Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask what NHS frontline staff think of Breathtaking?

495 replies

CloudyYellow · 20/02/2024 23:06

I have watched all 3 episodes. I worked on the frontline during Covid. I found it very triggering and my fury is back.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
campingwithdoggo · 21/03/2024 16:58

@GreekDogRescue how offensive and disrespectful

GreekDogRescue · 16/03/2024 20:15

Saschka · 16/03/2024 17:34

Oh right, you’re an “all the hospitals were secretly empty” conspiracy theorist. I wouldn’t have wasted my time answering if I’d known that up front.

Of course all hospitals were not ‘secretly empty’.
You are being utterly ridiculous.
If I’d known you were a conspiracy theorist I wouldn’t have wasted my time replying.

I suppose you think all the patients with early cancer symptoms who stayed at home ‘to save the NHS’ and who are now inoperable is a conspiracy theory too.

Saschka · 16/03/2024 17:34

GreekDogRescue · 15/03/2024 20:34

They didn’t have patients, ergo the time-consuming dance routines. The sick were told to ‘stay home to save the NHS’.
Many reasonably thought the NHS was there to save them, but what do they know.
Note there are no dance routines being choreographed now, because hospitals are full and they don’t have time.

Oh right, you’re an “all the hospitals were secretly empty” conspiracy theorist. I wouldn’t have wasted my time answering if I’d known that up front.

HRTQueen · 15/03/2024 20:37

Dance routine 🙄

It was a few people following a few steps and filming it

it was silly twatish behaviour by a few not staff who had just popped out of ICU and decided to make better use of their time

GreekDogRescue · 15/03/2024 20:34

DuncinToffee · 15/03/2024 20:06

Are you saying they were neglecting their duties looking after patients?

Have you actually watched the show?

They didn’t have patients, ergo the time-consuming dance routines. The sick were told to ‘stay home to save the NHS’.
Many reasonably thought the NHS was there to save them, but what do they know.
Note there are no dance routines being choreographed now, because hospitals are full and they don’t have time.

Saschka · 15/03/2024 20:25

It takes hours, days to organise a collaborated dance routine - especially as those involved were not professional dancers and many were not in good shape

It really really doesn’t. I’ve just watched a couple of the nurse Covid dance videos, and these were incredibly simple short routines, and frankly not executed massively well (people completely out of time with each other). I reckon about 20 mins for a motivated Zumba or barre class attender to pick these up.

It literally just looks like a group of people messing about on their break, which I have absolutely no problem with. No reason it would have detracted from patient care.

DuncinToffee · 15/03/2024 20:06

GreekDogRescue · 15/03/2024 19:59

It takes hours, days to organise a collaborated dance routine - especially as those involved were not professional dancers and many were not in good shape.
Healthcare workers are usually rushed off their feet yet during the pandemic they told the sick to ‘stay home to protect the NHS’.
Asa consequence many have died as they were told to stay at home so they missed the opportunity for early diagnosis that could have saved their lives.
It’s sickening.

Are you saying they were neglecting their duties looking after patients?

Have you actually watched the show?

GreekDogRescue · 15/03/2024 19:59

Alexandra2001 · 15/03/2024 09:24

People in stressful situations sometimes do irrational things or take part in things that some might say, are inappropriate.

They need to let off steam.

Has to be taken in context, millions of healthcare workers doing their very best, often with little support or correct PPE.

So what exactly is wrong with a singsong? dressing in ash and sackcloth wont bring anyone back from the dead.

Unlike Boris and his piss up parties, these people weren't making up the rules.

The general public didn't tell people to stay at home, that was Boris and Whitty.

Under diagnosis was and still is caused by years of under funding, an elderly and unhealthy population..... the rest of Europe was also hit by Covid, why has their health services returned to normal?

Why is a cancer patient in France or Germany so much more likely to get early diagnosis and prompt treatment?

It takes hours, days to organise a collaborated dance routine - especially as those involved were not professional dancers and many were not in good shape.
Healthcare workers are usually rushed off their feet yet during the pandemic they told the sick to ‘stay home to protect the NHS’.
Asa consequence many have died as they were told to stay at home so they missed the opportunity for early diagnosis that could have saved their lives.
It’s sickening.

Alexandra2001 · 15/03/2024 09:24

GreekDogRescue · 14/03/2024 19:54

Are you denying the TikTok dancing routines?
Do you think this an appropriate use of healthcare workers time during a pandemic?
My cousin died because people like you insisted that sick people should stay at home to ‘protect the NHS’.
Thousands are now dying because early diagnoses were missed.
And you call us ‘pathetic and juvenile’
Shameful.

People in stressful situations sometimes do irrational things or take part in things that some might say, are inappropriate.

They need to let off steam.

Has to be taken in context, millions of healthcare workers doing their very best, often with little support or correct PPE.

So what exactly is wrong with a singsong? dressing in ash and sackcloth wont bring anyone back from the dead.

Unlike Boris and his piss up parties, these people weren't making up the rules.

The general public didn't tell people to stay at home, that was Boris and Whitty.

Under diagnosis was and still is caused by years of under funding, an elderly and unhealthy population..... the rest of Europe was also hit by Covid, why has their health services returned to normal?

Why is a cancer patient in France or Germany so much more likely to get early diagnosis and prompt treatment?

Thedogscollar · 15/03/2024 09:10

@GreekDogRescue
Saw no Tik tok routines in my hospital.
I am a midwife not a nurse but we cared for ladies labouring with covid some became seriously ill ending up in ITU with early caesarean section to save their life. One lady on ECMO for months.

I'm very sorry your cousin died but that cannot be blamed on me, it was the government that decided the rules then chose to break them spectacularly multiple times.

People like me were not on tik tok it's not on my radar.
People like me went to work every night and cared for people like you and just got on with it.
People like me cried with and cared for patients affected with and by covid.
People like me were affected too.

DuncinToffee · 14/03/2024 21:03

Ofcourse but the Government made the final decision.

Front line NHS staff had nothing to do with it.

Janiie · 14/03/2024 20:56

DuncinToffee · 14/03/2024 20:42

It was Boris Johnson who appeared on tv daily to reiterate the message

Stay home, protect the NHS and save lives

Yes I know I saw him. My point was like Sturgeon, Drayford and every other leader he was making rules based on expert advice. He didn't make it all up himself.

DuncinToffee · 14/03/2024 20:42

It was Boris Johnson who appeared on tv daily to reiterate the message

Stay home, protect the NHS and save lives

Janiie · 14/03/2024 20:37

DuncinToffee · 14/03/2024 20:21

Stay home to protect the NHS came directly from the government, direct your blame and anger at them.

I think it was advice given to them by medical experts who knew there was a surge of very sick patients coming so needed to get the public to act responsibly and take the pressure off NHS services.

The many, many TikTok routines were indeed highly inappropriate and insensitive. Managers should've bollocked anyone who participated.

DuncinToffee · 14/03/2024 20:21

Stay home to protect the NHS came directly from the government, direct your blame and anger at them.

GreekDogRescue · 14/03/2024 19:54

Thedogscollar · 28/02/2024 21:23

Stop being so pathetic and juvenile.

Are you denying the TikTok dancing routines?
Do you think this an appropriate use of healthcare workers time during a pandemic?
My cousin died because people like you insisted that sick people should stay at home to ‘protect the NHS’.
Thousands are now dying because early diagnoses were missed.
And you call us ‘pathetic and juvenile’
Shameful.

Alexandra2001 · 02/03/2024 09:44

ThePure · 02/03/2024 07:38

I was responding to a poster who was saying we over reacted and should have known via our crystal balls that lockdowns would be more harmful than the virus. I think we still don't know if that was or was not the case. It's hard to weigh up everything on both sides of the argument

We surely knew a bad thing was coming and that many people had died in China and Italy but that's pretty much all we knew.

We didn't know the details at that early stage
Eg I can clearly recall people were still terrified that it might affect children which we now know it doesn't. We didn't know the risk factors. People were very worried if they had respiratory diseases even mild asthma. It's a fair assumption but later on we realised cardiac risk factors are much more relevant

We knew the age groups CV most affected from the data Italy shared.

LDs seem to have had the most impact on the UK, we started off with some of Europe's most run down public services.

Hence our MH crisis & so many having left the workforce, many because of ill health & unable to get treatment.

DuncinToffee · 02/03/2024 09:38

Alexandra2001 · 02/03/2024 07:34

It's all said with the benefit of hindsight though isn't it? When this new virus first arrived we did not know who would be most susceptible. It could have decimated children and young adults like Spanish flu did which would have been even less acceptable to society

Its not Hindsight.

Even before any talk of LD, it was well known the virus hit the elderly the hardest, same with "most" respiratory viruses.

But we had Boris and that gave us the edge.....

Exercise Cygnus provided plenty of warnings

ThePure · 02/03/2024 07:38

I was responding to a poster who was saying we over reacted and should have known via our crystal balls that lockdowns would be more harmful than the virus. I think we still don't know if that was or was not the case. It's hard to weigh up everything on both sides of the argument

We surely knew a bad thing was coming and that many people had died in China and Italy but that's pretty much all we knew.

We didn't know the details at that early stage
Eg I can clearly recall people were still terrified that it might affect children which we now know it doesn't. We didn't know the risk factors. People were very worried if they had respiratory diseases even mild asthma. It's a fair assumption but later on we realised cardiac risk factors are much more relevant

Alexandra2001 · 02/03/2024 07:34

It's all said with the benefit of hindsight though isn't it? When this new virus first arrived we did not know who would be most susceptible. It could have decimated children and young adults like Spanish flu did which would have been even less acceptable to society

Its not Hindsight.

Even before any talk of LD, it was well known the virus hit the elderly the hardest, same with "most" respiratory viruses.

But we had Boris and that gave us the edge.....

ItsAllAboutTheDosh · 01/03/2024 21:12

@ThePure we did know. The virus had already hit China and Italy. But on MN there were lots arguing that somehow British people were different and the virus would not hit in the same way. It should not have been a surprise when it did.

Saschka · 01/03/2024 19:06

Superfans · 29/02/2024 23:17

Of course they should have cohorted infected patients and not discharged to care homes but medics were supportive of this at the time. It’s not like there was a Tory bed manager in the hospital with a clipboard. Doctors were eagerly ushering people out the door including in the non Tory devolved nations. You forget, we thought there was going to be a massive influx and we would need every bed. Government and clinical staff saw nursing home patients as expendable. The brutal truth is many nursing home residents do have short life expectancy but not all. Basic medical care such as oral antibiotics weren’t given in many cases because it was assumed people were dying of covid but many died of pneumonia or plain old neglect.

The tories are an incompetent disaster but you’re kidding yourself if you think Labour would have been any better. They didn’t fail because they were too ideologically right wing but because they were too blinded by preheld beliefs and fallacies to assess the situation and lacked the bravery for difficult decisions.

Basically we fucked up badly and no one quite wants to admit it yet. Lots of people died because of it, some were harmed badly and most of of will live worse lives. It’s countless times worse than if we had just ignored the novel virus, incalculable damage. We overreacted when we should have kept our cool, then we made it worse with bad decisions time and time again. We need a good hard look at our media, at the quality of our so called scientific institutions and whether we care more about material reality or more political point scoring.

Obviously can’t speak for every hospital, but in ours we were completely taken by surprise by the speed it spread - we were trying to get people out of hospital and into care homes at a point where we thought there were only 5 cases in the UK, it was thought to only be a risk if you’d come back from certain parts of Italy, and testing could only be done in special infectious diseases testing centres (Guys and Royal Free in London, from memory). We were trying to get them out to safety, before the pandemic hit, but obviously had no idea they could be infected already at that point in time.

And then a week later, literally our entire hospital had it. We were swamped. Nobody thought we should discharge people to nursing homes at that point. This was long before lockdown, incidentally - it was the first week of March when things suddenly went nuts.

I do think people at NHSE/SAGE etc should have known what to expect in advance, but I’m not going to blame jobbing doctors and nurses, who had no experience of infectious disease outbreaks, for thinking they were doing the right thing based on what they were being told at the time.

ThePure · 01/03/2024 12:07

It's all said with the benefit of hindsight though isn't it? When this new virus first arrived we did not know who would be most susceptible. It could have decimated children and young adults like Spanish flu did which would have been even less acceptable to society

If we had chosen not to lock down when the rest of the world was doing that would certainly have been an outlier as a decision.

Whilst it turns out that it is mainly older people who died of Covid a) we did not know that at the outset and b) a small percentage of a very large number is still a large number. Had we not locked down and 'let it rip' many more people would have died overall, all at once in an overwhelming therefore traumatic way and more younger people would also have died.

It was bad enough as it was. If we had not locked down and 'let it rip' then NHS staff would need to know that society was accepting that we would let people die and would have no hope of saving them. It's the attitude that we simultaneously are to blame for not doing enough to save elderly people dying in care homes and also did too much by having lock downs that I cannot understand. You can't have one without the other either we accept that many people will die and pay that price as a society or we take the pain of lockdowns.

People blaming care home and hospital staff for not preventing Covid getting in or not saving infected people want to have their cake and eat it. When the levels in the community were so high it was an utterly impossible task to keep it out and there was no effective treatment.

The harms from the lockdowns were and are also terrible but we did not have the ability to properly weigh up which would be worst at the time.

SnakesAndArrows · 01/03/2024 10:29

Superfans · 29/02/2024 23:17

Of course they should have cohorted infected patients and not discharged to care homes but medics were supportive of this at the time. It’s not like there was a Tory bed manager in the hospital with a clipboard. Doctors were eagerly ushering people out the door including in the non Tory devolved nations. You forget, we thought there was going to be a massive influx and we would need every bed. Government and clinical staff saw nursing home patients as expendable. The brutal truth is many nursing home residents do have short life expectancy but not all. Basic medical care such as oral antibiotics weren’t given in many cases because it was assumed people were dying of covid but many died of pneumonia or plain old neglect.

The tories are an incompetent disaster but you’re kidding yourself if you think Labour would have been any better. They didn’t fail because they were too ideologically right wing but because they were too blinded by preheld beliefs and fallacies to assess the situation and lacked the bravery for difficult decisions.

Basically we fucked up badly and no one quite wants to admit it yet. Lots of people died because of it, some were harmed badly and most of of will live worse lives. It’s countless times worse than if we had just ignored the novel virus, incalculable damage. We overreacted when we should have kept our cool, then we made it worse with bad decisions time and time again. We need a good hard look at our media, at the quality of our so called scientific institutions and whether we care more about material reality or more political point scoring.

If we had “kept our cool”, by which I presume you mean avoided the first lockdown and kept schools open, far, far more people would have died in 2020 both in and out of hospitals.

Are you taking a purely utilitarian approach and suggesting that this collateral damage would have been preferable to what has actually happened?

Superfans · 29/02/2024 23:17

Of course they should have cohorted infected patients and not discharged to care homes but medics were supportive of this at the time. It’s not like there was a Tory bed manager in the hospital with a clipboard. Doctors were eagerly ushering people out the door including in the non Tory devolved nations. You forget, we thought there was going to be a massive influx and we would need every bed. Government and clinical staff saw nursing home patients as expendable. The brutal truth is many nursing home residents do have short life expectancy but not all. Basic medical care such as oral antibiotics weren’t given in many cases because it was assumed people were dying of covid but many died of pneumonia or plain old neglect.

The tories are an incompetent disaster but you’re kidding yourself if you think Labour would have been any better. They didn’t fail because they were too ideologically right wing but because they were too blinded by preheld beliefs and fallacies to assess the situation and lacked the bravery for difficult decisions.

Basically we fucked up badly and no one quite wants to admit it yet. Lots of people died because of it, some were harmed badly and most of of will live worse lives. It’s countless times worse than if we had just ignored the novel virus, incalculable damage. We overreacted when we should have kept our cool, then we made it worse with bad decisions time and time again. We need a good hard look at our media, at the quality of our so called scientific institutions and whether we care more about material reality or more political point scoring.