Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?

415 replies

Sunshineismyfavourite · 20/02/2024 21:16

Visited a beautiful NT country house today. Huge 17th century house with Capability Brown landscaped parkland. The house has lots of art by Van Dyck - one of my favourite artists and I was really looking forward to spending a couple of hours with DH wandering around in the beautiful spaces enjoying the peace and quiet. However, every time I stopped to look at a painting one of the staff would come up to me and start talking. This happened several times in every room we wandered into. I totally get the enthusiasm and expertise of the staff but I wasn't really interested in hearing about the Civil War etc., I just wanted to enjoy the paintings in peace. We do visit NT properties occasionally but have never found this to be a problem before.
The staff just seemed to be unable to read my body language as I was trying to walk away or indicate that I didn't want to talk or listen to them by not responding or engaging with them. Short of telling them to shut up it was impossible.
It was a very quiet day with not many visitors so they were probably bored but it was way too much for us.
AIBU by being a miserable bugger (I know I'm quite unsociable at times) or should I be allowed to wander round in peace? Perhaps they should give out 'don't talk to me' badges with the tickets if you want to be left in peace!

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 21/02/2024 09:16

Edwardandtubbs · 21/02/2024 07:52

They tend to do it with artworks because the houses are set up as family homes and so don’t have interpretation labels on them. Quite often visitors will be staring at a painting wondering about it and the steward is the only point of information.

Also - they are primarily there exactly as stewards. The main point of their job is not actually interpretation or even visitor welcome. They are there to keep the building and its contents safe, and to ensure that all visitors are kept safe during their visit.

Being knowledgable about the place is a side effect; it just so happens that many volunteers will be absolutely obsessed with the site.

Once you’ve trained them on fire, first aid, evacuation, basic conservation, how to use the radios, break and lunch rotas, visitor flow etc etc is there any time left for body language training?

The NT’s operating model is shocking. Exploiting volunteers in roles that should be paid and valued. Until they radically rethink their model the fact bombing will continue…

I usually use the lie ‘oh I used to work here’ - it tends to cut them off!

Other heritage organisations and museums manage to take the visitor experience and interpretation side of the role seriously and train the volunteers for it, so I really don’t know why the NT can’t- assuming your description of NT volunteer training is what they actually do rather than guesswork?

I totally disagree that the model of using volunteer room stewards, shared by visitor organisations and independent museums the world over, is exploitative. The reasons it is so common is that it allows places to open and events to take place that would simply not be cost effective with all paid staff. Volunteering is a two way street and people do it for all kinds of reasons. One of my fellow volunteers was a retired headmistress in her early 90s who went out and did voluntary work somewhere every day of the week. Another is a young disabled woman who is now doing a degree as a result. My sil is now a curator at the museum she started volunteering at before she was able to go back to work after dcs.
As has been raised on this thread, there are certain issues that come with using volunteers, but many of these can be addressed if you take their role seriously and give them full training, which it sounds like the NT may not always be doing.

fleurneige · 21/02/2024 09:14

Alicewinn · 21/02/2024 08:46

That’s happened to me before, they’re really bored volunteers

Well think about it t'other way round. This person isi giving time freely and has taken more time to be trained, to learn about the place and the artefacts, furniture, history, and has done lots of reading about it on top. And is passionate about the place. To me that doesn't mean that they are 'bored' - but because they so love the place, are prepared to give their time and share knowledge. If you spend 1 day a week standing around- I am sure you'd rather feel that you were of some use and could help, than ... being bored.

Just be polite and say thank you, and quietly say you enjoy visiting with your own thoughts. No need to be so rude.

And sorry, NT would not survive if it had to employ staff to cover all the sites and houses.

serin · 21/02/2024 09:13

Oh God yes this. We love visiting NT gardens but whenever we go into a property we get accosted. Worst was the room assistant who had made a mental judgement that we were "nice" and shared her awful opinions re the travelling community. 😔.
I get that some of them are a bit lonely and it's their day for going out to chat to folk, but when it's my day off and I just want a day where I don't have to talk to people....

LeSoleil · 21/02/2024 09:05

Take some brochures from a national double-glazing company and pretend to be the local sales rep. When the volunteers start talking about the age of the property, thrust a brochure in their hands and talk incessantly about how you can save the NT millions of pounds a year in energy bills through installation of a UPVC triple casement flush system. “You buy one, you get one free.”

Trethew · 21/02/2024 08:55

I dread and loathe this. I feel pounced on. It’s as if they can;t ready your body language as you stiffen and turn away. The first steward who accosts me gets a smile and the merest nod while I to look away and don’t engage. By the time I get to the last room I can be positively rude and put my hand up to stop them before they speak and then I feel really mean by the end. And this is an experience I have paid for.

BardRelic · 21/02/2024 08:54

MrsGlennBulb · 21/02/2024 08:45

We were once relentlessly pursued through the vast grounds of an English Heritage property by a volunteer who was on his day off (and just looking for a victim). Our mistake had been pausing to admire a mature tree.

I had a very long conversation about storks with an EH volunteer. It was interesting, tbf, and I found out quite a lot about storks, much of which I've forgotten. But I could see why he was volunteering - very much a people person who wanted to share his knowledge.

I've also come across some amazing NT volunteers who were fantastic with a friend's neurodiverse teenage son, who was asking all sorts of questions I doubt they were used to. And ultimately, if they are a bit intrusive and I don't want them there, I start telling them about the intricate details of my history PhD and wait until they edge away.

Iwasafool · 21/02/2024 08:54

I haven't been to a NT property in about 8 years. Had a horrible experience where we were totally ignored. We walked in and went to counter to pay, one person paying but two women on the tills so we stood next to these people in front of the woman not doing anything, I assumed she wasn't actully taking money so waited. Other people joined the queue and the people who came after us was served, I thought maybe the woman serving assumed we were being dealt with by her colleague. She was very chatty with both couples going in. So then she stared to serve the third lot of customers so second lot who came in after us. I said, "Am I invisible?" She tutted and the people who she had started to serve apologised. She was really short with me, didn't point out where to go as she had with previous customers.

We came to the conclusion my husband wasn't welcome due to colour, it was a very white part of the country. I'd have told them to stick it but we were meeting people inside but vowed never again.

I get your experience was annoying even though it was the opposite of mine.

DRS1970 · 21/02/2024 08:48

I find the same thing annoying too. I just want to take in the pictures, admire the furnishings, and take in the views. If I want to know the history of the room or anything else I am capable of asking. I wish they could just quietly hovver, as I am too polite to tell them to go away. 🙃

Alicewinn · 21/02/2024 08:46

That’s happened to me before, they’re really bored volunteers

AtomicBlondeRose · 21/02/2024 08:45

AngelinaFibres · 21/02/2024 07:43

My SIL was one of those. I'll pass on your feedback

Nice passive aggressive attempt to make me feel bad for sharing my actual experience. Of course it wasn’t every volunteer who was annoying but enough of them were that we took to avoiding them. That’s just a fact. I appreciate the intent but after too many people wanting to explain their personal interpretation of every painting in the Ferens or tell me who Phillip Larkin was, we started muttering “oh fuck there’s another one, let’s go” whenever we saw the blue. Great if people found them helpful but the simple truth was they actively put us off visiting places in Hull.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 21/02/2024 08:45

This seems common with many venues, including English Heritage.

It's easy to suggest 'ripostes' for the OP but when you're in the moment and put on the spot, most people want to avoid anything confrontational (like asking to be left alone.)

The volunteers are clearly trained to do this so speaking/contacting the management of the site is the answer.

We recently went to an EH site -mainly to walk the grounds - and the initial 'greetings' when we bought tickets were slightly OTT (the site has just opened for the spring season) and felt insincere.

When we left, the volunteer at the gate asked if we'd enjoyed our walk.
I felt that was intrusive. sometimes I go for walks in the countryside when I'm dealing with difficult stuff, and don't want to talk to anyone.

All they need to say is 'Goodbye, thanks for visiting.'

MrsGlennBulb · 21/02/2024 08:45

We were once relentlessly pursued through the vast grounds of an English Heritage property by a volunteer who was on his day off (and just looking for a victim). Our mistake had been pausing to admire a mature tree.

unloquacious · 21/02/2024 08:42

It’s like in America when you just want to eat out and talk quietly to your family and some overhyped waiter wants you to tell them your whole life story (for fear of not being tipped). Unable to understand body language or even words. It’s SO SO annoying!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 21/02/2024 08:39

I have to say I find museums and NT places much more pleasant to visit in the UK, despite overenthusiastic volunteers at times.

In some overseas museums they seem to assume you're going to steal or damage something and follow you round. Italy seems to be particularly bad for this.

CurlewKate · 21/02/2024 08:38

Amazing amount of ageism and snobbery on here!

enchantedsquirrelwood · 21/02/2024 08:36

I say 'You're so knowledgeable, I could listen to you all day, but I'm afraid I've only got half an hour and want to make sure I see as much as I can, so I'll have to move on now. Thanks so much' - and walk away briskly

Brilliant advice - it should work for all but the most overkeen volunteers!

Interesting comment about the retired teacher demographic - my aunt volunteered at a NT place in Derbyshire and she had been a teacher!

ChompingCabbage · 21/02/2024 08:36

This happened to me last time I visited a NT place. I prefer to just look in peace too but the way they approach you makes it difficult to tell them you want to be left alone without being rude.

NoFucksToGive · 21/02/2024 08:35

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 21/02/2024 07:29

One single person up thread used ‘use your words’ and then the OP got offended and repeated it - then about 10 people went off on one about it saying how loads of people keep saying it 😂 it’s hardly a mumsnet epidemic is it.

most other people legitimately said the OP should politely tell the volunteer to leave them alone. That isn’t infantilising or whatever, it’s true.

And I suspect people who say ‘use your words’ are either too used to saying it to their children (I thinks it’s a patronising phrase actually - even to kids) or are trying to be rude like pp suggested.

I actually never saw the OP replying, just thought I’d clear that up for you. The phrase “use your words” is used to be patronising on here, I’ve seen it on many boards used by less than pleasant posters. It is patronising and is often used to belittle posters.

TheLonelyStarbucksLovers · 21/02/2024 08:34

Think I'll tell my lovely mum who gives up her time to VOLUNTEER as a NT room guide not to bother given the comments on here. Clearly people don't appreciate it and just see the volunteers as 'old with nothing better to do'. I'll remind her to not speak to anyone unless shes spoken too in future.

Well yes - I personally would prefer this. Volunteers who only engage with people who engage with them sounds perfect to me.

As said upthread in defence of the overbearing well meaning volunteers I could ‘use my words’ to tell them I don’t want to hear what that have to say. Equally I could ‘use my words’ when I do want to hear what they have to say - wouldn’t that be better?

And yes, if you’re in a customer facing role, volunteer or not, you should be able to read basic body language. I tend to give them a vague nod and smile and wander off away from whatever’s being explained to me, yet still sometimes they follow and carry on talking.

MrsGlennBulb · 21/02/2024 08:27

Obimumkinobi · 21/02/2024 00:43

The only way to escape being cornered and blasted with facts about 17th Century ceramics against your will is to get a selfless friend to pretend they are going to sit on an old chair with a passive aggressively placed teasel on it. You have approximately 30 seconds from when the siren goes off and all NT volunteers are obliged to stop "mid fact" to run and form a Trutex clad ring around the offender. You can't help your friend now, all you can do is leggit to the cafe a raise a cream scone to the fallen. Its what they would have wanted.

😂😂😂 brilliant!

Ace56 · 21/02/2024 08:25

@UniqueReader

I mean…if your mum is one of the volunteers who incessantly talks at visitors and doesn’t leave them alone then yes, tell her to stop. If she’s not, then this thread is irrelevant to her so I don’t see the issue 🤷‍♀️

nonumbersinthisname · 21/02/2024 08:20

AngelinaFibres · 21/02/2024 07:43

My SIL was one of those. I'll pass on your feedback

I thought the CoC volunteers were fab, really good ambassadors for the City and I never had any problems with them being “too helpful”.

MinistryofInfo · 21/02/2024 08:20

@EnidSpyton the experience you describe with the guide who lectured at the world’s leading expert resonates with me on all sorts of levels!

I’m an experienced museum guide myself in my spare time as it happens, but I take people who have elected to go on a tour, which is a slightly different kettle of fish from those who just want to enjoy in peace.

I was once interviewed by the (rather fierce) curator at a particular museum and he asked me to describe five objects to see how I did. I picked a particular thing because I really liked it and applied my knowledge to it. I must have passed muster, but I was embarrassed afterwards to realise I’d been talking to the world expert on that particular object! That gave me the humility that your steward also described but, years and years later, I’m also quietly chuffed he found me acceptable!!

The flip side is that I absolutely hate being approached and talked at unless I’m open to it. I have a very strong background in art history and often have better knowledge of the artists etc. so please don’t share your fascinating fact about Reynolds or Gainsborough that I’ve heard 1,000 times before and so on and so forth unless I have joined a guided tour. For me the pleasure is in the looking and the discovery and the fitting in of that work into what I know of the artist or of that period. Unless I sense that you’re a like-minded soul, as can happen with some of the really good ones!

Both reading the room and pitching information in terms of duration and level are both absolutely skills that volunteers should be taught. A visit to Syon House - a long-awaited treat for my elderly mum - was ruined by an over-enthusiastic room steward whom we could not shake off. I would have been more abrupt with him, but she was a gentle soul who forebore rather more than was good for her, and she would have been even more upset had I remonstrated. We extricated ourselves eventually!

I suspect one of the issues with NT or other volunteers is that they are, to a large degree, drawn from a retired teacher demographic. To an extent that’s a transferable skill, but it has to be re-learnt in this context, as they’re not talking to a captive audience who must learn at all costs any more! And I agree with PP that volunteers should not gatekeep or say no for the sake of saying no - it riles me to hear volunteers demanding proof for quite sensitive concessions against organisational policies and so on (age, disability) for example. Again, a lot of that is down to a career in which, often rightly, they’ve had to say NO a lot but in this context it is absolutely NOT a transferable skill!

How much this puts people off coming back should be a matter of concern in a sector still struggling post-Covid and in a CoL crisis.

Hebedacious · 21/02/2024 08:10

Herdinggoats · 21/02/2024 00:11

Problem is is that most of them aren’t staff, they’re volunteers. This means you have lots of lonely old people who do the role because they want to chat and have an opportunity to speak to people. It pisses me right off-just leave me alone.

Wow; ageism is alive and well on Mumsnet that’s for sure!

To get back to the point of the thread, dh, who in reality is quite well versed in British and European history, always catches the eye of a volunteer as they start to move over and says “thanks but I’m just here for the beer” 😀

PurBal · 21/02/2024 08:04

I’ve only had one OTT volunteer and it definitely ruined the experience. I would expect that they might offer a titbit or answer questions. They’re not full on guides.

Swipe left for the next trending thread