Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask what NHS frontline staff think of Breathtaking?

495 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/02/2024 23:06

I have watched all 3 episodes. I worked on the frontline during Covid. I found it very triggering and my fury is back.

OP posts:
ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 29/02/2024 13:12

Medics in other countries who have watched this are often shocked at what was happening in the UK.

sunstreaming · 29/02/2024 12:40

To 'peakygold'. You sound very angry and I sympathise with your feelings. I wonder if you feel your needs/sacrifices were ignored because themedia and the rest of us concentrated on the sectors where people were very obviously at risk. I am sorry that you feel like this and suggest you maybe get some help to talk through your feelings and also,if needed, help to cope with any aftermath you are sufferring. Truly,none of us should have been treated so badly. But your comment about Rachel Clarke 'finding time to write the book during thepandemic' is inaccurate,I think. She kept a brief diary at the time,which has helped her and us to be better informed and she wrote the book afterwards. Also,you seem annoyed that NHS employees,whatever theirrole,were allowed to queue jump and were given presents.I agree this is unfair, but it's nothing new.In many situations,there are people whose contribution is overlooked,while the more visible person is praised.How many of us thank or give presents to our children's teachers, but don't acknowledge thecleaners/lunchtime supervisors -although these people also perform a vital role. We tend to think of the doctors and nurses in hospitals,but not the pharmacists, radiographers,physios,occupation therapists,porters,ward clerks,cleaners etc. Giving 'treats' to NHS staff was a bit clumsy in some ways,but I doubt any NHS staff thought the pizza or chocs actually repaid them for the horrendous pressures they were under.

Alexandra2001 · 29/02/2024 11:08

Janiie · 29/02/2024 10:53

're your remarks really based on NHS staff? or your political views? No people did not receive the care they should of'

NHS staff. Many on the 'front line'.

Of course people didn't receive the care they should have there was a pandemic, but if they needed respiratory support and deemed candidates that had a chance of survival, so not very elderly with multiple chronic health problems (as is the norm in critical care anyway) they got it.

It was well reported at the time that patients died because of a lack of equipment.

Now i'm certainly not saying thats all the Tories fault at all, chances are no amount of icu and ventilators could have ever been provided but to deny it never happened is ridiculous and goes against many NHS staffs' real experiences.

You may as well argue the UKs cancer care is brilliant and no one goes without.

Janiie · 29/02/2024 10:53

're your remarks really based on NHS staff? or your political views? No people did not receive the care they should of'

NHS staff. Many on the 'front line'.

Of course people didn't receive the care they should have there was a pandemic, but if they needed respiratory support and deemed candidates that had a chance of survival, so not very elderly with multiple chronic health problems (as is the norm in critical care anyway) they got it.

Alexandra2001 · 29/02/2024 09:43

Janiie · 29/02/2024 08:31

'but unless you can prove she & everyone else, is lying'

I can't prove anything. Like everyone else on here my comments are based on anecdotes from nhs staff.

Critical care capacity was quadrupled. Routine ops cancelled. Critical care was given whatever resources and staff that they needed. That, I'm afraid is as good as it gets in a deadly pandemic. Anyone who would benefit from respiratory support received it, even if it was in theatres as opposed to ICU.

Of course there are longer waits and a knock effect. Cancelling all routine care and imposing lockdown comes at a price.

Not into quoting partial out of context comments, you shouldn't either, weakens your argument, your choice though.

Are your remarks really based on NHS staff? or your political views?

No people did not receive the care they should of, my Aunt didn't and neither did my partners Gran, who died at home as there was nowhere to send her, 100s of 1000s didn't either, widely reported.

Knock on effects - why is it that no other country in Europe has such "knock on effects"?
The pandemic affected us all, yet its the UK that has these issues.

Are you really saying that anyone who supports the Labour party shouldn't have a voice?

Do you also think Alan Bates shouldn't have been allowed a platform on TV either?
Have we entered a world where the only truth is from the mouths of Tories?

Janiie · 29/02/2024 08:51

DuncinToffee · 29/02/2024 08:36

I can't prove anything

We shall leave it there

You do know it's a chat forum and not a court of law yes? All comments are anecdotal unless you'd like us to submit written and signed statements to you?

DuncinToffee · 29/02/2024 08:36

I can't prove anything

We shall leave it there

Janiie · 29/02/2024 08:31

'but unless you can prove she & everyone else, is lying'

I can't prove anything. Like everyone else on here my comments are based on anecdotes from nhs staff.

Critical care capacity was quadrupled. Routine ops cancelled. Critical care was given whatever resources and staff that they needed. That, I'm afraid is as good as it gets in a deadly pandemic. Anyone who would benefit from respiratory support received it, even if it was in theatres as opposed to ICU.

Of course there are longer waits and a knock effect. Cancelling all routine care and imposing lockdown comes at a price.

Janiie · 29/02/2024 08:24

'Once again, the program was based on a book written by a Labour party supporter'

Yep.

Alexandra2001 · 29/02/2024 07:10

Janiie · 29/02/2024 06:45

'unless you can come out of your hole and admit you have no idea what clinical staff actually went through then please just shut the hell up.'

I'm not in 'a hole' and no I won't shut the hell up. Its a chat forum, you will encounter a wide range of differing opinions on many issues. You shouldn't go around telling people to 'shut the hell up'.

Breathtaking was written by someone wirh a well known political agenda so of course it is not impartial. I've listened to plenty of stories of what when on in the nhs, again it was tough but there was a pandemic, What did you expect? We managed far better than overwhelmed Italy for starters.

No we didn't at all, the NHS was and still is "overrun"

Italy tried to treat everyone, with more beds and nurses they could treat more, its only now that we see what really happened in UK hospitals, our media supported the Govt line.

Longer term, Italy's health service is back to where it was, but the NHS has 8m on waiting lists, 12 hr waits in AE, the worst cancer care in Europe, larger and larger staffing issues, a shortfall of over 40k nurses, more nurses leaving than starting nurse training.
Thats before we get to other AHPS like Midwives, Physio's, OTs and Radiographers, again huge shortages.

MH provision is almost non existent.

Once again, the program was based on a book written by a Labour party supporter (with input from many other NHS staff, with editorial control for balance) but unless you can prove she & everyone else, is lying, why should we not listen to views from other sources? isn't that how we all learn?

Janiie · 29/02/2024 06:45

'unless you can come out of your hole and admit you have no idea what clinical staff actually went through then please just shut the hell up.'

I'm not in 'a hole' and no I won't shut the hell up. Its a chat forum, you will encounter a wide range of differing opinions on many issues. You shouldn't go around telling people to 'shut the hell up'.

Breathtaking was written by someone wirh a well known political agenda so of course it is not impartial. I've listened to plenty of stories of what when on in the nhs, again it was tough but there was a pandemic, What did you expect? We managed far better than overwhelmed Italy for starters.

Hotsausage2 · 29/02/2024 00:22

Janiie · 25/02/2024 14:22

'No-one is coming on to say it is all a bit of an exaggeration and actually everything was fine.'

No and nor have I! What I have said is it was a pandemic so yes it was of course tough but it was going on everywhere, the ppe shortages, the quadrupling of critical care services etc so for anyone to imply (and posters have, the drama cerainly does) that it was purely a problem specifically to England because of the Tories and Johnson is incorrect.

For the trillionth time it was global, same problems. Barring outliers like NZ obvs, I'm talking about comparable countries.

Bugger me- it was a bit tough.
unless you can come out of your hole and admit you have no idea what clinical staff actually went through then please just shut the hell up.
you have zero empathy for what we did and what we are still trying to cope with regarding the after effects.
you are coming across as just belittling and ignorant of what we went through.
No one is saying it wasn’t global, no one is saying everywhere struggled. What I and others are saying is that the programme sadly is acutely accurate of what occurred.

itsachange2024 · 28/02/2024 21:50

When everything was reconfigured and everyone sent home and people didn't want to come to AE in case they caught it, there was a week or so it actually was quite quiet and that was when the videos circulated. People were sourcing home made cpap machines etc and drawing up plans and separating corridors etc. That prep time was quite eeirie then it all started and it was so busy with new plans, meetings, adjustments, teaching, all the cases, getting changed all the time.
The series brought back the fear - we were all terrified it felt like you could catch it and become instantly very sick we just didn't know what to expect.

Thedogscollar · 28/02/2024 21:23

GreekDogRescue · 28/02/2024 20:07

Does It showcase the TikTok dancing nurses rehearsing in the empty hospitals?

Stop being so pathetic and juvenile.

DuncinToffee · 28/02/2024 20:36

GreekDogRescue · 28/02/2024 20:07

Does It showcase the TikTok dancing nurses rehearsing in the empty hospitals?

You could watch the show.

Tahinii · 28/02/2024 20:28

GreekDogRescue · 28/02/2024 20:07

Does It showcase the TikTok dancing nurses rehearsing in the empty hospitals?

They were empty because there were no visitors or staff walking around due to infection control. Outpatient clinics were cancelled. I find it hard to believe grown adults don’t realise this.

GreekDogRescue · 28/02/2024 20:07

Does It showcase the TikTok dancing nurses rehearsing in the empty hospitals?

Autienotnaughtie · 28/02/2024 05:37

A shocking watch. Not only did it bring back the awfulness of being in lockdown but also seeing that side of it. For the first 18m I didn't know a single person with covid all I had was the newspaper reports and news bulletins. It's unbelievable what was going on behind the scenes.

It seems like a joke that we clapped once a week now.

ThePure · 27/02/2024 00:13

So actually yes poor conditions in care homes literally are the Tory government's fault because they do not adequately fund local authorities so that they can pay better rates that are enough for care staff to be adequately paid and trained. The proposed lifetime cap on care fees due to come in next year as a sop to rich old Tory voters who don't want to sell their homes for care fees will only worsen the situation as it will stop the covert cross subsidy of LA residents by self funders which is actually the only way the sector survives. Good care is costly. I really do not understand what is the issue with people being required to sell a home they are not living in to pay for that.

ThePure · 27/02/2024 00:01

Most CH do have en suite bathrooms as the market demands it but the joke is that very few residents are actually able to use them as few can wash or even toilet independently and many require 2 staff to assist who cannot all fit in a tiny en-suite bathroom so the residents are actually taken to the larger communal bathrooms to be washed and the en suites are mostly ornamental.

ThePure · 26/02/2024 23:57

The hugely popular wealthy care home owners swanning around in Jags are largely a myth. Most care homes are owned by big faceless groups like Excelcare. I guess their shareholders are probably swanning around in Jags but it's not like all the wealth is vested in one person.

In London and the SE where property prices are high it is possible to make a tidy profit in the care home industry as house prices support high fees. In the rest of the U.K. there is very little money in it at all. Average fees in 2022/3 were £686 per week in the North to £955 per week in the South. It might sound like a lot but could you rent a place with all your bills and food included for that and 24hr care support as well? Most residents (60%) are local authority funded and the LAs pay rock bottom fees that barely cover costs. When care home owners in the East of England lobbied Norfolk council for a raise in the basic rate they showed that the rate the LA paid for residential care was actually less than to stay in a Travelodge without even any breakfast let alone any care support.

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 26/02/2024 11:48

@Janiie Firms that make PPE contacted the government wanting to help the NHS. One large firm offered to make extra PPE at cost. They said no one ever returned their calls. Because the government were too busy giving out large contracts to firms run by their friends who had never made PPE, and in lots of cases made PPE that could not be used as it did not meet the requirements.
Yes I blame the government for that. There may still not have been enough PPE, but there could have been a lot more if the government had acted in the best interests of the public, instead of their friends.

Alexandra2001 · 26/02/2024 11:48

Janiie · 26/02/2024 08:38

'This is down to our crumbling CH estate i.e shared toilet and washing facilities, residents and staff cannot help but mix..'

The owners should reinvest the massive fees that they charge in improving facilities! They charge a fortune, have shit facilities snd pay carers peanuts. Is that Johnson's fault too?

Well, the Tories have been in for 14 years, why haven't they regulated to change this?

Yes fees are super high but CHs are closing and those that are left are refusing to take complex patients.

My DDs care agency she worked for was/is handing back council and CH contracts, just not profitable.

Have you any idea how much it would cost to transform a Victorian house into a facility with on suite? and where would the patients go whilst building work done???

You re not thinking this through.

SnakesAndArrows · 26/02/2024 11:01

Janiie · 26/02/2024 08:38

'This is down to our crumbling CH estate i.e shared toilet and washing facilities, residents and staff cannot help but mix..'

The owners should reinvest the massive fees that they charge in improving facilities! They charge a fortune, have shit facilities snd pay carers peanuts. Is that Johnson's fault too?

Not all care homes have rich owners.

My DM lived in a not-for-profit home paying about £800 pw. LA residents paid less. We fund-raised for a new roof. Residents’ families built a Covid-safe meeting pod.

Ilikeviognier · 26/02/2024 11:00

non NHS. Just on the final episode now. It’s shocking watching. Very good how they show the Downing Street briefings against the reality in the hospitals. Anyone who works frontline needs a medal. Truly heroic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread