Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please can someone say what labours manifesto is?

234 replies

Gymnoob · 20/02/2024 11:20

Hi,

Looks like no choice but to vote labour this time. No idea what they actually stand for. I have listened to Kier and various things still none the wiser. I don’t know whether this is because they have less air time as the opposition or something else.

If anyone can sum up very briefly the 3 main policies or changes they will make.

To do the conservative comparison I would have said they wanted to;
Lower taxes (and plunge the £ into panic)
‘Fix’ the nhs
Have an odd obsession with sending everyone to Rwanda

But I can’t make a comparison for labour because no idea!

Thank you

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
kitfree1 · 21/02/2024 14:17

Janiie · 21/02/2024 10:03

Well its 4% now. 10% inflation wasn't ever a permanent thing you know.

10% is permanent in some people's minds.

ilovesooty · 21/02/2024 14:16

kitfree1 · 21/02/2024 14:13

Johnson one a landslide in an election against Corbyn. So many people must have thought that Johnson was a good Prime Minister.

Bless.

kitfree1 · 21/02/2024 14:14

Janiie · 21/02/2024 09:44

Well, read the article the pp posted. He changes his opinion like the weather. King Flip Flop.

More u-turns than a plumbing store.

kitfree1 · 21/02/2024 14:13

ShareTheDuvet · 21/02/2024 09:41

And Sunak supported a government run by Johnson, one of the very worst prime ministers we’ve had the misfortune to be “governed” by. Your point?

Johnson one a landslide in an election against Corbyn. So many people must have thought that Johnson was a good Prime Minister.

pointythings · 21/02/2024 14:12

The Starmer/Savile situation has been explained exhaustively on these threads. If you're still using it as a weapon, you haven't been paying attention. A simple Google search will find you all the explainers you need. start with this and follow some links.

I'm sure there are Labour supporters who also supported the Iraq war - that isn't the point though, is it? The point is the wholesale blaming of Labour for the war when the situation was more complex than that.

And yes, there are some Labour supporters who hold the Tories to higher standards than Labour. Of course there are. But overall, and in the media, it's the exact other way round. The latest round of lies from Kemi Badenoch around the Post Office scandal spring to mind - the Tory press are essentially ignoring it, or supporting Badenoch. If a Labour politician was doing all of this, they would be rabid with rage.

Why is Boris Johnson making false claims about Starmer and Savile?

How and why the rumour emerged, the facts of the case, and why the PM is talking about it

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/feb/02/why-is-boris-johnson-making-false-claims-about-starmer-and-savile

kitfree1 · 21/02/2024 14:10

ShareTheDuvet · 21/02/2024 09:25

@HettieHampshire I have also lived through many a change of government and couldn’t disagree more - education and services for families were infinitely better under Blair’s government than they are now. No comparison.

I’m so tired of this “nothing will change” bollocks. This last Tory government, especially since 2019, have been the most appalling bunch of lying, thieving, incompetent and corrupt wankers we have had the misfortune to be “governed” by. Johnson has done untold damage to politics in general by his atrocious premiership. We deserve better and Starmer is better - the idea that they’re the same as the bunch of bastards in power now is ridiculous.

I lived through changes of goverment recently, Cameron to May, May's government to Johnsons. Now Sunaks. Not much changed despite all the excitement in some quarters.

Katypp · 21/02/2024 14:00

You can roll on the floor as much as you want with my blessing.
The fact is though that (they do exist) Labour supporters do hold the Tories to higher account than their party as they are seemingly incapable of judging anything on its merits, just a blanket 'the Tories are awful Labour is better' rhetoric.
You haven't answered my questions by the way about the Gulf war and Starmer. Do you honestly think that Labour supporters would be Ok with the Tories taking us to war because some MPs voted against it and that Starmer would not be criticised for letting Saville continue under his watch?

pointythings · 21/02/2024 13:53

@Katypp you seem to be implying that the Tories are held to a higher standard than Labour. Pardon me while I roll on the floor laughing.

Also there's no such thing as 'Labour supporters'. They're a pretty diverse lot. (I say 'they' because I have no vote in general elections and tend to vote Independent locally because our independents are great).

Whereas anyone who still supports the Tories and intends to vote for them after the past 14 years... isn't. (I don't count among those people the Tory voters who intend to stay at home).

Katypp · 21/02/2024 13:46

@pointythings you are kind of proving my point that some seem to think Labour can do no wronmg and Tories can do no right. In reality, they are both a mix of the two.
Can I ask though, had the Tories taken us to war, would Labour supporters accept the nuance that some Tory MPs had voted against it? And had Rishi Sunak been DPP when the decision had been made not to prosecute Jimmy Saville, Labour supporters would accept that he did not make the actual decision? Of course they wouldn't, they would be baying for blood.

pointythings · 21/02/2024 13:22

@Katypp can we stop it with the tired old trope that Labour took us into war? The only opposition to the Iraq war came from Labour and Lib Dem MPs. The Tories supported it wholeheartedly.

As for the good things the Tories did: I can't think of very many that Labour wouldn't have done had they been in power. Perhaps the Tories pushed harder on marriage equality and I'm pleased about that, but it in no way cancels out the past 5 years of lies, corruption, cronyism and the disaster that is Brexit. Beyond that the sustained assault on the poor and the disabled has been unforgivable.

And no, it isn't going to get better fast. You may want people to be deluded about this, but I doubt very many are. The amount of shit that needs to be cleared up is there for all to see and it will take years.

Katypp · 21/02/2024 13:14

@SerendipityJane I would be inclined to agree with you about it being time for a change. My point is that anyone who thinks there is going to be much of a change is somewhat deluded.

SerendipityJane · 21/02/2024 13:08

I think the many, many MN posters who pepper every thread with 'blame the Government' are in for a rude awakening if/when Labour win the next election and they discover there's no magic money tree or magic wand

On the contrary. This poster is quite anticipating a shitshow. However it's impossible for it to start as bad as things have gotten with 14 years of Tory Crony rule.

I refer you to the truism that nappies and governments need to be changed and for the same reason.

Katypp · 21/02/2024 13:05

I think the many, many MN posters who pepper every thread with 'blame the Government' are in for a rude awakening if/when Labour win the next election and they discover there's no magic money tree or magic wand.
The posters I am thinking about seem to think at a stroke waiting lists will disappear, the NHS will suddenly become better run, crime will go down, schools will become educational utopias in fantastic buildings, private landlords will disperse into thin air, there will be a house for everyone who needs one, and everyone will be happy ever after until the nasty Tories win the next election.
The reality is much will be the same. The last Labour Govenment was 14 years ago, which means there are a lot of young adults who have never been adults in a Labour term and have fallen hook, line and sinker for the hype about how fantastic Labour will be and how they will cure all the country's ills.
The last Labour Government took us to war, left a legacy of crippling finance for schools and hospitals to deal with, introduced tuition fees and the ridiculous expectation that everyone was fit for university and created in the tax credits system the germ of dependancy culture we are living in now.
I know they did other things, but I am cherry picking the bad bits the same way as Labour supporters can see nothing positive about the Tories' time in office.
Every thread on here about the NHS and schools always features people who have worked in the establishments when Labour were in power and confirm it was not that brilliant then, but they are always shouted down by those who seem lacking in critical thought and think Labour will sort it.
They won't. They will produce a great manifesto promisijng the earth, get into power and then say they can't deliver as things were left in a worse state than they thought. There are rich Labour MPs the same as rich Tory MPs, but that's always brushed aside.
TLDR: Labour are not all they are cracked up to be and there's going to be a lot of disappointed people after the next election if Labour win.

SerendipityJane · 21/02/2024 12:55

the idea that the Tories are better with the economy.

If anyone thinks the UK economy is in any way a decent state, then they are simply thick.

pointythings · 21/02/2024 12:51

@caringcarer I see you are leaning towards believing the idea that the Tories are better with the economy. Time to post this again - dates back to 2021 but that doesn't matter much given Labour haven't been in charge in between now and then.

Meanwhile if you want to know more about Labour plans and ideas, there's this thing called Google.

Labour are much better at running the economy than voters think – new research

We looked at 100 years of Tory and Labour governments to see who was better at producing GDP.

https://theconversation.com/labour-are-much-better-at-running-the-economy-than-voters-think-new-research-162368

caringcarer · 21/02/2024 12:41

The only policies and beliefs I've heard about are

  1. Put 20 percent tax on independent school fees by taking away their charity status.
  2. They believe 1 percent of woman have a penis.
  3. They support mixed sex toilets.
  4. 24 million to be spend (down from 28) on creating green jobs.

I've no idea what else they believe or have policies for.

Historically Labour spend more on public services and tax more to.pay for it. However taxes are so high ATM I don't know if they would make them higher? Maybe they'll borrow more to improve public services.

dustcollective · 21/02/2024 11:57

Is there something stopping you from reading the information on their website? There are lots of policy ideas on there to read about.

Manifestos dont get published until a general election is called lest the Conservatives steal all the policies

SerendipityJane · 21/02/2024 11:49

pointythings · 21/02/2024 10:18

It's not surprising that we have the government we do when there are people who really don't understand basic mathematics, is it? Sigh.

Or History. Or English. Or Science ...

Crikeyalmighty · 21/02/2024 11:16

@HettieHampshire I'm left of centre but def not far left and I don't disagree. I think the big difference for me is the underlying ethos. Labour have more of a focus I feel on making sure the basics are not left to the free market and to hell with anyone who can't pay for private this and that. Tory's more of an emphasis on self preservation and self effort which I do partly agree with however at the moment unless you are lucky enough to have incredibly high paying jobs or family money you can't get yourself in a position to even cover off the basics easily- and as for saving or having kids- it's out the window for a lot of younger people- long term this really isn't good. Far too much emphasis on the short term policies that old people like ( and I'm 62) I don't disagree about corruption but with Labour I think it's more likely to be one too many grants to worthy causes rather than bunging mates and donors etc so I can live with that

pointythings · 21/02/2024 10:30

Getting a 10% rise on a pittance when food inflation is higher than that is still a loss of spending power. And with inflation still at 4%, that loss is getting bigger.

ShareTheDuvet · 21/02/2024 10:24

Janiie · 21/02/2024 10:15

'One relative doesn’t prove your point - that’s what “anecdotes aren’t data” means.'

Oh sorry you misunderstood. It wasn't just my vulnerable relative who received a welcome and appropriate 10% rise in PIP and ESA. All claimants did.

Nope definitely didn’t misunderstand. My point was that this rise has not made most disabled people feel safe, protected or cared for by this government.

IClaudine · 21/02/2024 10:22

Janiie · 21/02/2024 10:15

'One relative doesn’t prove your point - that’s what “anecdotes aren’t data” means.'

Oh sorry you misunderstood. It wasn't just my vulnerable relative who received a welcome and appropriate 10% rise in PIP and ESA. All claimants did.

I do hope your vulnerable relative is not too worried about the Tories' proposed cruel changes to ESA. It is a very worrying time for sick and disabled people.

HettieHampshire · 21/02/2024 10:20

@ShareTheDuvet I do agree that our present government has been the worst I can remember, especially for corruption and self interest. However give Labour power for long enough and they too will not be immune to the lures of corruption that power brings.

Maybe not for the first couple of years as they'll be desperate to prove they are 'different', but they will eventually.

I also agree with a PP that this time I will vote for whichever party I think will be the most authentic, honest and ethical. Their policies will be almost secondary to that, and I can't quite believe I'm saying that! I want a government I can be proud of.

pointythings · 21/02/2024 10:18

It's not surprising that we have the government we do when there are people who really don't understand basic mathematics, is it? Sigh.

Janiie · 21/02/2024 10:15

'One relative doesn’t prove your point - that’s what “anecdotes aren’t data” means.'

Oh sorry you misunderstood. It wasn't just my vulnerable relative who received a welcome and appropriate 10% rise in PIP and ESA. All claimants did.

Swipe left for the next trending thread