Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?

415 replies

Sunshineismyfavourite · 20/02/2024 21:16

Visited a beautiful NT country house today. Huge 17th century house with Capability Brown landscaped parkland. The house has lots of art by Van Dyck - one of my favourite artists and I was really looking forward to spending a couple of hours with DH wandering around in the beautiful spaces enjoying the peace and quiet. However, every time I stopped to look at a painting one of the staff would come up to me and start talking. This happened several times in every room we wandered into. I totally get the enthusiasm and expertise of the staff but I wasn't really interested in hearing about the Civil War etc., I just wanted to enjoy the paintings in peace. We do visit NT properties occasionally but have never found this to be a problem before.
The staff just seemed to be unable to read my body language as I was trying to walk away or indicate that I didn't want to talk or listen to them by not responding or engaging with them. Short of telling them to shut up it was impossible.
It was a very quiet day with not many visitors so they were probably bored but it was way too much for us.
AIBU by being a miserable bugger (I know I'm quite unsociable at times) or should I be allowed to wander round in peace? Perhaps they should give out 'don't talk to me' badges with the tickets if you want to be left in peace!

OP posts:
cookingwithabigail · 23/02/2024 12:19

GoodOldEmmaNess · 23/02/2024 08:05

One amazing house (Lyme Park in Cheshire) had had stuff taken out of some of the rooms to make room for squashy modern sofas, bean bags and toys. I don't pay the whacking charges to visit a toddler group!

Yes, I feel the same about the way in which National Trust properties so often seem like ultra middle class baby and toddler facilities. It's not the children that are the problem but the various odd ways in which they are pandered to. Most of the so called learning activities seem dire and joyless. When kids are wheedled into participating in them I just feel they are destined to be disappointed and put-off of history for life.
It's all so over-processed. When I was little we were just left alone to look at the same stuff as the adults in peace. And there was usually Just One Thing that captured kids' imagination on its own, without adults pushing it at them.
For example, in Raby Castle (not NT but the general point still applies) there was a rug that was the dead hide of the favourite spaniel of the lady of the house. I looked for it last time I was there and the room guide said it had been taken away as "some children found it upsetting".🙄

Aw, I loved the spaniel rug. Me and dh spent the rest of the day discussing having one made out of each of our pet cats when they passed away and what would visitors make of it 😂

Kittensat36 · 23/02/2024 12:15

Trinity65 · 22/02/2024 20:59

He sounds insufferable

Seeing as this thread is about guides waffling on, I thought it might be faintly amusing for posters to hear about the boot being on the other foot.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 23/02/2024 09:46

calicogoose · 21/02/2024 16:53

I was grateful for the intervention of a volunteer at a National Trust property in Oxfordshire. We saw a painting ( not at all good ) of an eighteenth century family connected with the property. I was touched to see a black child amongst the white children and thought they must be a family member or adopted into the family. I mentioned it to a volunteer and she explained the child represented slave plantations in the West Indies. I was shocked and asked why it was on display or why there was no clear explanation and warning to the symbolism in the horrible painting. The NT manager was so sneery about my concerns. It put me right off the National Trust.

Was that a few years ago? I think the heritage organisations have worked hard more recently to include/re-write a lot of the history of properties to ensure that the life stories of the non-royal/non-wealthy/non-white/non-male population are told.

Sennelier1 · 23/02/2024 09:37

You could've politely asked them to leave you to your own experience? "Thank you but I know the history, would just like to enjoy the paintings on my own in peace"?

bellocchild · 23/02/2024 09:34

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 23/02/2024 08:20

Well, for a start I can decide for myself what makes my visit 'meaningful,' I don't need to be talked at for that; and what might be meaningful to you isn't necessarily what's meaningful to me.

English Heritage are as bad. A friend and I went to Osterley and the only way to end the lecture was walking away - and even then one guide followed us into another room talking. Just let me look at stuff, thanks.

As I said, it's not the guides, it's the management! We even get special compulsory online courses on things like this. Where I work, we try to include the details which aren't in the books - but we leave the 'just lookings' alone.

OCDmama · 23/02/2024 08:54

I agree, it really puts me off NT places. If I want information I will ask or find it myself.

I work in the sector and we also have room stewards. We do a LOT of training to avoid the NT problem, and also keep an ear open.

There's also the problem of NT volunteers frequently getting things wrong or embellishing. I worked a project at Attingham and every time the volunteer came through with a tour group she kept changing who the portraits were of - a portrait was the owner's first wife, second wife or mistress.

babybythesea · 23/02/2024 08:37

EnidSpyton · 21/02/2024 00:21

Why are adults telling other adults to 'use their words' on this thread? Why are women infantilising other women? Bizarre behaviour.

In answer to the OP, I completely understand and it is so difficult to extricate yourself when someone is in full flow - it IS rude to stop someone talking and not as easy to do as people claim. NT volunteers do need to be better trained but at the same time there's something lovely about people wanting to share their passion, isn't there? You don't want to curb volunteers' enthusiasm, but striking a balance in their interactions with visitors is vital so as not to irritate and actually detract from someone's experience. It's a fine art and I'm not sure it's something you can actually teach, as it relies on the ability to read people.

I'm a frequent NT visitor and when I'm bored of listening to someone telling me about a piece of tapestry I'm not interested in or whatever, as soon as there's a pause in their flow of information, I say 'You're so knowledgeable, I could listen to you all day, but I'm afraid I've only got half an hour and want to make sure I see as much as I can, so I'll have to move on now. Thanks so much' - and walk away briskly. Works every time and no one's feelings are hurt in the process.

The problem with many volunteers is the assumption that you don't know anything about the place you're visiting or the period of history it represents, which I find bizarre when you'd surely operate from the perspective of expecting the people who visit to have an interest in the place/period of history to start off with, otherwise they wouldn't be there. The best tour I've ever had in a heritage attraction was at Cardiff Castle, where the lovely tour guide asked us all what we already knew and what we wanted to know more about before we started. I said to him how rare this was and he told me he'd been humiliated when he first started by lecturing a man about a particular battle or something, and then the man, much embarrassed, had to reveal to him that he was actually the world's leading expert on that battle and was a Professor at Harvard, on holiday. From then on, the volunteer said he always checked first before he started sharing information. I think all NT volunteers need to be told that story as a cautionary tale - ask first!

Edited

I’ve done similar as a very enthusiastic young person in my first job at a zoo. I had to give talks. There was a lady at one talk who came up at the end and asked a specific question about our animals and I answered but then went wider because I loved talking and gave her some ‘back to basics’ information about the species in general. She smiled along. Then my boss showed up and introduced her. Leading expert on the species. I’d read several scientific papers and two books by her. I was split between hero worship and mortification. I learnt a lesson that day and was careful not to go beyond what I’d been asked, and to double check background knowledge rather than making assumptions.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 23/02/2024 08:20

bellocchild · 22/02/2024 20:14

We guides do get encouraged to 'Make Visits Meaningful'.

Well, for a start I can decide for myself what makes my visit 'meaningful,' I don't need to be talked at for that; and what might be meaningful to you isn't necessarily what's meaningful to me.

English Heritage are as bad. A friend and I went to Osterley and the only way to end the lecture was walking away - and even then one guide followed us into another room talking. Just let me look at stuff, thanks.

BaroqueInterlude · 23/02/2024 08:17

I asked her stop while I was trying to check in and she told be she wasn’t allowed to. that they had to talk to everyone checking in. She was going over (I think) some of the terms and conditions.

I should imagine in a theme park they are covering themselves against possible complaints/claims so they don't get sued if someone drops their I-phone 15 pro from the top of a rollercoaster.

Trapunt0 · 23/02/2024 08:11

They are usually volunteers not staff so therefore probably also enthusiasts giving up time for this.
I'm a quiet watcher myself so know what you mean but knowing they are not staff does give a different light on it

GoodOldEmmaNess · 23/02/2024 08:05

One amazing house (Lyme Park in Cheshire) had had stuff taken out of some of the rooms to make room for squashy modern sofas, bean bags and toys. I don't pay the whacking charges to visit a toddler group!

Yes, I feel the same about the way in which National Trust properties so often seem like ultra middle class baby and toddler facilities. It's not the children that are the problem but the various odd ways in which they are pandered to. Most of the so called learning activities seem dire and joyless. When kids are wheedled into participating in them I just feel they are destined to be disappointed and put-off of history for life.
It's all so over-processed. When I was little we were just left alone to look at the same stuff as the adults in peace. And there was usually Just One Thing that captured kids' imagination on its own, without adults pushing it at them.
For example, in Raby Castle (not NT but the general point still applies) there was a rug that was the dead hide of the favourite spaniel of the lady of the house. I looked for it last time I was there and the room guide said it had been taken away as "some children found it upsetting".🙄

EmeraldA129 · 23/02/2024 04:06

Is NT the only organisation in the country that isn’t struggling to recruit & is over staffed?

YANBU op, they should know to observe customers & interact where this is wanted

CelestiaNoctis · 23/02/2024 01:17

They should have badges or stickers. One that indicates you're happy to be approached with more information and one that indicates you'd like quiet enjoyment alone. I'd leave a review with that suggestion and your experience.

WigglyVonWaggly · 22/02/2024 22:45

A foreign accent, a baffled smile and ‘no understand’ will get rid of them next time 😁

cookingwithabigail · 22/02/2024 22:42

MamaLazerou · 22/02/2024 21:09

Learn the phrase “I don’t speak English” in a really obscure language.

Even if they then start talking to you in said language look at them like you cannot understand them.

😂😂😂

MamaLazerou · 22/02/2024 21:09

Learn the phrase “I don’t speak English” in a really obscure language.

Even if they then start talking to you in said language look at them like you cannot understand them.

RawBloomers · 22/02/2024 21:08

fleurneige · 22/02/2024 13:29

Fair enough- but wouldn't you be interested in the history of wallpaper making and the old processes? Fascinating indeed. Most people have NO idea about how wallpaper used to be designed and especially, printed, and just how intricate and complicated and very time consuming. And how colours were obtained.

I like to look while I’m there, if I’m enamoured by something I can read up on how it used to be made or what the significance of different aspects were. At a later date I might go back and look again, knowing some of the stuff I read up about and, on seeing it again, forming questions that I might ask of a room guide.

So I might be fascinated by the history of wallpaper making, but not while I’m trying to look at the design and, especially, not orally. I cannot concentrate on two very different things at once like that. The talking would distract me from looking at the design and I wouldn’t take in the history properly either.

In a similar but very tangential fashion, I stayed at the Alton Towers resort a few years ago. They had kiosks for you to self-check in at, but as soon as you started a staff person came up and started talking to you telling you a bunch of stuff. It was incredibly distracting so I asked her stop while I was trying to check in and she told be she wasn’t allowed to. that they had to talk to everyone checking in. She was going over (I think) some of the terms and conditions. It was one of the worst check in experiences I’ve every had (and I’ve stayed at some crummy places!).

Trinity65 · 22/02/2024 20:59

Kittensat36 · 21/02/2024 07:46

I mostly visit these places with a friend whose knowledge of history, architecture and art is pretty spectacular. Many's the time I have doubled back to find him talking the volunteer into submission.

He sounds insufferable

bellocchild · 22/02/2024 20:14

We guides do get encouraged to 'Make Visits Meaningful'.

Greenly3 · 22/02/2024 19:41

I too visited 3 properties recently and
found the same thing happened. it is tough if you want to walk round undisturbed as it is something that I agree,body language should tell you if you want to engage or not. I understand you would feel rude saying please leave me alone. I really don’t know what the solution is. My friends and I had a lovely encounter with a guide in the drawing room of the house we visited. I get tired easily and asked if I could sit in one of the chairs . She was lovely and said I am sorry we don’t serve tea or coffee , you would enjoy one sat in that chair. It was a lovely moment.

BaroqueInterlude · 22/02/2024 18:50

Fionaville · 21/02/2024 21:30

I must be in the minority, but I actually love it when the room attendants/museum staff give a little talk on things. I linger anyway and just keep looking at the room/painting/artifact, until I'm satisfied. If I didn't want to hear it I'd say the same thing I say to shop assistants "I'm just looking, thanks"

Yes, I do too. I've often spent time afterwards online researching people they've mentioned who sound interesting, so it really does add value for me.

Pliudev · 22/02/2024 18:37

I thought this might be about something else. My husband was asked to attend an open day for teachers at a NT house eager to encourage more school visits. Unfortunately, as he was showing parties of teachers around, bossy voices kept interrupting by issuing loud instructions such as YOU CAN'T STOP THERE or NOT THAT WAY. He's a poet but couldn't get a word in edgeways.
I think some volunteers are a little over invested in their role and like to feel important.
Or they might have been trying to put off the school parties.

Sunshineismyfavourite · 22/02/2024 18:17

Wow wasn't expecting so many responses and interesting (and some not so interesting) posts!
Yes I'm grumpy at times, I'm also over 55 myself, and British as someone said! I also really enjoy feeling and being connected to people but preferably where and when I feel comfortable to do so, forced conversation with a stranger is rarely a pleasure.
I rather wish my DH had cracked his joke after our third interruption (though I said he'd better not) - he wanted to say he really enjoyed Van Dyck in Mary Poppins. Perhaps I should have let him use his words ...

OP posts:
Fanofbrianbilston · 22/02/2024 18:00

Start talking about colonialism/imperialism/the enclosures act and they soon leave you to it 😆 not many of the volunteers are educated about the links with the properties and slavery although occasionally they do have a ‘push’ on those topics.

Snowinsummer · 22/02/2024 17:54

I think you were probably just having a bad day. Next time either wear headphones (they don’t need to be on) or just smile & tell them that you’d prefer to absorb the atmosphere yourself & will ask if you have any questions.