Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH being selfish not wanting to give DD the money

518 replies

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

OP posts:
Xyz1234567 · 20/02/2024 18:34

However nice your daughter may be she is 100% spoilt rotten. I don't think you are actually doing her any favours by handing everything in life to her on a plate - and by God that is certainly what you are doing.

Just because the money is there, you don't have to give it to her. Let her strive a bit and feel proud of achieving something independently - and let your poor husband have a break. He has a stressful job and I am sure deserves to benefit from his own efforts and hard work.
Without being rude your descriptions of your perfect daughter are very saccharine and OTT.

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 18:35

My parents gave me this deposit but they did not do so at the expense of anything they wanted to do. I have never felt more important than them and I think that is how you're setting her up to feel.

This seems key. I plan to travel the world when I retire, and I would not be impressed if my DH decided the DC needed that money instead, even for a house deposit.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:37

Xyz1234567 · 20/02/2024 18:34

However nice your daughter may be she is 100% spoilt rotten. I don't think you are actually doing her any favours by handing everything in life to her on a plate - and by God that is certainly what you are doing.

Just because the money is there, you don't have to give it to her. Let her strive a bit and feel proud of achieving something independently - and let your poor husband have a break. He has a stressful job and I am sure deserves to benefit from his own efforts and hard work.
Without being rude your descriptions of your perfect daughter are very saccharine and OTT.

I don’t think we have the same description of spoilt.
To me spoilt is not related to the quantity of money/gifts but the attitude to receiving.

OP posts:
HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:37

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 18:35

My parents gave me this deposit but they did not do so at the expense of anything they wanted to do. I have never felt more important than them and I think that is how you're setting her up to feel.

This seems key. I plan to travel the world when I retire, and I would not be impressed if my DH decided the DC needed that money instead, even for a house deposit.

We have money to travel, especially now we are mortgage free, we could travel every school holiday if we wanted to!

OP posts:
Mirabai · 20/02/2024 18:38

With pensions, our homes and savings we have ensured our care is covered. But it’s also important we give our DD all we can.

Can you do care for 10 years @ £70k pa + inflation if necessary?

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 18:39

You seem to have a lot of spare money, OP. I don't mean this in a sarcastic way at all; it's good to read when there are so many posts from people having a hard time. I think you still have to arrive at some compromise with your Dh, though.

Honestly anyone working as a risk analyst in a bank is not going to struggle that much.

Yorkshireknitter · 20/02/2024 18:41

How much to give to your DD is a decision for your family to make together.

Once that decision is made, please start to have open conversations with your DD about money and make sure that the money is properly protected from potential cocklodgers taking advantage of her. While she has a nice BF now, that may change.

Giving her confidence to talk about and plan what to do with money, both earned and inherited, is also an important gift.

Mirabai · 20/02/2024 18:41

Despite all the dark mutterings on this thread, I grew up with wealthy friends who were all given similar nesteggs at a comparable age and they’re all fine, well-adjusted, hard-working, it didn’t really affect their view of life. And they all managed to avoid marrying Jane Austen cads, bounty hunters and cocklodgers! Really, this is all very quaint.

spriots · 20/02/2024 18:41

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:37

We have money to travel, especially now we are mortgage free, we could travel every school holiday if we wanted to!

But your DH clearly doesn't agree and feels like he could happily use some of his life savings.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:42

I’m going to step away from this thread, it’s upsetting and it’s absurd to me that people continue to call my DD spoilt when they don’t know her at all.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 20/02/2024 18:44

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:42

I’m going to step away from this thread, it’s upsetting and it’s absurd to me that people continue to call my DD spoilt when they don’t know her at all.

I get it OP, it’s just that it’s more money than many people on MN dream of so it brings out all manner of reaction.

Xyz1234567 · 20/02/2024 18:44

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:37

I don’t think we have the same description of spoilt.
To me spoilt is not related to the quantity of money/gifts but the attitude to receiving.

Well of course we don't! Your daughter, as I said, may be lovely. You are spoiling her life by giving her so much , she will never feel any pride in achieving things herself. It is you at fault, not your daughter!

Pogpog21 · 20/02/2024 18:44

Wow! A lot of very envious people here. Your daughter is very lucky. What a fabulous way to start life when prices are so mad.

The 425 is completely seperate to what you planned for her and I don’t think it should come into it. However as you know she is soon to inherit this early lump sum you could hold on to the savings you’ve built up for her for a while and gain interest in it while you see how things pan out over the next few years.

DHs mum should make it clear that the 425 is to put down on a house / flat and you should all tell her that it’s been agreed it’ll go to her in the most part so she can do just that. Ensure she does that and then see how the lay of the land is in a year or two and hold on to the money in the meantime. You are getting a little bit of the remaining inheritance so you can still enjoy a holiday/ fun stuff this year and next year using that money rather than touching the other money.

ps are you looking for a second daughter? :):))

NoraBattysCurlers · 20/02/2024 18:45

You are living in cloud-cuckoo land, @HelnPink

You are early 50s and could live another 50 years if the GGPs are anything to go by. The cost of living will increase in the coming decades and the real value of pensions will decline considerably. The money that you all passed up is probably money that you will very badly need someday. You have been incredibly naive.

It seems the only sensible pair here were the GGPs. At least, they managed to remain in their own home until they passed away at nearly one hundred.

spriots · 20/02/2024 18:45

Most of my friends were given big house deposits, some were given houses outright.

Those given deposits, even big deposits, have continued to work hard and get on in life.

Those given houses outright - that's a much more mixed picture. A few of those have basically wasted a lot of time on obscure artistic careers - trying to write novels, music career, one a failed circus artist.

Butterdishy · 20/02/2024 18:45

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:42

I’m going to step away from this thread, it’s upsetting and it’s absurd to me that people continue to call my DD spoilt when they don’t know her at all.

I think people are just concerned that your quest to give your daughter the world on a plate might be at your own (or your husbands!) detriment.

Medsy · 20/02/2024 18:45

The truly "ungreedy" thing to do would he to make some donations, especially as you are frobtline public sector workers, you must see all around you that hard working, "deserving" people nevertheless die in poverty... Yet you are thinking it would be good to give your daughter £££K to spend on "furnishings".
I'm really surprised by the attitude coming from public sector workers.
I'm also surprised someone with teacher parents and GP aunt/uncle would decide to go and work in a bank (it's not a crime, just unusual)
Also not sure why you are getting so involved when none of these funds are actually yours if I've read rightly: it's your husbands parents and husbands sisters money at stake here.
Last but not least, I can't imagine a world where my mother would know what I have in my sandwich every day, but not what I earn.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 18:50

Medsy · 20/02/2024 18:45

The truly "ungreedy" thing to do would he to make some donations, especially as you are frobtline public sector workers, you must see all around you that hard working, "deserving" people nevertheless die in poverty... Yet you are thinking it would be good to give your daughter £££K to spend on "furnishings".
I'm really surprised by the attitude coming from public sector workers.
I'm also surprised someone with teacher parents and GP aunt/uncle would decide to go and work in a bank (it's not a crime, just unusual)
Also not sure why you are getting so involved when none of these funds are actually yours if I've read rightly: it's your husbands parents and husbands sisters money at stake here.
Last but not least, I can't imagine a world where my mother would know what I have in my sandwich every day, but not what I earn.

Considering the poor treatment of public sector workers these days, I’m glad she has gone down the private route. She was never interested in a public sector job but had she been I’d have discouraged it.

OP posts:
ViciousCurrentBun · 20/02/2024 18:51

All she needs to know regardless of the exact amount decided on is how to protect her deposit whatever that may be if she does ever marry.

tachetastic · 20/02/2024 18:52

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

I think it is always difficult where family money is being discussed, and I agree that your MIL has the absolute right to give your DD all the money she wants, but I do see your DH's point of view (in my mind), that maybe 250k of that money would have come to him to help you both in your retirement had his mother not decided to bypass him and give it directly to her DGD.

So maybe his logic is that, as your own financial security may no longer be what he expected it to be, and as your DD's financial security is now better than ever (and possibly better than your own), perhaps you need the buffer more than she does, and anything you don't spend will end up with her anyway, but not for 30 or 40 years, which may be a nice bonus for her nest egg then.

And it doesn't sound like the two of you will burn through that money, whereas your DD might if she doesn't need it for a house deposit. I think you may be a safer pair of hands for that money until she really needs it later.

I'm with him.

Iwasafool · 20/02/2024 18:52

Medsy · 20/02/2024 18:45

The truly "ungreedy" thing to do would he to make some donations, especially as you are frobtline public sector workers, you must see all around you that hard working, "deserving" people nevertheless die in poverty... Yet you are thinking it would be good to give your daughter £££K to spend on "furnishings".
I'm really surprised by the attitude coming from public sector workers.
I'm also surprised someone with teacher parents and GP aunt/uncle would decide to go and work in a bank (it's not a crime, just unusual)
Also not sure why you are getting so involved when none of these funds are actually yours if I've read rightly: it's your husbands parents and husbands sisters money at stake here.
Last but not least, I can't imagine a world where my mother would know what I have in my sandwich every day, but not what I earn.

The OP might give plenty to charity, she doesn't need to tell you about it.

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 18:53

I also come from a very long lived family. My GG died at 101 and my granny at 97. I can afford to give my DC house deposits, but I think I may need it for my own care.

Toptotoe · 20/02/2024 18:54

I’d keep the £140k. £425k will give her a good deposit on a house.

Mostlyoblivious · 20/02/2024 18:56

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:41

She is aware we have savings for DD too, she has historically spent more on DD than us. She and her husband are both GPs and are fairly comfortable, they aren’t worried about finances at all and want DD to have the best start.

It might be slightly contentious that you keep the cash you’ve saved whilst they helped support her during those years - had you not saved they could have reasonably contributed less.

Autumn1990 · 20/02/2024 18:57

a significant number of people only buy a house due to family help. That’s how I got a house.
The only thing that’s important is that when she has a significant relationship that her capital in the property is protected