Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step Daughter no inclination to make her way

309 replies

Miffed1233 · 20/02/2024 04:45

I’ll try and state this factually & unemotionally

  1. SD has a professional career ahead of her and earns around 30k as a newbie. She studied hard to get qualified. Probably has the most disposable income in our household

  2. reluctantly (& rarely on time) pays towards household utility bills. Each month is a manual payment. Has avoided setting up a sto and has to be asked, frequently nagged and in some cases has been more than 10 days late paying. Comes across as avoidant

  3. I earn a lot more than my DP so pay all bills / mortgage (except food, which she pays). I haven’t minded doing this previously when children were young, but….

  4. sd clearly not saving towards a house and whenever her mum brings it up says she wont be in a position to buy a house for at least 5 years or unless she meets a man. (Her dating rarely goes beyond 3-5 dates before she is dumped)

She spends her income on frippery…Botox and overpriced beauty products / shoes / clothes (did I mention shoes?)

  1. Has now announced she is taking a year off to go travelling (for the 2nd time)

For info I’m mid 50’s and have reached a point where I’m finding it immoral that I’m having to continue to put a roof over her head whilst she has a “lifestyle”.
On current course will be in my 60’s before she “grows up”. I feel like this isn’t what I signed up for, life is too short etc

I’m normally the first to leap to the defence of youngsters today and the pressure of social media / house prices etc they face compared to my generation but feel this is not taking responsibility. I oscillate between wanting to downsize…so she gets the message (we live in a big house & she has a very nice room) and realising this isn’t something I’d actually want to do if I didn’t have this resentment. AIBU?

Talking with her mother about it is difficult. She agrees she should be saving for a house but is powerless to make her do so and meantime does everything for her (cooking, washing, cleaning her room). She defaults to defending her daughter and sees me as “attacking” her all the time. Love my DP to bits….what should I do? I feel my life is zooming by and I’ll have spent the majority of it providing for my children and hers and will be doing so well into my retirement. Surely this isn’t the natural order of life?

Putting aside my frustration it’s also sad that she is very capable and has more capacity than most but isn’t seizing or recognising the opportunity and good position she is interested

AIBU

OP posts:
CharlotteRumpling · 21/02/2024 07:58

Yes, apparently all of Gen Z have mental health problems if you read these boards.
I won't ever be charging my DC rent as it's not part of my culture, and I can afford to have them stay for free ( no judgement of those who do).I will expect them to save to move out eventually, and help with the house though.

Floofydawg · 21/02/2024 07:52

Why does mental health problems always get thrown in? Nowhere in the OP does it refer to any mental health problems. Just a grown adult who refuses to plan for her future and pisses all her money away on Botox and shoes.

Devonshiregal · 21/02/2024 07:46

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 22:05

Wow. As I posted earlier, apparently if you bring DC into the world, you have them for life. Because they didn't ask to be born!

I am not getting Botox, but apparently it's my duty to subsidise my DD;s Botox, should she get any.

That’s not what I said. At all. If your daughter is expecting other people to fund things like Botox then no you don’t need to choose to. However if she has mental health problems and is struggling in life it’s your duty to be there 100% to help her figure it out.

Devonshiregal · 21/02/2024 07:44

SomeCatFromJapan · 20/02/2024 22:23

@Devonshiregal do you have adult children?

Mine are younger. Raised an older step child though who I was very involved with.
This country is twisted in its bizarre desire to separate families and make it strange to support each other inter generationally, in my opinion. You can create contented, strong, independent adults who are also close to their family and can rely on them when times get tough.

Devonshiregal · 21/02/2024 07:40

Coyoacan · 20/02/2024 22:16

You may have vowed to protect your child and ensure their happiness but my intention was to bring up an independent and useful member of society.

And mine too but if they struggle to manage it, or never achieve it for whatever reason, I will be there. It is my duty as the person who chose to bring them into this world to do what I can.

your superiority is misplaced as my children are incredibly independent, resilient, go-getting and confident. As I have raised them to be.

DelphiniumBlue · 21/02/2024 07:30

I've nothing much to add to the advice that you need to get your wife on board except this:
Just so that you have an idea of reasonable figures, I calculated about a year ago that it cost about £350 pm to have adult DS living here, taking into account energy bills and food. That didn't include a rent element. He pays monthly, although not by standing order. If I need to remind him, I do it once and he transfers the money immediately- mobile banking makes all this very easy. I think if you are asking for different contributions to a variety of bills, it's just more admin and reminders- agree a figure, be clear on what it includes, and stick to it.
Obviously she should be cleaning her room, doing her washing and contributing equally to household chores, but if your wife is choosing to do these things for her, it puts you in a difficult position.
Has your wife said why she is continuing to do these things rather helping DD become a fully functioning adult?
If DD was paying her way, it would be her business what she spends her money on. It's only relevant in so far as she is presumably pleading poverty so as not to pay her share.
I think you need to have a long talk with your wife. Obviously you don't want to be saying that you as the higher earner you have the biggest say, but you could do a spreadsheet showing all costs and everyone else's contribution as a start. Presumably DW has always worked part time to facilitate childcare and running the house; you probably need to discuss whether this will remain the case going forward now that there are no children that need looking after, and what your spending priorities as a household are.

breadandroses1992 · 21/02/2024 07:29

Redpaisley · 21/02/2024 02:48

In your culture, 25 year olds expect their mothers to clean their room snd do washing while giving nothing back? They go travel the world, and use money on botox and lifestyle, while parents subsidise? If not, then stop using Op's post as an excuse to tell us how better your culture is comparec to British. You must really feel so strong to wrote 2 long posts irrelevant to Op.

No culture is perfect.

I also grew up in a multi generation household where my mother was treated like a slave by her husband and in laws, it is not always good to live in such set up.

Op, you subsidise SD's lifestyle, pay for mortgage and most bills and your wife accuses you of attacking her Dd when you tell her to not enable her, you are not the unreasonable one here.

I am not defending the behavior, I am just saying in response to PP who wouldn't want their kids at home is that it would be a more common phenomenon.

Think thanks have reported that in the UK it is the people in the income bracket of £35-60k who face falling into poverty. I would say that is probably the vast majority of people unless they get parental help.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/feb/20/uk-middle-classes-jobs-housing-costs-abrdn-financial-fairness-trust

Some people will take the piss with the help, others wouldn't. Like it or not this is our new reality and if there is no helps for kids between 35k to 60k income bracket and they don't manage to get a partner who earns above that income /has generational wealth, then we can probably expect them to seek help in their 30s (far worse cos they are older) or I suppose they will just struggle in poverty. Would probably get worse too, I suspect it would be people in our income class (£120k combined who would be the new working poor our only saving grace which protects us is our mortgage is currently only 2.3x income but that was facilitated by my MIL letting us stay).

Redpaisley · 21/02/2024 02:48

breadandroses92 · 20/02/2024 17:51

well my point is that now in our world, there are 35 year old american men moving back with their mum with their british wife and child in tow. Btw he has a college degree and a job he can do remotely plus has worked for years, so has his wife. So this example of a 25 year old kid still at home, no one raises an eyebrow these days. I did live at home to save a deposit and when I was doing that circa 2016 to 2019, we were far from the only ones, dh worked for an investment bank and he had colleagues on far higher salaries than this young lady doing the same thing. I mean there are guys on 80k who can't afford to buy on their own so yeah someone on 30k should probably cherish this opportunity.

I am from a different culture and grew up in a multigenerational household (though it was a very different set up- my dad and mum paid all the bills while my grandma did the childcare, and my dad gave my grandma an allowance plus paid for her medical bills and eventually a domestic helper to care exclusively for her). So in a sense, western culture coming full circle after a historical blip of 70 years (post war boom and home ownership becoming available to the masses)- i don't think its strange. Its natural for there to be friction as we all get accustomed to this new reality but at the same time, we should probably accept the fact that many many young adults are going to be like this young lady, my BIL and perhaps even live with their parents into their 40s.

In your culture, 25 year olds expect their mothers to clean their room snd do washing while giving nothing back? They go travel the world, and use money on botox and lifestyle, while parents subsidise? If not, then stop using Op's post as an excuse to tell us how better your culture is comparec to British. You must really feel so strong to wrote 2 long posts irrelevant to Op.

No culture is perfect.

I also grew up in a multi generation household where my mother was treated like a slave by her husband and in laws, it is not always good to live in such set up.

Op, you subsidise SD's lifestyle, pay for mortgage and most bills and your wife accuses you of attacking her Dd when you tell her to not enable her, you are not the unreasonable one here.

user1492757084 · 21/02/2024 00:05

Step-daughter or biological daughter, my answer would be the same.
You and your DP have not taught your children to wise up financially.
You and partner need to visit the accountant together and discuss the positive ways you could organise your affairs that encourage your children to be financially independent and saving savvy.

My path would include .. adult child over 25 pays full market rent on time each month. Have her pay her cost of utilities and food because she needs to learn the cost of living.
Set aside the rent payment, without her knowledge, to give you options to assist, such as paying her an amount, one pound for every two of her saved pounds, to match her savings when she moves out to purchase a home, or similarly repaying the rent amount. Set her a solid moving out of home date such as her 30th birthday.

This gives her reason to save and no excuse but to grow up.
It doesn't change how she has splurged to date nor have her owing a debt to you.

Be firm about your boundaries and rules. You and DP need to be on the same page.

Book another accountant appointment, once your rules are in place for just your SD and your DP, with the aim for SD to learn how to manage her payments, saving gaols and strategies, and how and where best to buy her first home.

So, take a step back and let the professionals treat her like an adult and you and DP treat her like the income earning adult that she is.

Your kids can always move out and do their own thing and come home for Sunday roasts, like most kids do.

Share these great posts with your partner.

Floofydawg · 20/02/2024 22:23

BruFord · 20/02/2024 22:20

i think I’d better call my Dad (85) to let him know that I need a holiday and could he please pay my household bills so I can have a break. I could def. use some Botox as well.

😂 My 78yo mum would laugh me out of the room!

SomeCatFromJapan · 20/02/2024 22:23

@Devonshiregal do you have adult children?

BruFord · 20/02/2024 22:20

i think I’d better call my Dad (85) to let him know that I need a holiday and could he please pay my household bills so I can have a break. I could def. use some Botox as well.

Coyoacan · 20/02/2024 22:16

Devonshiregal · 20/02/2024 22:01

I don’t believe ever - THEIR adult CHILD is exactly that. Theirs.

Just as with differing physically abilities, you don’t get to decide how your child will turn out mentally. If a person is content and “functioning” you wouldn’t need to support them. They’ll be self sufficient. However mental health diagnoses and physical disabilities and simply the world’s economics can have a huge impact on a person’s ability to be self-sufficient.

I believe that when you have a child you look down at them and vow to protect them and ensure their happiness to the best of their ability. What age do you break that vow and put yourself first? For me it’s never. For me I decided to bring them into this world - they didn’t ask me to - so I’m committed for life.

You may have vowed to protect your child and ensure their happiness but my intention was to bring up an independent and useful member of society.

Tooosday · 20/02/2024 22:14

Devonshiregal · 20/02/2024 22:01

I don’t believe ever - THEIR adult CHILD is exactly that. Theirs.

Just as with differing physically abilities, you don’t get to decide how your child will turn out mentally. If a person is content and “functioning” you wouldn’t need to support them. They’ll be self sufficient. However mental health diagnoses and physical disabilities and simply the world’s economics can have a huge impact on a person’s ability to be self-sufficient.

I believe that when you have a child you look down at them and vow to protect them and ensure their happiness to the best of their ability. What age do you break that vow and put yourself first? For me it’s never. For me I decided to bring them into this world - they didn’t ask me to - so I’m committed for life.

🙄

BruFord · 20/02/2024 22:13

Floofydawg · 20/02/2024 21:46

Some properly bonkers replies on here. If y'all want to work into your 60s/70s to support grown ups then crack on - I'll be on a sunbed somewhere with a fully loaded Kindle.

Ohh you sound proper nasty, @Floofydawg, spending your retirement soaking up the sun.
i have a mental image of Madge from “Benidorm” on her scooter. 🤣

(Totally joking, of course, wish you all the best).

CharlotteRumpling · 20/02/2024 22:05

Devonshiregal · 20/02/2024 22:01

I don’t believe ever - THEIR adult CHILD is exactly that. Theirs.

Just as with differing physically abilities, you don’t get to decide how your child will turn out mentally. If a person is content and “functioning” you wouldn’t need to support them. They’ll be self sufficient. However mental health diagnoses and physical disabilities and simply the world’s economics can have a huge impact on a person’s ability to be self-sufficient.

I believe that when you have a child you look down at them and vow to protect them and ensure their happiness to the best of their ability. What age do you break that vow and put yourself first? For me it’s never. For me I decided to bring them into this world - they didn’t ask me to - so I’m committed for life.

Wow. As I posted earlier, apparently if you bring DC into the world, you have them for life. Because they didn't ask to be born!

I am not getting Botox, but apparently it's my duty to subsidise my DD;s Botox, should she get any.

Devonshiregal · 20/02/2024 22:01

BruFord · 20/02/2024 21:30

@Devonshiregal At what point does a parent’s financial commitment to their adult child end?

I don’t believe ever - THEIR adult CHILD is exactly that. Theirs.

Just as with differing physically abilities, you don’t get to decide how your child will turn out mentally. If a person is content and “functioning” you wouldn’t need to support them. They’ll be self sufficient. However mental health diagnoses and physical disabilities and simply the world’s economics can have a huge impact on a person’s ability to be self-sufficient.

I believe that when you have a child you look down at them and vow to protect them and ensure their happiness to the best of their ability. What age do you break that vow and put yourself first? For me it’s never. For me I decided to bring them into this world - they didn’t ask me to - so I’m committed for life.

Tillycx · 20/02/2024 21:58

Floofydawg · 20/02/2024 21:46

Some properly bonkers replies on here. If y'all want to work into your 60s/70s to support grown ups then crack on - I'll be on a sunbed somewhere with a fully loaded Kindle.

Can only agree, since when were parents expected to subsidise kids through their 20s?? It’s one thing helping them start off into adulthood or helping them during hard times, quite another subsidising their Botox 🤦🏻‍♀️

Floofydawg · 20/02/2024 21:46

Some properly bonkers replies on here. If y'all want to work into your 60s/70s to support grown ups then crack on - I'll be on a sunbed somewhere with a fully loaded Kindle.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/02/2024 21:41

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 21:33

We can only go on what the OP said and he gave the impression she wasn’t. Although if you are many days late on paying your parents a small amount towards the bills, it doesn’t suggest someone financially very responsible. The first thing they need to put in place (today), is a fair amount towards the bills set up to go out of her account on pay day. She needs to pull her weight equally around the house too.

Surely if you were living at home at 25, you would have plenty of discussions with your parents about when you were moving out, plans to rent, saving a deposit etc? It wouldn’t just be open-ended so im sure her parents would have a good idea if she was saving.

the only thing we can take from the op that is definitely wrong is the paying late. For everything else we can’t tell as there is not enough information:

  • we don’t know the amount t she pays so can’t judge that
  • she pays begrudgingly, well I mean no one really wants to pay bills, it’s just something you have to do
  • she buys shoes - is that 10 pairs at 1,000 each which would be very extravagant or a pair of trainers, some work shoes and some boots at less than 100 each which might be reasonable.
  • the dp does the cooking, laundry etc but we don’t know if the sd expects it. Maybe if doing it for younger children, it’s just as easy to make her a portion/throw her clothes in too
  • when asked about buying a house she says it would take 5 years - pretty reasonable assumption even if saving a lot per month and I don’t think it’s it would be that normal to tell your parents how much you have in savings.
not saying that the sd is in the right but just feel like there isn’t enough info to conclude that she is a spoilt brat who is taking advantage and saving no money as a lot of people have concluded.
Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 21:33

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/02/2024 21:25

But we don’t know that she’s not saving

We can only go on what the OP said and he gave the impression she wasn’t. Although if you are many days late on paying your parents a small amount towards the bills, it doesn’t suggest someone financially very responsible. The first thing they need to put in place (today), is a fair amount towards the bills set up to go out of her account on pay day. She needs to pull her weight equally around the house too.

Surely if you were living at home at 25, you would have plenty of discussions with your parents about when you were moving out, plans to rent, saving a deposit etc? It wouldn’t just be open-ended so im sure her parents would have a good idea if she was saving.

Tillycx · 20/02/2024 21:32

No you shouldn’t be having to subsidise her, think you need to agree a reasonable board and lodgings that not only doesn’t leave you out of pocket but compensates for having another adult in the house who is there simply because leaves her with lots of disposable income. I have 1 adult DC still living at home which I don’t mind as in full time education and don’t expect them to move out immediately after getting first proper job but would expect them to have saved up for a house/rental deposit within a couple of years

BruFord · 20/02/2024 21:30

@Devonshiregal At what point does a parent’s financial commitment to their adult child end?

Devonshiregal · 20/02/2024 21:25

Miffed1233 · 20/02/2024 04:45

I’ll try and state this factually & unemotionally

  1. SD has a professional career ahead of her and earns around 30k as a newbie. She studied hard to get qualified. Probably has the most disposable income in our household

  2. reluctantly (& rarely on time) pays towards household utility bills. Each month is a manual payment. Has avoided setting up a sto and has to be asked, frequently nagged and in some cases has been more than 10 days late paying. Comes across as avoidant

  3. I earn a lot more than my DP so pay all bills / mortgage (except food, which she pays). I haven’t minded doing this previously when children were young, but….

  4. sd clearly not saving towards a house and whenever her mum brings it up says she wont be in a position to buy a house for at least 5 years or unless she meets a man. (Her dating rarely goes beyond 3-5 dates before she is dumped)

She spends her income on frippery…Botox and overpriced beauty products / shoes / clothes (did I mention shoes?)

  1. Has now announced she is taking a year off to go travelling (for the 2nd time)

For info I’m mid 50’s and have reached a point where I’m finding it immoral that I’m having to continue to put a roof over her head whilst she has a “lifestyle”.
On current course will be in my 60’s before she “grows up”. I feel like this isn’t what I signed up for, life is too short etc

I’m normally the first to leap to the defence of youngsters today and the pressure of social media / house prices etc they face compared to my generation but feel this is not taking responsibility. I oscillate between wanting to downsize…so she gets the message (we live in a big house & she has a very nice room) and realising this isn’t something I’d actually want to do if I didn’t have this resentment. AIBU?

Talking with her mother about it is difficult. She agrees she should be saving for a house but is powerless to make her do so and meantime does everything for her (cooking, washing, cleaning her room). She defaults to defending her daughter and sees me as “attacking” her all the time. Love my DP to bits….what should I do? I feel my life is zooming by and I’ll have spent the majority of it providing for my children and hers and will be doing so well into my retirement. Surely this isn’t the natural order of life?

Putting aside my frustration it’s also sad that she is very capable and has more capacity than most but isn’t seizing or recognising the opportunity and good position she is interested

AIBU

What? Of course it’s the natural order of things - YOU chose to have children and step children. You don’t get to choose how capable they are not whether they are a good, diligent person or a bit of a test. You committed to them as a parent though.

as for funding your partner? Did she carry your children for 9 months and physically damage her body for this? Care for them? Contribute to child rearing, emotionally support you, etc etc? Your finances are combined - a choice you made - there is no option for “what’s yours is yours, what’s mine is mine”. Unless you don’t you both as combined and want to split of course?

if you want to bugger off and travel the world go do it. That fine. Just don’t expect a family sitting there waiting for you when you come back.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 20/02/2024 21:25

Isitautumnyet23 · 20/02/2024 21:15

Its a little off the topic - but I do think it probably stems from that and to some extent, we are all guilty of it with younger children. The age kids walk to school by themselves, the age kids go to town by themselves, get on a bus etc has all got later and later. You only have to look at the (dreaded!) school whats app chats to see how parents literally do everything for their kids, rather than the kids needing to remember things for themselves and learn some independence. How did my parents cope without the group chat? We had to remember it ourselves for school or we got detention.

The world is as dangerous as it was 20/30 years ago and yet we seem to wrap kids in cotton wool so much more than we did when I was younger. We dont seem to think they are capable of things they used to be able to do at the same age perfectly well.

We had rented properties before we had a mortgage, always moved by ourselves etc, never asked for help. I didn’t think I was doing anything unusual running a home, raising kids late 20’s. Plenty of my friends had kids too and all had homes they owned or rented (juggled with work/childcare etc).

I also find it slightly cringey when we talk about relationships with kids in their 20’s still living at home. Its one thing asking your parents if its ok for your boyfriend to stay at 17/18, but mid-20’s is just so odd for me. Bringing your boyfriend back to a house with your parents in, im not surprised the OP’s daughter struggles with new relationships.

I do agree with the comments that its tough out there for young renters but the OP’s daughter could be saving a huge chunk of her salary living at home (short term) with a plan and not wasting her money away.

But we don’t know that she’s not saving