Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that love and relationship success is largely due to luck?

206 replies

Shakespearesister · 20/02/2024 20:11

Definitely bitter and biased here but bare with me…

Im almost 40, 3 small children and my long term relationship is falling apart.
There are a multitude of reasons why but it got me thinking about all my friends who are in happy marriages and relationships.

Lots of them are in similar positions to me, with awful, selfish men who don’t want to grow up, debt issues, wanting to get drunk/take drugs far too often, lazy and not sharing the household chores/mental load.
These are lovely, moral, intelligent women... they deserve more.

I also have friends who are with wonderful men who put them first, do their fair share, act like adults and are hands on parents, look after their wives and kids and our family first. (Sadly, there are very much in the minority.)
I get that some women stay too long with idiots (like me) and that’s on them, but AIBU to think that a lot of time, the people we end up with is just luck/bad luck?

I had no way of knowing what kind of father my partner would be when we met, he was attentive, generous and kind but has slowly become a monster.
No one can foresee addiction issues, potential infidelity etc years in the future.

AIBU to think some people just get lucky in love? Or is this to simplistic.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
myphoneisbroken · 23/02/2024 13:57

I agree that it's not luck. I made a bad choice about who I started a family with. A lot of this was due to my ignorance about relationships. I genuinely didn't have a clue. I was looking for somebody "interesting" that I "had something in common with" and "shared interests". I didn't look twice at the guys who would have made brilliant dads, because I thought they were boring. More fool me - they are now the ones who are great dads, loyal partners, and have got a good sense of humour.

I do congratulate myself on realising what a liability XP was after our first child and getting out (even though I really wanted more children). He went on to have another child and another break-up.

toomuchfaff · 23/02/2024 13:49

I had no way of knowing what kind of father my partner would be when we met, he was attentive, generous and kind but has slowly become a monster.
No one can foresee addiction issues, potential infidelity etc years in the future.

You're right - you had no way to know, but you stayed despite him showing you signs, he showed you many many times over the years, each time he showed a little bit more than the last, he tested the boundaries, he wasn't a monster at first - he became one along the way, you didn't set clear boundaries - when he started down that slope - your actions didn't let him know it wasn't acceptable, by your action, you didn't let him know it stops here - he was able to continue his downward spiral to become the monster because you enabled him to treat you that way, you told him by your acceptance that he could continue, you didn't stop, you didn't leave.... you took him back, you made up after that argument, you let it slide that infidelity, or that snipe, or that comment... a bunch of flowers, a promise it wont happen again...

Its not luck. The people who have nicer relationships than you; who have met nicer men, who have nicer husbands - they had people who they split up with - they had monsters in the making - but they left them behind.

Fernsfernsferns · 23/02/2024 13:31

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/02/2024 21:35

Obviously it's partly luck. But I think the best way of avoiding marrying an arsehole is being willing to be single for a looong time, potentially forever, rather than settle for someone who shows even the tiniest signs of being a potential arsehole. And realising you don't owe any man a single date, never mind sex or a relationship. The luck element lies in how much of a natural good judge of character you are, and in the relationships and expectations you've had modelled to you growing up. And of course in whether many decent men cross your path.

Hmmm.

My experience could be described as that. And one read is it worked out. But another read I feel is closer to the truth is I got labelled as ‘not relationship material’ in my social group which repelled some relationships that could have been for me without that.

i was single my whole life, bar two short relationships until i met my now husband in my early 30s

(literally max 3-4 months active stage, though one had an following unhealthy friendship for longer afterwards until I woke up and cut him off).

certainly at the outset I was after the whole package.

what the movies tell you to hold out for, chemistry, friendship, intellectual equal, partner, supporter.

while I did have some issues of self worth as a teen and 20 something they were by no means out of kilter with friends who did more successfully get into relationships.

i was unlucky I think not to meet someone who ticked my boxes and me theirs to have the standard late teens / university starter relationship.

but I found overtime that my singleness became a source of both stigma and fascination in my social circle.

literally ‘what is wrong with Ferns’ was a legitimate topic, as was grilling me about my dating life for the vicarious thrills.

On paper I have a lot going for me and I never lacked for male attention.

i became seen as some radioactive combination of damaged goods and unattainable for no particular reason.

of course the cycle took its toll and eventually I took myself off to therapy and rebuilt my self esteem and drew some better boundaries.

the changes I made with friends were as impactful as how I dealt with men.

i stopped discussing my dating life with anyone to keep my centre but also to change the narrative ‘friends’ were by now projecting onto me.

15 years past that several male friends in the social circle seem
both surprised I have a successful marriage and family and regretful they didn’t see that potential in me.

ive learned that men are pack animals. They seek the approval of their peers subconsciously. They often get interested in the girls that are in relationships because it’s safe, and there is the social confirmation that they are ‘girlfriend material’ or maybe just attainable. They can go ‘well she’s with him but I’m better in this way so maybe she’d consider me’

friendship groups dynamics and social status matter a lot until at least your mid 20s. If I had my time over I’d play the game differently

Diamondshmiamond · 22/02/2024 19:34

In the words of Baz Luhrman " your life circumstances are half chance, so don't congratulate yourself too much or berate yourself too much either"

Half chance, as I do think judgement enters into it, but chance nonetheless.

Merryoldgoat · 21/02/2024 22:38

I also always wonder, when I see posts that outline a man's many varied faults over the course of several paragraphs but then end "but I still love him"... what do these posters think love is?

This baffles me too.

Dogknowsbest · 21/02/2024 21:43

I don't think it's all down to luck. I think it's a product of so many factors. Psychologists frequently say that happy long-term relationships are more likely to happen if you have a secure attachment style. Self awareness is also important, in knowing who you would be suited to and your life priorities. I've noticed it's reflected in my friendship group as well. The happiest couples I know seem to come from these strong families, understand what's worth tolerating and what isn't and want the same things. There's nothing special about them - they just know what to look for because they know what a good relationship looks like.

Unfortunately, for me and a lot of other people we were modelled sub-standard relationships so that's what we think is normal.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/02/2024 21:35

Obviously it's partly luck. But I think the best way of avoiding marrying an arsehole is being willing to be single for a looong time, potentially forever, rather than settle for someone who shows even the tiniest signs of being a potential arsehole. And realising you don't owe any man a single date, never mind sex or a relationship. The luck element lies in how much of a natural good judge of character you are, and in the relationships and expectations you've had modelled to you growing up. And of course in whether many decent men cross your path.

gannett · 21/02/2024 21:29

TempestTost · 21/02/2024 18:17

A lot of the shitty relationships I see around me, both partners have real issues. It's not just the men by any stretch.

In my work I see a certain amount of this too, the women tend to be looking for support, financially but also sometimes more like protection, and the way they engage is manipulative. The men are exploitative. Both seem to lie quite a bit.

This is true and actually I've known more men who've made terrible romantic choices than women. They do it for similar reasons - desperation, fear of being alone, desire for social status and very often just plain lust.

The thing is people who are motivated by those things will often find each other (that or they'll find an abusive manipulator who senses their vulnerability). Which obviously isn't a great recipe for a healthy relationship.

Far too many people, men and women, would rather be in a shitty relationship with literally anyone who'll have them than be alone. I really don't know how they get like that.

gannett · 21/02/2024 21:24

Doone22 · 21/02/2024 19:52

Arts, films, books, tv etc have all conspired to make people think love is important when actually having shared values is.

I also always wonder, when I see posts that outline a man's many varied faults over the course of several paragraphs but then end "but I still love him"... what do these posters think love is? Are they mistaking it for lust? Protection? Codependence? Because to me, thinking someone is a great person is a prerequisite for love. If I thought someone was selfish, abusive etc, I wouldn't love them.

thesleepyhoglet · 21/02/2024 20:55

I do agree that men don't necessarily change, but the circumstances around them do (eg more responsibility, family etc) and that can reveal character traits that weren't so obvious before.

If I was talking to younger self now, I would say- you met his family. You thought something was off. It was. The Apple usually doesn't fall far from the tree. And look especially at what his relationship is like with his mother

Duckduckgoes · 21/02/2024 20:21

Our parents and upbringing impact what we look for in our own romantic relationships, so in that sense it's down to luck.

I think a woman who is financially independent, saw her dad play an active role, had a strong support network, clear boundaries etc. would very rarely go for the deadbeats described here on MN.

Meanwhile another woman who comes from an unstable home, perhaps had previous abusive relationships, struggles to make ends meet, and lives far away from family could miss the warning signs.

Or could also be a woman who naively thinks it could never happen to her might miss red flags while a woman who has been burned before would be extra cautious.

Whichever it is, not sure I'd describe that as luck. More a consequence of personality and circumstance.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 21/02/2024 20:09

There's always going to be a little bit of luck but mostly it could be prevented.

Look at his parents. Most people turn out like their parents. Or older siblings.

Or fully discuss issues before marriage- who does the chores, who stays home when the DCs are sick, who moves for whose career, family money, sex, parenting styles, social lives post parenting.

Past behaviour predicts future behaviour.

If he's a party goer pre DCs he is likely to continue after.

Etc etc

Maarlia · 21/02/2024 20:01

Bumpitybumper · 20/02/2024 20:51

No, they most often don't act like twats on the first date and will go out of their way to charm the object of their affection but the whole point is that it is an act. Some people are more capable of seeing through the charade and spotting the red flags whilst others seem less able or willing to do this. You may well think the man has done a 180 and completely changed, but I imagine that if he is a real bastard then there were some signs all along.

I genuinely think it's an evolutionary thing and some people are just very good at reading people and seeing the true character beneath. This will obviously boost your chances when it comes to romance as you are more likely to understand the person that you are forming a relationship with and have an accurate idea of their deficiencies and whether you can tolerate them.

And women too, not just men.

Let’s not kid ourselves.

In my experience my sons’ wives changed too. One covered her issues whilst dating, because for religious reasons, she didn't want sex before marriage and then confessed to me during her marriage that she was only interested in sex to have a baby and hated every aspect of it. Made for a very difficult marriage and a rejected male.

The most balanced, open and honest relationship is the male partner of my gay son.

Doone22 · 21/02/2024 19:52

Shakespearesister · 20/02/2024 20:11

Definitely bitter and biased here but bare with me…

Im almost 40, 3 small children and my long term relationship is falling apart.
There are a multitude of reasons why but it got me thinking about all my friends who are in happy marriages and relationships.

Lots of them are in similar positions to me, with awful, selfish men who don’t want to grow up, debt issues, wanting to get drunk/take drugs far too often, lazy and not sharing the household chores/mental load.
These are lovely, moral, intelligent women... they deserve more.

I also have friends who are with wonderful men who put them first, do their fair share, act like adults and are hands on parents, look after their wives and kids and our family first. (Sadly, there are very much in the minority.)
I get that some women stay too long with idiots (like me) and that’s on them, but AIBU to think that a lot of time, the people we end up with is just luck/bad luck?

I had no way of knowing what kind of father my partner would be when we met, he was attentive, generous and kind but has slowly become a monster.
No one can foresee addiction issues, potential infidelity etc years in the future.

AIBU to think some people just get lucky in love? Or is this to simplistic.

Arts, films, books, tv etc have all conspired to make people think love is important when actually having shared values is.

RawBloomers · 21/02/2024 19:37

Vonesk · 21/02/2024 19:22

To be honest, I think thats its unrealistic to think that men will view household jobs the same as women.
Just a example : there are signs in a local public toilet say ' Warning, these toillets are serviced by Male cleaners' these toilets were constructed with a section in the sink area with a 'seat' for nursing mothers. The actual cubicles are FILTHY and never clean.....I rest my case.

When you wrote this, did you have in your head a more complex line of argument that leads from your example to your initial assertion that you didn’t type out? Because what you’ve written does not work.

Vonesk · 21/02/2024 19:22

To be honest, I think thats its unrealistic to think that men will view household jobs the same as women.
Just a example : there are signs in a local public toilet say ' Warning, these toillets are serviced by Male cleaners' these toilets were constructed with a section in the sink area with a 'seat' for nursing mothers. The actual cubicles are FILTHY and never clean.....I rest my case.

Crumpleton · 21/02/2024 19:12

I do sometimes sit and ponder why it's mainly women that post on here re men being abusive/controlling/shit fathers etc yet it's women that bring these men into the world and in the main bring them up.

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 21/02/2024 19:04

What are we classing as a great relationship though?
I know for a fact that many many women ( and a few men) have stuck with very abusive men. They remained married to them until their dying day.
To the outside world they had met their ‘perfect match.’ But in reality this was far from the truth.
2 of my ex’s had violent fathers. These men beat their wives, spoke to them, and treated them like a piece of shit. Both will stay with their men until they die.
Again they would probably say to outsiders they have a good marriage. I only know different because their sons told me the truth.
Other relationships break down even though one party is happy. Sometimes the other just wants to leave.
I don’t think there are many first time around truly happy relationships. The number of blended families proves that point.
It is hard to be alone. Doing things alone. I think a lot of people want more than the other one wants to give. I finished it with an ex because he wanted full on commitment and I didn’t. I was happy to be exclusive but I didn’t want to live with him 100% of the time. He wanted marriage.
I have a friend and she found the same thing.
It’s complicated.

2mummies1baby · 21/02/2024 18:47

I think there is a certain amount of luck involved, but it's not as significant as upbringing (and other formative experiences) and personality type. How else do you explain the women who get rid of one terrible, abusive man only to end up with another one? I'd imagine their fathers have a hell of a lot to answer for in most cases...

5128gap · 21/02/2024 18:26

I think there's a huge amount of luck involved. A lot of the things that put a marriage under strain are bad luck. The economic climate, job loss, health issues, fertility problems, bereavement. Then there's the good look in choosing a partner who retains the qualities they had when you met them, and continues to love and value you, doesn't tire of you or meet someone they prefer to you. There's obviously a lot you can do to stack the odds in your favour, avoid red flags, work at the relationship and so on, but ultimately you have I think only a 50/50 chance of your relationship lasting? If there's no bad luck involved there must an awful lot of bad decision making.

Jurgenkloppsweddingring · 21/02/2024 18:19

ChilliPB · 21/02/2024 10:06

It’s not down to luck. Its priorities. My friends who married crap men generally did so because they wanted to settle down/have kids/buy a house earlier and so did that with the man that was available at that time. Many of them knew what he was like but chose to ignore. The ones that had higher standards and prioritised that, ended up with much better men.

@ChilliPB exactly!

TempestTost · 21/02/2024 18:17

A lot of the shitty relationships I see around me, both partners have real issues. It's not just the men by any stretch.

In my work I see a certain amount of this too, the women tend to be looking for support, financially but also sometimes more like protection, and the way they engage is manipulative. The men are exploitative. Both seem to lie quite a bit.

TempestTost · 21/02/2024 17:51

Garlickit · 21/02/2024 03:11

Very much in agreement with this. People who didn't come from dysfunctional backgrounds always seem to think it's something you can just "get over". The reality is that most of us never even knew they were dysfunctional. What you know of life is what you know, there's no magical state of detachment giving an informed overview of family dynamics.

So I picked men who were less-worse than my father, but I behaved very much as my mother had. I saw red flags but was not equipped to grasp their significance. Worst of all, I overlooked nice, sane, decent, well-balanced men. They didn't compute as potential partners - and, in any case, it's unlikely they would've stuck with me for any length of time.

All that is luck. Until we achieve my dream society, in which everyone does therapy as a matter of course, it will continue to affect a large proportion of relationships.

Luck affects things in other ways, too. Perfect self-determination is a fallacy. For instance, I'm not even bothering to think about a relationship any more because I have a debilitating illness and live in a place with very few potentially compatible residents. It's just not a good use of my time under the circumstances. You or family members can get sick, your industry can collapse, war can break out ... our lives are impacted by events beyond our control all the time!

Along with "therapy for all", I want to see a world in which women ditch inadequate partners faster and more decisively. Too many men get away with being selfish dickheads because they can. They should start finding out that they can't!

I am not sure people think it's necessarily easy to change such behaviours. But it's the only way to improve things, so it's about the only advice you can give someone.

Roselilly36 · 21/02/2024 16:48

I agree OP, finding the right partner is purely down to luck. And I say this as a woman about to celebrate their Pearl Wedding.

Jurgenkloppsweddingring · 21/02/2024 16:45

@KimberleyClark exactly what I was trying to get across in my post: The man is just a vessel to achieve the woman's dream of children, a wedding etc. So basically just using them and/or making poor choices of partners. Once those babies come along, the man is, as you say, surplus to requirements, ignored and discarded, or simply kept around to help pay the mortgage and bills/finance her to be a SAHM