Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset with partner over this?

283 replies

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:26

Partner is adamant he doesn't want another baby (for context we have a 2 year old). I'd love another. We are on different pages about this.

However, I am not on any form of contraception because hormonal contraceptives cause awful side effects for me and I've never found one that suited. So after the birth of our child I wanted a break from the pill, and partner was on board with this saying we'd use condoms. However, over the past 12 months alone he has had unprotected sex with me on 18 occasions (the rest being with a condom). I know this because I use an app to track my periods and you can record sex and whether protected or not (presumably to track and date any pregnancies). So he is obviously really lax about this, despite saying he's adamant it's a no.

I've raised the conversation again this past week about his thoughts on another baby, and he says the same "absolutely not". I point out to him the contradiction in his actions and his words. His defence is "I always ask you what point you're at in your cycle so I make sure the timing makes it unlikely" and "I pull out sometimes so it's fine". I asked him if he understood that he's giving me mixed messages by saying one thing and doing another? He said "I have no explanation for that other than I prefer sex without a condom because it feels better". I said OK but you surely then accept the risk that comes with? He just shrugged, repeating he was reassured by the point I was at in my cycle.

OK, he may have a point, in that we've had unprotected sex at "safer" points in my cycle 18 times over the past 12 months and I'm not pregnant. But, there is some risk still, and if he's so adamant he's against having another baby, why would he take that risk even if it was a tiny one?? He can't answer this.

He then deflected onto me and said "you're happy to take that risk too". Well yes, because I'm not horrified at the thought of another baby or massively opposed to it, as you say you are? If I were, I'd not be letting you anywhere near me without a condom.

My head is a mess, and I feel he's confused and upset me a lot with this.

AIBU?

OP posts:
DollyLolly1989 · 21/02/2024 10:13

Does he abstain from sex if you tell him you were at a fertile time of the month? He's definitely giving you mixed messages. What if you were to fall pregnant? Would be expect you to just get an abortion?

Universalsnail · 21/02/2024 10:10

This happened to me. I really really wanted another child to the point at times his instance he didn't made me consider ending the relationship. I can't explain it. Felt like such a raw issue for me.

He kept saying he was going to get a vasectomy but then also knew I wasn't on birth control, encouraged me not to be as it makes me sick but also wasn't consistent with condom use.

I got pregnant. He got upset and accused me of tricking him and suggested I "do the right thing" although wouldn't answer me when I asked him if he meant I should get an abortion. Things were pretty tense for a week.

But then he got over it. We had the baby. He was as happy and excited as the other children. He went and got a vasectomy straight away. My internal longing for a last baby went away and I've never even been broody since. We're happy. He jokes about it sometimes.

I was happy to take the risk
I think you need to weigh up whether you are happy to keep taking the risk or not. I was confident my partner would step up if I did get pregnant and so didn't really see why I needed to go on hormones or insist in condoms everytime even though I hate them when I wanted to get pregnant whilst he took no responsibility for his own desire to not have children. I was right he did step up.
But you have to consider what happens if he doesn't step up. Both for your new baby but also for your existing child who could end up with seperated parents. It is a big risk, and one in hindsight I probably shouldn't have taken even though I was confident he would stay, but it's easy for me to say that now, at the time my longing for another child seemed to over ride my sense of what's best. Arguably it's great if worked out for me but I ultimately risked my children's stability and in hindsight that wasn't great parenting on my part.

JanefromLondon1 · 21/02/2024 10:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

Frizzyleaf · 21/02/2024 10:09

I think he has made it really very clear that the child is unwanted. He’s said “absolutely not” and told you he would be unhappy.

I know you would love and cherish your baby but think how the child would feel knowing they never wanted by their father. You have no way to know that he would even acknowledge them. You cannot control what he will say to them or his other child as they grow up. As cosy says what will he say to their sibling?

I can see this must be heartbreaking for you as you clearly want another baby, but it seems very cruel to the child to be deliberately conceived in these circumstances.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 10:08

cunningartificer · 21/02/2024 10:04

You're right to have had the conversation, but he sounds a bit selfish. He's obviously being massively inconsistent and not very bright to be so against another child while having unprotected sex. You need to push it further though--what would he expect you to do if you conceived? He can't rationally ask you to abort a wanted child that he has made no real attempt to avoid conceiving! I would not have unprotected sex with him unless he made it clear he was happy to lovingly accept the consequences should you get pregnant. I'm worried you're playing with fire and it would put an intolerable strain on your relationship.

I asked him this. He said he'd never expect me to abort or even so much as suggest that I do so. But that he wouldn't be happy about it either?

OP posts:
fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 10:07

Aquamarine1029 · 21/02/2024 10:05

The only question you should be asking is what's best for your existing child, and having another baby your partner doesn't want isn't it. Your current line of thinking is completely and utterly selfish.

Agreed.

OP, sorry but it is selfish, and it is a choice you are making.

Believe me, I know what it's like to want a child - but this is not the best thing, for any of you. It's not going to just magically work out. He's told you very clearly that he doesn't want it.

If you're going to do it then do it. But you need to understand that this is your decision and not something that is just happening to you. You are making this choice.

Beezknees · 21/02/2024 10:07

He shouldn't be having unprotected sex with you if he doesn't want another baby, simple as that.

However, I would be using contraception if I were you. As someone who had a baby with a man who didn't really want one, I could tell you a lot about the damage it causes. Please don't put a potential child through that. Trust me.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 10:06

Frizzyleaf · 21/02/2024 09:48

He’s a selfish shit for putting this all on you and I would also be furious with him.

I think he’s using this a way to ensure he gets sex. He probably thinks if there isn’t the possibility of a baby then you will stop wanting it. He obviously isn’t completely dead set against having another child or he would take precautions, but it’s almost worse in that I think he just sees the child as ‘something’ he could walk away from if and when it suits him and/or punish you for.

Ultimately as the only reasonable adult in the relationship you have to think of the cost to you and your children and the relationship of you did fall pregnant.

Sounds like he would find every excuse to opt out and to blame you for it Flowers

Thank you. I think you're right sadly x

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 21/02/2024 10:05

The only question you should be asking is what's best for your existing child, and having another baby your partner doesn't want isn't it. Your current line of thinking is completely and utterly selfish.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 21/02/2024 10:04

Your updates are making it sound more and more like the reason you consent to this is because you want to get pregnant and are hoping that you do "accidentally"

cunningartificer · 21/02/2024 10:04

You're right to have had the conversation, but he sounds a bit selfish. He's obviously being massively inconsistent and not very bright to be so against another child while having unprotected sex. You need to push it further though--what would he expect you to do if you conceived? He can't rationally ask you to abort a wanted child that he has made no real attempt to avoid conceiving! I would not have unprotected sex with him unless he made it clear he was happy to lovingly accept the consequences should you get pregnant. I'm worried you're playing with fire and it would put an intolerable strain on your relationship.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 10:04

@rainywednesday34

I'm so sorry for your situation, that's awful and especially leaving you on Christmas Day 🙁

Finding someone else isn't really an option because I'm 40 this year. I'd be too old 🙁

I appreciate your comments, thank you x

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 21/02/2024 10:04

So you get pregnant
He doesn't want it
You go your separate ways
What happens when he picks up other child for his contact time? How do you explain that to your youngest child? Daddy only wanted your brother? Or do you let the child think you don't know who dad is?
This is never going to end well

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 10:03

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 10:02

@fritaskeeter
No I don't necessarily want to be a single mum, of course I don't. My ideal scenario would be we have another baby as a family and stay together, all happy and on board with this. But that's clearly not going to happen. So if I were to become pregnant, my next best scenario would be to raise my children without him.

OK - so you're making an active decision to have a child with someone who doesn't want one and be a single mum.

If you're going to make that choice then own it.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 10:02

@fritaskeeter
No I don't necessarily want to be a single mum, of course I don't. My ideal scenario would be we have another baby as a family and stay together, all happy and on board with this. But that's clearly not going to happen. So if I were to become pregnant, my next best scenario would be to raise my children without him.

OP posts:
upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:59

@Ginandjuice57884

What do you mean by "rapey"? I consented to the unprotected sex as much as he was happy to engage on it.

OP posts:
rainywednesday34 · 21/02/2024 09:59

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:47

Just to be clear, if I feel pregnant again and he didn't support me, I'd be fully prepared to leave and be a single mum to both my children. It wouldn't be ideal obviously, but there's no way I'd stay with a man who made it clear a child of ours was unwanted.

You have to think about the unborn baby OP. Look at my situation… this is the hardest thing I’ve ever had to go through. I too had this mindset. I was fooling myself because even though I had this same thinking process deep down I thought that my partner wouldn’t leave me anyway! 1. Because we’ve been together for years 2. He was having unprotected sex with me so he must want a baby or would “accept” it 3. We have a child already together so why would another change anything?

not the case. He left me on Xmas day and hasn’t looked back since. If a baby is something you really want then move on and find another man who wants one with you. This isn’t healthy.

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 09:58

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:54

@fritaskeeter
There's no "secretly wanting" on my part - I'm really clear that I want another child. I've been very upfront with him about that. So he knows if I was to fall pregnant I'd not be devastated, far from it. Ideally, I'd like him to be on board of course. But if he's not, and if he walked away and left me pregnant, I'd raise the child alone, along with our other child. I'd choose that over a termination.

Yes, I know you want another child. I meant unless you secretly want the single mum situation.

If you want a child and he doesn't, it doesn't take a genius to work out that is probably what's going to happen.

If that's what you want then crack on - you're making an active decision.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:57

NeedAdvice8 · 21/02/2024 09:56

Ultimately you need to decide what you want to do, whether it is carrying on like you do now and deal with the consequences if you get pregnant, or insisting on contraception. I’m just saying that you shouldn’t convince yourself that he’s signalising he’d be happy with another baby. In my opinion, he’s immature and selfish, but he isn’t sending you mixed signals.

Fair enough, thanks. I appreciate your viewpoint.

OP posts:
upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:57

@Aquamarine1029 through what? My eldest child and I had a great life together, even if I was a single mum for the first 10 years. Yes there were times it was bloody hard but it wasn't horrific. There are plenty of lovely memories as well amongst the hard graft. I know what it entails and I'd be prepared to do it again if it came to a choice between a baby with someone who doesn't want that baby, or pressure from him to terminate.

OP posts:
NeedAdvice8 · 21/02/2024 09:56

Ultimately you need to decide what you want to do, whether it is carrying on like you do now and deal with the consequences if you get pregnant, or insisting on contraception. I’m just saying that you shouldn’t convince yourself that he’s signalising he’d be happy with another baby. In my opinion, he’s immature and selfish, but he isn’t sending you mixed signals.

Ginandjuice57884 · 21/02/2024 09:55

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:26

Partner is adamant he doesn't want another baby (for context we have a 2 year old). I'd love another. We are on different pages about this.

However, I am not on any form of contraception because hormonal contraceptives cause awful side effects for me and I've never found one that suited. So after the birth of our child I wanted a break from the pill, and partner was on board with this saying we'd use condoms. However, over the past 12 months alone he has had unprotected sex with me on 18 occasions (the rest being with a condom). I know this because I use an app to track my periods and you can record sex and whether protected or not (presumably to track and date any pregnancies). So he is obviously really lax about this, despite saying he's adamant it's a no.

I've raised the conversation again this past week about his thoughts on another baby, and he says the same "absolutely not". I point out to him the contradiction in his actions and his words. His defence is "I always ask you what point you're at in your cycle so I make sure the timing makes it unlikely" and "I pull out sometimes so it's fine". I asked him if he understood that he's giving me mixed messages by saying one thing and doing another? He said "I have no explanation for that other than I prefer sex without a condom because it feels better". I said OK but you surely then accept the risk that comes with? He just shrugged, repeating he was reassured by the point I was at in my cycle.

OK, he may have a point, in that we've had unprotected sex at "safer" points in my cycle 18 times over the past 12 months and I'm not pregnant. But, there is some risk still, and if he's so adamant he's against having another baby, why would he take that risk even if it was a tiny one?? He can't answer this.

He then deflected onto me and said "you're happy to take that risk too". Well yes, because I'm not horrified at the thought of another baby or massively opposed to it, as you say you are? If I were, I'd not be letting you anywhere near me without a condom.

My head is a mess, and I feel he's confused and upset me a lot with this.

AIBU?

he has had unprotected sex with me on 18 occasions

That sounds a bit rapey. You're both responsible for contraception and agreeing on it.

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:54

@fritaskeeter
There's no "secretly wanting" on my part - I'm really clear that I want another child. I've been very upfront with him about that. So he knows if I was to fall pregnant I'd not be devastated, far from it. Ideally, I'd like him to be on board of course. But if he's not, and if he walked away and left me pregnant, I'd raise the child alone, along with our other child. I'd choose that over a termination.

OP posts:
takealettermsjones · 21/02/2024 09:54

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:52

@takealettermsjones

I'm fully aware of what being a single mum entails thanks, I have an adult child who I raised by myself for 10 years until I met my partner.

I didn't mean that in a snarky way - you're on here asking for advice. But okay. Good luck.

Aquamarine1029 · 21/02/2024 09:53

upsetandangrywithhim · 21/02/2024 09:52

@takealettermsjones

I'm fully aware of what being a single mum entails thanks, I have an adult child who I raised by myself for 10 years until I met my partner.

You would want to put your children through that?