Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH being selfish not wanting to give DD the money

518 replies

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

OP posts:
DuesToTheDirt · 20/02/2024 20:17

Another vote for Team DH!

squirrelnutkin10 · 20/02/2024 20:18

Sadly op you are on the receiving end of the politics of envy with many posters.
Yes your family are fortunate but that does not mean your DD should not benefit and why not, it is your DH's grandparents earned money.
I would however not give all the £140, 000 as well as the inheritance but put a hefty chunk ..maybe 100K into a good savings fund.
One reason is should she marry and eventually divorce she could lose half her property, including her inheritance,,sad as that is to think about..
I have lived in London and with a 400k deposit and a job in finance it is likely she would be able to raise at least another 400K herself giving her 800K to buy in a decent area.
Then you all have a safety net/nest egg too, and your husband and you,could use the 40K for fun/holidays etc.
Ignore those who are bitter!

mfbx5sf3 · 20/02/2024 20:18

How much would the extra money impact your life OP? I am all for children first- but sometimes it’s ok to give yourself a bit of joy

Isitovernow123 · 20/02/2024 20:18

Hi Op

Well done for raising a child for is well adjusted for life, albeit with a few advantages many will never get.

i am with your DH on this one - the money was saved to help your daughter out but, with this money from your mother, she’ll never need it.

I really like the idea of splitting the money, so you can pay for a wedding etc, but also enjoy more of your lives left together- you never know how long you have, regardless of how long you parents/grandparents live for.

Two thing to consider for the future though.

Are your DH and SiL happy to pay inheritance tax on this money should your MiL die within 7 years of your daughter receiving it?

Do your PiL have enough money/property to pay for care if they need it in the future? Doesn’t matter how far ahead, any council can look at this as potential deprivation of assets.

Genevieva · 20/02/2024 20:18

I’m with you husband on this. She is a very lucky girl that her lovely family are so keen for her to get the bulk of her great grandparents’ estate. She also sounds like a very lovely girl who would recognise this and want you to enjoy your savings. Keep some aside for a wedding and some more aside for your own safety net (you are still young enough to need this) but also live a little.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/02/2024 20:20

EarringsandLipstick · 20/02/2024 18:27

He’s agreed we should keep a wedding fund (or whatever you want to call it) and offer some money towards decor and furnishing.

I think this is madness. She's getting so much. She doesn't need any more help with decor & furnishing. Keep your money. Perhaps something you can't now anticipate will happen in the future, needing significant cash.

But it’s also important we give our DD all we can.

No it's not. It's important that you support her, and your personal circumstances mean you can do this far more than most. You are loving parents and that's wonderful, but it doesn't have to be boundless.

I’ve felt a little attacked for wanting to support my DD and like some people think she shouldn’t be given anything.
No they don't. But there's a big difference between 'not anything' & 'everything'

I can’t imagine anyone who could help their child out to this extent not wanting to.

Really? You are already doing loads. DD will get far more than any other immediate family member.

Or are we all stuck in a “I struggled so everyone else should too” mindset

But you didn't struggle. DD is not struggling and will not. Why do it to such excess?

@HelnPink

this OP

Iwasafool · 20/02/2024 20:21

BIossomtoes · 20/02/2024 19:05

Exactly that. Whatever OP maintains this is someone who will never know the satisfaction of buying anything that she’s gone without to save up for. It’s quite sad really.

Oh to have the opportunity to be that sad.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 20/02/2024 20:21

I don’t think anyone is saying not to give your daughter anything but this is half a million pounds! More than most people will ever dream of. Also can you take over from Martin Lewis as a money saving expert as I for one cannot fathom how 2 teachers can have a fully paid mortgage, enough savings for their own retirement and care and a “spare” £140k sloshing around!

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/02/2024 20:27

BirthdayRainbow · 20/02/2024 19:24

Your husband is a tight arse. I have zero tolerance for useless dads after my h whinged about one of the kids asking for another few pounds a week for food.

Why should he benefit because his dds grandma has decided to be so lovely and generous. He begrudges his own child ffs.

@BirthdayRainbow

you are so right! He should give his daughter his house as well as his inheritance. She could rent it out or something! And he can live in a shed and be happy about it.

goody2shooz · 20/02/2024 20:30

@HelnPink well it’s a nice problem to have! I agree with pp saying she should get all the inheritance from the other family members, and you keep what you saved. Will your dd have tax implications on the larger amount of inheritance though?

serin · 20/02/2024 20:33

TooOldForThisNonsense · 20/02/2024 20:21

I don’t think anyone is saying not to give your daughter anything but this is half a million pounds! More than most people will ever dream of. Also can you take over from Martin Lewis as a money saving expert as I for one cannot fathom how 2 teachers can have a fully paid mortgage, enough savings for their own retirement and care and a “spare” £140k sloshing around!

Well I imagine OP bought when houses were much cheaper. In 1994, our 4 bed detached, with an acre garden, was £80k. Ordinary people were able to buy decent family homes and still have money left over to live.

SkaterGrrrrl · 20/02/2024 20:34

I agree 100% with DH and am certainly not bitter or envious, having received a significant house deposit from my own parents.

ScribblingPixie · 20/02/2024 20:34

I'm really glad you are going to keep some 'fun' money and tell your sister-in-law to do the same. Yes, housing is expensive in London but the inheritance you've talked about will mean that your DD can bypass the lower rungs and can choose somewhere safe and secure. She has a good job and will be able to work towards her own goals in relative comfort at a very young age. Hopefully all of you can enjoy the next few decades together; don't sacrifice your own lives, OP, there's no need.

Winter2020 · 20/02/2024 20:35

If your daughter can buy a reasonable place without the extra money then I would just keep the savings as a rainy day fund for all of you.

I appreciate that you have other savings but you never know if you/your partner/ your daughter will have a health emergency and be unable to work again.

Your daughter might have a family one day and a big mortgage and your savings might allow her to take a longer maternity leave or to go part time for a while - or to help her pay crippling childcare for a couple of years.

Just spending the savings hard won over 24 years because there is no immediate need seems a shame.

Just to add that your husband's sister sounds amazing to genuinely not mind her niece receiving inheritance some of which would usually pass down the generations and reach her.

Zanatdy · 20/02/2024 20:40

Some of these comments are ridiculous so I can see why OP has ducked out. I think some generations find it hard to help kids out. My parents generation especially, my mum thinks it’s odd my ex will gift our kids a chunky deposit (not this amount) and although she would loan me 10k or so towards my own deposit (thanks to also living near london I’m 47 and still down own but will soon) she wouldn’t ever hand over half her life savings to my brother and I despite both of us living in flats for example. Nor do I expect her to, I really don’t. But I think for our kids generation it really is going to be hard for many of them to buy what my parents generation had - a family home for 20k!

I earn 3-4 times what my parents did on a single salary but have always struggled due to living in the south. I am intending to head back north soon. I think a lot of people resent people being handed a leg up when they work so hard themselves and struggle. That’s why you’re getting a hard time OP. I’m sure if most posters were in your situation they’d be happy for your daughter to get 400k. It really will still mean a mortgage of 300k or so and probably still only get a tiny house or a flat. That’s the reality of london prices. I still don’t think you should be giving her the extra 140k though. Maybe your husband would like to buy a holiday home or something with that money, something her children would enjoy. Also remember she might be in a similar boat your husband and you when she needs to buy a family home, as she’s not married yet and she could be in a good position with double income to buy something. She will need to ensure she protects that money / investment from future husband too

marshmallowburn · 20/02/2024 20:45

You seem to have an awful lot of money for 2 teachers in yyour early 50's but maybe teachers are paid well in the UK?
I'm with your DH. Take long service leave and go on a world trip. Come back and work part time if it makes you happy.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 20/02/2024 20:47

BIossomtoes · 20/02/2024 19:05

Exactly that. Whatever OP maintains this is someone who will never know the satisfaction of buying anything that she’s gone without to save up for. It’s quite sad really.

I have to take exception to this (unfort, as I normally agree with your posts!).

Firstly, OP has said her DD doesn’t know about any of this money, the 140k or the 425k. She had help at university relative to many - but she also had a job at university unlike many. I suspect she does know what it’s like to save up for something, to make choices.

Secondly, the satisfaction you have described isn’t one that strikes me as especially meaningful. There’s nothing quite like the satisfaction of “I earned this” - but that’s a very different thing. If I can spare my children from “I suffered for this”, I would. I would NEVER deny them the satisfaction of earning their way in life, financially or otherwise. But why not spare them suffering? Suffering doesn’t make one’s life better, or morally superior. It doesn’t confer a higher level of understanding or replace empathy. It’s not necessary to a fulfilled, useful and moral life.

ThinWomansBrain · 20/02/2024 20:47

YABU - £425k would buy a 1 bed flat in Brixton outright.

AppropriateAdult · 20/02/2024 21:01

OP, I know when 90% of the replies are all saying the same thing it can feel like a bit of a pile-on, but taken individually most of the responses have been fairly measured. For what it's worth, your daughter sounds like a lovely person, and I agree with you that being financially supported isn't the same as being 'spoilt'. But calling your husband greedy and selfish just seems wildly out of proportion to what he's done, which is to make the very reasonable suggestion that almost half a million pounds is enough to gve your daughter ample comfort and security for the time being, and might allow you both to enjoy the money you've worked so hard to save. The fact that you had earmarked it for her does not mean there's anything ethically dubious about changing that plan now - the family's financial status has changed significantly, so of course you can reassess your own situation. The idea of aging parents doing without so that more money can be heaped onto a child who is already well set up for life seems really joyless to me, and is not an example I'd want to set for my own children.

Lollipop81 · 20/02/2024 21:03

I’m with you. You saved it for your child, I would give it her too. Your clearly comfortable without the money.

PaminaMozart · 20/02/2024 21:04

StevieNicksWannabe · 20/02/2024 16:46

Whatever you decide to do...make sure your daughter, if she decides to move in with or marry someone down the line, protects her deposit.

THIS ^....... absolutely.

Also, what about the tax implications of the various proposals regarding these monies? I've not got a clue, but I'd certainly look into this

Alwaystired23 · 20/02/2024 21:05

I think the 1st thing you should do is speak to your DD and see what she thinks/wants to do and take it from there. Your dh is not greedy or selfish. What's the rush to give her all this money now? She's just finding her feet in life, give her a chance. My parents recently gifted me 10k towards my new car. As much as I appreciate it, I also felt embarrassed. You don't know how she might feel about it all.

Cornishclio · 20/02/2024 21:11

Whilst I understand your desire and the rest of the familys desire to help your DD on to the property ladder I think you should be disclosing to your DHs parents and sister that you have also been saving for her. Maybe they think that unless they give her virtually all of her GMs inheritance buying a property in London is not possible. Whereas as you have saved too technically she does not need as much as £425k for a deposit especially as she is so young. Why a 4 bed house at only 24? Your MIL may then feel that a bigger share should go to her, your DH and his sister providing the amount your DD gets is enough to buy a house. Are you she even wants to do that at her age? She may eventually decide she does not want to stay in London. Supposing she uses the lot to go travelling the world and packs up her job? Would you and her GM be happy with that or does the money come with strings that it has to be spent on something you feel worthwhile like a property?

I also think your DH is not being unreasonable in thinking that the inheritance is a large enough gift that some of your savings could be used for your benefit either as fun money now or maybe an early retirement fund. You may not want to retire early but maybe he does.

We helped our daughters too but not to the extent that you are considering as we thought they needed to show some commitment to managing their money well before giving them large financial gifts and we had two children so naturally we treat them the same. I shared my inheritance 50/50 with my children with me keeping half and the other half divided among them. I also think that part of being an adult means that you take responsibility yourself for providing by working and saving. You are taking that away from your DD by handing her it all on a plate.

Illbebythesea · 20/02/2024 21:13

450k is more than most people will ever inherit in their entire lives, she doesn’t need any more than that!!

Epidote · 20/02/2024 21:16

I'm with your husband here. The large amount of money is unexpected but very welcome. It will ease your DD life towards a mortgage and also you can enjoy your own savings.