Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

National Trust visit spoilt by overzealous staff or AIBU?

415 replies

Sunshineismyfavourite · 20/02/2024 21:16

Visited a beautiful NT country house today. Huge 17th century house with Capability Brown landscaped parkland. The house has lots of art by Van Dyck - one of my favourite artists and I was really looking forward to spending a couple of hours with DH wandering around in the beautiful spaces enjoying the peace and quiet. However, every time I stopped to look at a painting one of the staff would come up to me and start talking. This happened several times in every room we wandered into. I totally get the enthusiasm and expertise of the staff but I wasn't really interested in hearing about the Civil War etc., I just wanted to enjoy the paintings in peace. We do visit NT properties occasionally but have never found this to be a problem before.
The staff just seemed to be unable to read my body language as I was trying to walk away or indicate that I didn't want to talk or listen to them by not responding or engaging with them. Short of telling them to shut up it was impossible.
It was a very quiet day with not many visitors so they were probably bored but it was way too much for us.
AIBU by being a miserable bugger (I know I'm quite unsociable at times) or should I be allowed to wander round in peace? Perhaps they should give out 'don't talk to me' badges with the tickets if you want to be left in peace!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OnceinaMinion · 25/02/2024 13:10

I think it’s worth pointing out NT cut a lot of staff in the last few years. So there may only be a house manager/curator covering several properties and responsible for everything.
When my friend was made redundant they didn’t end up filling her role which had then been downgraded. So there’s probably very little curatorial work going on in her old house now.

peakygold · 25/02/2024 12:40

My advice would be to never visit Audley End House if you don't like being bothered. The House is owned by English Heritage, but the contents are held in trust, so EH have to ensure absolutely nothing is touched, taken or photographed. When the guides are not talking at you, they are watching you like a hawk. There is literally a volunteer every few feet. It get very wearisome quite quickly.

EnidSpyton · 25/02/2024 12:32

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 25/02/2024 09:56

I'm sorry, but that is 'bleeding obvious', as I've said before. No matter what your education was like or how old you are, it is a matter of general knowledge that Britain's indigenous population is white-skinned, so anyone not white-skinned has to have come here from somewhere else originally

Sorry but there’s so much wrong with that statement, whether it’s the ignoring of evidence for dark skinned people very early, such as Cheddar Man, or the idea that you haven’t ‘come from here originally’ if you are dark skinned. If you have grown up here you come from here. There have been waves of immigrants of many colours including white; just because you are white doesn’t mean you don’t have ancestors from somewhere else, whether Celts, Saxons, Vikings….

I meant this comment in the context of the appearance of a Black child in an 18thc portrait depicting a wealthy British family, at a time when immigration and globalisation were much more limited in our part of the world. Anyone in the 18thc living in Britain who wasn’t white (or mixed race) would have to have recently been brought or travelled to Britain from somewhere else. I don’t think there’s anything offensive about stating historical fact. Black Britons were not living in this country in large numbers - people born and brought up in the UK to Black parents - before the 20thc. Pretending otherwise is just historically inaccurate.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 25/02/2024 09:56

I'm sorry, but that is 'bleeding obvious', as I've said before. No matter what your education was like or how old you are, it is a matter of general knowledge that Britain's indigenous population is white-skinned, so anyone not white-skinned has to have come here from somewhere else originally

Sorry but there’s so much wrong with that statement, whether it’s the ignoring of evidence for dark skinned people very early, such as Cheddar Man, or the idea that you haven’t ‘come from here originally’ if you are dark skinned. If you have grown up here you come from here. There have been waves of immigrants of many colours including white; just because you are white doesn’t mean you don’t have ancestors from somewhere else, whether Celts, Saxons, Vikings….

Brabican · 25/02/2024 09:27

Also @EnidSpyton
You assert that links to the Slave Trade at Upton Park and other NT properties is, and I quote you, 'Bleeding obvious'. Well, I have just looked on line and whether an NT property was built using questionable funds is not at all obvious. Upton Park attributes the money coming from the Shell Oil company. It may have used funds from the Slave Trade but it is certainly not obvious.

Brabican · 25/02/2024 08:56

@EnidSpyton If you were a volunteer for the National Trust, you probably have great sympathy for their cause. You explain away other organisations creating more sensitive displays because they are London or wherever. Upton Park is near Birmingham, a very diverse city. It is in the interest of the National Trust to make Upton Park an attractive place to visit, regardless of the ethnicity of visitors. I don't think it is doing that.
I think I am right in saying that The Smith Family was not connected to Upton Park. The most recent owner collected paintings and it is this collection on display. I think the Smith Family painting is far more important as a snapshot of the acceptance of slavery in the eighteenth century Britain than it is as a painting. The painting was pre painted by the artist and the heads of the family added on. It was a cheap way to acquire a family portrait.
If you are having this very poor painting on display, it needs to be set in context.
There are other dodgy paintings in this collection. Many have no connection to the house.
It may be a case of a poor curator just bunging them on display without thinking about the implications. However, I do believe the National Trust has a responsibility to manage sensitively paintings with questionable provenance. It should constantly be challenging itself to make displays relevant and to prompt thoughtful interaction with visitors.
As others have already said, a good volunteer can explain the background to items which are not explained by signs.
As many other posters and you yourself have said, these stately homes were often built using money made by the slave trade. A lot of people will find the existence of these houses troubling. It is the responsibility of the NT to show why they are worth preserving. I don't think the National Trust is managing to do this at Upton Park.

EnidSpyton · 25/02/2024 07:24

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 08:54

@EnidSpyton
If you follow the NT link it suggests that the black child is an unidentified attendant. I think most visitors would have assumed that to be the case. It was a volunteer who told me that the child was a symbol of the family's wealth and represented owning slave plantations.

Not to be pedantic, @calicogoose , but the NT link says it is unknown as to whether the child is a depiction of an actual servant owned by the family or meant as a symbol of slavery. There is more than one possible way of looking at the painting, and it is open to interpretation.

Either way, real or symbolic, the child represents slavery in Britain because there would have been no other way for a small Black child to be in 18th century Britain without being a slave.

I'm sorry, but that is 'bleeding obvious', as I've said before. No matter what your education was like or how old you are, it is a matter of general knowledge that Britain's indigenous population is white-skinned, so anyone not white-skinned has to have come here from somewhere else originally. It is also a matter of general knowledge that Britain was heavily involved in the slave trade in the 18th century. I don't think the NT is asking a lot from visitors to make that connection themselves.

I used to volunteer in a NT property behind the scenes many years ago and the reality is that:
a) Individual properties have widely varying budgets for things like displays and labelling, and often have to make very difficult choices about where their money goes - conservation has to be the priority in many properties
b) The curators of NT properties have a huge amount of responsibilities beyond the collections in the buildings. Expecting them to have an encyclopaedic knowledge of every object on every surface in the home they manage is utterly unreasonable. They do their best, of course, but some properties have tens of thousands of objects contained within them.

Your other points about NT properties attracting less diverse populations than London galleries are a little misleading, as you suggest this is proof they are unwelcoming to people of colour. London is the most racially diverse part of the UK. So of course you're going to find a hugely diverse group of people visiting - it's on their doorstep. Most NT properties are situated in rural parts of the UK where the population of people of colour is very low. Less than 20% of the UK population is non-white. Most of this population is centred around the big cities. So on an average day in an NT property in the middle of, say, the Somerset countryside, no, you're probably not going to see any people of colour visiting. Is that because they don't feel welcome? Or is it just because there are so few people of colour living in the area?

I do take umbrage with your insistence that the NT is doing a terrible job of representation because I don't think it's true. Many of their properties have done a thoughtful and considered job of telling the stories of their difficult pasts over the past decade, and there are numerous and regular initiatives to encourage and welcome visitors from a wider range of backgrounds. Nowhere is perfect, but you using one example of a painting you felt was badly displayed to write off a whole organisation's dealings with slavery is more than a little unfair. I think you need to go and see some other properties and how they deal with similar pasts before you make such sweeping judgements.

I also think some onus has to be on visitors to educate themselves. If I'm going somewhere for the day, I will look it up and find out some information before I go, so that I have a base of general knowledge that I can then use to find out more once I'm actually inside. If I can't find out what I want to know from a room guide, I'll take a photo and then look it up myself when I get home. I don't expect to be 'told' everything I want to know, just as I don't expect everyone in the property to know everything about everything on display.

RawBloomers · 25/02/2024 03:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 25/02/2024 00:58

RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 18:23

Your post insinuated, through it’s rather aggressive manner, that someone pointing out that a lack of Black perspective would make NT properties less attractive to the Black population necessarily meant that they did not consider other issues could be a factor. My point was - wind your neck in, all that was being said was that it is a factor.

I won't " wind my neck in " on your command. 😂

CameltoeParkerBowles · 24/02/2024 18:25

Sunshineismyfavourite · 20/02/2024 21:16

Visited a beautiful NT country house today. Huge 17th century house with Capability Brown landscaped parkland. The house has lots of art by Van Dyck - one of my favourite artists and I was really looking forward to spending a couple of hours with DH wandering around in the beautiful spaces enjoying the peace and quiet. However, every time I stopped to look at a painting one of the staff would come up to me and start talking. This happened several times in every room we wandered into. I totally get the enthusiasm and expertise of the staff but I wasn't really interested in hearing about the Civil War etc., I just wanted to enjoy the paintings in peace. We do visit NT properties occasionally but have never found this to be a problem before.
The staff just seemed to be unable to read my body language as I was trying to walk away or indicate that I didn't want to talk or listen to them by not responding or engaging with them. Short of telling them to shut up it was impossible.
It was a very quiet day with not many visitors so they were probably bored but it was way too much for us.
AIBU by being a miserable bugger (I know I'm quite unsociable at times) or should I be allowed to wander round in peace? Perhaps they should give out 'don't talk to me' badges with the tickets if you want to be left in peace!

I'm very late to this thread, but - Aargh! - I hear you! That's so annoying. I was in a shop last week - one which sells artisanal goods. The proprietor took it upon herself follow me around and explain the name and function of EVERY SINGLE THING I looked at, despite the fact they were all clearly labelled and I have no problem reading that stuff. I couldn't shake her off! I kept saying, "Yes, I can see from the label, thanks", but she wasn't put off. Eventually, I put back all the things I had been considering buying and left.

RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 18:23

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 17:03

I don't actually understand the point you are trying to make as what you have just posted is basically the same as I said. It's just worded differently.

It's a well known fact that there are certain areas of "culture" or "entertainment" that are not frequented by certain minority groups for a whole variety of reasons. It is a complicated topic and much more complex than just saying "Oh well they don't depict it from a black/gay/BAME/Irish/Scottish perspective".

Your post insinuated, through it’s rather aggressive manner, that someone pointing out that a lack of Black perspective would make NT properties less attractive to the Black population necessarily meant that they did not consider other issues could be a factor. My point was - wind your neck in, all that was being said was that it is a factor.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 17:16

As regards the OP I always greet a volunteer in these places purely to acknowledge them and I may ask them something. If I felt someone was pestering me I would say "Thanks for that. I'm going to have a wander now". Surely it's not difficult?

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 17:07

C8H10N4O2 · 24/02/2024 12:41

No its factual. Any kind of realistic education in schools about the slave trade and the impact it had and continues to have is a very recent change in the curriculum.

When I was at school the slave trade wouldn't be mentioned unless you studied that period in history and then it was glossed over and merged into the successful building of empire and trade. There would be some low key mentions that there was a bit of slavery and obviously we set our faces against it but nothing on the enduring effects or the staggering amount of wealth accumulated on the bodies of slaves. Any "problems" with race and slavery were considered an US problem, nothing to see here in glorious Britain where more time was spent discussing white British abolitionists than the actual victims or exploiters.

I have to agree with the other poster that this is not my experience. In fact I taught slavery for all my career both here in the UK and in Commonwealth countries. I was going to go on and try to describe a situation in a class relating to this and perception of the slave trade by black Caribbean children but decided it is too hard to do in this format. It would get slated regardless of how I told it.

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 17:03

RawBloomers · 24/02/2024 11:01

No. And that is a bizarre extrapolation, saying a lot more about your knee jerk reaction to the idea of change than the words I wrote.

I’m suggesting the previous poster was indicating that the perspective of Black people was not considered.

Though this wasn’t a part of my response, personally I think the effect of that lack of perspective is that we all get a narrower and less informative experience.

In terms of Black participation in NT, all the things that fail to attract White people probably fail to attract Black people too. But it will remain even less relevant and even less enticing to them if their perspective is routinely ignored.

Edited

I don't actually understand the point you are trying to make as what you have just posted is basically the same as I said. It's just worded differently.

It's a well known fact that there are certain areas of "culture" or "entertainment" that are not frequented by certain minority groups for a whole variety of reasons. It is a complicated topic and much more complex than just saying "Oh well they don't depict it from a black/gay/BAME/Irish/Scottish perspective".

GoodOldEmmaNess · 24/02/2024 16:41

Actually, apologies @C8H10N4O2 . I take back that bit where I said "In fact I wondered to myself whether your post might be an instance of the tendency (in all of us) to continue to operate with ageist assumptions even as we age ourselves, and to regard ourselves as exceptions to the rule." I did ponder the persistence of ageism in older age , but it was unfair to say that the pondering was prompted by your post, which is restricted to the changes in the curriculum. I think my mind just dawdled forwards beyond that.Blush

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 24/02/2024 16:40

ZebraPensAreLife · 24/02/2024 12:50

My point is that other organisations handle issues of provenance better than the National Trust and if they want to attract a more diverse set of visitors and become more inclusive, the NT needs to learn from other institutions.

I’m not sure the NT as an organisation does want this, though. I sometimes get the feeling they’d prefer not to have any visitors at all!

I think it’s the difference between running a property funded by entrance fees and an organisation funded by memberships: it’s in their interest to increase memberships regardless of visits rather than visits. I have also heard NT staff talk about certain properties being at or near capacity so they ideally want to funnel visitors towards other properties rather than increase the numbers at all of them. As an organisation they don’t seem to have the passion for sharing their properties with a wide range of visitors that some other heritage organisations I have worked with do, though obviously there are many passionate and dedicated people working for them.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 24/02/2024 16:29

I didn't assume you were younger than me, @C8H10N4O2 . In fact I wondered to myself whether your post might be an instance of the tendency (in all of us) to continue to operate with ageist assumptions even as we age ourselves, and to regard ourselves as exceptions to the rule.
The fact is that some older people are racist and/or naive about racism and some aren't. Which I imagine is the same among younger people.
I don't disagree with the idea that NT properties are under an obligation to give adequate information about racism and the origins of family wealth. I just wanted to express disagreement about your age-related points.
And I don't think that there is anything 'frankly laughable' about lifelong education in racism. Nowhere, by the way, did I say that people were actively seeking information out. I just think there are several channels - mostly the media but also the efforts of organisations like the NT - through which we absorb the evolving awareness of racism.

bots2014 · 24/02/2024 16:04

Interestingly, I've been a member of NT for nearly 10 years, but hardly encountered such enthusiastic room guides. They normally left me alone unless I asked them questions, so I'm quite happy with them. Mostly likely because I'm not white/British, I kind of realizing it after reading this post... 🤔

C8H10N4O2 · 24/02/2024 16:02

GoodOldEmmaNess · 24/02/2024 14:44

That just isn't true. I'm sixty, and the slave trade most certainly was taught to me when I was at school.(EDIT: I mean, the slave trade in its British aspect and as a source of unjust British wealth, not just as an american issue). Additionally, the evolution in everyone's awareness of both the history of racism and its continuing effects i n our society means that none of us gets our education in these matters primarily from school. It is a constant learning process, one that older people have been engaged in for longer than younger people - and which for older people is informed by their direct memories of a more brutal period in the history of British racism. The Special Patrol Group, the Brixton and Tottenham riots; the murder of Stephen Lawrence. I am sick of the ageist assumption that older people are either more racist or more naive about racism or both.
God, it is only once you get into older age that you realise how completely arrogant you have been as a young person by assuming yourself to be more progressive than your parents' generation.

Edited

What makes you think I'm younger than you?

I'm describing my education and experience. The idea that white people routinely connect the riots and Stephen Lawrence or racism in general and self educate on the subject of the slave trade is frankly laughable, as is the suggestion that they actually seek out that information.

My now adult children had very little in the curriculum on this either although black history month did exist by then (but always discussing the same small handful of approved black people).

My cousins in Bristol used to have to pass the delightful statue of Colston almost daily. Lengthy campaigns to move that statue or at least change the lionising description of a man who literally drowned black people for the insurance as their market value was less than the insured value all failed because the good white folk of Bristol thought he was a good bloke.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 24/02/2024 14:44

C8H10N4O2 · 24/02/2024 12:41

No its factual. Any kind of realistic education in schools about the slave trade and the impact it had and continues to have is a very recent change in the curriculum.

When I was at school the slave trade wouldn't be mentioned unless you studied that period in history and then it was glossed over and merged into the successful building of empire and trade. There would be some low key mentions that there was a bit of slavery and obviously we set our faces against it but nothing on the enduring effects or the staggering amount of wealth accumulated on the bodies of slaves. Any "problems" with race and slavery were considered an US problem, nothing to see here in glorious Britain where more time was spent discussing white British abolitionists than the actual victims or exploiters.

That just isn't true. I'm sixty, and the slave trade most certainly was taught to me when I was at school.(EDIT: I mean, the slave trade in its British aspect and as a source of unjust British wealth, not just as an american issue). Additionally, the evolution in everyone's awareness of both the history of racism and its continuing effects i n our society means that none of us gets our education in these matters primarily from school. It is a constant learning process, one that older people have been engaged in for longer than younger people - and which for older people is informed by their direct memories of a more brutal period in the history of British racism. The Special Patrol Group, the Brixton and Tottenham riots; the murder of Stephen Lawrence. I am sick of the ageist assumption that older people are either more racist or more naive about racism or both.
God, it is only once you get into older age that you realise how completely arrogant you have been as a young person by assuming yourself to be more progressive than your parents' generation.

CatSighs · 24/02/2024 13:16

Gosh, this thread has covered some ground since I last looked a few days ago!

ZebraPensAreLife · 24/02/2024 12:50

My point is that other organisations handle issues of provenance better than the National Trust and if they want to attract a more diverse set of visitors and become more inclusive, the NT needs to learn from other institutions.

I’m not sure the NT as an organisation does want this, though. I sometimes get the feeling they’d prefer not to have any visitors at all!

C8H10N4O2 · 24/02/2024 12:41

ICantbelieveitMeldrew · 24/02/2024 10:17

What an ageist post. Appalling.

No its factual. Any kind of realistic education in schools about the slave trade and the impact it had and continues to have is a very recent change in the curriculum.

When I was at school the slave trade wouldn't be mentioned unless you studied that period in history and then it was glossed over and merged into the successful building of empire and trade. There would be some low key mentions that there was a bit of slavery and obviously we set our faces against it but nothing on the enduring effects or the staggering amount of wealth accumulated on the bodies of slaves. Any "problems" with race and slavery were considered an US problem, nothing to see here in glorious Britain where more time was spent discussing white British abolitionists than the actual victims or exploiters.

Pliudev · 24/02/2024 11:31

I'm in agreement with Calicogoose who makes many valid points. It should be remembered, though, that the London galleries and those in other major cities, have a far more racially mixed demographic. I know that Tate St.Ives struggles to attract more diverse visitors (and staff). It is a challenge our cultural institutions are working to meet with varied success.

Many (if not most) of the properties that the NT owns have connections to slavery of one kind or another. Let’s not forget the deprived and undernourished children in this country who left school to labour long hours in textile factories and mines, making their owners wealthy. In Cornwall, they were sent into narrow tunnels to scrape arsenic deposits from the walls. Consequently, they lived short lives.

It seems to me, the really important role of the NT is to educate its visitors in how unjust the society was (and remains) that subsidised the creation of its grand houses and to reveal their history. That’s not to say visitors should be pestered by worthy attendants but that the information should be obviously displayed and further information available if asked for. At the moment there is a struggle going on within the NT because right wing factions are trying to prevent this from happening. Should they prevail, then, a great opportunity will be lost to reveal our history.

calicogoose · 24/02/2024 11:26

My point is that other organisations handle issues of provenance better than the National Trust and if they want to attract a more diverse set of visitors and become more inclusive, the NT needs to learn from other institutions.
I also pointed out that it was a volunteer who knew more about the painting than the paid House curator, who honestly gave me the impression that she just didn't care about the historical background of items even if they referenced the Slave Trade.
So well done in this instance to the volunteer. I was grateful to her. Not so much the dismissive NT curator.

Swipe left for the next trending thread