Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Homemade gifts, your real thoughts.

113 replies

Itsmychristmasdress · 20/02/2024 21:26

I am making a picture for a friend for her birthday.
It's not professional looking at all. It's obvious it's home made should I just buy something instead?
Are home made gifts really shit?
Honestly?
Yabu. Yes shit. Buy something instead.
Yanbu. The thought always counts even if the finished product is not amazing.

OP posts:
Punxsatawnyphil · 20/02/2024 23:02

Depends on what it is. I've had some beautiful etsy type personalised scrabble art from SIL.
I have been creative with some of my Grandparent gifts, homemade family tree etc.
I love things that has thought put into it even if it's not my taste.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 20/02/2024 23:01

I love a homemade gift, and I don't think I've ever been given a bad one. My friends are not manky people, and I don't worry about their kitchens.
Even if the gift isn't something I would choose, I still love it.

i don't give homemade gifts though, because I have no craft skills.

laret · 20/02/2024 22:57

I don't like homemade gifts - the things I've received are usually not very well made or designed. I don't like edible gifts except from family, I am always too suspicious of hygiene standards.

DH likes the look of homemade/unique items so I often buy him things from Etsy - but they are made by people who have expertise in that craft and they are usually well made, and have plenty of reviews.

BarbaricPeach · 20/02/2024 22:56

I'd always appreciate the thought behind the gift. Whether I actually want the item or not varies. Basically, would I want a shop bought version of the gift? If so, I'd love the handmade one. If not, I'd rather just have a card. So if your friend would buy 3d paper flower art, then it's a great present. If not, the thought will be appreciated but the item will be tat to store or dispose of.

My friend crocheted a blanket for my son when he was born. I absolutely love how much effort she put into it, and I love the blanket itself. A crochet blanket is a practical thing that I might have bought for my child anyway. But if she started giving me other crocheted items as presents, I'd still appreciate the thought but not the items as crochet isn't my style at all outside blankets.

Blackcats7 · 20/02/2024 22:55

I would love a homemade gift whether it was to my taste or not because I would know a friend gave me their time and effort which is priceless.

buswankerz · 20/02/2024 22:53

I love home made gifts.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 20/02/2024 22:53

I love homemade gifts and display things people have given to me (like paintings) around my house and love tbe memories.

Legendairy · 20/02/2024 22:49

To be honest it depends if its actually any good or not. Some of my friends/family paint and they are brilliant and I have a had a couple of gifts from them. I also love photo gifts, so not handmade as such but personalised.

I would feel really awkward if it wasn't good enough to display and probably would display it anyway, but only you know if that's the case.

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 20/02/2024 22:48

I've been waiting years for my friend to draw me a bloody picture. But she's very good at drawing. If she wasn't very good at drawing I wouldn't want her attempts Grin

TheChosenTwo · 20/02/2024 22:46

Generally I’d be polite about a homemade gift but unlikely that I’d use/display/eat whatever it was.
Exceptions from this are that a jewellery making friend made me some earrings that I absolutely loved, they are beautifully made and incredibly simple. Also my dds have made cushion covers which are now the cushions in the front room, no theme to them and they don’t match anything in the room let alone each other but I love that they made them as their first projects at a sewing class MIL enrolled them into when they were young teens. Have had them for years now and I still smile when I look at them.
But generally, if someone made me a piece of art (unless a young niece or nephew etc) it wouldn’t be displayed although I’d be very touched that you had gone to the effort and been very thoughtful.

PaminaMozart · 20/02/2024 22:45

I grew up with a mother who spent her days sewing, knitting, crocheting, embroidering, baking cakes etc etc - instead of spending time with me. So many Christmases I was bequeathed yet another embroidered picture, beautifully and expensively framed. For years, decades!, I hung on to these gifts, too guilty to get rid of them, even though they weren't to my taste and merely reminded me of my lonely and barren childhood.

It's nearly 20 years since she died, and I finally - finally!! - donated the last of said pictures to a charity shop. The relief is immense - and I no longer care enough to feel guilty.

StrawberrySquash · 20/02/2024 22:44

Like all gifts it's great if it's something the recipient actually likes. But if you make a million jars of marmalade and dole them out to everyone regardless of their tastes then a chunk of people won't appreciate the gift.

Sconeswithnutella · 20/02/2024 22:44

I love a homemade gift as long as it’s not edible. I don’t know the state of someone’s kitchen/ cooking abilities etc so I wouldn’t eat it.
A picture I would love!

spookehtooth · 20/02/2024 22:43

I don't think there's a generic answer, sorry. I think it's a very personal judgement about the individual receiving the gift. If you understand them well, then undoubtedly it'll be received as hoped.

If you're brave, you could invite honesty after presentation, take it on the chin and learn from it to fine tune your judgement. I do that with food, the main thing I gift randomly

Fionaville · 20/02/2024 22:41

I would absolutely love a picture that a friend had made. Honestly, I'd much prefer that to toiletries or a candle. I wish my friends made homemade gifts!
Your friend sounds like an arty person who will really appreciate it. Don't scrap it!

vincettenoir · 20/02/2024 22:37

I like homemade gifts when it's something to eat or wear or use. But I don't generally like other people giving me stuff for my home unless they are really in tune with my taste.

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 20/02/2024 22:35

I would be touched you created it for me, would probably hang it up.

There's a funny episode of King of Queens that has the dilemma of recieving a bad portrait of themselves. (I'll link to it.) Flowers are quite inoffensive, I think keep touching it up and remember artists are self critical and often think their work is crap.

Doug and Carrie Get A Hideous Portrait | The King of Queens

As an anniversary gift, Deacon and Kelly get Carrie and Doug a hideous oil painting.From Season 8 Episode 17 ‘Present Tense’. When the Heffernans receive an ...

https://youtu.be/A2ml6Bja7Mk?si=a2CzmnhajP2EV1-B

RawBloomers · 20/02/2024 22:34

I like homemade gifts that are good - I’ve had pottery, food and clothing gifts that have been homemade and absolutely fantastic. But they were all good enough to be sold at a craft fair.

Homemade gifts that look amateur hour (unless from my DC) not so much. I don’t really see how it’s the thought that counts here - it seems a fairly selfish thing to do rather than a generous thing. I have hobbies I love doing but I’m not very good at, if I made gifts for people instead of getting them something they’d actually have a use for, it’s me that gets the benefit of that, not the person I’m giving it to.

coxesorangepippin · 20/02/2024 22:30

Not my thing really

Doingmybest12 · 20/02/2024 22:27

Generally no I wouldn't like a home made gift. I think often they are about the maker and what they want, rather than the recipient. But we are all different and according to this thread lots enjoy these gifts.

Itsmychristmasdress · 20/02/2024 22:27

PriOn1 · 20/02/2024 22:21

Is it child like as in a very simple design, or as in looking as if a child might have painted it?

Hope you can understand the difference I’m getting at.

I know what you mean..the first I hope.

It could potentially be done by a child butvthe outcome would be the same, if ya get me!

OP posts:
Itsmychristmasdress · 20/02/2024 22:26

No not showing it sorry, just in case
It's a 3d flower design.

Yes it's 3d like Phoebe's awful paintings in friends 🤣

OP posts:
Tailfeather · 20/02/2024 22:22

Can we see it?

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 20/02/2024 22:21

How large is the painting? Does it represent something she wrote about?

I suppose it would be too outing to show us?

PriOn1 · 20/02/2024 22:21

Is it child like as in a very simple design, or as in looking as if a child might have painted it?

Hope you can understand the difference I’m getting at.