Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask what NHS frontline staff think of Breathtaking?

495 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/02/2024 23:06

I have watched all 3 episodes. I worked on the frontline during Covid. I found it very triggering and my fury is back.

OP posts:
DuncinToffee · 26/02/2024 08:44

In his 2019 manifesto, Boris Johnson promised to ‘fix the crisis in social care once and for all'

He lied

Janiie · 26/02/2024 08:38

'This is down to our crumbling CH estate i.e shared toilet and washing facilities, residents and staff cannot help but mix..'

The owners should reinvest the massive fees that they charge in improving facilities! They charge a fortune, have shit facilities snd pay carers peanuts. Is that Johnson's fault too?

Alexandra2001 · 26/02/2024 07:56

Janiie · 25/02/2024 21:03

'This government pushed discharges very hard - without a plan in place'

Every government did the same! Those clinically ready for discharge were discharged both to protect them from the surge of infected people being admitted and also to make space for those requiring hospital care.

What should they have done? Kept everyone in for a month when they'd inevitably have got it in hospital anyway?! It was a no win situation. They should havd had a better chance in a care home than in an acute hospital setting.

They didn't at all, the death rate in UK CH's is way higher than other comparable countries.

This is down to our crumbling CH estate i.e shared toilet and washing facilities, residents and staff cannot help but mix.... far fewer hospital beds and staff compared to almost all other European countries.

We see it now in Cancer Care, we don't have staff or the scanners, hence our cancer outcome rates are terrible.

Alexandra2001 · 26/02/2024 07:50

Janiie · 25/02/2024 18:15

'You don't serious expect CH's to stockpile PPE and then throw it away (then replace) as it becomes out of date do you? they ve not got that sort of money'

Well exactly, but some folk seemed to think the NHS should've had warehouses full of it and chuck it out when out of date. Not remotely practical. Production and distribution were massively ramped up and swiftly too.

Care homes have many residents in their own rooms. They should've used strict infection control measures for hospital transfers. Even if phe suggested no issue with spread if I'd been a manager or owner I'd have erred on the side of caution.

What???

Its the Governments job to have contingency plans for a pandemic, the PPE required for a influenza pandemic is the same for CV ie masks, aprons and hand gels.
The Govt ran these stocks down.

Analysis of official financial data suggests £325m was wiped off the value of the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) emergency stockpile, reducing it from £831m in 2013 under the Conservative-led coalition government to £506m by March last year

and

Accounts suggest funding for “stockpiled goods” that are “held for use in national emergencies” was increased between 2008 and 2011, when pandemic preparedness was identified as a national priority for the NHS. But since 2013 the value of the stockpile has fallen

stevie2024 · 26/02/2024 02:45

Haven't read the full thread yet, but I can echo what I have read so far. I have watched the first episode and had to stop. I am not NHS but was supporting thousands of students at a uni which went into lock down. The sense of fear and anguish was unrelenting for all of the staff and the stress of trying to support the students, especially international students who had no option but to stay in the UK due to travel bans and lockdowns in their own countries. A lot o my colleagues crumbled under the weight of it, and we were not front line NHS staff, so I can only imagine how much more stressful, terrifying and tragic is must have been for you all. We were part of a local group - firefighters, the police and council workers who came together to try and support our communities, and I will never forget a discussion about body bags by the fire service. Horrendous.

As I said, I have had to stop after one episode - I cried nearly all the way through it.

Thank you to the NHS staff - you saved thousands of lives, and saw out those who didn't survive with the most dignity that you could offer. ❤️

Shantayyoustaysashayaway · 26/02/2024 00:52

We're going to watch it tomorrow night. My eldest dd is a night worker in a nursing home & she said watching it brought back loads of memories.
I know I'll find it hard. Both of my parents got hospitalised in December 2020. We was able to call my mum every day & thankfully she was OK.
My dad was deaf so we couldn't speak to him & where his oxygen levels kept dropping he got really confused. It absolutely tears me up thinking my darling dad must have thought we'd all abandoned him (mum got taken in a week after dad) & no-one wanted to visit him. By the time we did he was on palliative care so wasn't aware we was there. We couldn't see his body or get chance to say goodbye before his funeral & after the funeral I had to leave my mum as wasn't in her bubble.
I fukn hate this government, as far as I'm concerned my dad's death is on Johnson along with every else who sadly died.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 26/02/2024 00:50

And even when hospitals were pretty sure a patient had covid, they were instructed not to tell care homes. Because the government knew care homes would not accept discharged patients who were known to probably have covid.

It is also clear from the comments you have made on this thread that you have zero understanding of how care homes work. Just like the government then.

It was the same with the government guidelines for state schools. It was clear whoever wrote them had no knowledge of state schools and had probably only been in private schools. They had no knowledge of how small classrooms are in the state sector and that pupils are already squashed in. Many of the guidelines were physically impossible to do.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 26/02/2024 00:44

I see you are still defending the government.
Discharging patients to an empty care home night have made sense. But they did not do that. They discharged people to any care home that would take them meaning that people already living in care homes were infected and died.
They provided no PPE to care homes, and suppliers to care homes could not get PPE.
The government admitted at one point they had not realised that care workers often worked in more than one care home, so they carried covid from one home to another.
It made no sense. The reality was the government was prepared to sacrifice elderly people, for the sake of younger people who were taken into hospital.
It was never about protecting elderly people.
And no other countries did not do the same. I still remember Italy publicising how someone aged 99 recovered from covid in ICU in Italy. In the UK that 99 year old would never have been given an ICU bed.

A care home near me had about half of its residents die during the pandemic. A friends mum who lived there died of covid. She had been living in there and patients discharged from hospital brought covid into the home. It was predicted at the time this would happen in many care homes, the government did not listen as they did not care. They just talked bollocks about throwing a protective ring around care homes, and in reality that was simply a slogan.

Janiie · 25/02/2024 21:03

'This government pushed discharges very hard - without a plan in place'

Every government did the same! Those clinically ready for discharge were discharged both to protect them from the surge of infected people being admitted and also to make space for those requiring hospital care.

What should they have done? Kept everyone in for a month when they'd inevitably have got it in hospital anyway?! It was a no win situation. They should havd had a better chance in a care home than in an acute hospital setting.

Tahinii · 25/02/2024 20:26

Janiie · 25/02/2024 19:56

'And it was also your precious tory government that was at the top of the decision making chain that ordered covid patients to be discharged into care homes'

You do know every country did the same not just those run by Precious Tories? Hospitals were about to be inundated with infected patients and you seriously think vulnerable people, clinically ready for discharge should have just sat in the wards for a few weeks until testing was available?! It was the lesser of the 2 evils, get them out to what should have been a safer place.

This government pushed discharges very hard - without a plan in place - and caused a care home catastrophe. It wasn’t only the elderly, many care home staff died too. I’m sure if they were your colleagues, you’d get it. You’re not seeing the problems came from the top. Also not all care home owners are rich. Many care homes closed because they were no longer financially viable due to all the deaths of their residents. This meant a huge upheaval for the remaining residents too. It was a mess that we are still addressing in 2024.

Janiie · 25/02/2024 19:56

'And it was also your precious tory government that was at the top of the decision making chain that ordered covid patients to be discharged into care homes'

You do know every country did the same not just those run by Precious Tories? Hospitals were about to be inundated with infected patients and you seriously think vulnerable people, clinically ready for discharge should have just sat in the wards for a few weeks until testing was available?! It was the lesser of the 2 evils, get them out to what should have been a safer place.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 19:36

Janiie · 25/02/2024 19:29

Yes yes we know Gov has responsibility. My point being these rich care home owners driving about in Jags, paying their staff peanuts and and putting their hands up saying 'not our fault!' Really need to up their game a bit too don't they?

Sadly, the demographic of care home residents meant they were always going to be the highest risk. Care home owners need to work with their partners and do better planning and preparedness wise going forward.

I agree that care home staff should be paid more.

But it doesn't matter how rich the owners are, it's still not their responsibility to stockpile for pandemics. Your precious tory government dropped the ball on that one. And it was also your precious tory government that was at the top of the decision making chain that ordered covid patients to be discharged into care homes.

MotherOfVizslas · 25/02/2024 19:36

I found it very triggering, it brought back all the fear and despair of that time. Plus the bloody stupid clapping which is somehow meant to be a suitable substitute for, you know, actually paying us what we're worth😡

Janiie · 25/02/2024 19:29

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 19:14

You know who has responsibility for planning and preparing for potential pandemics, including holding stocks of equipment or other supplies that may be needed? Even if that means spending a lot of money on those stocks, and having to discard items that cannot be used?

The government, and the DHSC operating on behalf of the government.

You know who doesn't have that responsibility?

Care homes.

Yes yes we know Gov has responsibility. My point being these rich care home owners driving about in Jags, paying their staff peanuts and and putting their hands up saying 'not our fault!' Really need to up their game a bit too don't they?

Sadly, the demographic of care home residents meant they were always going to be the highest risk. Care home owners need to work with their partners and do better planning and preparedness wise going forward.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/02/2024 19:14

Janiie · 25/02/2024 18:15

'You don't serious expect CH's to stockpile PPE and then throw it away (then replace) as it becomes out of date do you? they ve not got that sort of money'

Well exactly, but some folk seemed to think the NHS should've had warehouses full of it and chuck it out when out of date. Not remotely practical. Production and distribution were massively ramped up and swiftly too.

Care homes have many residents in their own rooms. They should've used strict infection control measures for hospital transfers. Even if phe suggested no issue with spread if I'd been a manager or owner I'd have erred on the side of caution.

You know who has responsibility for planning and preparing for potential pandemics, including holding stocks of equipment or other supplies that may be needed? Even if that means spending a lot of money on those stocks, and having to discard items that cannot be used?

The government, and the DHSC operating on behalf of the government.

You know who doesn't have that responsibility?

Care homes.

Sunnydaysaregone · 25/02/2024 19:01

Care homes have many residents in their own rooms. They should've used strict infection control measures for hospital transfers. Even if phe suggested no issue with spread if I'd been a manager or owner I'd have erred on the side of caution.

Janiie how would you have done that? Surely you understand that dementia patients have an urge to wander? My close relative was in a care home with a learning disability wing. Some residents were in their 30s and 40s and fully mobile despite severe learning disabilities. Early in the pandemic that care home lost 15 residents to covid after a patient was admitted from hospital who tested positive 24hrs later. 15 deaths ie 25% of the entire home. A devastating loss for both their families and the staff.

They all had single rooms but as a care home manager how would you propose to isolate them unsupervised in their bedrooms? Lock bedroom doors? Sedate them?

Tahinii · 25/02/2024 19:01

Janiie · 25/02/2024 17:09

'TBH could have gone a whole lot further, esp in regard to care homes'

Yes I wish it had. I'd be interested to know why privately owned homes hadn't stockpiled ppe as some expected the NHS to have done just in case of a pandemic and also why, anyone discharged from hospital wasn't automatically barrier nursed as they do in norovirus or mrsa outbreaks? Not blaming the poorly paid staff but surely the managers and owners should've thought about strict infection protocol for hospital transfers in a deadly virus outbreak?

Tell me you know nothing about social care and hospital discharges without telling me you know nothing.

  1. people are not “automatically barrier nursed” in noro and similar outbreaks. Who told you that?
  2. residential care homes are not required to have medical staff on site, they provide social care as per their CQC registration. The guidance around PPE and isolation changed frequently, especially as the beginning. If medical staff were unclear, you can be damn sure social care staff were equally unclear.
  3. care homes with LA funded residents could not - and cannot - refuse residents to return without breaking their contractual obligations. Hospital beds were filling up with patients who needed medical care. Do you really think people would have sat back and allowed medically fit people to remain in a bed unnecessarily? The amount of funding put in place to discharge patients quickly was like nothing I have ever seen.
  4. have you ever been inside a dementia care home? Have you ever met a person with advanced dementia? Many of them don’t understand PPE or isolating. I suppose you could have put them all on 1:1 care but who is funding this and where are the care staff coming from?
  5. the privately run homes could not get access to PPE! Don’t you think they tried? Their employees were dying at a high rate. They didn’t sit back and think “eh well never mind”.
Infinity234 · 25/02/2024 18:55

I’ve been meaning to watch.

I work in childcare and that was scary at first, especially as staff were complying with all rules but we were watching parents drop off their kids with us then going for coffee at each other’s houses etc. We had covid deniers, refusing to wear masks at drop off, getting cross if we sent children home with temperatures. A teacher from my children’s school died from it and I remember being so angry at these people not taking it seriously.

I can’t even begin to imagine the horror of being on the wards and dealing with it all then reading the comments of conspiracy theorists.

SnakesAndArrows · 25/02/2024 18:47

Janiie · 25/02/2024 18:15

'You don't serious expect CH's to stockpile PPE and then throw it away (then replace) as it becomes out of date do you? they ve not got that sort of money'

Well exactly, but some folk seemed to think the NHS should've had warehouses full of it and chuck it out when out of date. Not remotely practical. Production and distribution were massively ramped up and swiftly too.

Care homes have many residents in their own rooms. They should've used strict infection control measures for hospital transfers. Even if phe suggested no issue with spread if I'd been a manager or owner I'd have erred on the side of caution.

Well, we had large warehouses of expensive stuff that was unsuitable and will need to be destroyed, so your cost argument doesn’t hold up.

It would have been better to have had a large, central, constantly replenished stock holding of compliant gear that was then used as rotating stock for “peacetime”. Yes, there would be a bit of wastage because of the need to hold excess stocks, but if done correctly and short shelf life stock donated to care homes etc. there would be minimal waste. And there would be sufficient PPE for a future pandemic.

But that would have required long term, risk based thinking from experts in infection prevention and logistics, and your Tory mates don’t understand anything except short term politicking and making a fast buck from the public.

BonzoGates · 25/02/2024 18:45

Truly sobering. Thank you for all you did ThePure. Humbled.

ThePure · 25/02/2024 18:32

About 70-80% of care home residents have dementia but many are independently mobile not just lying in their beds. People with dementia do not understand or abide by barrier nursing restrictions. They wander about, they will not wear masks, they invade personal space and they do not wash their hands. They get aggressive if you try to force them. It is basically impossible to barrier nurse them without 1:1 staffing which care homes are not resourced for.

On the inpatient dementia ward at our hospital we quickly realised that the patients would not be effectively barrier nursed and we made a Red Zone corridor for new admissions, suspected cases and general hospital returners where at least they had some space to wander about. Most care homes would not have the space or the staffing resources to do that.

This worked out well for quite a few months until the delta variant came along and then as soon as we had one +ve case within days 100% of the staff and patients were infected and over half of the patients died. Yes they were old and had dementia and their life expectancy and quality of life wasn't great in any case. In a hard nosed pragmatic way you could say that locking down the country was not worth it to save them. You might be right. But they were (nearly) all loved by someone and it was hugely traumatic for us staff to try to look after so many people dying in a horrible way all at once whilst either sick yourself or impossibly short staffed. It was a horrible experience far far worse than anything else in my medical career. Obviously I am used to people dying, palliative care, breaking bad news but not in the volume and the circumstances that happened in the pandemic and it really hurts for people to suggest that my real lived experience is not true or exaggerated.

Even suggesting it was actually possible to prevent infections coming into care homes with the level of virus circulating in the community is pie in the sky. Care homes need staff who have to work closely with residents and the staff were getting infected by their kids at school when those were open and by their spouses working in acute hospitals or wherever. There is no PPE that's 100% effective especially as we had only paper masks not FFP3. At the time we were blamed and scapegoated by angry families for 'letting the virus in' but no-one was successful in keeping it out because it was impossible.

The only way to save care home residents was to bring down infection rates in the whole community by lock downs and later by vaccination. It can certainly be debated whether it was worth the undoubted societal harm from lockdowns but to not do that would have meant accepting even more people in care homes would die. You cannot have your cake and eat it which politicians appeared to be trying to do.

Janiie · 25/02/2024 18:15

'You don't serious expect CH's to stockpile PPE and then throw it away (then replace) as it becomes out of date do you? they ve not got that sort of money'

Well exactly, but some folk seemed to think the NHS should've had warehouses full of it and chuck it out when out of date. Not remotely practical. Production and distribution were massively ramped up and swiftly too.

Care homes have many residents in their own rooms. They should've used strict infection control measures for hospital transfers. Even if phe suggested no issue with spread if I'd been a manager or owner I'd have erred on the side of caution.

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2024 17:59

Janiie · 25/02/2024 17:09

'TBH could have gone a whole lot further, esp in regard to care homes'

Yes I wish it had. I'd be interested to know why privately owned homes hadn't stockpiled ppe as some expected the NHS to have done just in case of a pandemic and also why, anyone discharged from hospital wasn't automatically barrier nursed as they do in norovirus or mrsa outbreaks? Not blaming the poorly paid staff but surely the managers and owners should've thought about strict infection protocol for hospital transfers in a deadly virus outbreak?

CH's tend to be just large houses, they simply do not have the staff or the space to isolate patients, though what restraint would be applicable and lawful in a CH to isolate a patient with dementia.... with or without CV.

Also, the advice given to CH's, long after the lock down began, was there was no issues with spread, i posted this at the time, it was all there on the PHE website.

You don't serious expect CH's to stockpile PPE and then throw it away (then replace) as it becomes out of date do you? they ve not got that sort of money.
We had PPE stocks but ran them down during austerity.

However, you do make the case for higher pay (why hasn't it been done?) and to put the sector under the NHS.... long over due.

Janiie · 25/02/2024 17:09

'TBH could have gone a whole lot further, esp in regard to care homes'

Yes I wish it had. I'd be interested to know why privately owned homes hadn't stockpiled ppe as some expected the NHS to have done just in case of a pandemic and also why, anyone discharged from hospital wasn't automatically barrier nursed as they do in norovirus or mrsa outbreaks? Not blaming the poorly paid staff but surely the managers and owners should've thought about strict infection protocol for hospital transfers in a deadly virus outbreak?

Topsyturveymam · 25/02/2024 17:03

ThePure · 25/02/2024 15:08

Anyway spoke to soon
Superfans has now come on to say that it WAS in fact all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine

'NHS staff reactions should also take this into account'
Eh? We don't know what we lived through and witnessed ourselves then??

Yeah, another ‘interesting’ post from someone who wasn’t there, no doubt! Great comment … ‘decisions not to escalate care were made in fear and worry about scarcity’
So not actual scarcity then - FFS!

Swipe left for the next trending thread