Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with partner over this?

283 replies

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:26

Partner is adamant he doesn't want another baby (for context we have a 2 year old). I'd love another. We are on different pages about this.

However, I am not on any form of contraception because hormonal contraceptives cause awful side effects for me and I've never found one that suited. So after the birth of our child I wanted a break from the pill, and partner was on board with this saying we'd use condoms. However, over the past 12 months alone he has had unprotected sex with me on 18 occasions (the rest being with a condom). I know this because I use an app to track my periods and you can record sex and whether protected or not (presumably to track and date any pregnancies). So he is obviously really lax about this, despite saying he's adamant it's a no.

I've raised the conversation again this past week about his thoughts on another baby, and he says the same "absolutely not". I point out to him the contradiction in his actions and his words. His defence is "I always ask you what point you're at in your cycle so I make sure the timing makes it unlikely" and "I pull out sometimes so it's fine". I asked him if he understood that he's giving me mixed messages by saying one thing and doing another? He said "I have no explanation for that other than I prefer sex without a condom because it feels better". I said OK but you surely then accept the risk that comes with? He just shrugged, repeating he was reassured by the point I was at in my cycle.

OK, he may have a point, in that we've had unprotected sex at "safer" points in my cycle 18 times over the past 12 months and I'm not pregnant. But, there is some risk still, and if he's so adamant he's against having another baby, why would he take that risk even if it was a tiny one?? He can't answer this.

He then deflected onto me and said "you're happy to take that risk too". Well yes, because I'm not horrified at the thought of another baby or massively opposed to it, as you say you are? If I were, I'd not be letting you anywhere near me without a condom.

My head is a mess, and I feel he's confused and upset me a lot with this.

AIBU?

OP posts:
CJsGoldfish · 21/02/2024 22:27

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:52

@takealettermsjones

I'm fully aware of what being a single mum entails thanks, I have an adult child who I raised by myself for 10 years until I met my partner.

Yet, you'd choose that for another child because YOU want one 🤷‍♀️

It's not 'mixed messages' at all and I think you know that, you are just looking for validation so that when you do conceive the child YOU want you can direct the narrative
He's a selfish twat, absolutely he's told you he doesn't want to use condoms because HE doesn't like them but he's also clear he doesn't want any more children. If you wish to be with the kind of man who is happy to put ALL of that on you and take no blame when the inevitable happens, that's fine. As long as you're going into this knowing that he doesn't value you and your child/children will see that you are not respected, crack on

Why you'd choose THIS to be the father any potential child deserves is a mystery. Wouldn't they deserve much better that a selfish man child who never wanted them?

UGH! I think you know what you're doing OP and I wish you'd realise that it is in no way in favour of any baby you conceive 🤷‍♀️

Vye1988 · 21/02/2024 22:06

I want to preface with saying I think your husband is being immature and taking no responsibility for contraception.

Men vary, I've got male friends who would jump out of a 3 storey window naked to avoid sex with a woman who offered the 'pull out method'.

In the moment if you say your happy for him to not use a condom, his brain cells have all gone to his genitals.
I think you are putting to much weight on the difference between his words and actions, this is meaningful to you because you want another child, everytime he agrees a little spark of hope builds in you. But really, he is not thinking about the consequences, he is in the moment putting no thought into it. He has not given you intentionally false hope, you are interpreting his actions that way to fit a narrative you want.

Your options are, carry on as you are (reframe your thoughts because you cannot control his, or continue being full of false hope), take control and say no to unprotected sex and accept you will not have another child or consider whether this marriage is right for you.

I do feel sorry for you, I've been in the position of longing for another child and it's an awful place to be.

Good luck.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 21:28

VampireWeekday · 21/02/2024 19:50

Just read your latest update. How do you feel about it? In a way it would annoy and upset me even more playing the natural cycle tracking contraception game after he's said he wouldn't mind having a baby. If it were me I'd either want a real no condom for sex policy, and sex naturally whenever you want it, or start being more careful. It feels kind of cruel to say he'd be ok with it then minimise the chances, but so they stay high enough to be just possible.

Your conversation sounds like a good starting point though, maybe give it a while and bring this up again if you feel you want a more serious chance.

Edited

I feel better about things in all honesty. I do feel as though after our most recent conversation we are more on the same page than i think either he or I realised before. If that makes sense.

OP posts:
Jabberwonky · 21/02/2024 20:22

Just carry on and get pregnant then.
He won't be happy and the relationship is doomed if not already.
Bring your children up yourself. Job done.

VampireWeekday · 21/02/2024 19:50

Just read your latest update. How do you feel about it? In a way it would annoy and upset me even more playing the natural cycle tracking contraception game after he's said he wouldn't mind having a baby. If it were me I'd either want a real no condom for sex policy, and sex naturally whenever you want it, or start being more careful. It feels kind of cruel to say he'd be ok with it then minimise the chances, but so they stay high enough to be just possible.

Your conversation sounds like a good starting point though, maybe give it a while and bring this up again if you feel you want a more serious chance.

VampireWeekday · 21/02/2024 19:43

You need to make it crystal clear that you will not have an abortion and that the cycle tracking is not reliable. Make it crystal clear that you want another baby and so won't insist on contraception. If he's so bothered he won't have unprotected sex.

I have the opposite situation to you. I also can't do hormonal contraception and I am adamant I don't want another baby, DH would quite like one but has accepted it's a no from me. I simply refuse to have sex without a condom. If he tries to talk me into it, it's a flat no. the risk of getting pregnant is so horrifying to me that it's an instant turn off. I accept this means less sex than I would otherwise have, but these are the actions of someone who really doesn't want a baby.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/02/2024 19:09

takealettermsjones · 21/02/2024 09:45

If you get pregnant, one of three things will happen:

  1. He'll pressure you into a termination you don't want
  2. He'll leave
  3. He'll stay and you'll have the baby, but you'll do everything because "he didn't want this baby," you'll end up resenting him, and the children will pick up on the negative vibes

This.

I would refuse to have sex with him unless he takes responsibility for contraception- either by way of condoms or a vasectomy.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 21/02/2024 19:00

Tell him that his an idiot. If you get the flu for example the point in your cycle changes as it often delays your period so many things can. In which case a point he thinks is safe isn't. Either he wears one all the time, has a vasectomy if he really does not want more children or accepts that a pregnancy will end up happening and that his still putting it all on you. Personally I would stop tracking my cycle and tell him that my period starts when it starts, I carry supplies just incase. So then either he takes full responsibility regarding avoiding the pregnancy he does not want or accepts it will happen because he thinks the feel without is more important. Ultimately though if you want a baby and he doesn't you may resent him for it and he will probably be furious when one does come along.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 21/02/2024 18:52

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 17:20

I can't tell if you are serious or not.

But if you are - the reason OP is responsible is because we are talking about a child being brought into the world, which is a pretty big thing.

You could even that the potential child's needs should actually outweigh 'something OP wants to happen'.

I don't think that's hard to grasp.

But in my opinion, whilst it's not ideal, a child's needs can be fully met by having one parent who wants them desperately and loves them dearly. Is it preferred? No, I'd say two parents on board is better! But do I think all the kids out there who, for whatever reason, only have one loving involved parent are not having their needs met? No, I do not.

For me, it's a bit like saying that someone with an inherited illness would be irresponsible to have children because the child could end up disadvantaged if they also inherit the illness. Yes, it's not necessarily going to end up in the most perfect idealised situation, but does that mean the child is better off not existing at all? Not for me, no.

How about women who have kids through sperms donation? Are they inherently irresponsible because the child won't even have a father?

SlumberDearMaid · 21/02/2024 18:38

Man, this guy is really, really good at getting bare-back sex. It’s crystal clear that’s all he cares about.

@AgentJohnson’s line is very amusing, but it’s quite frankly all I could think about the entire way through this thread…..

Good luck to you, OP.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 18:10

AgentJohnson · 21/02/2024 17:44

You’re playing a dangerous game with this twat.

He wears a condom, he gets a vasectomy or he doesn’t have sex with you, those are his options. Why isn’t his twatery an effective form of non hormonal contraception already?

Your last line made me laugh 😂
I needed that. Thank you.

OP posts:
upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 18:09

@Universalsnail
Yes that's my thinking. If it happens it happens.

OP posts:
chrisfromcardiff · 21/02/2024 18:05

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 15:43

Reminder for those with shit reading comprehension:

I didn't come here asking if I would be unreasonable to try to get pregnant with this man. I can and will make my own judgement about that.

I came here to ask if I'm unreasonable to feel upset and angry at what feels like mixed messages on his part about conceiving another child.

Hth.

OK. Yes you are right to be confused and angry with him for his "mixed" messages. There. That answers your original post. So why is this going on for 10 pages? You just get snippy when people give you their opinions.

Universalsnail · 21/02/2024 18:04

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 17:42

Thought I would update after the conversation I've just had with him.

He is now saying that, on reflection, he clearly cannot feel as strongly about this as he initially thought, and that maybe he's more in the "if it happens it happens" camp than he'd realised, because as I've "rightly pointed out" (his words), he's been very lax about contraception. He also apologised for the mixed messages.

He said that whilst he doesn't actively want a baby, if I were to become pregnant, so be it, and we'd make it work. He assured me he would stand by me and support me and love the baby no differently to our existing child.

I said it may all be a moot point anyway as at my age I may struggle to fall pregnant at all, even with accurate timing. He said (exact quote): "you never know, you might fall pregnant more easily than you think".

That was the end of the conversation.

So it seems he has reflected on his initial stance and revised it somewhat, saying perhaps he wasn't as strongly opposed as he originally claimed to be, and therefore he'd support me if I became pregnant but he's not actively wanting to hoping for that outcome.

I'm not sure if I'm any further forward?

Honestly that sounds great. I would just carry on as you are. Maybe you'll have another baby. Maybe you wont. Either way it doesn't need to be a big issue in your relationship anymore 🙂

pikkumyy77 · 21/02/2024 17:55

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:45

@NeedAdvice8

But what he says is inconsistent with his actions, and that's my point. If a partner tells you they love you and then cheats on you, you'd not believe they love you would you? Well I wouldn't. Actions need to match up with words, imo. That's what I'm so pissed off about. I feel he's led me a merry dance all this time. I was holding onto hope he didn't actually feel so strongly opposed after all because he was happy to take the risk of me becoming pregnant.

Believe actions not words. That the s how you will come to understand this person.

DeeCeeCherry · 21/02/2024 17:49

He's told you he doesnt want another child. & you're not listening. You need to actually listen, and decide whether this is a dealbreaker for you or not. All this stuff about no condom, your fertility cycle etc is just an unnecessary red herring. Ask him to have a vasectomy, I'm pretty sure his answer will clear your mind more. But if he says 'Yes ok' you're back to square 1 anyway aren't you.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 21/02/2024 17:44

That more of an ambiguous situation than before.

Before he didn’t want a baby. But was happy to have unprotected sex when he could.

Now he might be ok if you get pregnant. Might be. and he can carry on having unprotected sex and you don’t know how he will feel if you got pregnant

AgentJohnson · 21/02/2024 17:44

You’re playing a dangerous game with this twat.

He wears a condom, he gets a vasectomy or he doesn’t have sex with you, those are his options. Why isn’t his twatery an effective form of non hormonal contraception already?

SpeedyDrama · 21/02/2024 17:44

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 17:33

It's "on" both of them. It's within both of their power to prevent a child being brought into the world.

Just because he is behaving irresponsibly (which I don't dispute), doesn't mean that she also should.

Because the fallout of that is that a child is brought into the world who is not loved by its father.

OP is putting her own selfish desires above the needs of this potential future child.

The ‘child’ is imaginary and unlikely to come to be. There is a possibility of a baby, but that possibility (as minimal as it is) completely falls on the man in this scenario. He doesn’t want a baby and yet is not only not taking active care for it not to happen, he’s taking active action for it to happen. Therefore it is completely on him. The op has already been clear and honest with him, that’s her doing her bit in this. It’s up to him how to move forward with the information given to him, and he’s decided to play roulette in order to have a few minutes of unprotected sex.

I feel you’re one of these people who thinks it’s a woman’s job to make up for men’s shortcomings and feckless behaviours. What do you suggest the op do to rectify the situation? Because the options are take medication that doesn’t agree with her, have a serious and very likely irreversible sterilisation or not have sex with her partner.

fridgegrazer · 21/02/2024 17:43

Presumably he still doesn't want a vasectomy though?

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 17:42

Thought I would update after the conversation I've just had with him.

He is now saying that, on reflection, he clearly cannot feel as strongly about this as he initially thought, and that maybe he's more in the "if it happens it happens" camp than he'd realised, because as I've "rightly pointed out" (his words), he's been very lax about contraception. He also apologised for the mixed messages.

He said that whilst he doesn't actively want a baby, if I were to become pregnant, so be it, and we'd make it work. He assured me he would stand by me and support me and love the baby no differently to our existing child.

I said it may all be a moot point anyway as at my age I may struggle to fall pregnant at all, even with accurate timing. He said (exact quote): "you never know, you might fall pregnant more easily than you think".

That was the end of the conversation.

So it seems he has reflected on his initial stance and revised it somewhat, saying perhaps he wasn't as strongly opposed as he originally claimed to be, and therefore he'd support me if I became pregnant but he's not actively wanting to hoping for that outcome.

I'm not sure if I'm any further forward?

OP posts:
Noideawwhatsoccuring · 21/02/2024 17:37

Him saying he would love and care for another child, stay in the relationship etc means nothing. because it hasn’t happened Why would he say ‘well actually if you get pregnant and don’t abort I will leave’

What would be the consequences of that? It won’t be good for him will it. One possibility is that you won’t have sex with him or have unprotected sex with him.

Him saying that won’t stop him trying to get you to abort the baby, won’t stop him throwing it back at you when it suits, won’t stop the child growing up knowing their dad slightly resents them or him deciding to eventually leave.

Men who have unprotected sex aren’t always trying for children. Obviously it’s always a possible consequence. But that’s not how they view it.

Just because a man has unprotected sex with you doesn’t mean they have changed their mind and want a child.

Anyone saying they would be fine with a hypothetical situation they would prefer not to be, can promise how they will react.

and a man that’s quite selfish, isn’t going to tell his current partner that he would react badly, want an abortion, treat the kids differently if she got pregnant.

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 17:33

SpeedyDrama · 21/02/2024 17:27

Yes but if a man doesn’t want a child brought into the word it’s on him to make sure it doesn’t happen. He has several options and is still choosing to have unprotected sex. Two adults of opposing sexes having unprotected sex have to accept that there is a possibility of making a baby, if one of them isn’t on board with that, they have to take one of the very broad options available to them to self protect themselves from being a parent in 9 months.

It's "on" both of them. It's within both of their power to prevent a child being brought into the world.

Just because he is behaving irresponsibly (which I don't dispute), doesn't mean that she also should.

Because the fallout of that is that a child is brought into the world who is not loved by its father.

OP is putting her own selfish desires above the needs of this potential future child.

SpeedyDrama · 21/02/2024 17:27

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 17:20

I can't tell if you are serious or not.

But if you are - the reason OP is responsible is because we are talking about a child being brought into the world, which is a pretty big thing.

You could even that the potential child's needs should actually outweigh 'something OP wants to happen'.

I don't think that's hard to grasp.

Yes but if a man doesn’t want a child brought into the word it’s on him to make sure it doesn’t happen. He has several options and is still choosing to have unprotected sex. Two adults of opposing sexes having unprotected sex have to accept that there is a possibility of making a baby, if one of them isn’t on board with that, they have to take one of the very broad options available to them to self protect themselves from being a parent in 9 months.

BetterWithPockets · 21/02/2024 17:25

OP, you’re definitely getting a bashing on here and I’m sorry about that. Viewed dispassionately, though (although I can see it might feel differently to you — the same way as it does when a friend, for example, can’t see quite how bad a relationship is, because they’re in the middle of it, and can’t take a step back, but everyone else can see it as clear as day), it doesn’t seem as though he is giving mixed messages. Yes, his actions belie his words — but I think you’re reading too much into that. You’re seeing it as having unprotected sex = him being prepared to risk an unplanned pregnancy = he can’t be that adamant about not having another baby. From the outside, though, he just looks like a stereotypical bloke, thinking with his dick and nothing else. I suspect he’s not remotely thinking about the risk of pregnancy at that moment — just what feels better for him, which is having sex without a condom.

Where you go from here is a whole other question, of course…