Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask what NHS frontline staff think of Breathtaking?

495 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/02/2024 23:06

I have watched all 3 episodes. I worked on the frontline during Covid. I found it very triggering and my fury is back.

OP posts:
LadyWhistledownAteMyHamster · 23/02/2024 09:49

I'm NHS hospital, but not clinical. I don't think I can watch it.
One thing I would say is that at my trust, there was never a time when we didn't have enough PPE. However the issue was the constant changes in guidance which scared staff - for example one minute it was standard masks only, the next FFP3 had to be worn, and then a few days later it would be back to standard masks. How is that supposed to reassure staff that we were keeping them safe? It just felt like the rules were being made up at a national level as we went along...

Janiie · 23/02/2024 09:01

Supernova23 · 22/02/2024 09:39

Absolutely not competent in it after a 30 minute training session though. That’s terrifying! Properly understanding mechanical ventilation and the effects your interventions have takes years. You may well have had to manage them in this emergency scenario, but you absolutely weren’t competent at it. No disrespect.

It does not 'take years' to operate and monitor a ventilator.
Anyone can be shown vert quickly. Of course they would then be supervised and have an experienced ICU nurse on hand but I heard of this exact situstion in the pandemic where instead of 1:1 ICU nurses had 1:2 or even 1:3 with odps and ward nurses working alongside them.

Supernova23 · 23/02/2024 08:45

Hotsausage2 · 22/02/2024 22:39

Haha- no disrespect. Whatever.
I never claimed to be ‘competent’ , I just said what happened.
You didn’t need to put me down like that. Totally uncalled for and you have zero knowledge of what my experience was, and the fact that I stupidly volunteered to work in that area.
Talk about nurses disrespecting nurses.
pretty fucking sure you couldn’t do my job either but whatever. I doubt you’d have the guts to put yourself outside your comfort zone.
You know what- your comment has upset me more than the sodding trolls. Cheers. Come and tell me I’m incompetent to my face.

Wow, calm down. I’m literally stating facts. I’m not saying that YOU were incompetent, I’m saying that you could not have been competent at that role. It’s impossible. This is not an opinion but a fact. You can’t walk into any specialised area and be competent at it after half an hour of training.

Of course I couldn’t walk into a new role and be competent after half an hours training. Duh. Stop being so angry.

captainjacksparrow · 23/02/2024 08:21

I can’t watch this as there are no subtitles (same with Mr Bates) but I’m not sure I could face it in any event.

im not NHS but work in children’s social care. My sw were going into hundreds of homes, schools etc with no PPE and no way of social distancing depending on the home.

we lost several colleagues and a dear friend of mine caught covid from a home visit which she passed to her husband and child who both died.

these things will never be forgiven or forgotten. I think people really struggle to comprehend that people were willingly going to work knowing it could kill them but they were doing so to help others.

I don’t begrudge the NHS anything

Damnloginpopup · 23/02/2024 08:02

Horrific watching and nothing but admiration for the frontline staff.

I worked right through, frontline homeless housing, 60hpw and felt sufficiently at risk that I isolated myself and my children went to live with my ex. I isolated my team from each other, enforced a strict one in one out policy on changeover and hoped that would keep us safe.

We were very lucky. COVID didn't hit our town the way it hit others. Nobody I know died or got seriously ill. Remarkably, inspite of a total lack of cooperation from our residents we didn't get it into our buildings until the September and even then it was contained and didn't cause harm. We had it so, so easy comparatively. We merely had the fear and of that I can only ever be thankful. My COVID experience, relatively speaking, was nothing.

At the very start, before lockdown, I'd put things in place. I had an idea of what was coming. I knew and accepted I was at serious risk of becoming a casualty and was frightened. We all were. By fuck was I lucky. My heart goes out to those whose reality was so horrifically different.

I felt anger, frustration, contempt and heartbreak watching this. It felt so very real and those who have posted here back up that feeling. Thank you for what you did, for taking that risk, for what you gave up.

For me, the strangest, overriding thought while watching was how quickly we have moved on, put it in the past, forgotten, buried it...it is SO recent FFS!

BionicEar · 23/02/2024 01:44

I haven’t yet watched, because am unsure how it will make me feel.

I have relatives and friends who work for the NHS. What they went through was horrendous. So many were and continue to affected both only physically but mentally by their experiences of Covid.

Two of my relatives were training to work I the NHS at the time. I recall them saying that initially they had no protection as the hospitals would not supply them with it and it had to come via the medical schools at the Universities where they were training. So when it came, it was of more inferior quality than what was provided for NHS staff. They were given no choice about where they were placed (whilst still waiting for better protection) as were told would fail their courses if objected. Absolutely appalling. Both got Covid a number of times when it was rife.

Recall one of my relatives just absolutely broken on the phone, after caring for a young person (same age) who died during their shift, then coming out to be met by protestors jeering and giving abuse saying Covid was all a hoax.

Our beloved Aunt was in a care home when Lockdown came into place. She died at the beginning of April of natural causes. We weren’t allowed to be with her at the end. A month later we had her funeral which was surreal as there was only a handful of us, including the vicar at a short service. We weren’t allowed to sit together, nor could we gather afterwards to share our memories. Later found out that was one of the dates there was a party held by MPs. Still makes me really angry that so many people died alone, and their families/friends were denied the opportunity to grieve/celebrate their lives together, whilst there was partying going on by MPs.

OhcantthInkofaname · 23/02/2024 01:37

Do any of you think if the US response had been quicker and tougher that it wouldn't have been so bad? The US had a pandemic action plan that the administration in office failed to use.

ThePure · 23/02/2024 01:18

I'm crying over Davina dying
One of our HCAs very nearly died. He was in hospital for months on ECMO all alone. A young lad, no risk factors except ethnicity.

I also remember them coming around and taking all our FFP3 masks away as we were supposedly 'green zone'. It felt very scary to be left just with a paper mask and a plastic apron dealing with patients who were at least suspected of having Covid and many of them of course did. The whole 'zone' thing was totally dumb as people were most infectious in the 5 day wait for the test to come back before they got shipped to the Red zone. Shutting the stable door. After a while it all collapsed anyway as every ward was a Covid ward. A few months later the policy changed (new evidence aka supply issues resolved) and we got them all back again

Also the sending back to care homes with no testing. I was working on a long stay mental health unit and tried to resist people being sent back to us untested but was screamed at by the acute hospital Drs even though their wards were at times largely empty. It was a huge ethical dilemma: leave the person there where they would likely get Covid if they didn't have it already or let them come back to us and spread it to everyone. We had to let them come and we scrupulously barrier nursed them but inevitably one day it did spread and infected every single patient and staff member and half of the patients died.

Obviously I am used to death but for every single patient to be really ill all at once was
nothing I had ever experienced plus no staff as they were all ill too, phoning everyone's families telling them awful news every day, many of them angry and blaming us and having no effective treatment (we had one oxygen cannister for the whole ward so if the acute would not take them it was basically palliation).
I have locked all those memories down tight but I couldn't carry on my inpatient job after that. I work in the community now.

WingingItSince1973 · 23/02/2024 00:11

@peakygold sounds just like someone today I spoke to about the programme who said it wasn't as bad as that and during their discussions with doctors all over the country (they practice alternative medicine so not sure why they were talking to doctors) and apparently all these doctors said their hospitals were empty and it was all a lie by the media, not sure what that reason would be. After a lot of back and forth I no longer class her as a friend. I almost mentioned the vaccines as I know she was very very vocal about that too! Made me so so mad. Thank you for all those that worked so hard and in absolute awful conditions knowing you were facing possible consequences of being around patients but with no back up from the powers that be. That's to all nhs workers, care home workers, bus drivers etc etc etc. Thank you for keeping us as safe as possible xxxx

beguilingeyes · 22/02/2024 23:00

Willyoujustbequiet · 22/02/2024 22:13

I'm ex frontline NHS.

There are no adequate words. Part of me thinks this should be compulsory viewing to hammer it home to the idiots who still think its just a cold.

Anyone who votes Tory should hang their head in shame.

This is the most enraging part of the whole thing. None of these leeches have faced any consequences whatsoever. Didn't Hancock demand immunity in exchange for testifying?
I still can't understand how 'I can't recall' Sunak and Johnson were allowed to get away with 'losing" their WhatsApp messages.
Where is Dido Harding now?

Hotsausage2 · 22/02/2024 22:39

Supernova23 · 22/02/2024 09:39

Absolutely not competent in it after a 30 minute training session though. That’s terrifying! Properly understanding mechanical ventilation and the effects your interventions have takes years. You may well have had to manage them in this emergency scenario, but you absolutely weren’t competent at it. No disrespect.

Haha- no disrespect. Whatever.
I never claimed to be ‘competent’ , I just said what happened.
You didn’t need to put me down like that. Totally uncalled for and you have zero knowledge of what my experience was, and the fact that I stupidly volunteered to work in that area.
Talk about nurses disrespecting nurses.
pretty fucking sure you couldn’t do my job either but whatever. I doubt you’d have the guts to put yourself outside your comfort zone.
You know what- your comment has upset me more than the sodding trolls. Cheers. Come and tell me I’m incompetent to my face.

sprigatito · 22/02/2024 22:21

Half way through the second episode and DH and I are both in tears. Neither of us was frontline NHS. How on earth did you get through it, all the fear and pain...just unspeakable.

Willyoujustbequiet · 22/02/2024 22:13

I'm ex frontline NHS.

There are no adequate words. Part of me thinks this should be compulsory viewing to hammer it home to the idiots who still think its just a cold.

Anyone who votes Tory should hang their head in shame.

Callipygion · 22/02/2024 21:34

I hope they make Dido Harding, Michelle Mone, and everyone else who lined their pockets, watch this series every single day whilst they are in prison.

BluestripeWhitestripe · 22/02/2024 21:33

I can’t watch it.
Non medical people in corridors stopping staff wearing masks in the corridor until the removed them to not be seen in public areas. Threatened with disciplinary action if you kept a mask on.
GPs being given 5 paper masks only to last them all month.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 22/02/2024 21:29

Apologies in advance as I am not NHS staff, but have friends and family who are. I've watched all three episodes and read every post on here. My heartfelt thanks, gratitude and sympathy to all of you who lived this and have been affected since. I've always had the utmost respect for NHS staff and continue to do so. I'm so sorry for the additional stress you have all endured as a result of the naysayers and conspiracy theorists on top of it all.

The third episode really hit home for me about the chap (I think he was supposedly 68) who had a bowel blockage / tumour but was not operated on due to lack of ICU beds. This has really made me realise how lucky my Mum was. She was 75 and diagnosed with colon cancer in Feb 2020. There were many hospital appointments and I could see what was happening, and worried about her contracting Covid as it hurtled our way from Italy. Initially, she was told she would have the tumours removed via keyhole surgery. On the day of lockdown, her colorectal surgeon said this wouldn't be possible and she would have to undergo a full hartmans procedure. On 30 March 2020, I dropped her off at hospital knowing I wouldn't be able to visit her during her recuperation. She got out of the car and didn't look back at us, as she was so scared it might be the last time she saw us. I worried for her, but I also worried for her surgeon and all of the HCPs involved in her care, as I knew they were all at risk and under such enormous pressure. She was in ICU for almost a week afterwards as she had a reaction to the anaesthetic and low BP. We had the option of speaking via ipad / video, but chose not to as we had an unspoken agreement that it would make it more emotional, and also we just wanted to let the nurses and doctors do their jobs. (I also knew by this point that there were people dying of Covid)

She spent two weeks in hospital and came out to a very strange world, but at least she came out. I'm a single person, so I was able to care for her alongside the district nurses who would drop off packs for me including aprons, masks and dressings. I wore a mask while I tended to her wounds and never hugged her, or stayed too close for too long for fear of passing on Covid. I was a key worker myself and was entitled to a school place for my daughter, but didn't take it up and left my job to keep her safe.

I believe fate played a part in her survival. The timing of her diagnosis and operation at the very start of the Pandemic meant that she was able to get that ICU bed she needed. I also believe that the switch from keyhole surgery to remove the tumours to full hartmans procedure saved her life. I will be forever indebted to her colorectal surgeon and her team.

The selflessness of those NHS staff at that time, and still now, fills me with pride. I have health issues myself, and every time I attend an appointment, I take in some hand made soaps for them (I make them myself) It will never be enough to repay them, though for saving my Mum's life. I know part of it was luck, and there were some horrendous choices that had to be made, but I thank you all from the bottom of my heart for all you did.

My Mum will be 80 this year. Thanks to the wonderful NHS staff that's she is still here and I treasure every extra day she has.

Sorry this seems like a bit of a pointless post in many ways, and only a snapshot of a story within the Pandemic. Yes, the bigger story will be told in time and throughout the future, but this is my thanks to you all.

Setters2020 · 22/02/2024 21:27

I learnt 4 things

  1. It was for many a frightening way to die.
  2. NHS England should not have been the ones making the clinical decisions .
  3. So often there wasn't a right or wrong way to do things , just a choice between bad and very bad.
  4. Those of us In less populated areas had it 'easy'.
noodlebugz · 22/02/2024 21:26

I won’t watch it - because I’m pretty sure I’d induce the fury and I have enough going on right now. Perhaps at the right time I will, but I imagine it’ll be really triggering.
Edit - frontline worker but on mat leave during the first wave. Second time we were a covid ward when for some unknown reason we had a ‘hot end’ of the ward - I caught it from work while caring for my grandma at home.

BrambleJamandCustard · 22/02/2024 21:15

Cant bring myself to watch it. I know others are the same

Thomasina79 · 22/02/2024 20:52

The book is brilliant and well worth reading, I read it during covid and then read it again a year or so afterwards. I worked ina GP surgery at the time of covid and whilst not stressful like our hospital colleagues, it was still very difficult!

Panic71 · 22/02/2024 20:43

mumsneedwine · 22/02/2024 20:15

@Panic71 I remember the look of the parents. Scarred faces from the masks. Looking exhausted. One came 3 hours late and we just stayed with their child until they arrived. We knew. Nothing good was happening.

I felt we had the backs of our colleagues in the nhs. I’m sure that parent was so grateful knowing her child was being cared for by you x

mumsneedwine · 22/02/2024 20:15

@Panic71 I remember the look of the parents. Scarred faces from the masks. Looking exhausted. One came 3 hours late and we just stayed with their child until they arrived. We knew. Nothing good was happening.

JustBeKinder · 22/02/2024 20:09

Ive been a nurse for 49 years and I came out of retirement to work as a Covid vaccinator so I wasn’t working frontline ITU but we saw thousands and thousands of people coming through to us who were frightened but thankful we were there, not one of the people I worked with had any qualms about putting themselves at risk, we just wanted to help and we d do it all again in a heartbeat. I watched Breathtaking mostly in tears when I saw what my colleagues had gone through and the protesting people verbally abusing staff as they left work should be ashamed of themselves. Throughout my time in nursing I ve been stressed, understaffed, treated like a second class citizen, abused and assaulted but have never seen anything like the scenarios that went on during Covid. My next door neighbour, a fit and active 95 yr old died from Covid after being taken to a care home from hospital. I m 67 and I still work part time for NHS but I fully understand why Drs and nurses no longer want to work there and why they need a decent pay rise…..it seems memories are very short !

Panic71 · 22/02/2024 20:06

Not NHS but senior leader in a school and I found it very triggering too.
We cared for the children of NHS workers and seeing their faces on collection of their children will haunt me. They were broken and terrified of passing it on to their children and us. I also remember the fear from staff having to work in school and then going home and caring for their elderly parents.
I massively feel for shop workers who are often not mentioned in covid memories and bus drivers - the list goes on

mumatlast14 · 22/02/2024 20:05

I can't bring myself to watch. But I have been raging about this since day 1 and the abuse, gaslighting and denial I've received has been unfathomable. I hope people now realise how horrific it is. Also be clear, covid isn't over. Many are STILL dying of covid (often acquired in hospital). We know HEPA removes covid from the air and FFP2/3 masks prevent transmission yet policy has removed all infection control for covid from all healthcare settings. The damage covid continues to cause with long covid and organ & brain damage is criminal because even more so because we are not using known solutions.