Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that love and relationship success is largely due to luck?

206 replies

Shakespearesister · 20/02/2024 20:11

Definitely bitter and biased here but bare with me…

Im almost 40, 3 small children and my long term relationship is falling apart.
There are a multitude of reasons why but it got me thinking about all my friends who are in happy marriages and relationships.

Lots of them are in similar positions to me, with awful, selfish men who don’t want to grow up, debt issues, wanting to get drunk/take drugs far too often, lazy and not sharing the household chores/mental load.
These are lovely, moral, intelligent women... they deserve more.

I also have friends who are with wonderful men who put them first, do their fair share, act like adults and are hands on parents, look after their wives and kids and our family first. (Sadly, there are very much in the minority.)
I get that some women stay too long with idiots (like me) and that’s on them, but AIBU to think that a lot of time, the people we end up with is just luck/bad luck?

I had no way of knowing what kind of father my partner would be when we met, he was attentive, generous and kind but has slowly become a monster.
No one can foresee addiction issues, potential infidelity etc years in the future.

AIBU to think some people just get lucky in love? Or is this to simplistic.

OP posts:
Plumtop11 · 21/02/2024 06:50

I do think there is an element of luck yes. I think it's around timing though. I know of many couple who have separated recently who go swept up late 20s when everyone was getting married and had kids and did it because the timing was right, but not necessarily the person.

I'll admit I came from a broken home, saw many disasterous relationships from mum afterwards and that made me super picky and to want a marriage that wouldn't end in divorce. I waited for the perfect person for me and am very happily married at 15 years with 2 DC. In previous relationships I love them but had even told one DP not never propose as I knew I'd say no- he just wasn't good enough to marry (infidelity/lifestyle issues).

Coincidentally · 21/02/2024 06:42

wafflingworrier · 20/02/2024 21:29

Thinking about it, some of it is also how much self-worth you have when you seek a life partner.
As in, this massively impacts what you are willing to put up with and how you seek/expect to be treated by someone who loves you.
If your self worth is high, you will logically think "he says he loves me but his behaviour is disrespectful/doesn't reflect that"
If your self-worth is low, you won't. That's why abusers often erode a person's self worth before beginning physical violence.

Self worth is again linked to your own upbringing and childhood experiences, but also adult experiences. If you've never been shown love in a healthy, respectful way, it is much harder to set clear and high boundaries and expectations.

This thread is really thought provoking and this post is spot on. The was an interesting guy on the ‘Diary of a CEO’ podcast the other day, who started Tinder and had read lots of research about what makes a good relationship. -there were three things but the the first was precisely this. If both partners meet at a time when they gave positive stuff-esteem and stability, and friendship circle the relationship is more likely to last because they aren’t just grabbing at anything to try to fix something broken in them which leads to ignoring red flags.

rainydaysandwednesdays · 21/02/2024 06:32

I have a great skill of being able to work people out very early on. I can sniff out bullshit from a mile away.

My first two relationships were at a time in my life when I was vulnerable and I made bad choices. Those men revealed what they were almost immediately (albeit whilst on their best dating behaviour) but I chose to ignore the red flags, consciously or unconsciously. Guess what happened?!

My third relationship was different. I was older, more confident and listened to my gut. I'm now with the most amazing man and couldn't ask for more.

Maybe the answer is that some people have the ability to sniff this stuff out and some people don't? People, objectively speaking don't change their character but I guess external factors (the grind of life, new babies, work stress etc) can bring out the worst in people.

GreatGateauxsby · 21/02/2024 06:31

Merryoldgoat · 20/02/2024 20:18

I’ll be honest, I know on MN you hear a lot how men change and you’d never have seen it, but in my 46 years I’ve not known anyone whose character has truly changed.

I think we often choose to minimise red flags and make big decisions too quickly.

Yep.

My friends who married lovable dickheads are now just married to plain old dickheads.

I do think meeting a good man you are compatible with in the first place with is sheer luck but i was prepared to be alone indefinitely if i didnt meet someone great.

I remember being out with 4 friends at lunch.. they were commiserating a 5th friend laura who just had a 2nd baby with her useless DH.
One said how "lucky" we were to have such good DHs.
I told her it i didnt agree. It wasnt luck, it was by design. Laura knew he was useless and married him anyway. We actively selected men who would make good husbands and fathers. She thought about it and agreed.

The reality is the 4 of us all have good, kind, hardworking, family-oriented husbands who are still imperfect in random ways... and who laura would describe as "boring bastards" and "betas". Her dh is tall, objectively good looking and v arrogant and not a good husband or father.

95% + of the time you know these guys are going to be crap its not a surprise.

RecycleMePlease · 21/02/2024 06:23

I think we're encouraged to not sweat the small stuff, and see a relationship as a team, but a lot of men just don't think that way - they are the main character and struggle to let go of that.

Which is greatly magnified once you have kids, and suddenly the small stuff is a mountain of small stuff, and the team is a lot bigger and more demanding, so the non-team-player-ness becomes crystal clear and a massive problem. Then if you split, it's an even bigger problem, because he'll treat it all as an attack.

Or at least, that's what happened to me.

I think we need to teach girls to be more discerning, to protect themselves (eg. by keeping earning, rather than sacrificing so much for the family), and to be prepared (and able) to walk away rather than suffer.

Left turn for my post, but it's what I really like about Taylor Swift - she knows her worth, and clearly walks away when something isn't right.

Oh, and men can change - especially where drugs are involved. Steroids and cocaine turned mine from a self-absorbed, but likeable person to a cold, malicious bastard.

Ariona · 21/02/2024 06:22

Merryoldgoat · 20/02/2024 20:18

I’ll be honest, I know on MN you hear a lot how men change and you’d never have seen it, but in my 46 years I’ve not known anyone whose character has truly changed.

I think we often choose to minimise red flags and make big decisions too quickly.

This! It's always there, many just choose not to see it.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/02/2024 06:16

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/02/2024 05:51

This I love my DH dearly but his flaws were there from the start ( slightly lazy, slap dash about other peoples' preferences, ignores what he doesn't want to confront). In his defense he is also very practical, a great cook, a generous lover and devoted Dad. But yes 25 years on I could have predicted my bug bers now had I paid sufficient attentiin on dates 1-5.

I'd like to add I am not perfect either, I can be bossy and over critical, I am messy and disorganised. But I am generally kind, hard working and prepared to take a chance. We rub along ok and have 2 wonderful DCs together.

fritaskeeter · 21/02/2024 06:15

It's a combination of luck, personality (your own and your potential partner's) and the choices we make.

Some of the choices we make are partly based on luck too (our upbringing, messages we got from our parents and the world etc), but some are made through our own free will.

No one wants to choose a 'bad' partner, no one is really to blame. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

Everyone is different in how much they are able to break free of any negative influences they've had in the past that might have a bearing on their choice of partner. Everyone has had different experiences. Everyone is attracted to different personalities and people.

It's complicated but like the whole nature/nurture debate, it's a mixture.

Mummadeze · 21/02/2024 06:11

When you have low self esteem stemming from emotional abuse in childhood it feels impossible to make a good choice, especially as a young person. It then feels impossible to leave that bad situation. A lot of people on this thread are really minimising that.

SlumberDearMaid · 21/02/2024 06:07

I do think it is absolutely down to luck, but probably not for the same reason as you, @Shakespearesister

It is pure, dumb luck as to whether you’re born into a family with two loving parents, including a loving, caring, present, engaged Dad.

If that’s your role model, you’re pretty much gold. No guarantees of course, but you stand a much better chance of attracting and maintaining good men / and naturally repelling the dodgy ones.

I haven’t even had to send any bad men packing. I have nothing but good things to say about any of my exes. They were all lovely. Just not right for me! And my DH is as described in my second sentence above.

So yes, absolutely luck. I am lucky enough to have a rock, solid ‘shark cage’, due to nothing more or less than my upbringing.

Boomer1964 · 21/02/2024 05:54

Everyone changes and evolves over the years and due to major life events. I think couples make it work if they want to stay together. I've changed for the better and so has DH. We've had some pretty majori issues but wanted to stay together. We have paid off the mortgage, DH has retired early and I'm back to working full time giving me financial independence, first GC due soon and both DC in decent jobs. Life is very good. I don't think I would have been happier staying single or divorcing at some point look at the positives and remember you aren't perfect yourself!

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/02/2024 05:52

Hard work maintaining the relationship, especially with children. I think many people let that part of the relationships go, hence more couples with children tend to divorce than othes without.

Statistically the opposite is true.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 21/02/2024 05:51

FortyFacedFuckers · 20/02/2024 20:27

Probably not what you want to hear OP but I agree with this!

I know in my own relationship of 20 years the biggest conflict are things that I turned a blind eye to 20 years ago!
All of my friends that are in shit relationships say he changed etc but I can honestly say the signs were there at the start

This I love my DH dearly but his flaws were there from the start ( slightly lazy, slap dash about other peoples' preferences, ignores what he doesn't want to confront). In his defense he is also very practical, a great cook, a generous lover and devoted Dad. But yes 25 years on I could have predicted my bug bers now had I paid sufficient attentiin on dates 1-5.

Ggttl · 21/02/2024 05:45

I remember knowing who the druggy, lazy and useless boys were at school and I would never have married any of them. I think a lot of people project their idea of a great partner onto someone they fancy and ignore the reality. The idea that you enjoy someone’s company, have some fun and then move on before it becomes serious seems to be a bit disapproved of on here, but I think it is better than trying to settle down and have children with the first person you find attractive.

Guavafish1 · 21/02/2024 05:32

Luck... meeting someone you really want to be with.

Hard work maintaining the relationship, especially with children. I think many people let that part of the relationships go, hence more couples with children tend to divorce than othes without.

I agree, lots of women settle as they want to have children.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 21/02/2024 05:21

it’s mostly not down to luck, a lot of it is down to our pasts and self esteem as to who we choose to enter a relationship with, how quickly we enter relationships, how we behave when we’re in them, whether we ignore red flags or not. If you had a happy, loving childhood you’re more likely to have happy relationships in your adult life than if you didn’t. There are outliers of course, anyone can fall victim to abuse etc but it’s less likely.

I think women do settle for less than what they deserve though a lot more than men because of the desire for kids. I suppose it’s luck as to when you meet the one you deserve, as there a lot of dregs out there to wade through and reject 🤣

Noicant · 21/02/2024 05:14

I think there was luck in meeting my DH but the getting married and having a DC was a conscience decision. He is just an all round responsible person, he’s not overly close to his parents for example but he was always respectful and dutiful.

He on the other hand probably couldn’t have anticipated how badly I adjusted to parenthood from an emotional perspective. Having said that I think he knew me well enough to know that a) I would never ever neglect my responsibilities and b) I would get my shit together at some point.

Theres a big dollop of trust involved about what aspects of someone personality become more pronounced especially under stress. So I don’t think it’s that people change radically it’s about what side of them wins out. So I’m definitely more selfish than my DH BUT it’s moderated by some empathy and sense of duty and he can ultimately count on that.

If I had been selfish with little sense of empathy it would have been very optimistic to have a child with me and think it would lead to a happy family. I think for those of us from disordered backgrounds it’s hard to discern whats important sometimes.

I remember a thread from a while back where a young woman had a really fucking lazy boyfriend who wasn’t pulling his weight with housework and they had been planning a child. She got a lot of advice telling her to not bother as he’s be no more helpful when a kid came along. It was clear as day he would be a shit dad but how many people let things like that slide? unequal division of labour even before kids or someone who can’t be arsed to get you a cup of tea when you are sick, or doesn’t just wash up when it needs doing or generally prioritises themselves again and again even in seemingly small and unnoticeable ways. I think the signs are often there but some of us are shit at picking them up (I dated enough turds to know my radar was completely off).

ImustLearn2Cook · 21/02/2024 05:07

@Shakespearesister I agree with you on this: but being in the right place at the right time has a lot to play.

I look back on my life and in so many instances of success there was an element of luck, being in the right place at the right time, meeting just the right person or opportunity and then jumping on it or responding to it.

So, I do think that this is true of relationships too.

However, life is also a series of decisions and choices so luck is only part of the equation.

I read an interview with Richard Branson years ago and he talked about luck being part of his success.

And people can change for all sorts of reasons. I knew a couple who were married and were well suited to each other. They bought their first house together. They moved in. Their next door neighbour was very religious and part of a religion where they try to convert people. The wife ended up becoming very religious and it did change her. They stayed together despite this for a few years but it eventually ended their relationship because of how much it changed her and every aspect of her life was always devoted to God, church and being a good Christian.

People can and do change for all kinds of reasons.

People that I know who never seem to change are usually people who haven’t grown or matured or traveled or done much that is different from their usual routine.

GurningCompetition · 21/02/2024 04:52

What about the actual numbers of relationship-worthy men available?

Rard · 21/02/2024 04:44

I wonder if those who insist it is not luck and is due to upbringing, not seeing red flags etc. have ever had a relationship where they have been completely blindsided by a partners behaviour?

I can say without a doubt, confidently, that I have had this happen to me and that there were no prior warning signs. One ex in particular had a secret online life that did not present itself in their real life at all. It wasn’t just me who was blindsided, but my friends, my family, their friends and their family. Their own mother was completely shocked by their behaviour, so much so she wept to me when she found out. I don’t believe that myself and every other person who knew him missed the warning signs. From my own experiences I know that some men are master manipulators and can compartmentalise parts of their life and personality, especially when it comes to sex and/or fetishes.

OooScotland · 21/02/2024 04:37

I didn’t vote because I don’t think yabu, but no, I don’t think its luck. Its a lot of things, but not luck.

asdunno · 21/02/2024 04:29

There's lots of factors. It starts with the upbringing you had, how well you were taught to be confident in yourself and have good esteem levels and how positive your social experiences were as a child. Over factors can be financial, mh, environmental.
And sometimes it luck.

Supersares · 21/02/2024 03:50

Certainly the people we meet in life is often down to luck, but the ones we have a relationship with is usually down to choice. In the heady early days of a romance we can be blinkered though, especially for romantic types or if there’s a strong physical attraction. Ending a relationship can be hard too, we’re often keen to try and make things work when sadly they’re not going to. If you are with the right person and manage a long lasting happy relationship then yes there’s an element of luck, but lucky in that you’ve both made it work.
Its a complex area!

Passingthethyme · 21/02/2024 03:38

I agree with poster below. I think second time around, I'll be much smarter and think about my choice. I think when you're young, dumb and in love you don't really think things through. A great boyfriend might be a very different father. In hindsight I know I fucked up

telestrations · 21/02/2024 03:34

I'll be honest for me personally no. Second time round I very purposely looked for and attracted a partner who would treat me and make me feel how I wanted. Which is what I got.

First time round I thought I was but I listening to what he said instead of watching what he did. And I did not get what I thought I was.

And did some work on myself in-between

Swipe left for the next trending thread