Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that love and relationship success is largely due to luck?

206 replies

Shakespearesister · 20/02/2024 20:11

Definitely bitter and biased here but bare with me…

Im almost 40, 3 small children and my long term relationship is falling apart.
There are a multitude of reasons why but it got me thinking about all my friends who are in happy marriages and relationships.

Lots of them are in similar positions to me, with awful, selfish men who don’t want to grow up, debt issues, wanting to get drunk/take drugs far too often, lazy and not sharing the household chores/mental load.
These are lovely, moral, intelligent women... they deserve more.

I also have friends who are with wonderful men who put them first, do their fair share, act like adults and are hands on parents, look after their wives and kids and our family first. (Sadly, there are very much in the minority.)
I get that some women stay too long with idiots (like me) and that’s on them, but AIBU to think that a lot of time, the people we end up with is just luck/bad luck?

I had no way of knowing what kind of father my partner would be when we met, he was attentive, generous and kind but has slowly become a monster.
No one can foresee addiction issues, potential infidelity etc years in the future.

AIBU to think some people just get lucky in love? Or is this to simplistic.

OP posts:
Bringonthesun24 · 21/02/2024 03:29

I think alot of people are underestimating the power of childhood role models and your own childhood and parent relationship. When our core beliefs are developing at a young age the way relationships are modelled have such a big impact on our lives. So these red flags seem normal behaviour to us because that's all we have seen and known. Obviously there will be exceptions in the minority. Our attachment styles play a part. If you have a secure attachment due to a healthy upbringing then you will have good boundaries and will wait out to find a partner who is also secure and good for you.
Whereas if you have an anxious or avoidant attachment then the relationships will be difficult.

I myself have had to learn this the hard way through counselling, reading books and studying psychology. I know my relationships haven't been great because of my childhood and trauma. Some people are just born into this and therefore it is luck on weather or not you are brought up with the right role models.

RawBloomers · 21/02/2024 03:13

I think there’s some luck involved in the serendipity sense, being in the right place at the right time sort of thing, not having huge trauma hit your relationship. But also, you’re more likely to have that luck meeting if you aren’t hung up on being in a relationship for the sake of it (or for the sake of children or whatever) because spending a lot of time stuck with guys who aren’t a great fit means you won’t be as available to meet other guys. And you’re more likely to meet more guys who might be a good fit if you put yourself out there in some way. Also, you’re more likely to survive trauma to your relationship if you (both) have forgiving and generous attitudes towards each other and aren’t too hung up on things in life going a particular way.

I also think there is an element of needing to be a suitable partner yourself. For all the talk of men who are shit partners (and I’m not denying that’s a huge issue, but it’s well covered on this thread), some women are too. Common traits that tend to hurt relationships include, I think, amoung many other issues - people pleasing and conflict avoidance. Things that tend to be good (again, IMO) include self-acceptance, courage, knowing yourself well enough to understand when things matter to you and when they’re things someone else has told you you should want, the confidence to speak up early on if things are bothering you along with the communication skills to do so well.

Garlickit · 21/02/2024 03:11

WellThatEsculatedQuickly · 20/02/2024 21:13

I think it goes all the way back to childhood. If you experienced unconditional love and okay family dynamics in childhood then you are much more likely to achieve a loving and positive relationship as an adult. If you experienced trauma, family dysfunction and/or abuse and a lack of protective factors, then achieving a healthy relationship as an adult will be much harder and less likely. And, I guess, the circumstances that we are born into is down to luck. So yes, it is luck.

Very much in agreement with this. People who didn't come from dysfunctional backgrounds always seem to think it's something you can just "get over". The reality is that most of us never even knew they were dysfunctional. What you know of life is what you know, there's no magical state of detachment giving an informed overview of family dynamics.

So I picked men who were less-worse than my father, but I behaved very much as my mother had. I saw red flags but was not equipped to grasp their significance. Worst of all, I overlooked nice, sane, decent, well-balanced men. They didn't compute as potential partners - and, in any case, it's unlikely they would've stuck with me for any length of time.

All that is luck. Until we achieve my dream society, in which everyone does therapy as a matter of course, it will continue to affect a large proportion of relationships.

Luck affects things in other ways, too. Perfect self-determination is a fallacy. For instance, I'm not even bothering to think about a relationship any more because I have a debilitating illness and live in a place with very few potentially compatible residents. It's just not a good use of my time under the circumstances. You or family members can get sick, your industry can collapse, war can break out ... our lives are impacted by events beyond our control all the time!

Along with "therapy for all", I want to see a world in which women ditch inadequate partners faster and more decisively. Too many men get away with being selfish dickheads because they can. They should start finding out that they can't!

WandaWonder · 21/02/2024 02:44

Threewordseightletters · 21/02/2024 02:39

This thread is making me feel very sad. So many women feeling they have settled or made choices that have not played out well. Are so many men fundamentally incompatible with having a sincere and supportive relationship?

I know it is hard for people on here to get on here but it can work the other way around not every single female in a relationship is perfect or makes a great partner either

Threewordseightletters · 21/02/2024 02:39

This thread is making me feel very sad. So many women feeling they have settled or made choices that have not played out well. Are so many men fundamentally incompatible with having a sincere and supportive relationship?

Ruthietuthie · 21/02/2024 02:31

As someone who used to make poor relationship choices, it wasn't luck but the fact that I was (although I didn't realize it at the time) deeply damaged by an abusive childhood. It was only after counseling that, suddenly, somehow, I ended up with decent men.

TempestTost · 21/02/2024 01:43

Olinguita · 20/02/2024 23:47

Same. I also married the nice guy and he went off the rails after his father passed away. His behaviour and personality completely changed. He is not a particularly nice person any more. We are nearly three years into this. The DH currently sleeping downstairs on the sofa (his choice) bears almost no resemblance to the man I fell in love with.

There were a few character flaws that in retrospect were apparent in the dating phase but nothing, nothing could have prepared me for the extent what happened after marriage.

DH fared very badly during the pandemic from a mental health standpoint and I don't think that helped. Lockdown really did a number on him. He is still severely depressed and extraordinarily difficult to live with. This guy was once sunny, energetic and kind-hearted. Can you really predict when you get engaged how a partner is going to behave in a hypothetical pandemic that unbeknownst to you is about to occur a year or two down the line? Can all of you who are in happy relationship situations now truly say that you have thought about/discussed how your partner would react in an extreme adverse scenario? Did you stress-test your relationship for potential trauma, illness, bereavement, natural disasters, attacks by bears etc etc?

Maybe my experience isn't that common but I 100% believe that people can change for the worse or that a crisis can reveal worse aspects of their nature that would never have surfaced in normal times.

And before anyone asks, I've been supporting and encouraging him to access mental health care, and we are stopping at one DC.

@colouringindoors I'm really sorry to hear what you have been through, that sounds so hard 💐

Edited

I would say that an unexpected MG crises is one thing that can be truly bad luck.

Similarly, addictions usually are somewhat predictable, but there are exceptions, I've known of a few where someone had an injury and ended up addicted to opioids and it completely changed everything in a very short time.

colouringindoors · 21/02/2024 00:15

ChatBFP · 20/02/2024 21:11

And @colouringindoors, it's not a guarantee, just maximisation. I am really sorry that happened to you.

Thanks. I think your points are good. I'd say we scored 9/10 when we married. Families, outlook, priorities etc bang on. Not one single person saw what happened coming.

TripleChins · 21/02/2024 00:13

I think that one of the things that can be problematic is that it can be exhilarating to be in a relationship with someone dysfunctional at the start. They blow hot and cold and their partners get huge dopamine highs when all's going well and then crash when things aren't. It can be addictive and like a lot of addictions, logic and common sense go out of the window.

I know it's a cliché, but hurt people hurt people, and I say that acknowledging that i was difficult to be in a relationship with before I truly processed my traumatic past/childhood.

Some people have quite strong rescuer/helper tendencies, and are drawn to people they can nurture, but i think there is much greater potential for chaos when this dynamic is present. Ideally both partners will have worked on any significant "stuff" we might be carrying before getting into a relationship, and especially before introducing children, although of course none of us are perfect and we all have a past.

A couple consisting of two emotionally healthy adults who are self aware and can communicate assertively and regulate themselves using healthy coping mechanisms have a much better chance at being successful than the alternative.

I also think a similar outlook on life, goals and beliefs is important, but without the ability to communicate well and from a place of security it's so much harder to work on the relationship because no one's voice is actually being heard and their relational needs are less likely to be met.

colouringindoors · 21/02/2024 00:10

Thanks @Olinguita I appreciate that. I'm so sorry you're in a similar position, it can be devastating. Take care 💐

Olinguita · 20/02/2024 23:47

colouringindoors · 20/02/2024 21:06

Well I don't think you're being unreasonable. I married the nice guy. Everyone said so. Calm, kind etc. 15 years into marriage he developed what was diagnosed years later Bipolar disorder and was so severely ill and disturbing (sectioned more than once) it was like a bomb went off in our marriage and devastated my and dcs health and wellbeing.

Same. I also married the nice guy and he went off the rails after his father passed away. His behaviour and personality completely changed. He is not a particularly nice person any more. We are nearly three years into this. The DH currently sleeping downstairs on the sofa (his choice) bears almost no resemblance to the man I fell in love with.

There were a few character flaws that in retrospect were apparent in the dating phase but nothing, nothing could have prepared me for the extent what happened after marriage.

DH fared very badly during the pandemic from a mental health standpoint and I don't think that helped. Lockdown really did a number on him. He is still severely depressed and extraordinarily difficult to live with. This guy was once sunny, energetic and kind-hearted. Can you really predict when you get engaged how a partner is going to behave in a hypothetical pandemic that unbeknownst to you is about to occur a year or two down the line? Can all of you who are in happy relationship situations now truly say that you have thought about/discussed how your partner would react in an extreme adverse scenario? Did you stress-test your relationship for potential trauma, illness, bereavement, natural disasters, attacks by bears etc etc?

Maybe my experience isn't that common but I 100% believe that people can change for the worse or that a crisis can reveal worse aspects of their nature that would never have surfaced in normal times.

And before anyone asks, I've been supporting and encouraging him to access mental health care, and we are stopping at one DC.

@colouringindoors I'm really sorry to hear what you have been through, that sounds so hard 💐

HelloDarlingWhatAreYouDoingHere · 20/02/2024 23:43

Not luck. We are programmed by our childhoods to seek out certain partners and it takes a lot of work to unpick that and know how to find someone more suitable. Most people don't realise this until they get their fingers badly burned.

LondonVeritas · 20/02/2024 23:42

Shakespearesister · 20/02/2024 20:39

I completely agree with a lot of what you have said, but is it not bad luck that you have to make the decision to leave one of these bad men to begin with?

Let’s say woman A is in a relationship and he develops alcoholism but chooses to seek help and they work at it.
woman B is in the same situation but her husband is in denial and spirals, how is that not bad luck?
Not being antagonistic, genuinely curious!

If someone turns into an alcoholic at 35 they’ll will have shown addictive tendencies throughout their life. Either that or has shown other unhealthy coping mechanisms. Or they might have shown signs of other unhealthy behaviours victim mentality, anger, commitment phobia etc

Fernsfernsferns · 20/02/2024 23:39

Rollerskaty · 20/02/2024 20:34

Good or bad luck, and unintentionally repeating patterns from childhood.

Agree with this, but then part of making a better choice is coming to terms with you childhood shitty patterns sooner than later.

i had a crap time with relationships in my 20s.

took myself to therapy and was able
to understand and overcome my shit patterns

which empowered me
to choose a better and different partner than if I’d been a bit ‘luckier’ younger

and I also have really great interpersonal skills to navigate my relationship well.

im more emotionally mature than my partner and sometimes that is a drag.

but he’s a decent guy and willing to work at being a better one.

in contrast I know a couple getting divorced now where they seems to have an easier ride than I did meeting and getting together

but it turns out their relationship has been on a downward spiral of unspoken resentments for years.

the guy is now doing the emotional work. Late but better late than never

his STBEXW is pushing on for divorce.

She comes from family background of emotional neglect and seems to be repeating a pattern of cutting and running to avoid facing up to and working through her own shit.

Em94 · 20/02/2024 23:32

I think meeting that person is down to luck but I also agree that we all ignore red flags!
I met my partner 8 years ago and we’re heading for breaking up , but when I think back to when we met I ignored so many things that I’ve realised with age we’re massive red flags

FilthyforFirth · 20/02/2024 23:30

Superlambaanana · 20/02/2024 23:03

Really what all the lucky people here are saying is that rather than being lucky, they are incredibly highly skilled - at spotting men who are going to turn nasty later in a relationship. Bully for you girls, but apart from sounding really rather self righteous, anti women and frankly pretty ridiculous, you also completely let men off the hook.

So all the millions of women out there who have had terrible experiences at the hands of men should just have engaged their brains or done more thorough research into their partners' previous histories. Oh yes of course that information is published in 'Bad Men's Previous Relationships History Weekly'... 🙄

Are these women forced into relationships against their will? Presumably the vast majority of them can leave whenever they choose. But a lot dont it seems, and this is where not luck but choice comes in.

I dont feel lucky, I simply knew what I wanted and was willing to stay single unless I found it.

I will accept the argument of a lucky childhood in that I had a stable home life where good standards were modelled to me

MorticiaSand · 20/02/2024 23:20

Reflecting on people I know socially and through work who are married or partnered up, I guess they may have all felt 'lucky' at the start of their relationships. However, years later they will freely admit either ambivalence to their spouse, or strong negative emotions. I know several people who admit loathing their partners, but they are all stuck for financial reasons. One stays with her husband for half his pension (but hates him for being a control freak), and another refuses to leave her husband because he funds her business. One woman stays because she has been with her husband for so long, and had so many arguments over the years that she sees it as the new normal. She admits she doesn't have the courage to go it alone. Another is dreading her husband giving up work and retiring, as he currently works abroad for several months before coming home on leave for a few weeks. She always drafts jobs for him to do to get him from 'under her feet'. One colleague is living with her partner who is an alcoholic. She has poor credit from bankruptcy, and her only way to buy a house was through him. She freely admits she would leave him if she had the financial means as she finds him disgusting, yet felt lucky at the start of dating to have met someone who rescued her from her financial disaster. I have a tradesman who works for me, and has been a long term single Dad to two children. He has sole custody, and the kids don't see their mother as she moved away. He met a woman who also had kids, and I guess he felt lucky to have a special connection at the start He always appeared loved up at the beginning and talked positively about her. They all moved into her 2-bed house to save money when the cost of living crisis hit. He doesn't feel so lucky now, with four teenagers living under the same roof who don't get along. They have no lounge as it has been taken as a bedroom, and he admits going camping at the weekend alone to get away from his new blended family. He says when everyone is home then it feels like standing room only. He cannot afford to get another house, and is stuck. His relationship is now strained by these factors. People may start out feeling lucky, and then change their mind as time and circumstances shift.

Mumsanetta · 20/02/2024 23:12

Merryoldgoat · 20/02/2024 20:18

I’ll be honest, I know on MN you hear a lot how men change and you’d never have seen it, but in my 46 years I’ve not known anyone whose character has truly changed.

I think we often choose to minimise red flags and make big decisions too quickly.

Nailed it in the first post. How someone deals with relationship problems or life problems such as addiction will be evident in how they deal with any type of issue or conflict early on in the relationship. It also follows that these men will not settle with women who won’t tolerate their shit (as the women will be out the door pronto) and they instead marry women who are likely to stick around despite their shit.

saythebellsofstclements · 20/02/2024 23:12

I would say my luck has been pretty bad in that every man I have ever met has been unsuitable in the end so I've ended it, sometimes quickly, sometimes it has taken a while to notice the incompatibility - especially if they are good at masking.
I've never consciously searched for a man and also I'm very happily independent. At this point I'm single and happy and have no intention of going through the whole 'finding out if someone's suitable' rigmarole again. It's been a waste of time so many times. I'm done with it.

So yes - there's an element of luck in that the people you meet are going to be compatible or not. No-one I have met, has been.

Mabris · 20/02/2024 23:10

Merryoldgoat · 20/02/2024 20:18

I’ll be honest, I know on MN you hear a lot how men change and you’d never have seen it, but in my 46 years I’ve not known anyone whose character has truly changed.

I think we often choose to minimise red flags and make big decisions too quickly.

You've hit the nail in the head. In life we overlook bad behaviour under the guise of being in love. People don't change, they either become a better or worst versions of themselves but their true core personalities remain the same. Once I realised that, i started making the right choices re life partner. And I'm now happily married for 12 years

Familiaritybreedscontemptso · 20/02/2024 23:06

I think the ‘luck’ comes in childhood - do you have good, healthy relationships modelled to you? Are you taught self worth and how to advocate for yourself?

The luck I had to be born into that is what gave me the skills, knowledge and confidence to find and recognise a good partner, and the ability to work at the relationship within secure boundaries. There are so many things women put up with on here that I just never would - I know I’m worth more. People don’t really change.

TempestTost · 20/02/2024 23:05

Superlambaanana · 20/02/2024 23:03

Really what all the lucky people here are saying is that rather than being lucky, they are incredibly highly skilled - at spotting men who are going to turn nasty later in a relationship. Bully for you girls, but apart from sounding really rather self righteous, anti women and frankly pretty ridiculous, you also completely let men off the hook.

So all the millions of women out there who have had terrible experiences at the hands of men should just have engaged their brains or done more thorough research into their partners' previous histories. Oh yes of course that information is published in 'Bad Men's Previous Relationships History Weekly'... 🙄

I am not sure where you get that logic? Noticing someone is an ass doesn't absolve them from being an ass. Not noticing doesn't make you at fault.

TempestTost · 20/02/2024 23:03

I do think there is an element of luck, but it can be more about being in an environment that makes it more worthwhile to work things out rather than just leave. Or having temperaments that work together.

This is going to sound quite awful, but when I think about a lot of the long term good marriages I know, they are people who came from pretty stable, good marriages themselves, or even blended families but stable good relationships were modeled. By the men and women.

I think a lot of things old fashioned parents used to say about marrying someone from a "good" family were correct. Of course it isn't a sure thing, nothing is, there are really nice families that produce twits and psychos. But a lot of the people I know who married twits and psychos, when you look at the larger family, you see more twits and psychos.

And the good dads I know very often had good dads themselves or other men who played that role.

I also think the people who seem to struggle more often to identify bad men tend to come from a place where they had more problematic examples of men in their life growing up.

I can think of notable exceptions, but overall I think it's a pattern.

Superlambaanana · 20/02/2024 23:03

Really what all the lucky people here are saying is that rather than being lucky, they are incredibly highly skilled - at spotting men who are going to turn nasty later in a relationship. Bully for you girls, but apart from sounding really rather self righteous, anti women and frankly pretty ridiculous, you also completely let men off the hook.

So all the millions of women out there who have had terrible experiences at the hands of men should just have engaged their brains or done more thorough research into their partners' previous histories. Oh yes of course that information is published in 'Bad Men's Previous Relationships History Weekly'... 🙄

Pacificisolated · 20/02/2024 22:55

In my experience, everyone I know just settled down with whoever they were with at around 30 without too much consideration for their future parenting capacity. So I guess it is luck when you don’t really analyse their suitability beforehand.
Sadly it has been entirely predictable who turned out to be a selfish and disengaged father amongst our friends. If they are generally selfish with their time or resources prior to having a baby then the higher the likelihood he becomes nasty and resentful after the baby.

Swipe left for the next trending thread