on board with this saying we'd use condoms. However, over the past 12 months alone he has had unprotected sex with me on 18 occasions (the rest being with a condom). I know this because I use an app to track my periods and you can record sex and whether protected or not (presumably to track and date any pregnancies). So he is obviously really lax about this, despite saying he's adamant it's a no.

I've raised the conversation again this past week about his thoughts on another baby, and he says the same "absolutely not". I point out to him the contradiction in his actions and his words. His defence is "I always ask you what point you're at in your cycle so I make sure the timing makes it unlikely" and "I pull out sometimes so it's fine". I asked him if he understood that he's giving me mixed messages by saying one thing and doing another? He said "I have no explanation for that other than I prefer sex without a condom because it feels better". I said OK but you surely then accept the risk that comes with? He just shrugged, repeating he was reassured by the point I was at in my cycle.

OK, he may have a point, in that we've had unprotected sex at "safer" points in my cycle 18 times over the past 12 months and I'm not pregnant. But, there is some risk still, and if he's so adamant he's against having another baby, why would he take that risk even if it was a tiny one?? He can't answer this.

He then deflected onto me and said "you're happy to take that risk too". Well yes, because I'm not horrified at the thought of another baby or massively opposed to it, as you say you are? If I were, I'd not be letting you anywhere near me without a condom.

My head is a mess, and I feel he's confused and upset me a lot with this.

AIBU?

OP posts:
fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 17:20

EnterFunnyNameHere · 21/02/2024 17:13

Um no - but the other option (seeing as contraception seems to be off the table for both parties) seems to be her abstaining from sex, and it seems very unfair that she somehow is being irresponsible if she doesn't do this.

My point, which I don't think is that hard to grasp, is why is OP responsible for preventing something she wants to happen, when her partner (who doesn't want it to happen) isn't apparently bothered enough to do so?

I do understand the fact that we are talking about a whole new human being potentially being involved, but it seems wrong that OP has to take action to prevent something she wants just because another adult can't be arsed!

That said, I do think saying "if you're so adamant you don't want DC, get the snip or wear condoms or no sex for you" would be an interesting way of finding out how strongly the man actually feels!!

I can't tell if you are serious or not.

But if you are - the reason OP is responsible is because we are talking about a child being brought into the world, which is a pretty big thing.

You could even that the potential child's needs should actually outweigh 'something OP wants to happen'.

I don't think that's hard to grasp.

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/02/2024 17:20

LoveFood · 21/02/2024 16:26

I have skim read this thread. But this is what I was going to say.

His messages are not mixed. he is very clear. 1. he does not want a child. 2. if you do get pregnant he will blame you for not being "smart" enough to figure out when you are more or less likely to get pregnant.

Personally, I would say to him very clearly that you are no longer taking any responsibility for thinking about this. If you have a regular cycle, the most I'd be willing to tell him is what my regular cycle length is and, if asked, what day in the cycle you are at. If he does not want to get pregnant it is then up to him to figure out when is and isn't safer AND to 100% accept this isn't a guaranteed solution and that if you get pregnant you will a) be happy and b) will not be taking the "blame".

I agree with @HollyKnight and @LoveFood. I don't think the signals are mixed at all. He's just expecting things to work out fine, and will put the "blame" at your door if they don't.

I thought of another analogy which might help explain why I don't think the signals are mixed, and why he's just focussed on his pleasure.

Bear with me on this as it will seem a bit left-field at first!

We all know that sex with strangers carries a risk of STIs, and in particular HIV. So it's strongly advisable to use a condom for casual sex. And yet, there are many, many men who don't bother with condoms for casual sex/one night stands.

Do you think they are giving out mixed messages? Do you think they secretly want to catch HIV?

Or do you think it's just because they're not really thinking about the risk, and just focussing on the fact they want to have sex?

I think we can all agree that no one wants to catch an STI! And yet some men (and women) continue to have unprotected sex. Why? Because it brings them pleasure, and they push the risk to the back of their mind.

Can you see the analogy there OP? We wouldn't be suggesting that not using a condom for casual sex meant that secretly people wanted to catch HIV or another STI. So I don't think that your DP continuing to have sex during your "safe" parts of the cycle indicates that he actually does want to have another baby when he's been very clear that's not the case. He just wants to continue to have the kind of sex that feels the best - no condom - and doesn't want to think about the small but undeniable risk he's taking. Just like the blokes who have a one night stand without wearing a condom!

My honest viewpoint is that you don't have the right to resent him for not wanting another baby. In the same way as he doesn't have the right to resent you because you DO want another one. Having a baby is a very big deal, and it's probably the one issue that's hard to find a compromise with. Neither of you are unreasonable in how you feel about future babies. But I think he's been very clear about what he wants. I also think that because you're feeling broody, you're trying to look for any sign that he doesn't mean what he said. No judgement from me, the ovary urges are incredibly powerful!! But I really don't think the fact that he's continued to have sex with you is any kind of secret message that he does want another child.

From what you've said, things might work out OK if you accidentally fell pregnant. But only you know if he's likely to hold a grudge and have digs at you for years about "your" failure to not fall pregnant!

I hope none of this sounds antagonistic OP as it's not intended that way. Trying to agree whether to have a baby is a really difficult obstacle to navigate when the two parties don't see things the same way.

I don't think it's fair resenting him for "mixed messages" when he's been clear. But I do think it's unreasonable for him not to be better informed about the risk and not to have a proper conversation with you about the level of risk you're taking. Preventing pregnancies is a joint responsibility - you know the risks as you've made sure you're well-informed. He will have no right to complain if you fall pregnant.

HarrietStyles · 21/02/2024 17:18

Maybe he has already had a vasectomy and hasn’t told you?

Sorry if it’s already been mentioned, I’ve not read full thread.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 21/02/2024 17:13

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 16:50

Are you suggesting she has no option other than to bring a child into the world?

Don't be ridiculous.

Um no - but the other option (seeing as contraception seems to be off the table for both parties) seems to be her abstaining from sex, and it seems very unfair that she somehow is being irresponsible if she doesn't do this.

My point, which I don't think is that hard to grasp, is why is OP responsible for preventing something she wants to happen, when her partner (who doesn't want it to happen) isn't apparently bothered enough to do so?

I do understand the fact that we are talking about a whole new human being potentially being involved, but it seems wrong that OP has to take action to prevent something she wants just because another adult can't be arsed!

That said, I do think saying "if you're so adamant you don't want DC, get the snip or wear condoms or no sex for you" would be an interesting way of finding out how strongly the man actually feels!!

PeloMom · 21/02/2024 16:59

If he’s so certain he should schedule a vasectomy.

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 16:56

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 13:42

I love how I'm at fault here. I'm the selfish one, for having sex with him when he's said he doesn't want a baby and yet happily has unprotected sex with me 🤔

And it's ME who's selfish here. Unbelievable.

You're both selfish.

Neither of you should be bringing a child into the world knowing that they will not be loved or wanted by their father.

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 16:54

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 10:40

@Candleabra
I don't like his behaviour now. Back then, I had no issue with his behaviour because like I say, I assumed he'd changed his mind or moved into the "meh, if it happens it happens" camp, because of how lax he was being. Then on raising it with him and pointing out the inconsistency he looks at me like I've got 2 heads and is all "eh? No I definitely still don't want a baby". Right, so why've you risked just that 18 times this past year alone?? Then he's send me confused and upset, in tears, and just walked away from me. No apology nothing. Doesn't care.

At the end of the day, when your child asks you why they were brought into the world and why they have a dad that doesn't love them, you can explain that you gave up because he risked it 18 times so you thought it wasn't worth putting your foot down and you let yourself get pregnant knowing that their dad would not love them.

It's your fault and your decision as much as your partner's to bring a child into the world, and you have control over it.

All of the consequences of that decision are on you, as much as they are on him.

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 16:50

EnterFunnyNameHere · 21/02/2024 10:15

I'm confused by this. I do somewhat agree in that a child should definitely be wanted by both parents. But, if OP would be fine with a pregnancy and doesn't get on with hormonal contraception, but her partner doesn't want to wear condoms (so doesn't), what is it that you're suggesting OP actually does?

Are you suggesting she has no option other than to bring a child into the world?

Don't be ridiculous.

Disturbia81 · 21/02/2024 16:49

SpeedyDrama · 21/02/2024 16:45

If he doesn’t want a baby the responsibility is wholly and completely on him to make sure that doesn’t happen. I can see how it’s a mind fuck for you @upsetandangrywithhim .

And yes it’s less likely to happen at certain parts of your cycle and with you age. However about 7 years ago my partner and I had unprotected sex on the very last day of my period, and I have a 6 year old to testify that even regular cycles can mean jack shit at times.

Yep.. men who don't want 100% don't want babies need to get a vasectomy or abstain.
Condoms if neither of those but still risky.
He is being an irresponsible arsehole

SpeedyDrama · 21/02/2024 16:45

If he doesn’t want a baby the responsibility is wholly and completely on him to make sure that doesn’t happen. I can see how it’s a mind fuck for you @upsetandangrywithhim .

And yes it’s less likely to happen at certain parts of your cycle and with you age. However about 7 years ago my partner and I had unprotected sex on the very last day of my period, and I have a 6 year old to testify that even regular cycles can mean jack shit at times.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 16:40

Creatureofhabit87 · 21/02/2024 16:07

If he doesn’t want a baby you have to take responsibility to say put a condom on or no sex. Just because you want a baby it doesn’t mean it’s ok to get pregnant when he doesn’t want one.

And at what point is he taking any responsibility? I missed that part. Or is he exempt from taking responsibility because he's a man and therefore immune from responsible behaviour, lest it may impede his sexual pleasure? 🙄

OP posts:
LoveFood · 21/02/2024 16:26

HollyKnight · 21/02/2024 15:44

I don't think he is sending mixed signals at all. I think it is very clear that he doesn't want another child AND that he is a selfish lazy bastard who is leaving the risk up to you to manage.

I have skim read this thread. But this is what I was going to say.

His messages are not mixed. he is very clear. 1. he does not want a child. 2. if you do get pregnant he will blame you for not being "smart" enough to figure out when you are more or less likely to get pregnant.

Personally, I would say to him very clearly that you are no longer taking any responsibility for thinking about this. If you have a regular cycle, the most I'd be willing to tell him is what my regular cycle length is and, if asked, what day in the cycle you are at. If he does not want to get pregnant it is then up to him to figure out when is and isn't safer AND to 100% accept this isn't a guaranteed solution and that if you get pregnant you will a) be happy and b) will not be taking the "blame".

TheSingingBean · 21/02/2024 16:22

I get it OP - he's being totally inconsistent and I'm not surprised you're finding that difficult.

Some of the replies here are utterly batshit and deliberately unpleasant.

Creatureofhabit87 · 21/02/2024 16:18

Universalsnail · 21/02/2024 16:10

Why can't he take responsibility and put a condom on his own penis? Why does she have to take all the responsibility for his sperm when she is completely fine about getting pregnant and has expressed that too him clearly.

It’s both of their responsibilities but she is allowing him to do it when she knows he doesn’t want a baby! If you insist at the point of the penis entering then surely problem solved?!

Universalsnail · 21/02/2024 16:10

Creatureofhabit87 · 21/02/2024 16:07

If he doesn’t want a baby you have to take responsibility to say put a condom on or no sex. Just because you want a baby it doesn’t mean it’s ok to get pregnant when he doesn’t want one.

Why can't he take responsibility and put a condom on his own penis? Why does she have to take all the responsibility for his sperm when she is completely fine about getting pregnant and has expressed that too him clearly.

Creatureofhabit87 · 21/02/2024 16:07

If he doesn’t want a baby you have to take responsibility to say put a condom on or no sex. Just because you want a baby it doesn’t mean it’s ok to get pregnant when he doesn’t want one.

Maray1967 · 21/02/2024 16:06

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:47

Just to be clear, if I feel pregnant again and he didn't support me, I'd be fully prepared to leave and be a single mum to both my children. It wouldn't be ideal obviously, but there's no way I'd stay with a man who made it clear a child of ours was unwanted.

I think you either reassure yourself that you’re prepared to do this and carry on as you are - getting your ducks in a row as they say on here in case you do get pregnant - or you tell him he has two choices - condoms or vasectomy.

Personally I’d make it very clear that I would expect him to welcome a baby he fathered while having unprotected sex. It is totally unacceptable to push the responsibility on to you telling him where you are in your cycle because there is no cast iron guarantee of that being safe.

If he ‘wasn’t happy’ if I got pregnant, I’d sure as hell make sure everyone you’re close to knows what risks he took and basically what an idiot he’s been. Then I’d divorce him.

Universalsnail · 21/02/2024 16:05

Honestly I see it on this forum all the time as a solution to problems as if women just have sex for men.

There's one above "if he doesn't give up sex"
Like... I mean I sure af don't want to give up sex in my relationship. I feel sorry that there so many women who seem to think sex is some kind of transaction and not an active desire for many women.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 15:58

HollyKnight · 21/02/2024 15:44

I don't think he is sending mixed signals at all. I think it is very clear that he doesn't want another child AND that he is a selfish lazy bastard who is leaving the risk up to you to manage.

I suspect you're right 🙁

OP posts:
HollyKnight · 21/02/2024 15:44

I don't think he is sending mixed signals at all. I think it is very clear that he doesn't want another child AND that he is a selfish lazy bastard who is leaving the risk up to you to manage.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 15:43

Reminder for those with shit reading comprehension:

I didn't come here asking if I would be unreasonable to try to get pregnant with this man. I can and will make my own judgement about that.

I came here to ask if I'm unreasonable to feel upset and angry at what feels like mixed messages on his part about conceiving another child.

Hth.

OP posts:
TeaGinandFags · 21/02/2024 15:37

Alternatively book his vasectomy for him.

If he doesn't like condoms and won't give up sex, that is your only other option. He will have to endure condoms for three months afterwards, or for however long it takes to get the all clear, but somehow he will survive.

That is if you're prepared to put up with his nonsense.

I wish you well x

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 15:37

fusspot25 · 21/02/2024 15:29

@Universalsnail the difference is there wouldn't be another child in the mix who wasn't wanted.

I don't know why people are bothering with any form of constructive advice anymore because op clearly just wants an echo chamber of people telling her to crack on and it's fine because of course he'll come round when baby arrives 🙈

Wow some people have really shit reading comprehension, don't they.

Four posts now explaining what I came here for and what my question was. And STILL people invent a more exciting narrative for their own entertainment.

Sad.

OP posts:
TeaGinandFags · 21/02/2024 15:30

18 times and he doesn't want a baby!!

He's having a laugh!

Offer him a clear choice between condoms and abstinence. When he chokes, ask him how he'd react if you fell pregnant. Help his decision by informing that no way on this earth are you having a termination just to make his life easier.

Provide him with a hard Paddington stare to ensure he knows you're not joking.

fusspot25 · 21/02/2024 15:29

@Universalsnail the difference is there wouldn't be another child in the mix who wasn't wanted.

I don't know why people are bothering with any form of constructive advice anymore because op clearly just wants an echo chamber of people telling her to crack on and it's fine because of course he'll come round when baby arrives 🙈

Swipe left for the next trending thread