Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that love and relationship success is largely due to luck?

206 replies

Shakespearesister · 20/02/2024 20:11

Definitely bitter and biased here but bare with me…

Im almost 40, 3 small children and my long term relationship is falling apart.
There are a multitude of reasons why but it got me thinking about all my friends who are in happy marriages and relationships.

Lots of them are in similar positions to me, with awful, selfish men who don’t want to grow up, debt issues, wanting to get drunk/take drugs far too often, lazy and not sharing the household chores/mental load.
These are lovely, moral, intelligent women... they deserve more.

I also have friends who are with wonderful men who put them first, do their fair share, act like adults and are hands on parents, look after their wives and kids and our family first. (Sadly, there are very much in the minority.)
I get that some women stay too long with idiots (like me) and that’s on them, but AIBU to think that a lot of time, the people we end up with is just luck/bad luck?

I had no way of knowing what kind of father my partner would be when we met, he was attentive, generous and kind but has slowly become a monster.
No one can foresee addiction issues, potential infidelity etc years in the future.

AIBU to think some people just get lucky in love? Or is this to simplistic.

OP posts:
Rard · 21/02/2024 10:02

I think some people on this thread are simplifying things far too much with the argument that the woman just didn’t see the red flags / warnings / signs or that she had poor relationships modelled to her.

With women who have experienced relationships with addicts, they will know that addicts become experts in deception, manipulation and most importantly - concealing the addiction.

In my mid-20s, I was in a relationship with a man who turned out to have a porn addiction. He was a lovely, charming man on the surface. Our sex life was fine, there were no red flags in terms of his sexual appetite or preferences. He was a student at the time, so often stayed up until the small hours ‘doing assignments’. Unbeknownst to me, these ‘assignments’ were actually watching copious amounts of porn for hours at a time. But seriously, who would suspect that? I only happened upon it by chance when he forgot to erase his browser history one day and it popped up! It was only after I discovered the addiction that he became nasty, I assume because he felt shame and didn’t want it to be exposed.

With the easy accessibility of the internet on phones, access to porn, gambling, other women etc has become so easy. It’s also become so much easier to hide. Gone are the days when someone would spot your boyfriend / husband sneaking out of BetFred, instead it’s all done secretly online. It’s much easier to cover your tracks when you can just delete internet history, close the browser or even in the cases of some of my friends, have another secret phone entirely!

I don’t think it’s always the woman being naive or just not seeing the red flags or having poor relationships modelled by their own parents. It’s clearly not as simplistic as that.

Bumpitybumper · 21/02/2024 09:50

VitaminDneeded · 21/02/2024 09:39

This type of attitude is actually really messed up.

the idea that being good at choosing a partner is an evolutionary thing is nonsense and is thinly veiled victim blaming.

from a scientific perspective it doesn’t make sense as it doesn’t stop people having kids.

what about women in Afghanistan or Iran? Are they all idiots who choose sexist pigs? Should they wait for a feminist man?

some people have a better idea of what ‘good’ looks like because their fathers or other male role models have been good men. Many others have been brought up normalising sexist and borderline abusive behaviour in the relationships around then, so the red flags don’t show up so much.

a lot of our decision making is unconscious and is based on us looking for the ‘familiar’

No, it's not victim blaming. It's empowering for women to believe that they have power over their own destiny and aren't completely beholden to luck.

I believe we have evolved as a species to have an ability to read other people and identify red flags. Some call it gut instinct, some call it intuition but we all know exactly what I'm talking about and it is obviously pretty vital to our survival. I think some people have a really good radar for bad eggs either through genetic chance or through their upbringing and life experience. Some people just aren't as good as picking up on the warning signs that seem obvious to other people. We all have strengths and weaknesses and for some people this just isn't their strength. They therefore are much more susceptible to choosing bad partners that other women would avoid. It's not their fault but it obviously isn't something that's good for them or their children so it obviously would be a good idea to work on this for their own sake.

We aren't talking about women in other cultures with more limited choices. This thread is obviously about women in this country that have more autonomy over their lives and choices then women in Afghanistan etc. I'm also not saying that a woman's upbringing couldn't impact their ability to spot the bad men as of course it could, but that doesn't mean that these women are forever predetermined to keep choosing bad partners due to 'bad luck'.

VitaminDneeded · 21/02/2024 09:39

Bumpitybumper · 20/02/2024 20:51

No, they most often don't act like twats on the first date and will go out of their way to charm the object of their affection but the whole point is that it is an act. Some people are more capable of seeing through the charade and spotting the red flags whilst others seem less able or willing to do this. You may well think the man has done a 180 and completely changed, but I imagine that if he is a real bastard then there were some signs all along.

I genuinely think it's an evolutionary thing and some people are just very good at reading people and seeing the true character beneath. This will obviously boost your chances when it comes to romance as you are more likely to understand the person that you are forming a relationship with and have an accurate idea of their deficiencies and whether you can tolerate them.

This type of attitude is actually really messed up.

the idea that being good at choosing a partner is an evolutionary thing is nonsense and is thinly veiled victim blaming.

from a scientific perspective it doesn’t make sense as it doesn’t stop people having kids.

what about women in Afghanistan or Iran? Are they all idiots who choose sexist pigs? Should they wait for a feminist man?

some people have a better idea of what ‘good’ looks like because their fathers or other male role models have been good men. Many others have been brought up normalising sexist and borderline abusive behaviour in the relationships around then, so the red flags don’t show up so much.

a lot of our decision making is unconscious and is based on us looking for the ‘familiar’

KimberleyClark · 21/02/2024 09:16

The pure chance that your parents are both great and model what a good relationship looks like, as opposed to growing up in a single parent household with an absent father. This will cloud your desire, judgement and thought process. How do you know what good looks like when it has never been modelled to you.

I'm not sure about this. DH’s parents were not a model of a happy marriage . They stayed together because they were devour Catholics and divorce out of the question. But my DH always realised their relationship wasn’t normal and was determined not to be like them. We’ve been married nearly 34 years.

clementyne · 21/02/2024 09:04

Oblomov24 · 20/02/2024 20:43

I agree with merryoldgoat, I don't know of any men who changed. All the red flags, for twats were clearly visible, I'm just bemused how the women didn't spot them.

I know everyone's different but in my case I was 18, he was mid 20s, and I just didn't have enough experience of men to really know what red flags to look for. I was used to besotted schoolboys. He set about early on convincing me that his behaviour was legitimate and that I didn't know adult relationship rules. His bursts of anger were not his fault, and so on. But the flags were (to me at least) always just below the surface and hard to pinpoint - subtly ruining important days, being controlling by sulking, that sort of thing. Bigging himself up while putting me down, for years. Told me I couldn't tell friends or family about our arguments because that's not right in adult relationships, and to my shame I believed this until I was in my late 20s, even then just told my best friend.

Now I look back and I can see the flags and the patterns that were precursors for what was to come. Now, with experience, when my friend tells me her DP punches a hole in the door in an argument I tell her to leave because when she has DC he'll hit her too. But I just didn't know back then, and of course after DC the facade broke completely and he turned into someone who would scream and swear at me, call me awful names, push me into walls, shove into me, break things to in anger. I didn't have enough experience to realise that the one would lead to the other.

I also think in my case I was unlucky to have come from the "stay together for the kids" type of dysfunctional family and I genuinely didn't know what a loving relationship looked like. We were an insular family with no real relationship role models in the extended family, and I just didn't know what a healthy loving relationship looks like.

So anyway, I think there's lots of reasons why women don't spot the flags that seem obvious to others. Now they're obvious to me too, and wouldn't fall for it again. But that knowledge has cost me fifteen years of my life.

FilthyforFirth · 21/02/2024 08:59

Merryoldgoat · 21/02/2024 08:49

Yup. I ignored some very clear indications early boyfriends were arseholes.

After a particularly bad experience I decided to get my head together before meeting anyone else.

Being treated badly wasn’t my fault, but it was obvious I would be treated badly by those men from the outset.

What a sensible comment. It isn't victim blaming to point this out. Being treated badly is of course the fault of the man. No one is disagreeing with that or letting men off the hook.

But allowing that behaviour to continue by staying largely is a choice. Women are worth more and shouldn't put up with less.

I think a pp point about being friends first and observing behaviour is spot on. I moved in with DH after 5 months. In normal circumstances this is far too quick and with anyone else I wouldn't have.

But I had known him for 12 years at this point and we had been great friends for the majority of that time. Living with him didn't expose anything I didn't already know.

But had it done, I would have ended it, not married and had children with him. That isn't luck, it was a series of choices.

KimberleyClark · 21/02/2024 08:57

WandaWonder · 21/02/2024 02:44

I know it is hard for people on here to get on here but it can work the other way around not every single female in a relationship is perfect or makes a great partner either

Very true. Some decent men find themselves in a relationship with women who just want children, and once they have them the man is surplus to their emotional requirements.

BIossomtoes · 21/02/2024 08:55

Let’s say woman A is in a relationship and he develops alcoholism but chooses to seek help and they work at it. woman B is in the same situation but her husband is in denial and spirals, how is that not bad luck?

That has nothing to do with luck and everything to do with the character of the alcoholic. I say that as the grateful wife of a recovering alcoholic.

Lovesacake · 21/02/2024 08:51

I think for me luck came into it in terms of timing. If I’d have met my DH at an earlier point in my life we probably wouldn’t have worked as a couple. But luckily I met him at a time where he was just what I needed, and I think the same is true for him too.

Merryoldgoat · 21/02/2024 08:49

FilthyforFirth · 21/02/2024 08:24

I think a lot of things are down to choice but people dont want to accept that as then they have to take responsibility for their choices.

It may well be luck meeting the right or wrong man but staying with him, marrying, having children etc is a choice. Very few women are forced into these relationships.

Yup. I ignored some very clear indications early boyfriends were arseholes.

After a particularly bad experience I decided to get my head together before meeting anyone else.

Being treated badly wasn’t my fault, but it was obvious I would be treated badly by those men from the outset.

Merryoldgoat · 21/02/2024 08:46

Dancerprancer19 · 21/02/2024 08:27

When men aren’t good dads, they often haven’t been great friends especially over the small thankless stuff. Things like, do they help with washing up when there is a mixed group of friends? Do they equally help get ready when people are coming over? Do they take care of others when they aren’t well? Do they remember friends’ birthdays? At work, do they unload the dishwasher?

The issue seems to me that we have too low a bar for men in general outside of romantic or parenting relationships. It might be annoying that your male co-worker doesn’t ever go and get the milk but does it stop him getting a girlfriend and becoming a dad? Probably not. Will he be an equal partner? Probably not.

Hard agree.

DH and I were friends a while before getting together.

I heard and saw what he was like. Cooking food for him mum in hospital, helping friends with boring tasks, doing housework whilst at home with parents, spoke about people kindly, generous with time, money and feelings.

Has basically been the same for 20 years.

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 21/02/2024 08:43

My ex husband changed but not for the better. It seemed like every minor negative trait he had when we were in our 20s suddenly became massive red flags once we were in our 40s with children

But conversely his behaviour in his 20s was not unlike my BIL and yet BIL has grown into being a grown up and grown out of the negative traits

So maybe luck who knows

Dancerprancer19 · 21/02/2024 08:27

When men aren’t good dads, they often haven’t been great friends especially over the small thankless stuff. Things like, do they help with washing up when there is a mixed group of friends? Do they equally help get ready when people are coming over? Do they take care of others when they aren’t well? Do they remember friends’ birthdays? At work, do they unload the dishwasher?

The issue seems to me that we have too low a bar for men in general outside of romantic or parenting relationships. It might be annoying that your male co-worker doesn’t ever go and get the milk but does it stop him getting a girlfriend and becoming a dad? Probably not. Will he be an equal partner? Probably not.

FilthyforFirth · 21/02/2024 08:24

I think a lot of things are down to choice but people dont want to accept that as then they have to take responsibility for their choices.

It may well be luck meeting the right or wrong man but staying with him, marrying, having children etc is a choice. Very few women are forced into these relationships.

Jl2014 · 21/02/2024 08:08

I think a lot of things in life are down to luck but many people don’t want to acknowledge that as it would make them seem less responsible for their good fortune.

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 21/02/2024 08:05

Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
I don’t think it’s luck so much as having certain privileges.
Such as:
The pure chance that your parents are both great and model what a good relationship looks like, as opposed to growing up in a single parent household with an absent father. This will cloud your desire, judgement and thought process. How do you know what good looks like when it has never been modelled to you.
Sure there are people who will work much harder to find a completely good fit in a partner, but that’s the issue, they have to try much harder.
How many times do we hear women with lots of children with unsuitable men say “I had a baby because I wanted someone to love.”
It’s very complicated.
I agree 100% that women who do not want children can afford to be far more picky,
I also think lots of people are oblivious to how abusive their partner is.
The way sone people speak to each other for example is appalling. Yet many people tolerate this. Their children live with this and think it is the correct way to speak to someone you love.
A clear example will be found on here in a few weeks; Mother’s Day. This place will be full of downtrodden women, treated like dog crap yet they are still will this vile men.

gannett · 21/02/2024 07:39

It's not luck. Relationships are one of the things in our lives we have the most agency over but a lot of people don't use that agency - they bow to social pressure and family pressure, among other things.

Whether people can really change is a bit of a simplistic debate. Everyone evolves as a person thanks to life experiences, getting older etc, but most people retain their essential character. Am I the same person at 40 as I was at 20? Completely different in some ways, exactly the same in others. I've known people who've turned their lives around radically from addiction, depression etc. (Sadly also known people who spiralled into those things.) I think the key is that while people can change, it's only ever from within and never in the context of a relationship. You can't make them change.

But I think that's a red herring too in some ways, because whether you end up in a healthy relationship is less about your partner and more about your self-knowledge. We read a lot about red flags, raising your bar etc, but all those things are different for different people. We're not homogeneous and neither are men. You have to really be honest with yourself about what kind of relationship you want, what kind of partner you want; what behaviours are your red lines and what you can't tolerate. All of this is subjective.

I think a lot of people overlook their own subjective desires/turn-offs when their partner is objectively good on paper - good-looking, or a good earner, or a sensible family man. But those things aren't as important as compatibility - do you like to have the same sort of sex, do you share interests and values, do you have the same approach to sociability, do you have the same domestic standards, and if you don't share these things are you at least able to tolerate the other's differences? Compatibility isn't a moral or ethical judgment, it's simply: do I fit with this person?

And you shouldn't need to work all that out in the first few dates. Way too much emphasis is placed on sussing out red flags when you've only met someone a handful of times. But you need to be prepared to leave a relationship once incompatibility becomes clear. This is more common after a few years, often after you move in with them. But a lot of people give in to the sunk-cost fallacy and plough on until irritation and annoyance fester into resentment and hatred.

As a child-free woman it definitely seems to me that the desire for children is a significant factor in people I know making terrible relationship decisions and overriding what you want in a partner. And I know that not wanting children freed me up - to never enter into a relationship unless everything about it worked for me, and then to spend literal years assessing DP before properly committing to him.

redskybluewater · 21/02/2024 07:30

I have a long( +25) happy marriage but we got together when I was still a teen. Subconsciously I must have chosen to be with him for a reason but it wasn't in any way thought out. I came from a stable family, as did he, but we never consciously sort that out. I believe it is a combination of factors that keep us together, but I couldn't separate which are conscious, which not.

I feel that sometimes there's a bit of complacency and self congratulatory behaviour going on here. It's similar to those parents who have babies who eat well or sleep well and are sure it's because of them, of how well informed they were, of how they knew to do such and such a thing. Then sometimes they go on and have a second child and realise that actually there's a substantial element of "nature" rather than solely "nurture" involved in any outcome.

The life we are born into is what it is. Those who feel positive often feel it's been down to them, those who feel negative feel it's down to others. Probably there's an element of both.

Whatsgoingonwithmyhead · 21/02/2024 07:25

In my case several women I know picked men despite subtle red flags (eg one dismissed the fact her DH once slept with a prostitute before their relationship began because he was young & naive….)

I could see the good eggs and the bad among my friends partners early on

I also know a few females who moan about being single but can’t see that they are massively hard work. Another friend is stupidly picky about looks etc despite being very average herself

However others have been unlucky eg friend who married a good man but he completely went off sex and wanted a sexless marriage . Was still a fab partner in other respects and a good dad

PurpleFlower1983 · 21/02/2024 07:15

I think most of the time the red flags are there, however subtle. Whether women notice them or choose to notice them is another matter.

Saltandpeppero · 21/02/2024 07:13

Some women will see the poor fathers and partners that they grew up with and fight extra hard to make sure they don't end up with a man like this. Some women know that they are more susceptible to being manipulated and less able to naturally identify red flags so they do the work needed to improve this.

My mum has poor judgement and has never been able to admit this to herself even though it manifested in her choice of husband, jobs, course she wanted to study and various other life decisions. I worked very hard not to end up with her lack of discernment or to end up with a man (my father) like she did. From my teens I began to address my innate naivety, to the extent people around me now generally see me as “wise” and discerning.

nottojog · 21/02/2024 07:12

I think a lot of relationships turn toxic due to the reluctance of one or both to admit that it has run its course. Children/finances keep people who shouldn't be together (love/respect has gone) and they spend years unhappily together, and then the bad behaviours begin and the blame game starts.

I think luck begins at the very start - meeting the one for you involves a little bit of luck.

Saltandpeppero · 21/02/2024 07:01

I agree with a lot of what most have said - you can say luck is involved to an extent as some people just had a bunch of bad choices to choose from , whereas others had better options to begin with.

However many women do ignore red flags. For instance I was talking to a (very handsome ) guy I’d met online dating and just a casual chat in the app over one night revealed so many red flags about him I just unmatched the next day.

He asked me what his job was before telling me what his was and his wasn’t displayed on his profile like mine was . That made me suspect he was possibly looking for someone to live off - I told him but then asked what I did. He said he did “some painting work” for houses his brothers renovates as he had been made redundant last year. He didn’t seem to have a plan for what was next.

I then asked him did he live with his brother? And he did, he lived with his brother and nephew.

He seemed confused when I asked him why he hadn’t married his ex who he was with for 7 years.

He has a degree but worked in a manual Job completely unrelated to that. And I don’t mean a well paid trade like joinery etc And now he was talking about studying “e-commerce” at a “night school” which no doubt is self-funded and he probably won’t use.

He was personable and polite but he was ultimately not a good match for me due to his lack of focus, and ambition.
I can see he’s just someone who will float through life. I could just see him moving in with me and struggling to financially contribute while never proposing, plus never pulling his weight.

If we’re all honest with ourselves when we meet guys, ask the right questions and really think about reality vs potential it would be better for all of us. I get why women settle out of desperation for kids but personally I couldn’t knowingly give my kids a sub-par lazy dad so as loud as my clock is ticking I have to maintain my standards.
If I didn’t, it would weigh heavily on my conscience.

I think society really needs to address the issue of a lack of good responsible men who have their life together though, instead of this AT /red pill stuff which is making men even more awful.

Bumpitybumper · 21/02/2024 06:57

SlumberDearMaid · 21/02/2024 06:07

I do think it is absolutely down to luck, but probably not for the same reason as you, @Shakespearesister

It is pure, dumb luck as to whether you’re born into a family with two loving parents, including a loving, caring, present, engaged Dad.

If that’s your role model, you’re pretty much gold. No guarantees of course, but you stand a much better chance of attracting and maintaining good men / and naturally repelling the dodgy ones.

I haven’t even had to send any bad men packing. I have nothing but good things to say about any of my exes. They were all lovely. Just not right for me! And my DH is as described in my second sentence above.

So yes, absolutely luck. I am lucky enough to have a rock, solid ‘shark cage’, due to nothing more or less than my upbringing.

I think we can stretch the definition of 'luck' to make almost anything fit. It is luck if you are born with the innate ability to read people and spot red flags that others can't. It's luck that you have the kind of upbringing and role models that set expectations of partners high and prevent you from settling for less. It's luck if you don't have the strong biological urge to have children that will drive you to settle for a partner earlier in order to facilitate having babies. The list could go on...

Personally I don't think it's massively helpful or really accurate to say because the above are at play then people's experiences of love and relationships are defined by luck. Ultimately we are all born with a mixed hand of attributes and things outside our control will happen in our lives that can shape us but importantly we also have autonomy and self determination. Some women will see the poor fathers and partners that they grew up with and fight extra hard to make sure they don't end up with a man like this. Some women know that they are more susceptible to being manipulated and less able to naturally identify red flags so they do the work needed to improve this.

I also think some women need to believe it's luck because they think there is shame attached to accepting that they have made an avoidable mistake when choosing their partner. This absolutely shouldn't be the case as these men are manipulative and some women are for a variety of reasons easier targets for them. This isn't the woman's 'fault' but she would be wise to work on what she can to stop the same happening again and increase her chances of spotting the bad eggs at a much earlier stage.

ImustLearn2Cook · 21/02/2024 06:52

The belief that our personality and our character is set and cannot change is a bit outdated. There has been plenty of evidence and research to prove otherwise.

People’s personality or character can change over time as we age, from environmental influences, life experiences etc. Personality can change from major life events. A kind, decent person can morph into a monstrous and cruel person because of a head injury causing brain damage, from taking drugs, from some kind of traumatic experience, for getting involved with the wrong crowd (breaking bad).

And some people who were immature, selfish or lazy can over time and growing up become more mature, considerate of others and a motivated person who does their fair share (self improvement).