Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step Daughter no inclination to make her way

309 replies

Miffed1233 · 20/02/2024 04:45

I’ll try and state this factually & unemotionally

  1. SD has a professional career ahead of her and earns around 30k as a newbie. She studied hard to get qualified. Probably has the most disposable income in our household

  2. reluctantly (& rarely on time) pays towards household utility bills. Each month is a manual payment. Has avoided setting up a sto and has to be asked, frequently nagged and in some cases has been more than 10 days late paying. Comes across as avoidant

  3. I earn a lot more than my DP so pay all bills / mortgage (except food, which she pays). I haven’t minded doing this previously when children were young, but….

  4. sd clearly not saving towards a house and whenever her mum brings it up says she wont be in a position to buy a house for at least 5 years or unless she meets a man. (Her dating rarely goes beyond 3-5 dates before she is dumped)

She spends her income on frippery…Botox and overpriced beauty products / shoes / clothes (did I mention shoes?)

  1. Has now announced she is taking a year off to go travelling (for the 2nd time)

For info I’m mid 50’s and have reached a point where I’m finding it immoral that I’m having to continue to put a roof over her head whilst she has a “lifestyle”.
On current course will be in my 60’s before she “grows up”. I feel like this isn’t what I signed up for, life is too short etc

I’m normally the first to leap to the defence of youngsters today and the pressure of social media / house prices etc they face compared to my generation but feel this is not taking responsibility. I oscillate between wanting to downsize…so she gets the message (we live in a big house & she has a very nice room) and realising this isn’t something I’d actually want to do if I didn’t have this resentment. AIBU?

Talking with her mother about it is difficult. She agrees she should be saving for a house but is powerless to make her do so and meantime does everything for her (cooking, washing, cleaning her room). She defaults to defending her daughter and sees me as “attacking” her all the time. Love my DP to bits….what should I do? I feel my life is zooming by and I’ll have spent the majority of it providing for my children and hers and will be doing so well into my retirement. Surely this isn’t the natural order of life?

Putting aside my frustration it’s also sad that she is very capable and has more capacity than most but isn’t seizing or recognising the opportunity and good position she is interested

AIBU

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/02/2024 17:53

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 17:34

She has no clear plan and will not be able to manage running a home/paying bills on time as she’s still being treated like an 18 year old.

You need to be firm and tell her its time to move out and be a grown up.

Edited

She has studied and qualified and got a 30k job at 25 so she’s not exactly doing nothing.

we don’t know she isn’t saving. She’s said she can’t buy a house for 5,years without a partner. Saving 500 a month for 5 years would give a 30k deposit and on 30k she can borrow about 130k, factor in some pay rises in the next 5 years and in 5 years time she probably is able to get a 200k house. I would expect her to be able to do it earlier so her statement to her mum is realistic. We have no insight in to how much she is spending v saving v contributing to the house so can’t comment on it.

BruFord · 20/02/2024 17:53

@breadandroses92Yes, but at some point the older family members want to stop working so hard to subsidize the younger ones!

It sounds as if the OP might like to start planning for retirement, perhaps working less hours, having some nice holidays, but at present, he has no idea when his adult SD is planning to start supporting herself. Plus he mentions other children so if SD is the eldest, it’s setting a precedent for the younger ones to expect Dad to financially support them through their 20’s.

He says that he feels as if life is zooming by as he supports everyone else-I have some sympathy, he deserves a break. Why can’t he spend his money on Botox instead of the household bills?! 😂

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 17:51

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 17:43

I just re-read and think she’s 20’s not 30’s.

I still think its absoltely bizarre wanting to live with your parents when your a grown adult. The only reason ive ever known people do that is to save a deposit or perhaps work going on at their own house (as a temporary thing). There’s a whole world out there, she’s got a great career, so she could either be saving for a place of her own or rent with friends.

Im pretty sure she’s going to regret wasting her good salary on botox when she had a chance to save. She needs the parents to be firm with her, not pander to her like a teenager.

well my point is that now in our world, there are 35 year old american men moving back with their mum with their british wife and child in tow. Btw he has a college degree and a job he can do remotely plus has worked for years, so has his wife. So this example of a 25 year old kid still at home, no one raises an eyebrow these days. I did live at home to save a deposit and when I was doing that circa 2016 to 2019, we were far from the only ones, dh worked for an investment bank and he had colleagues on far higher salaries than this young lady doing the same thing. I mean there are guys on 80k who can't afford to buy on their own so yeah someone on 30k should probably cherish this opportunity.

I am from a different culture and grew up in a multigenerational household (though it was a very different set up- my dad and mum paid all the bills while my grandma did the childcare, and my dad gave my grandma an allowance plus paid for her medical bills and eventually a domestic helper to care exclusively for her). So in a sense, western culture coming full circle after a historical blip of 70 years (post war boom and home ownership becoming available to the masses)- i don't think its strange. Its natural for there to be friction as we all get accustomed to this new reality but at the same time, we should probably accept the fact that many many young adults are going to be like this young lady, my BIL and perhaps even live with their parents into their 40s.

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 17:43

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 17:38

my BIL is moving in with his mum (in the usa) with his wife and 1 year old baby daughter in tow. He is 35 this year! His mum is absolutely delighted apparently. I don't know if there is a plan to save a deposit.

I would say while its not great she has no plan, these are unusual times and no one thought what my BIL is doing is strange.

Edited

I just re-read and think she’s 20’s not 30’s.

I still think its absoltely bizarre wanting to live with your parents when your a grown adult. The only reason ive ever known people do that is to save a deposit or perhaps work going on at their own house (as a temporary thing). There’s a whole world out there, she’s got a great career, so she could either be saving for a place of her own or rent with friends.

Im pretty sure she’s going to regret wasting her good salary on botox when she had a chance to save. She needs the parents to be firm with her, not pander to her like a teenager.

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 17:38

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 17:34

She has no clear plan and will not be able to manage running a home/paying bills on time as she’s still being treated like an 18 year old.

You need to be firm and tell her its time to move out and be a grown up.

Edited

my BIL is moving in with his mum (in the usa) with his wife and 1 year old baby daughter in tow. He is 35 this year! His mum is absolutely delighted apparently. I don't know if there is a plan to save a deposit.

I would say while its not great she has no plan, these are unusual times and no one thought what my BIL is doing is strange.

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 17:34

She has no clear plan and will not be able to manage running a home/paying bills on time as she’s still being treated like an 18 year old.

You need to be firm and tell her its time to move out and be a grown up.

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 17:32

Gloriosaford · 20/02/2024 17:27

Too many young people are infantilised by their parents these days; it does them no favours; yes living alone is expensive but that's life
I agree, but the unaffordability of housing also serves as a disincentive to independent living.
Fledging/flying the nest is an important rite of passage!

Only in western culture. and it only became very normalised in the post war boom when mass home ownership became the norm and renting was seen as a short term solution between moving out of the family home and buying your house. Was it very normal in Victorian times?

Most people seemed to be servants/lived in employer provided accommodation i.e. factory workers and many seem to have lived with family until they got married. My DH's grandfather lived with his in laws when he was first married for a few years and when DH and I did that circa 2016-2019, he said 'ahhh just like I did in the 1950s'. What was lucky though was that we did manage to buy at the end of that but then it was 2019 where there was practically deflation and the brexit effect on london flats!

I sympathize with OP but at the same time the social norms of the past 70 years should perhaps be seen in the context of an absolute blip.

Poppyzo · 20/02/2024 17:31

If she is only just out of uni and wants to go travelling I would be encouraging her. But maybe give her and any other children an age limit for being at home. Say 23? You do sound negative and frustrated. But maybe it’s you and your partner that need to be having these conversations.

Northernparent68 · 20/02/2024 17:31

FirstTimeMum897 · 20/02/2024 05:08

I would leave DP and force a sale of the house. Fuck that. Life is too short to spend it pandering to a spoilt 20 something brat.

Edited

I think this is right-neither she nor your wife will change. You may have to gear up to consider leaving

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 17:28

Floofydawg · 20/02/2024 15:38

Mine would have chopped off her own arm rather than move back home. She's 20 and fully independent and I couldn't be more proud.

we stayed with his mum until late 20s and then bought a flat. His sister moved out, rented, got married, continued renting, rented a bigger flat with a baby and dog. She seemed a lot independent then and was actually quite sneery about us still living at home.

They are now moving back to live with his mum at the ages of 31 and 35, with a baby in tow. to be fair, they are fleeing a war but her dh told me they were planning to move back with the baby to his mother's house as she has a good size house (and her mum is sponsoring his wife's visa). That was a good year before the war . I suppose the war expedited the decision.

There is the term boomerang kids, its a lot easier to live with your parents in your 20s compared to your 30s. I am glad i stayed with MIL in my 20s rather than moved out and rented and then found i had to stay with her again (just as when most people are planning to start their own little families) as I didn't have any proper savings due to renting.

Gloriosaford · 20/02/2024 17:27

Too many young people are infantilised by their parents these days; it does them no favours; yes living alone is expensive but that's life
I agree, but the unaffordability of housing also serves as a disincentive to independent living.
Fledging/flying the nest is an important rite of passage!

Beautiful3 · 20/02/2024 17:22

At 23 I had moved out of home. By 27 I was married with a child. You're doing her no favours at her age by treating her like a baby. She'll live with you until she's in her 30s!!!

Suchagroovyguy · 20/02/2024 17:21

Trulyme · 20/02/2024 12:52

The only issue here is her not paying rent on time.

I think YABVVU

You sound very jealous that she is doing better than you in life.

Eh? 😬

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 16:51

DH and i have been on the other end, we were earning £75k combined by the end of our 3 year stint (in 2019) with his mum (while his mum was earning below minimum wage). His mum refused all of our contributions. We did save up a lot of money and bought our flat in London at age 27 and 29. In all fairness, we ended up living there as i had to wait for the home office to issue my visa and while i was working while waiting for my visa, we weren't really in the position to rent. That alone took 8 months, and it took around a year for dh and i to be stable in our jobs, and then another year to buy a flat (got gazumped twice!). so yes that does add up to 3 years!

i think she may still not be totally aware of her financial future if she doesn't plan (and it doesn't sound like she is getting any cash gifts). I am not sure why but a lot of people seem to think that everything will work out eventually. Show her the numerous articles in the media where people are renting privately in their 40s on middling incomes (she could easily be one of those on middling incomes, we don't know her true earning potential at 25) and how it sucks 50% of their incomes. Sounds crass but i am sure you probably know some real life examples. that should give her a wake up call. Explain that for most people, it is inheritance, bank of mum and dad or hotel of mum and dad that gets them the deposit. Given that its hotel of mum and dad that she has access to, she should be thanking her lucky stars and kissing the ground you walk on (not even kidding) cos so many people would kill for that.

2in13 · 20/02/2024 16:41

@followmyflow Things are stacked up against young people but that doesn't mean she shouldn't endeavour to try.

It's a poor attitude for her to not want to help contribute to the family household. She's begrudgingly paying 1 bill in the house but has the ability to save up and go traveling for a year. She can enjoy her life whilst also setting herself up for the future and also pulling her weight in the house.

It's not so much that he wants to kick her out but he also doesn't want her living there forever which is fair

Tooosday · 20/02/2024 16:26

followmyflow · 20/02/2024 16:08

idk i find this post sad. why are you begrudging her joy/travel/buying what she likes...she is spending her own money. she is living in her family home and paying her own way and you want to kick her out. i dont get it. you should know that everything is stacked against young people nowadays... i really dont understand this attitude. of course she wont be in a position to buy a house until 5 years, have you seen house prices? some people take a bit more time than others, some people mature slightly slower, thats just the way it is. she is your family, by marriage, but still. how long have you been her stepfather?

Edited

🙄

followmyflow · 20/02/2024 16:08

idk i find this post sad. why are you begrudging her joy/travel/buying what she likes...she is spending her own money. she is living in her family home and paying her own way and you want to kick her out. i dont get it. you should know that everything is stacked against young people nowadays... i really dont understand this attitude. of course she wont be in a position to buy a house until 5 years, have you seen house prices? some people take a bit more time than others, some people mature slightly slower, thats just the way it is. she is your family, by marriage, but still. how long have you been her stepfather?

Str3bor · 20/02/2024 16:05

I think for me she needs to have a standing order set up to pay her way, that would be non negotiable. Not sure what she pays you but I’d be asking for a minimum of 20% of her net monthly pay.

if your DP wants to continue to do her chores than let her, in the grand scheme of things I don't think that really contributes to her not wanting to move out. She sounds like she probably doesn’t appreciate or notice what gets done for her anyway.

its a tough one, you want to help your kids but don’t want them to be taking the piss and she should be looking at her future and considering saving up now while she can instead of blowing all her money every month. I know someone who ended up paying their 35 year old sons house deposit because they were so desperate to get him out, maybe that’s her tactic 🤣

on the flip side she might go travelling for a year and come back and decide she enjoyed her own space and move out, your DP might enjoy it also and realise that it’s time for her to move out. I’d let her go travelling and have the conversation when she comes back about her plans for moving out

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/02/2024 15:40

What is it you want though - to move out? To pay more rent? To save more?

I think you need to work out what you want then come up with a plan.

if it’s to move out then say that after traveling she can only come back for x months before getting her own place

if to save then make her pay more but put an element aside (are you sure she’s not saving - I don’t think my parents were ever aware how much I saved)

if to contribute more then set clear rules in place.

Floofydawg · 20/02/2024 15:38

Mine would have chopped off her own arm rather than move back home. She's 20 and fully independent and I couldn't be more proud.

Maray1967 · 20/02/2024 15:31

Thelightis · 20/02/2024 05:09

No way are my DC moving back in with me once they finish uni

I love them dearly but that's just not going to happen

Mine is back but pays board and, although not the tidiest person alive, behaves well - always asks if it’s ok if his girlfriend comes over etc

Im quite enjoying having him back - although he’s moving out soon.

Coyoacan · 20/02/2024 15:20

Many years ago my uncle and aunt downsized in order to get rid of their freeloading 28yo son

strawberry2017 · 20/02/2024 15:03

Your main problem is your DP as she is not on your side.
Who does the house belong to? Why is she only paying for food?
How long have you been together? Are their other children?
I think you need to be having a serious chat with your partner and confirming this is not ok. You are being taken advantage of. If rent is due it's paid on time every single month.
No exceptions.
Realistically I want to give loads of advice but whilst her mother is still treating her like a 6 year old there's nothing wr can say that will really help. You have a DP problem coz if she was on your side none of this would happen.
You need to seriously think if this is what you want your future to look like as it's not going to get better.

stomachamelon · 20/02/2024 15:02

@Tooosday I totally get that.

LuckySantangelo35 · 20/02/2024 14:56

Could you not give her your house op?

Honestly that’s what some posters on here seem to think

Swipe left for the next trending thread