Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask what NHS frontline staff think of Breathtaking?

495 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/02/2024 23:06

I have watched all 3 episodes. I worked on the frontline during Covid. I found it very triggering and my fury is back.

OP posts:
DuncinToffee · 25/02/2024 16:18

Care homes was the topic of the film 'Help' with Jodie Comer

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2024 16:07

Janiie · 25/02/2024 15:58

The clapping thing was ridiculous but it was a more a community morale boost than actually applauding nhs staff. It allowed folk to legally chat in their front gardens to their neighbours which of course they could anyway as long as they SD.

'Rachel Clarke is politically motivated and invested in a certain narrative and the documentary should be seen in that light'

Exactly.

Was it a documentary? that makes things even worse!!!

But as i said, the drama was made with input from many other NHS staff, the program makers and of course the ITV editorial team.

TBH could have gone a whole lot further, esp in regard to care homes.

Janiie · 25/02/2024 15:58

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 15:41

Thankfully I missed that somehow! The clapping thing felt weird in general - the first one was sort of spontaeous and cathartic, but after that it became a sort of mandatory virtue signalling thing, with politicians being filmed doing it. Vomit inducing when you know how little they actually gave a shit.

The clapping thing was ridiculous but it was a more a community morale boost than actually applauding nhs staff. It allowed folk to legally chat in their front gardens to their neighbours which of course they could anyway as long as they SD.

'Rachel Clarke is politically motivated and invested in a certain narrative and the documentary should be seen in that light'

Exactly.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 15:41

Thankfully I missed that somehow! The clapping thing felt weird in general - the first one was sort of spontaeous and cathartic, but after that it became a sort of mandatory virtue signalling thing, with politicians being filmed doing it. Vomit inducing when you know how little they actually gave a shit.

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2024 15:38

Janiie · 25/02/2024 14:22

'No-one is coming on to say it is all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine.'

No and nor have I! What I have said is it was a pandemic so yes it was of course tough but it was going on everywhere, the ppe shortages, the quadrupling of critical care services etc so for anyone to imply (and posters have, the drama cerainly does) that it was purely a problem specifically to England because of the Tories and Johnson is incorrect.

For the trillionth time it was global, same problems. Barring outliers like NZ obvs, I'm talking about comparable countries.

Look how Germany managed?

The UK was an outlier at the time with our v high death rates

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist Yes Johnson wanted everyone out at 6pm for Tom following his death.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 15:18

NHS bed occupancy was lower than currently

Bed occupancy is a poor measure to use unless you are also taking acuity into account.

ThePure · 25/02/2024 15:08

Anyway spoke to soon
Superfans has now come on to say that it WAS in fact all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine

'NHS staff reactions should also take this into account'
Eh? We don't know what we lived through and witnessed ourselves then??

SnakesAndArrows · 25/02/2024 15:03

Janiie · 25/02/2024 14:22

'No-one is coming on to say it is all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine.'

No and nor have I! What I have said is it was a pandemic so yes it was of course tough but it was going on everywhere, the ppe shortages, the quadrupling of critical care services etc so for anyone to imply (and posters have, the drama cerainly does) that it was purely a problem specifically to England because of the Tories and Johnson is incorrect.

For the trillionth time it was global, same problems. Barring outliers like NZ obvs, I'm talking about comparable countries.

Did they give contracts for fake PPE to their mates too?

Superfans · 25/02/2024 14:52

Ultimately the reaction to covid led to more mortality than the disease. Fear was deliberately inculcated in the general public and health professionals for unclear reasons. The conspiracies about medical staff are ridiculous but it’s true palliative care decisions and decisions not to escalate care were made in fear and worry about scarcity and this led to avoidable deaths. Acute respiratory disease the last thing you need is panic. See also early intubation. NHS bed occupancy was lower than currently and while some ITU’s were undoubtedly busy the idea the NHS was overwhelmed particularly in the first lockdown is clearly false. Rachel Clarke is politically motivated and invested in a certain narrative and the documentary should be seen in that light. NHS staff reactions to the documentary should also take into account this context.

Brandnewskytohangyourstarsupon · 25/02/2024 14:47

Hotsausage2 · 20/02/2024 23:42

I’m on the second episode and I wish I hadn’t started watching. I can’t stop crying and I feel so sick. The memories are just piling back in.
i worked in ITU and I remember the whole PPE issue. Being told to reuse gowns,seeing people die without family. Having a coup,e of days off and coming back and finding out 10 people had been taken off vents and died. Holding iPads over vented patients so that families could say goodbye.
Sorry- I’m so bloody angry and upset at the crappy government who allowed this mess. They had fucking time to prepare, and they didn’t bloody care.
The bit about knowing how many Drs had died but not the rest of the staff really upsets me. · 20/02/2024 23:42*

I’m on the second episode and I wish I hadn’t started watching. I can’t stop crying and I feel so sick. The memories are just piling back in.
i worked in ITU and I remember the whole PPE issue. Being told to reuse gowns,seeing people die without family. Having a coup,e of days off and coming back and finding out 10 people had been taken off vents and died. Holding iPads over vented patients so that families could say goodbye.
Sorry- I’m so bloody angry and upset at the crappy government who allowed this mess. They had fucking time to prepare, and they didn’t bloody care.
The bit about knowing how many Drs had died but not the rest of the staff really upsets me.

This, 100% this.

Same, exactly the same experience.
PTSD & flashbacks. I can’t talk about it because I get so so emotional.
I don’t think I will ever get over it.

DuncinToffee · 25/02/2024 14:37

Not to mention the so called protective ring around care homes claim from Hancock

ThePure · 25/02/2024 14:27

Well I guess the independent enquiry is set up to investigate that so we shall see what they say...

I have some sympathy that it was an unprecedented situation and obviously mistakes can be made in good faith but there were dodgy dealings with our PPE procurement, our pandemic planning was poor and some of the decision making around lockdowns and 'eat out to help out' was questionable

Janiie · 25/02/2024 14:22

'No-one is coming on to say it is all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine.'

No and nor have I! What I have said is it was a pandemic so yes it was of course tough but it was going on everywhere, the ppe shortages, the quadrupling of critical care services etc so for anyone to imply (and posters have, the drama cerainly does) that it was purely a problem specifically to England because of the Tories and Johnson is incorrect.

For the trillionth time it was global, same problems. Barring outliers like NZ obvs, I'm talking about comparable countries.

Autumntimeagain · 25/02/2024 14:21

peakygold · 21/02/2024 08:02

It's a dramatisation of a book an NHS doctor found time to write during the pandemic! I'm sure the series won't document how NHS staff were given free food, free takeaways and discounts, and propelled to the front of every supermarket and petrol queue, whatever their role in the organisation 🙄

Seriously ?

  1. You think everyone in the NHS actually received those things ? I know I didn't receive any free food or discounts, and neither did my colleagues.
  2. Even if every single person in the NHS DID get those things, would YOU be willing to sacrifice your safety/life, and the safety/lives of your family, your mental health and your marriage ? for 'free food' ???
  3. Every single person working in the NHS, regardless of their 'role' or place of work, was put at huge personal risk, every single shift/day of work. Porters , cleaners, admin staff, records staff, theatre staff, were all walking through entire NHS sites to do their jobs, walking through entire hospitals, passing hundreds of other staff, security on the entrance doors dealing with hundreds of distressed relatives trying to get to see loved ones etc. They ALL put their own lives at risk. Even the damn managers were having to put their lives at risk.

But you simply think that these people were somehow 'benefiting' from 'special treatment' and onto some kind of 'cushie' set up ffs ???

The real 'benefit' was that you could quickly shop and get home (or to your caravan/hotel room) and get some sleep before you had to do it all again. (Also was a benefit to the 'public', as they were less likely to be 'infected' by NHS staff after a bloody shift !)

Working 15-18 hour shifts, understaffed, overstretched, watching people die was what they were going through, NOT having a bloody 'jolly' ffs !

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 14:19

she also didn't clap for Captn Tom

I may have missed something but I do not recall any clapping for Captn Tom. People clapped for the NHS, which the government and media enthusiastically promoted because clapping is a hell of a lot easier than adequately funding it.

Topsyturveymam · 25/02/2024 13:37

You’re talking to deaf ears I’m afraid with Janiie. She’s just popped up on this thread to try and defend the actions of Boris and his cronies. She wasn’t part of frontline services, just claims to have heard a few stories from people that were apparently!

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2024 13:26

Janiie · 25/02/2024 13:03

'What on earth has her political views got to do with the series?'

Impartiality. Someone with an agenda is not going to present a balanced story. I'd have thought that was obvious.

It was a horrible time, lots of things did go well though as I keep on saying. The provision of critical care for those who needed it and the organised redeployment of staff to support those in the red zone.

But no one is "impartial" everyone has a vote, she votes Labour (i assume?) the balance will come from other nhs opinions and the program makers.

I ve just looked on her Wiki page and she opposed the Doctors contract, appeared on QT and was interviewed several times over the course of the pandemic, she also didn't clap for Captn Tom.

No mention of Momentum or the Socialist workers party.

You seem to be saying that only Conservative supporters can have their views publicly aired, as everyone else is a "leftie" and is obviously a liar.

ThePure · 25/02/2024 13:06

The thing is Janie that all the frontline NHS staff commenting on this thread say that Rachel Clarkes experiences resonate with our own. No-one is coming on to say it is all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine.

All those experiences depicted in the drama: PPE being rationed and removed, 'green' zones that were nothing of the sort, pressure to discharge to care homes seeding spread, no staff fit to come into work, colleagues getting very ill in ITU, calling relatives on Zoom about their dying family member, wards full of very sick people deteriorating quickly and dying, not being able to give people the care they would usually have had and them dying as a result. Those were all experiences that I personally had during the pandemic too. I mean the violin playing seemed like poetic licence but the rest of it was pretty much as I was experienced it

The fact she is usually a palliative care Dr seems irrelevant to me. Loads of people got redeployed to Covid wards during the pandemic. I had friends who were community paediatricians and dermatologists working on Covid wards. We all went to medical school and did general medical rotations whatever our subsequent specialties and we had to pull on that knowledge. That was part of the 'coping' and a sign of how far off business as usual we were. Whatever Rachel Clarkes political views might be the story she has told is real.

Janiie · 25/02/2024 13:03

'What on earth has her political views got to do with the series?'

Impartiality. Someone with an agenda is not going to present a balanced story. I'd have thought that was obvious.

It was a horrible time, lots of things did go well though as I keep on saying. The provision of critical care for those who needed it and the organised redeployment of staff to support those in the red zone.

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2024 12:55

Janiie · 25/02/2024 11:41

'Janiie’s experiences don’t resonate with me'

My experiences? All I've said is it was the same everywhere. Ppe of course in short supply. It was globally. I've also said the NHS managed the surge by quadrupling critical care capacity. Not sure what is controversial about these comments?

It was a tough time yes, there was a pandemic. I just don't believe a palliative care doctor who is a leftie was best placed to be the source of the itv drama.

What on earth has her political views got to do with the series? if so, then your views should be disregarded too, being from the Liz Truss side of the debate.

The program clearly states that the drama is based on the book AND those of various NHS staff.

Do you think that medical staff, during the pandemic, stuck to their specific disciplines? or that Hospitals had a "all hands to the pump policy?

Palliative care specialists were heavily involved in managing CV patients.

You'll have to link to the German, Italian French equivalents of Michele Mone
German and other European health services have not had the issues the NHS has suffered during or since, we are unique in that regard.

BonzoGates · 25/02/2024 12:33

Of course you also need experienced staff (and not falling over from exhaustion), O2 supplies, PPE...

BonzoGates · 25/02/2024 12:29

I've also said the NHS managed the surge by quadrupling critical care capacity. Not sure what is controversial about these comments?

The NHS attempted to manage the surge by quadrupling critical care capacity.

Fixed it for you Janiie.

MrsMurphyIWish · 25/02/2024 12:18

beguilingeyes · 25/02/2024 09:03

One thing that used to piss me off about Johnson and his cronies during all this was his insistence that everything was 'world beating '. Our response, our vaccine etc.
We didn't need it to be world beating. We just needed it to work.
I see that now he's back crawling up Trump's arse despite all his posturing about Ukraine. Zelensky is just a photo of for him.

Johnson and his slogans - every evening the same rhetoric. I would love to have my students analyse his speeches for persuasion if wasn’t so disgusting that he used words to disguise the truth of what was happening.

Topsyturveymam · 25/02/2024 12:02

Tahinii · 25/02/2024 11:34

Those of us who actually worked on the frontline of health and social care know the truth. Second hand stories mean nothing. Of course anyone can say anything online. I could be lying, anyone could be lying. The stories I know are mirrored across the U.K. Janiie’s experiences don’t resonate with me. I do know some areas managed the covid response better than others. Whether that was due to resources, management or population and demographics, I do not know.

Yes, same here. Doesn’t resonate at all with me and what happened in my hospital and what I saw first hand.
Along with the bad stuff, I did see such a lot of bravery and absolute professionalism which will stay with me too.

Autumntimeagain · 25/02/2024 11:58

It's triggered horrific memories of that time, and highlighted the HUGE risks we were taking with our and our families lives, all because we had no option but to put our faith in the management and government.

When you worked in the NHS, there was NO option to refuse to work, you would simply be fired, at a time when no-one was hiring at all. Therefore, the choices were, risk your life (and your families lives), or end up unemployed, unable to pay your bills, and eventually on the street homeless.

And for us having to work through, and bear witness to the atrocities that we were complicit in carrying out under the guise of 'policy' (e.g sending elderly residents back to full care homes without testing knowing full well the risks and threat to life involved or not receiving the correct or out of date PPE, refusing family any contact with the dying, because we were told to) and under constant threat of severe sickness or potential death due to lack of proper equipment and lack of management support for staff welfare, as well as living daily with the unbearable work pressure, severe staff shortages, guilt and terror, do you know what we got ?

We got a small stone, with a rainbow painted onto it, a couple of sweets and a 'commemorative' coin ! Oh, and 'applause' from the public. (I personally also received lifelong sickness/disability from Long Covid and PTSD)

I can now only work in a very limited capacity, due to these disabilities, and now my managers are trying everything they can get rid of me, because I'm not 'adaptable' to be sent to work anywhere they want to put me at a moments notice !

So they abuse you mentally, physically and emotionally, then get rid of you asap. (But would be the 1st ones on the phone to 'welcome' you back if Covid resurged again !)

How do you think we feel about it ? How would YOU feel ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread