Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?

415 replies

Sunshineismyfavourite · 20/02/2024 21:16

Visited a beautiful NT country house today. Huge 17th century house with Capability Brown landscaped parkland. The house has lots of art by Van Dyck - one of my favourite artists and I was really looking forward to spending a couple of hours with DH wandering around in the beautiful spaces enjoying the peace and quiet. However, every time I stopped to look at a painting one of the staff would come up to me and start talking. This happened several times in every room we wandered into. I totally get the enthusiasm and expertise of the staff but I wasn't really interested in hearing about the Civil War etc., I just wanted to enjoy the paintings in peace. We do visit NT properties occasionally but have never found this to be a problem before.
The staff just seemed to be unable to read my body language as I was trying to walk away or indicate that I didn't want to talk or listen to them by not responding or engaging with them. Short of telling them to shut up it was impossible.
It was a very quiet day with not many visitors so they were probably bored but it was way too much for us.
AIBU by being a miserable bugger (I know I'm quite unsociable at times) or should I be allowed to wander round in peace? Perhaps they should give out 'don't talk to me' badges with the tickets if you want to be left in peace!

OP posts:
Herdinggoats · 21/02/2024 20:02

“next room was a brilliant man who said “I can tell you stuff or I can leave you to browse” and we said “just browsing thanks!” “

this man sounds absolutely perfect!

TuxedoCatsRule · 21/02/2024 19:59

I have been enjoying this thread and don’t know whether to side with Team OP or the poor enthusiastic-but-restrained volunteers or the jaded volunteer trainers!

A recent visit to a non NT house recently showcased the full gamut mentioned in the thread - the woman on the desk said in a voice laden with meaning that she had “lots of volunteers in today, at least one in every room!” First room there was a visitor being held prisoner by a keen volunteer so we enjoyed that room quietly. Next room we were pursued from end to end by a keen chap but it meant we couldn’t show each other anything interesting without him joining in or asking poor DS questions.

next room was a brilliant man who said “I can tell you stuff or I can leave you to browse” and we said “just browsing thanks!”

following room a woman who was also brilliant and said I just have to show you this one thing (very cool, we would not have seen it otherwise)

then a woman who knew absolutely nothing and kept saying that my husband would know because he was a man and finally a very young girl who loitered like a ghost and added atmosphere if nothing else. It was quite the range and I felt sorry for the volunteer manager really.

SarahAndQuack · 21/02/2024 19:48

BaroqueInterlude · 21/02/2024 17:59

Fine if you are and he is, but you risk an awkward moment if you're lying and the guide enthusiastically asks you what your favourite works are from the artist's 'yellow period' 😁

I will tell you it doesn't make a blind bit of difference anyway.

I'm a medievalist; I know quite a bit about history. Every now and again I have been irritated enough to say I'm a medievalist, or that I teach history. Almost invariably volunteers simply steam on with their explanation.

Caffeineislife · 21/02/2024 19:38

It's obvious from this thread that there are a variety of thoughts on volunteers. As someone said up thread there are all sorts of ways to engage visitors.

However, there is an audience (quite a sizeable and vocal one at that) for what many on this thread find overbearing. Just after Covid many of our volunteers were shielding and nervous about coming back to volunteer (especially inside), so the room stewards/ guides were somewhat stripped back. The comment cards and emails were full of disappointment and wishes for the volunteers back. Whilst some of MN would rather not have the level of interaction there is a vocal group who love it. Certain bus tour groups love the interaction. Plenty of visitors also respond well to it and it is often fed back as hugely positive in the comment cards which is what management use to inform training and volunteer use.

On the idea of a badge scheme, I can assure you even if such a system was brought in some of the most overbearing will ignore it anyway.

No matter how much training we give, volunteers are unpaid and volunteer their time. We can train and guide but if they wish to ignore it, they will and there is little we can really do. No-one wants to say they cannot volunteer there anymore due to them been overbearing or a bit of a bore. I've been part of the training group when we acquired a military museum as part of our group. It had previously been independent and run entirely by volunteers (all old servicemen in the armed forces). The comment cards were not kind, our department was asked to investigate and help them with their tours. We first went to see what was going on. Well, tours were advertised as 40 minutes long and as an overview of certain exhibitions (aircraft, tank, a couple of notable service people related to the site, a couple of notable medals), the reality was... The shortest tour I went on for over an hour and had great detail about the engine, cockpit layout, paintwork, the preservation process and history of every aircraft. A massive tangent about some medals that were not on the advertised tour that took about 30 minutes and then saw me, looked at his watch and finished the tour. The longest tour I went on was nearly 3 hours. Again, huge detail about every aircraft, long winded tangents about everything. It became very grandpa Simpson for a time as we heard all about his war story. There was a couple of veterans in the tour group and a good hour was spend reminiscing together. Fantastic men who did incredible things for our country but tour guides they were not. I spoke to the tour groups afterwards, there were mixed reviews. The 2 veterans had a wonderful time and absolutely loved the tour. Several loved the stories. Some really loved the knowledge and the ability to answer every question. Others found it too long and a bore fest. We went daily for a month and the feedback was so mixed. The most vocal group absolutely loved it. The less vocal ones hated it and vowed never to come back. They were lovely men, who just really wanted to share their passion and tell their stories. No matter how much rejigging, guiding them and making suggestions we made, the tours were still nearly 3 hours long as it only took a question from the group or someone in the tour group to be a veteran and the tangents began.

Same was for when they were not guiding. They stood near exhibitions and were supposed to answer any questions and interact with visitors. Again, their passion and love for their subject took over, it was very much a pouncing situation. They just loved to share their stories and were very passionate that the history was not lost. No amount of some people just want to take it in/ let people come to you could deter them.

Justpontificating · 21/02/2024 18:51

fleurneige · 21/02/2024 18:20

I am 58 and have a passion for history, and I enjoy NT Houses so much, I intend to volunteer when the time comes. Or do you think retired people should go straight into a care home and stop living.

Yes, I do hope I would read people's reactions and know how to leave them alone. And would expect to politely tell me that they would rather be left to visit without expert information, rather than be passive aggressive or just unpleasant.

Some time ago a MN suggested a building and level of care, money available etc to something akin to a workhouse for the retired 😳🤯

fleurneige · 21/02/2024 18:20

I am 58 and have a passion for history, and I enjoy NT Houses so much, I intend to volunteer when the time comes. Or do you think retired people should go straight into a care home and stop living.

Yes, I do hope I would read people's reactions and know how to leave them alone. And would expect to politely tell me that they would rather be left to visit without expert information, rather than be passive aggressive or just unpleasant.

BaroqueInterlude · 21/02/2024 17:59

mydamnfootstuckinthedoor · 21/02/2024 17:56

"Ah yes indeed, I am an art historian and this particular artist is my specialist field ... "

Fine if you are and he is, but you risk an awkward moment if you're lying and the guide enthusiastically asks you what your favourite works are from the artist's 'yellow period' 😁

mydamnfootstuckinthedoor · 21/02/2024 17:56

"Ah yes indeed, I am an art historian and this particular artist is my specialist field ... "

rainbegone · 21/02/2024 17:50

Wbeezer · 20/02/2024 21:21

I had this happen recently, I ended up leaving polite DH to listen while I scurried off. It's my job to read all the labels and then tell DH all the interesting facts I've discovered, if someone else does it it spoils my fun!

This is my job too! Grin

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 21/02/2024 17:46

Best NT volunteer ever . We had a great conversation.

National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?
National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?
Justpontificating · 21/02/2024 17:35

cookingwithabigail · 21/02/2024 15:47

Yes we did have an EH membership when the kids were younger. They're adults now. They used to buy the little wooden swords in the gift shop then charge around fighting everything 😂

You’ve brought back some fond memories there ! 😀

YouOKHun · 21/02/2024 17:20

@calicogoose If the NT had to put a trigger warning on everything with an iffy provenance they’d be in trouble. If they had to pack those things away there’d be nothing to see in certain houses (unfortunately).

WhatnowMrs · 21/02/2024 17:13

Maybe they’re trying to covertly checking us out in case we’re Just Stop Oil protesters or some such about to launch an assault on something?

MuseumAssistant · 21/02/2024 17:04

UniqueReader · 21/02/2024 00:25

No it's not a silly over reaction. Giving constructive criticism directly to the venue is absolutely reasonable if you are not happy with part of you experience but that was clearly not the type of comment I was objecting too...

Ok, when I said it was an overreaction, I was assuming your mother didn't fit the description of the sort of volunteers people are complaining about.

If you think she does, then yes, feeding back to the venue is the best thing to do.

They can't retrain volunteers if they don't realise there's a problem.

calicogoose · 21/02/2024 16:53

I was grateful for the intervention of a volunteer at a National Trust property in Oxfordshire. We saw a painting ( not at all good ) of an eighteenth century family connected with the property. I was touched to see a black child amongst the white children and thought they must be a family member or adopted into the family. I mentioned it to a volunteer and she explained the child represented slave plantations in the West Indies. I was shocked and asked why it was on display or why there was no clear explanation and warning to the symbolism in the horrible painting. The NT manager was so sneery about my concerns. It put me right off the National Trust.

fleurneige · 21/02/2024 16:49

Haydenn · 21/02/2024 10:09

It is not ageist to recognise that the majority of National Trust volunteers are of retirement age. It is something that the national trust itself has long acknowledged, as well as their continued struggle to attract younger volunteers.

It is also not ageist to recognise that the reason many volunteers enjoy the role is because when they are retired volunteering provides weeks with structure, interest and opportunities for social interaction.

Doesn't mean they are bored old foggies though!

SweetBirdsong · 21/02/2024 16:29

@cookingwithabigail · Today 14:54

The visitors don't owe you an audience though. They've paid and will visit in the way they choose to. I don't care about facts either. I don't collect them and I'm not usually that interested in the intricate history of a place. I just want to look at things, relax, enjoy the atmosphere. I couldn't care less about what happened in such and such a room in 1758 and what battle took place in the area etc. It's just a trip out to get out of the house to be honest.

Being talked at and forced to engage in unwanted interaction can be really uncomfortable and difficult for some people. Are these people supposed to be excluded from visiting these places? Even introverts, autists, the depressed, the bereaved and the disinterested are allowed to go on trips too you know.

I agree that the badge idea is great.

Yeah this. ^

Maybe not with FUCK OFF on it though 😆 (tempting as it is!!!)

Maybe a 'code colour'... Like if you don't want anyone approaching you, you were a red circle badge. If you DO want to interact, wear a green circle badge. The size of a 2p piece. Make it a little sticky label. That would do.

@historygeek12

I am a guide in a historic house privately owned not NT and when people come into a room I say morning/afternoon and then I just say please let me know if you have any questions and then leave it up to them , some people love to chat and others just prefer to absorb the history themselves!

Perfect! That sounds ideal. And you sound nice. 😃

And of course, some volunteers are just like you, but it's the ones who are a bit pushy and chatty that people are a bit irked with.

Uricon2 · 21/02/2024 16:22

Aethelthryth · 21/02/2024 09:38

I have found this problem even worse in non-NT houses, still owned by the family, because the unwanted information about basic history comes with an extra dollop of Uriah-Heeping about His Lordship and when the volunteer was last talking to Her Ladyship, coupled with additional family + royalty photos on the piano. Hatfield House was particularly dreadful: we would have liked to stay longer and look more carefully but ended up fleeing from room to room to escape the volunteers. The best volunteers say "Hello, do let me know if you have any questions" then just shut up.

Seen this in action. On one occasion smiley older gent ran up the stairs past the tour group, no one had any idea who he was but the guide (having greeted him and literally bowed with his "Good morning my Lord") then spent some time regaling us with his life history from birth.

At one of the Royal houses, I actually had a room guide stomp off in a huff because I was insufficiently enraptured by one of the late Queen Mother's interior design ideas, even though I'd said clearly "their house their rooolz" (or words to that effect) You'd have thought I'd committed high treason.

SpamhappyTootsie · 21/02/2024 16:19

LaraMargot · 21/02/2024 15:30

We went to the Auckland project and ended up discussing Spanish art with Jonathan Ruffer who endowed it with £160 million. I wasn't going to tell him to bugger off.

Oh you lucky thing! That was the place I mentioned upthread, where we took turns to squelch round and take in as much as we could in half an hour. Such a fantastic place and the guides certainly seem to know their stuff, even when they aren’t the owner. I did have a lovely chat about Frosterley Marble and the other places I’ve seen it. We’ve plans to go there again and take longer to take in everything.

TeamKronos · 21/02/2024 15:56

An alternate problem... I was at the Royal Academy of Arts recently and asked a member of staff if they knew anything about the work on display in the room they were standing in. I had some questions about it. They said shortly, "No," and that was it, no further interaction, no suggestion where I might find information, no advice to ask another member of staff who might know anything about the work I'd paid to see.

Creatureofhabit87 · 21/02/2024 15:52

Sounds like when you walk into Lush and immediately want to leave!!

YouOKHun · 21/02/2024 15:51

Generally I’ve found that I’m left alone at NT properties (and other similar non-NT historic houses and the overbearing guides are rare, of course they’re the ones that stick in the mind. I’m not keen on lazy generalisations about ageing, it equalling loneliness or loneliness itself being presented as some sort of character flaw. Why are any of us in the roles we are in, paid or otherwise? Probably for a variety of reasons.

Most guides just say “let me know if you have questions” and I think that’s enough. More than that every time you cross the threshold of another room gets a bit much. As mentioned by a PP, the more “problematic” guides generally appear at your side with an open question or statement about the room/house/contents rather than asking if you have any questions and this makes it more difficult to extract yourself from a conversation that has already started, without being rude. In those situations I usually respond with “how interesting, I’ll definitely come and find you IF I have further questions, thank you”, said with a smile and as stepping away. This is both definite and affirms the other person as having valuable information, because I don’t want to be rude, abrupt or unkind. It’s perfectly possible to close down a conversation without being rude.

I have chronically low frustration tolerance and an even lower boredom threshold so I often find I don’t stop long enough in many of the rooms anyway. I’m then kicking my heels next to the lavender bags and tartan rugs in the NT gift shop while my DH is still in the first room doing a forensic examination of a bit of carpet or a Meissen jug. You’re best off slipping into the room behind my DH while he keeps the guide talking ;)

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 21/02/2024 15:51

cookingwithabigail · 21/02/2024 15:16

Sometimes I just go somewhere because they have nice trees and I like the scones in the coffee shop 😂

I always found the English Heritage places were more relaxing to visit. The NT always seemed like they were just tolerating visitors and were convinced you were going to end up misbehaving in some way so needed constant supervision whilst there.

English Heritage sites typically have less stuff to break.

I once spent a morning at the entrance to an EH castle as my group was doing an event inside and they wanted one of us out the front to help tell visitors what to expect. All morning there was an EH staff member doing a massive hard sell on membership on every single person that came in. I felt sorry for her training for a career in heritage only to end up like a glorified double glazing salesman but even more sorry for the visitors who had to get past her to get in. I have never experienced quite such a hard sell with National Trust.

cookingwithabigail · 21/02/2024 15:47

Justpontificating · 21/02/2024 15:33

We re the opposite.
We find NT more relaxing as there are less kids. EngHeritage have more castles and kiddy events. NT more old houses. So the former attract more kids. We went to EH when boys were young but quickly moved on to NT for a bit of peace, quiet and less fake staging.
If you’ve got young kids then yes EH more relaxing because there are lots of other kids around I suppose.

Yes we did have an EH membership when the kids were younger. They're adults now. They used to buy the little wooden swords in the gift shop then charge around fighting everything 😂

Silverbirchtwo · 21/02/2024 15:38

They never talk to me, I have to go up to them and do the excuse me could you tell me...

I must not look like an NT sort of person.