Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male friend wants more- I feel bad

61 replies

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 11:54

He's honestly really attractive, much moreso than I am. I feel like he's nicer than me, more going for him and really out of my league, I am surprised he's interested and maybe subconsciously that's why I reject him.
We were good friends,we talked pretty much daily but understandably he has distanced himself a little now as he knows I don't want more.
I do fancy him, I just don't know what it is. He was a little reserved but so was I. I was interested, I just don't know what happened. When we saw each other we could talk for hours, we honestly got on so well.
He really hasn't done anything wrong. The day after we met up he asked me out again but I just didn't feel like it for some reason.
I've been single for such a long time. Honestly never had someone like him interested in me before, we get on so well too.
I'm probably being an idiot but anyway I've turned him down now. I feel like I led him on a little because I used to talk to him so much, even though it was as friends.

OP posts:
mrsjareth · 20/02/2024 13:33

I'm getting the feeling that you do like him but you don't like yourself. You seem to have a lack of self confidence and belief in yourself, why shouldn't someone like him want to be with you? I think you should give it a go and maybe agree to a date and see how you feel. I believe in loving yourself before you can love someone else though.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 20/02/2024 13:32

Self preservation perhaps?

Flossieskeeper · 20/02/2024 13:28

Are you going to regret not pursuing this? If so acknowledge your fears but don’t let them rule you.

if you aren’t going to regret not pursuing this then you’ve done the right thing, and as you say he needs a little space.

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 13:21

He still talks to me, it's just not an every day thing like we used to. He just needs a bit of space.

OP posts:
dimllaishebiaith · 20/02/2024 13:17

WhatWhereWho · 20/02/2024 13:05

That's somewhat unfair. He asked her out and got knocked back so has taken a step back - could be embarrassment, feels he misread the situation, just protecting himself, not wanting to come across as not listening or moving on.

The OP is saying she might have given the impression she wanted more too (and it seems she does). Am not sure anyone is 'the bad guy' here.

OPs further posts have given the impression she wants more, unfortunately I wasnt gifted with futuresight so I was unable to tailor my reply to her future responses

I still think a guy who is "good friends" only until you refuse to have sex with him is a bad friend, but it feels more like this wasnt a friendship in the first place and more of a getting to know each other with the potential of a relationship, but again I couldnt have tailored my reply to the OPs future replies.

Islandlifex · 20/02/2024 13:17

I'm a woman and if I revealed romantic feelings for a good friend that weren't reciprocated, I would also back off from the friendship temporarily due to feeling awkward and vulnerable.

It is unfair to assume that because of his gender, his sole motive for befriending the OP was purely to get her into bed. Men are just as likely to be hurt by this as we are, it's just human nature to feel that way after being vulnerable with somebody and being rejected. It is easy for feelings to develop within friendships. Give him some time, it's a great healer.

BobbyBiscuits · 20/02/2024 13:08

You sound like you really, really like him. I honestly don't see why you wouldn't give him a chance? You have plenty too offer him, or anyone. Everyone has their own unique talents and attributes and he likes you for yours.
If you feel like you are too vulnerable for a relationship, would you seek counselling to maybe help your feelings? Maybe if you can talk to someone you might gain confidence. Then you will see if you still care about him or not. It's better to work on yourself rather than focussing on this one bloke, if you know you are not willing to date him at this time, if ever.

WhatWhereWho · 20/02/2024 13:05

dimllaishebiaith · 20/02/2024 11:59

We were good friends,we talked pretty much daily but understandably he has distanced himself a little now as he knows I don't want more.

No he wasnt a good friend. Good friendship isnt contingent on having sex. He wasn't a friend at all if he is unwilling to be a friend if you wont sleep with him

I feel like I led him on a little because I used to talk to him so much, even though it was as friends.

Being a friend with a man who you don't intend on having sex with is not leading them on. Him pretending to be your friend so you would fuck him is him leading you on.

Honestly women arent just there to provide sex on demand. We are living breathing people with our own feelings and needs. You aren't just there to cater to him when he decides its suddenly time to change the direction of the relationship.

That's somewhat unfair. He asked her out and got knocked back so has taken a step back - could be embarrassment, feels he misread the situation, just protecting himself, not wanting to come across as not listening or moving on.

The OP is saying she might have given the impression she wanted more too (and it seems she does). Am not sure anyone is 'the bad guy' here.

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 13:05

He's great, I've been single for 5.5 years so it might just be me. I dunno what's missing.

OP posts:
ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 20/02/2024 13:02

It sounds like you to actually like him amd there's no negative to him.

You mention what others might think? Are you crazy? There's no way in hell that I would let a decent man that I find attractive go because of someone else's potential thoughts.

This seems to be more about your self esteem and not feeling good enough.

Is he decent, single and kind?
Are you attracted to him?

I also suspect you have the rose tinted glass on. The amount of people who describe their partner as extraordinarily good-looking is huge as most are just normal.

What's the real fear here?

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 20/02/2024 12:55

From what i have seen, a good friend scenario between opposite sexs where they meet up for drinks, go out together and at the others house will more often than not result in sex

OP, your choice, your life

Turmerictolly · 20/02/2024 12:52

Sounds like you don't feel like you're good enough and that he'll ' find this out' eventually and reject you? Is that what you are afraid of? It sounds like you are attracted to him and he has good qualities and you enjoy being with him. Why not give it a chance if the door is still open? Be honest and just tell him why you're confused. What have you got to lose - he's already started to distance himself for self preservation.

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 12:41

Yeah I understand, he hasn't been needy, just shown his interest. I can see why he thought I wanted more.

OP posts:
randomchap · 20/02/2024 12:39

Just because there are good signs it doesn't mean you have to date.

However, if you aren't dating because you feel you're not worth it, or aren't valuable enough, or don't deserve a good man, then maybe you need to look into this.

CommentNow · 20/02/2024 12:37

Its gut instinct.

I've turned down a few lads in my youth that were handsome and popular and objectively out of my league.

They always turned out to be clingy or needy or I found out something later that I didnt like (one particularly memorable instance was reconnecting with an old spark, dating and so on. We went to bed together for the first time and that was the moment he chose to tell me he had a long distance girlfriend so he couldn't have sex with me because it "wouldnt be right because hes not like that!"). I left, obviously. He calls me the next day saying hes dumped her so would I like to go on a date! Mindblowing.

Trust your gut.

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 12:30

Is it normal to fancy someone, get on really well but not want to date?

OP posts:
StroppyTop · 20/02/2024 12:12

Also, who cares what other people may or may not think? They’re not on the inside of this (potential) relationship.

StroppyTop · 20/02/2024 12:11

I can understand this. The cognitive dissonance between knowing he likes you like that and you feeling at heart that you’re not enough for him (wrongly).

I don’t know the answer, other than working on your self esteem and taking some
time to think about things (or just to not think about things, let it all percolate).

Flowers
determinedtomakethiswork · 20/02/2024 12:07

I think he sounds lovely! He clearly thinks more of you than you think of yourself.

randomchap · 20/02/2024 12:07

He's got to know you, and would like more than a friendship. That's not a bad thing.

Now he knows that those feelings aren't reciprocated he's backed off. That's perfectly understandable, the relationship is now unequal with you both wanting something different.

It's a shame you weren't on the same page.

You do seem very negative and hard on yourself.

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 12:07

Markinatree · 20/02/2024 12:06

I don’t understand? Are you saying you do want to be with him but you feel you aren’t good enough for him?

It's almost like people would think what on earth is he doing with her. What have I got to offer him? And that puts me off.

OP posts:
fatphalange · 20/02/2024 12:07

You're overthinking. If you fancy him and want to date him, you would know.
If you're confused then you're right that you're not in the right frame of mind to be dating anyway.

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 12:06

AmaryllisChorus · 20/02/2024 12:05

The fact hat he has pulled back from the friendship says more about him than you. You’re allowed to talk to people and explore feelings- it isn’t leading them on!

That's unfair. Anyone might feel a bit embarrassed and a bit vulnerable after showing interest in a friend and being rejected. Men are allowed to have feelings and process them too.

Yes absolutely, if it were me I'd feel awkward because the other person would maybe start acting differently for fear of leading you on.

OP posts:
Markinatree · 20/02/2024 12:06

I don’t understand? Are you saying you do want to be with him but you feel you aren’t good enough for him?

Maybenotbaby · 20/02/2024 12:05

AmaryllisChorus · 20/02/2024 12:04

I get it. It can be an instinctive reaction: mismatch - different leagues! I'd feel deeply uncomfortable dating a man who is way better looking, wealthier etc than me. I would feel I couldn't relax. But might come around to the idea over time Grin

But...you are already friends and you already connect. It is so good that he wants a date because you get on so well and have so much to say to each other.

Why not just get in touch and suggest a meet up, get the spark of conversation going again? See how you feel.

He's like model good looking, it's crazy. He literally has everything going. Honestly he's not cold shouldered me because I didn't sleep with him, he's just pulled back for a little bit as he wants to move on.

OP posts: