Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?

415 replies

Sunshineismyfavourite · 20/02/2024 21:16

Visited a beautiful NT country house today. Huge 17th century house with Capability Brown landscaped parkland. The house has lots of art by Van Dyck - one of my favourite artists and I was really looking forward to spending a couple of hours with DH wandering around in the beautiful spaces enjoying the peace and quiet. However, every time I stopped to look at a painting one of the staff would come up to me and start talking. This happened several times in every room we wandered into. I totally get the enthusiasm and expertise of the staff but I wasn't really interested in hearing about the Civil War etc., I just wanted to enjoy the paintings in peace. We do visit NT properties occasionally but have never found this to be a problem before.
The staff just seemed to be unable to read my body language as I was trying to walk away or indicate that I didn't want to talk or listen to them by not responding or engaging with them. Short of telling them to shut up it was impossible.
It was a very quiet day with not many visitors so they were probably bored but it was way too much for us.
AIBU by being a miserable bugger (I know I'm quite unsociable at times) or should I be allowed to wander round in peace? Perhaps they should give out 'don't talk to me' badges with the tickets if you want to be left in peace!

OP posts:
RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 11:01

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:42

You are suggesting that this practice as you see it puts off a black person from going? You believe that the black population is knowledgable about this as a group and so will not go? Is it maybe that they like many white sectors of the population are just not interested in that kind of thing? Is it an age thing eg what 18 year old really is interested in this? Is it a poverty thing? Who can afford a NT entrance fee which can be steep? No - it always has to come back to racism doesn't it?

No. And that is a bizarre extrapolation, saying a lot more about your knee jerk reaction to the idea of change than the words I wrote.

I’m suggesting the previous poster was indicating that the perspective of Black people was not considered.

Though this wasn’t a part of my response, personally I think the effect of that lack of perspective is that we all get a narrower and less informative experience.

In terms of Black participation in NT, all the things that fail to attract White people probably fail to attract Black people too. But it will remain even less relevant and even less enticing to them if their perspective is routinely ignored.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:54

Of course you can @calicogoose. The NT has millions of items in its collection and it is a long job to cover all of these with eg Lavender Labels , other labels to explain this and that. It is a fine line between leaving people to appreciate something without total over explanation. On the other hand maybe this is needed because of falling education standards.

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 10:48

Back to the OP, it was a volunteer who explained the symbolism in the painting. The NT link explains the official line on the painting with its reference to an unidentified attendant.

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 10:45

The great majority of posts on MN are based on posters experiences.
Based on my experience many museums and galleries are more successful in recognising diversity, explaining the provenance of historical items and paintings than the National Trust.
This is my experience and I have the right to express my views.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:44

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 10:41

There are relatively few visitors of colour to National Trust properties. I know that the National Trust has had a target of increasing membership from ethnic minority groups. Ditto from families.
If you visit any NT property there is not diversity in terms of visitors. Compare this to the National Gallery, the Tate Galleries and other London Galleries and Museums which make a big effort to be inclusive.
On the day I visited Upton Park there was only one person off-colour there at the same time as I was there. It is a snapshot but a revealing snapshot. I visited the Tate yesterday and it was completely different in terms of diversity. I believe that the Tate offers a more inclusive experience.
These are my experiences based in my visits. I was aggressively told that there was no need to highlight links with slavery because to quote the poster it is 'bleeding obvious' and yet the National Trust link to the work of art still continues to suggest that the black child is an unidentified attendant. So not 'bleeding obvious' to National Trust curators.

Well the obvious thing is that of course URBAN museums will attract more people of colour - they are accessible to start with. Many of them are also free.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:42

RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 01:01

I assumed it was a point about the lack of a Black perspective informing NT practices.

You are suggesting that this practice as you see it puts off a black person from going? You believe that the black population is knowledgable about this as a group and so will not go? Is it maybe that they like many white sectors of the population are just not interested in that kind of thing? Is it an age thing eg what 18 year old really is interested in this? Is it a poverty thing? Who can afford a NT entrance fee which can be steep? No - it always has to come back to racism doesn't it?

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 10:41

There are relatively few visitors of colour to National Trust properties. I know that the National Trust has had a target of increasing membership from ethnic minority groups. Ditto from families.
If you visit any NT property there is not diversity in terms of visitors. Compare this to the National Gallery, the Tate Galleries and other London Galleries and Museums which make a big effort to be inclusive.
On the day I visited Upton Park there was only one person off-colour there at the same time as I was there. It is a snapshot but a revealing snapshot. I visited the Tate yesterday and it was completely different in terms of diversity. I believe that the Tate offers a more inclusive experience.
These are my experiences based in my visits. I was aggressively told that there was no need to highlight links with slavery because to quote the poster it is 'bleeding obvious' and yet the National Trust link to the work of art still continues to suggest that the black child is an unidentified attendant. So not 'bleeding obvious' to National Trust curators.

Cherrysoup · 24/02/2024 10:30

ThinWomansBrain · 20/02/2024 23:54

That's brilliant! Maybe I should put this quotation on a sweatshirt and wear it on every NT visit!

Bad idea, the print would be so tiny, the letchy ones would be peering at your chest for hours😂
One of these maybe

Or my t-shirt that says ‘Shh, no-one cares’.

I would not leg it or leave early, I’d just politely say that I wanted to look round quietly. I don’t understand these people who don’t just say!

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:18

@calicogoose I asked you and you did not answer. Can you explain as I am curious about your thinking.

What is the point you are making about the fact that there was only one person of colour looking around the property? The painting put them off ? It is a thing that people of colour do not enjoy doing? Can you explain?

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:17

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 09:11

London Galleries and Museums ( and other urban galleries I imagine) are really careful to identify and explain links to slavery. I was taken with a beautiful image of a small black child in a painting by Gabriel Rossetti at the recent Rossetti Exhibition. However, signage explained that the child was 'owned' by a white man who was paid for the child to sit for the painting. It gives a different perspective on a Victorian family, largely seen as reforming.
It is important in my view to explain the background to an unidentified child in the painting. The painting of the Smith Family is rubbish. It is not from scratch but had the family faces imposed on the top of an existing painting. Again, without the knowledge of a volunteer, I might not have noticed this.
@EnidSpyton you write that visitors should be aware of ' the bleeding obvious'. The demographic of NT membership is old. Most visitors would not be aware of the provenance of the painting. It is disingenuous to use this as an excuse for NT properties to gloss over uncomfortable issues.

What an ageist post. Appalling.

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 09:11

London Galleries and Museums ( and other urban galleries I imagine) are really careful to identify and explain links to slavery. I was taken with a beautiful image of a small black child in a painting by Gabriel Rossetti at the recent Rossetti Exhibition. However, signage explained that the child was 'owned' by a white man who was paid for the child to sit for the painting. It gives a different perspective on a Victorian family, largely seen as reforming.
It is important in my view to explain the background to an unidentified child in the painting. The painting of the Smith Family is rubbish. It is not from scratch but had the family faces imposed on the top of an existing painting. Again, without the knowledge of a volunteer, I might not have noticed this.
@EnidSpyton you write that visitors should be aware of ' the bleeding obvious'. The demographic of NT membership is old. Most visitors would not be aware of the provenance of the painting. It is disingenuous to use this as an excuse for NT properties to gloss over uncomfortable issues.

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 08:54

@EnidSpyton
If you follow the NT link it suggests that the black child is an unidentified attendant. I think most visitors would have assumed that to be the case. It was a volunteer who told me that the child was a symbol of the family's wealth and represented owning slave plantations.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 24/02/2024 08:15

louderthan · 24/02/2024 01:25

Having worked in the heritage sector I would put money on this being some sort of misguided directive from on high; that all visitors have to be approached in a certain time frame because customer service/engagement/widening participation etc etc.
Definitely worth feeding back to site managers or on social media etc. I'd imagine that lots of the staff/volunteers aren't that happy with it either.

But approaching doesn’t mean you have to bang on at them.
I think you are right though that it is a consequence of training and direction from above because while it’s not unique it NT places it’s particularly bad at those ime. The worst thing about the trust is how very centralised it is.

louderthan · 24/02/2024 01:25

Having worked in the heritage sector I would put money on this being some sort of misguided directive from on high; that all visitors have to be approached in a certain time frame because customer service/engagement/widening participation etc etc.
Definitely worth feeding back to site managers or on social media etc. I'd imagine that lots of the staff/volunteers aren't that happy with it either.

RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 01:01

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 23/02/2024 23:41

What is the point you are making about the fact that there was only one person of colour looking around the property? The painting put them off ? It is a thing that people of colour do not enjoy doing? Can you explain?

I assumed it was a point about the lack of a Black perspective informing NT practices.

RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 01:00

EnidSpyton · 23/02/2024 23:34

I'm sorry, but I should think most people are able to look at a portrait of a British family in the 18thc with a Black person in it and work out that probably that Black person symbolises a connection to slavery.

Britain having been involved in the slave trade in the past is not a secret. It's a widely known fact. It has formed the history of many of our towns, cities and cultural and historical institutions. We can't pretend it didn't exist and having evidence of it on display enables us to confront and explore our collective history as a nation.

The NT has actually done a sterling job in many of its properties in recent years to highlight the more troubling episodes in their histories and tell hidden stories of underrepresented people. That being said, I don't think we should really need infantilising signs next to everything to inform us of the bleeding obvious.

I think, given the utter lack of attention to the subject that most people had at school, that you are incorrect in your assumption that most people would know without it being spelt out. They’d be more likely to think it was in keeping with recent casting in historical dramas that has tried to integrate people of colour into the narrative in positive ways, either through colour blind casting or by providing a backstory in keeping (though often sanitized) with the times.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 23/02/2024 23:41

calicogoose · 23/02/2024 19:21

@socialdilemmawhattodo
The NT property was Upton Park, the painting was the Smith Family.
It was last year. I am used to London Galleries and I was taken aback by the curator's casual attitude to the racism on display in the painting. I wrote to the National Trust about it and they simply referred me back to her.
I counted one other person of colour looking around the property.
It is a horrible painting and they need to remove it or have a special section explaining the painting's background and provenance.
I compared the management attitude unfavourably to the Rossetti Exhibition at the Tate last year which dealt sensitively with the slavery issue.
The National Trust needs to deal with the painting properly.

What is the point you are making about the fact that there was only one person of colour looking around the property? The painting put them off ? It is a thing that people of colour do not enjoy doing? Can you explain?

EnidSpyton · 23/02/2024 23:34

calicogoose · 23/02/2024 19:36

www.nationaltrustcollections.org.uk/object/446713

Here it suggests that the unidentified black child is an 'attendant'. Talking to a knowledgeable volunteer, it became clear that the child represents slave plantations.
The National Trust need to do their homework and ask for advice from a more urban gallery such as the Tate on how to deal with links to slavery in their properties.
The volunteer knew a great deal more than the paid curator.

I'm sorry, but I should think most people are able to look at a portrait of a British family in the 18thc with a Black person in it and work out that probably that Black person symbolises a connection to slavery.

Britain having been involved in the slave trade in the past is not a secret. It's a widely known fact. It has formed the history of many of our towns, cities and cultural and historical institutions. We can't pretend it didn't exist and having evidence of it on display enables us to confront and explore our collective history as a nation.

The NT has actually done a sterling job in many of its properties in recent years to highlight the more troubling episodes in their histories and tell hidden stories of underrepresented people. That being said, I don't think we should really need infantilising signs next to everything to inform us of the bleeding obvious.

Justifiedcheese · 23/02/2024 23:27

Fanofbrianbilston · 22/02/2024 18:00

Start talking about colonialism/imperialism/the enclosures act and they soon leave you to it 😆 not many of the volunteers are educated about the links with the properties and slavery although occasionally they do have a ‘push’ on those topics.

Make sure it's relevant first. Had a visitor trying to be right on at a place I help with loudly opining that the creator "must have got all his money from the slave trade". He was a) a brewer from a background of woollen drapery ( all England based) b) a leading abolitionist.

calicogoose · 23/02/2024 19:36

www.nationaltrustcollections.org.uk/object/446713

Here it suggests that the unidentified black child is an 'attendant'. Talking to a knowledgeable volunteer, it became clear that the child represents slave plantations.
The National Trust need to do their homework and ask for advice from a more urban gallery such as the Tate on how to deal with links to slavery in their properties.
The volunteer knew a great deal more than the paid curator.

calicogoose · 23/02/2024 19:21

@socialdilemmawhattodo
The NT property was Upton Park, the painting was the Smith Family.
It was last year. I am used to London Galleries and I was taken aback by the curator's casual attitude to the racism on display in the painting. I wrote to the National Trust about it and they simply referred me back to her.
I counted one other person of colour looking around the property.
It is a horrible painting and they need to remove it or have a special section explaining the painting's background and provenance.
I compared the management attitude unfavourably to the Rossetti Exhibition at the Tate last year which dealt sensitively with the slavery issue.
The National Trust needs to deal with the painting properly.

RawBloomers · 23/02/2024 18:35

BaroqueInterlude · 23/02/2024 08:17

I asked her stop while I was trying to check in and she told be she wasn’t allowed to. that they had to talk to everyone checking in. She was going over (I think) some of the terms and conditions.

I should imagine in a theme park they are covering themselves against possible complaints/claims so they don't get sued if someone drops their I-phone 15 pro from the top of a rollercoaster.

This isn’t a way to cover themselves legally because talking at people while they are distracted with something else - especially when you do it that way by design - would not be accepted in a court as an acceptable way to provide warnings. And since it is an ineffective way of providing additional information, it’s not useful in terms of trying to stop people from making mistakes.

In any case it was in the hotel, which is not inside the park, and you don’t have to stay at the hotel into go into the park. So they only have the normal concerns of a hotel, not the concerns of a theme park.

cookingwithabigail · 23/02/2024 13:18

GoodOldEmmaNess · 23/02/2024 12:34

😁Cats would have to be place mats, I think. I've got a terrier, and stuffed with stones or sand he would be quite a good doorstop.

😂😂😂

SabrinaThwaite · 23/02/2024 13:18

OCDmama · 23/02/2024 08:54

I agree, it really puts me off NT places. If I want information I will ask or find it myself.

I work in the sector and we also have room stewards. We do a LOT of training to avoid the NT problem, and also keep an ear open.

There's also the problem of NT volunteers frequently getting things wrong or embellishing. I worked a project at Attingham and every time the volunteer came through with a tour group she kept changing who the portraits were of - a portrait was the owner's first wife, second wife or mistress.

We have Attingham visits too - I'm very glad they bring their own tour guide! I am on hand to answer questions though - sometimes I just have to say I'm not sure can I get back to you on that.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 23/02/2024 12:34

😁Cats would have to be place mats, I think. I've got a terrier, and stuffed with stones or sand he would be quite a good doorstop.