Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH being selfish not wanting to give DD the money

518 replies

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

OP posts:
CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 19:26

BirthdayRainbow · 20/02/2024 19:24

Your husband is a tight arse. I have zero tolerance for useless dads after my h whinged about one of the kids asking for another few pounds a week for food.

Why should he benefit because his dds grandma has decided to be so lovely and generous. He begrudges his own child ffs.

Eh? Yours is a completely different situation. The OPs husband wants to keep part of his own savings. Not grab the inheritance.

BirthdayRainbow · 20/02/2024 19:24

Your husband is a tight arse. I have zero tolerance for useless dads after my h whinged about one of the kids asking for another few pounds a week for food.

Why should he benefit because his dds grandma has decided to be so lovely and generous. He begrudges his own child ffs.

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 19:22

SallyWD · 20/02/2024 19:20

Seeing that no one else in your family seems to want money, it's highly likely that your daughter will also inherit her grandmother's house, your house and by the looks of it, her aunt's house too! Surely this is all too much. Will she ever actually value money? I think of the satisfaction DH and I got from working and saving to buy everything we had. If we'd just been given it on a plate I don't think we'd have appreciated it the same way.
I'm sure she's a wonderful person but she sounds very indulged by the whole family.

What do you think we should all do with our homes then?

OP posts:
samarrange · 20/02/2024 19:21

Almost every "How to live longer" thing that you can do, whether it's eating more spinach v less bacon, or cutting down on drinking, or whatever, only buys you time that is both (a) statistical — not much point in upping your spinach if you, as an individual, are going to get run over by a bus — and (b) at the end of your days. More time in the nursing home, in other words.

In contrast, £140,000 after tax probably (depending on your income and expenses) represents three whole years of early retirement, maybe more. And it's front-loaded: you get those extra three (etc) years when you are 63 instead of 66, or whenever you were otherwise planning to retire. If you can reasonably expect to get to, say, 75 with both of you in good enough health to fully live the retirement you want, that would means 33% more great years.

So keep the money. Compared to £425,000 it will barely touch the sides, and as others have said, DD will inherit from you when the time comes. Obviously don't blow it on reckless living, but trade it for time. DD sounds lovely and I'm sure she would not hold it against you even if she knew of your plans.

CountryFrost · 20/02/2024 19:21

I think it’s incredible that you have worked and invested so hard in your daughter’s future. Personally if I was comfortable financially (which it sounds you both are), I would keep to the plan of giving her the savings. Her grandmother giving her money is an unrelated factor

SallyWD · 20/02/2024 19:20

Seeing that no one else in your family seems to want money, it's highly likely that your daughter will also inherit her grandmother's house, your house and by the looks of it, her aunt's house too! Surely this is all too much. Will she ever actually value money? I think of the satisfaction DH and I got from working and saving to buy everything we had. If we'd just been given it on a plate I don't think we'd have appreciated it the same way.
I'm sure she's a wonderful person but she sounds very indulged by the whole family.

DodoTired · 20/02/2024 19:17

The best thing for your DD (now that she’s pretty much sorted with her own property in London) would be not to be saddled with her parents’ care costs later in life. How much money really you have for that, as it’s very expensive? Next best thing would be seeing her parents enjoying nice retirement after all the hard work they put in.

so Im with your husband in this situation.
she is also going to be high earner, which is wonderful, so you can now focus on yourself.

congratulations on raising loving and caring daughter btw

Tbry24 · 20/02/2024 19:14

When your daughter turns 30give her what you and your husband have saved, I’d personally not even give her that but have it in a savings pot judt incase you need it.

your DHs mum should keep ALL of her inheritance, that is for her to enjoy her life as her parents wanted. Then in her will she should leave it 50/50 for her son and daughter. The granddaughter does not get all of it at 25 when th rest of you still have life’s to live and enjoy.

Nobadvibes · 20/02/2024 19:13

The comments on this thread are the most bizarre comments I’ve ever seen. Why are people so triggered by this situation. Inheriting money is hardly spoilt, parents saving hardly spoilt.

I would top up to 500k houses/ flats are expensive in London. Even if she buys a flat she’s benefiting from paying off a mortgage and not rent. It would be an investment, plus the property market in London seems to be constantly in reading.

GardnerAva · 20/02/2024 19:12

@HelnPink you sound like an amazing parent. You probably didn't need to post this as no doubt people will have very different life experiences and ideas on what you should do. You know your family and daughter best. She's lucky to have you. In your case I'd do exactly the same , down to insisting at least some of what was saved for her went to her. Try not to feel bad about the thread

isthewashingdryyet · 20/02/2024 19:10

You won’t need a wedding fund for her as she is someone who shouldn’t get married in order to protect herself.

isn’t the advice to wait a year after getting a life changing sum of money, to see where best to spend it

Movinghouseatlast · 20/02/2024 19:08

I agree with your husband. Life is short, you should use your savings to enjoy yourselves.

I just don't get people who scrimp and save for their children. Then the children scrimp and save for their children and so it goes on.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/02/2024 19:07

I am with your husband. She has a great amount as a house deposit and is getting some more for fun. Keep some aside for wedding/ when she has a child but keep some back for yourselves to have fun with. Go part time, travel and enjoy yourselves.

BIossomtoes · 20/02/2024 19:05

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 19:00

Literally every bit of advice on MN that is contrary to what the OP suggests is dismissed as "the green-eyed monster"and "you must be jealous." Not jealous here. There are other reasons to disagree.

Exactly that. Whatever OP maintains this is someone who will never know the satisfaction of buying anything that she’s gone without to save up for. It’s quite sad really.

Butterdishy · 20/02/2024 19:01

Regardless of what you decide, I'm not sure a 4 bed in Clapham is a realistic or necessary goal at all. You don't have to provide your DD with the exact same opportunity you had when her circumstances are very different.

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 19:00

Literally every bit of advice on MN that is contrary to what the OP suggests is dismissed as "the green-eyed monster"and "you must be jealous." Not jealous here. There are other reasons to disagree.

cansu · 20/02/2024 19:00

You are being greedy on your dd behalf. That is a very significant amount. The money you had saved is no longer needed. I agree with your husband.

Gerwurtztraminer · 20/02/2024 18:58

Ignore all the green eyed monsters on the thread OP. Of course you want to help her out and it's fantastic that you can. You know your daughter and that she will be grateful and isn't 'entitled/spoilt' etc.

I don't think many of them have a clue what you get in the London property market. I'm in a slightly run down 1960's block of flats on the edge of Zone2/3 and my 2 bedroom is probably worth around £450K at the moment - which astonishes me! As you say, even with a large mortgage she's highly unlikely to be buying much more than a flat (albeit a large one) on Clapham or Brixton. Depending on how long out of her Post grade she is, her salary is likely to be between £45-60K. Most banks for a first time buyer would loan around 3.5x salary, maybe even as much as 4.5x (but thats risky), so max of say £150k - £250K mortgage. Add that to her inheritance deposit and something from you & DH and you are right, it's around £700K - £800K maximum, which will not buy a terraced house at all, less alone 3-4 bedrooms!

Sounds like you and DH hopefully can reach a compromise about how to spend the £140K savings and still have some fun for yourselves. It sounds like his list of things can be done without using 'her' savings but even if you do spend a bit it still leaves plenty in reserve. (I do think keeping some funds back for the unexpected in the future is a good idea).

Autumn1990 · 20/02/2024 18:57

a significant number of people only buy a house due to family help. That’s how I got a house.
The only thing that’s important is that when she has a significant relationship that her capital in the property is protected

Mostlyoblivious · 20/02/2024 18:56

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 15:41

She is aware we have savings for DD too, she has historically spent more on DD than us. She and her husband are both GPs and are fairly comfortable, they aren’t worried about finances at all and want DD to have the best start.

It might be slightly contentious that you keep the cash you’ve saved whilst they helped support her during those years - had you not saved they could have reasonably contributed less.

Toptotoe · 20/02/2024 18:54

I’d keep the £140k. £425k will give her a good deposit on a house.

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 18:53

I also come from a very long lived family. My GG died at 101 and my granny at 97. I can afford to give my DC house deposits, but I think I may need it for my own care.

Iwasafool · 20/02/2024 18:52

Medsy · 20/02/2024 18:45

The truly "ungreedy" thing to do would he to make some donations, especially as you are frobtline public sector workers, you must see all around you that hard working, "deserving" people nevertheless die in poverty... Yet you are thinking it would be good to give your daughter £££K to spend on "furnishings".
I'm really surprised by the attitude coming from public sector workers.
I'm also surprised someone with teacher parents and GP aunt/uncle would decide to go and work in a bank (it's not a crime, just unusual)
Also not sure why you are getting so involved when none of these funds are actually yours if I've read rightly: it's your husbands parents and husbands sisters money at stake here.
Last but not least, I can't imagine a world where my mother would know what I have in my sandwich every day, but not what I earn.

The OP might give plenty to charity, she doesn't need to tell you about it.

tachetastic · 20/02/2024 18:52

HelnPink · 20/02/2024 14:17

Hi all,
First off, DD has no idea the money exists, so this isn’t coming from her or her being greedy, but here is the situation.

Early last year DHs lovely grandparents sadly passed away within 6 weeks of each other at 98 and 4 weeks off of 100. They were incredibly loving, kind people, they still lived at home (they had carers but hated the thought of a nursing home). They only had one child (DHs mum) who had two children, DHs sister never had children and DH and I only have DD, who’s 24 almost 25.
We all live in Cumbria, apart from DD who as moved to London, works in Risk Analysis for a big bank and is very happy.

DH and I are early 50s very recently mortgage free (woohoo about time!), we have savings and are comfortable with our pensions (both public sector workers so perhaps the only good thing going for us!)

DHs sister is also mortgage free, as are his parents.

His grandparents house has now been sold, considering we are north west the £500,000 sale price for a dated 3 bed bungalow has come as an unexpected surprise to all. His parents (mum) was the only named beneficiary in their wills so it’s mostly up to her. They had no debt, funerals prepaid etc.

DHs mum has decided she wants give a large chunk (£425,000-£450,000) to my DD (her only grandchild) as a house deposit. DD loves where she lives (Clapham North/Brixton) and probably wouldn’t get a house or flat that would last her for very long outright in that area (or maybe even anywhere in London?) so a mortgage would be needed. The rest of the money would be split between his parents, his sister and us. With some given to DD just to have fun with, holidays or clothes etc.

DH and I have also been saving for DD for the last 24 years. She didn’t require much help through uni (just accomodation and se paid her phone and sent occasional gift cards) so we have about £140,000 set for her. Some we will keep back to help with her wedding if she chooses to get married, but most was intended to help with a house deposit.
DH now thinks we shouldn’t give DD what we have saved, he thinks £425,000 is plenty and if she lived in the north would buy her a bloody nice house! I feel like that’s unfair, the £425,000 isn’t from us, it’s from a combination of her great grandparents whose money it is and her grandparents, aunt and us all being willing to pass on inheritance so she can benefit from it. The money we saved is just from us wanting to provide her with security and I think she is still entitled to that.
DD is one of the kindest, funniest, smartest most beautiful people I know and I want to give her all the help we can to ensure she is happy and successful, I think we should give her the money we have saved like initially planned and then keep a good chunk back as a wedding fund (I’m not sure how much weddings are these days but £25,000 held back maybe?)
DH wants to spend the money on us, holidays, shopping and cutting to part time hours (which we can afford anyway now our mortgage is paid).

AIBU to think he is being greedy and selfish and DD is entitled to all the money including what we saved for her. She doesn’t know she is getting the inheritance or the money we have saved so he insists she won’t know either way!

I think it is always difficult where family money is being discussed, and I agree that your MIL has the absolute right to give your DD all the money she wants, but I do see your DH's point of view (in my mind), that maybe 250k of that money would have come to him to help you both in your retirement had his mother not decided to bypass him and give it directly to her DGD.

So maybe his logic is that, as your own financial security may no longer be what he expected it to be, and as your DD's financial security is now better than ever (and possibly better than your own), perhaps you need the buffer more than she does, and anything you don't spend will end up with her anyway, but not for 30 or 40 years, which may be a nice bonus for her nest egg then.

And it doesn't sound like the two of you will burn through that money, whereas your DD might if she doesn't need it for a house deposit. I think you may be a safer pair of hands for that money until she really needs it later.

I'm with him.

ViciousCurrentBun · 20/02/2024 18:51

All she needs to know regardless of the exact amount decided on is how to protect her deposit whatever that may be if she does ever marry.