Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step Daughter no inclination to make her way

309 replies

Miffed1233 · 20/02/2024 04:45

I’ll try and state this factually & unemotionally

  1. SD has a professional career ahead of her and earns around 30k as a newbie. She studied hard to get qualified. Probably has the most disposable income in our household

  2. reluctantly (& rarely on time) pays towards household utility bills. Each month is a manual payment. Has avoided setting up a sto and has to be asked, frequently nagged and in some cases has been more than 10 days late paying. Comes across as avoidant

  3. I earn a lot more than my DP so pay all bills / mortgage (except food, which she pays). I haven’t minded doing this previously when children were young, but….

  4. sd clearly not saving towards a house and whenever her mum brings it up says she wont be in a position to buy a house for at least 5 years or unless she meets a man. (Her dating rarely goes beyond 3-5 dates before she is dumped)

She spends her income on frippery…Botox and overpriced beauty products / shoes / clothes (did I mention shoes?)

  1. Has now announced she is taking a year off to go travelling (for the 2nd time)

For info I’m mid 50’s and have reached a point where I’m finding it immoral that I’m having to continue to put a roof over her head whilst she has a “lifestyle”.
On current course will be in my 60’s before she “grows up”. I feel like this isn’t what I signed up for, life is too short etc

I’m normally the first to leap to the defence of youngsters today and the pressure of social media / house prices etc they face compared to my generation but feel this is not taking responsibility. I oscillate between wanting to downsize…so she gets the message (we live in a big house & she has a very nice room) and realising this isn’t something I’d actually want to do if I didn’t have this resentment. AIBU?

Talking with her mother about it is difficult. She agrees she should be saving for a house but is powerless to make her do so and meantime does everything for her (cooking, washing, cleaning her room). She defaults to defending her daughter and sees me as “attacking” her all the time. Love my DP to bits….what should I do? I feel my life is zooming by and I’ll have spent the majority of it providing for my children and hers and will be doing so well into my retirement. Surely this isn’t the natural order of life?

Putting aside my frustration it’s also sad that she is very capable and has more capacity than most but isn’t seizing or recognising the opportunity and good position she is interested

AIBU

OP posts:
J97King · 22/02/2024 12:47

It sounds like the cost of her staying with you is minimal and she does pay rent, albeit reluctantly. So I think this is not about money. You just don't want her there.

Barney60 · 22/02/2024 12:26

I know this doesn't answer your question but what youve posted has puzzled me for a couple of years now, i dont feel shes alone in the staying at home spending money on Botox expensive shoes and clothes ect.
I work with loads of younger people, all earning a decent enough wage to probably leave home, professional and responsible jobs vary on amounts due to qualification, length of service, band ect
In my direct line of contact id say 80% (that are single ) still live at home (all under 35) all have Botox ,lashes ,nails done, all have top of the range phones and cars, one even has a Tesla, possibly on contract i dont know, and i know its none of business, mostly bar 2 are female, and dont seem to have any intention of moving out soon, also dont seem to be making plans too. (im not in South of UK)
One did move in with her boyfriend but they broke up and shes now back home.
I find this slightly odd, i couldnt wait to leave home and flat share.
Does any one think they have it so good theres no reason for them to move?

AmIEnough · 22/02/2024 10:52

My partner won’t hear of it! So there really is nothing I can do

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 22/02/2024 09:59

AmIEnough · 22/02/2024 07:50

I feel for you! Don’t even get me started on this subject. I am very much in the same boat, my husband has two sons, one of whom lives with us, earns £31,000 a year, pays absolutely nothing to contribute towards his life here, even ask his dad to go to Sainsbury’s with him, because he knows that way, he won’t have to pay for whatever he buys there. He’s spoilt, entitled, smug, and just spend his money on a flash, Mercedes-Benz car, designer clothing. Has even said he wants to buy a property but couldn’t afford to live in it so may do so and rent it out and continue to live here for nothing! To say The, I am fuming, doesn’t even begin to explain how I feel. of course he will never move out, why would he! I have no advice for you as I am at a loss to know how to handle my own situation. I hope you get some better advice from other people on here.

Have you asked him to pay you rent? That’s the starting point. If you want it to be different you and your partner need to initiate it.

AmIEnough · 22/02/2024 07:50

I feel for you! Don’t even get me started on this subject. I am very much in the same boat, my husband has two sons, one of whom lives with us, earns £31,000 a year, pays absolutely nothing to contribute towards his life here, even ask his dad to go to Sainsbury’s with him, because he knows that way, he won’t have to pay for whatever he buys there. He’s spoilt, entitled, smug, and just spend his money on a flash, Mercedes-Benz car, designer clothing. Has even said he wants to buy a property but couldn’t afford to live in it so may do so and rent it out and continue to live here for nothing! To say The, I am fuming, doesn’t even begin to explain how I feel. of course he will never move out, why would he! I have no advice for you as I am at a loss to know how to handle my own situation. I hope you get some better advice from other people on here.

likethislikethat · 22/02/2024 01:54

My daughter is 16. I'm a single parent. She knows she will have to find her way, with some assistance, either at the point of going to university or around that age.

It does no-one any good to keep adults as children, to overindulge them or to be their slave.

In the OP's case, I;d give her 3 months to get out and find a place or go travelling after which she would not be coming back.

Harsh as it is, she is 25, not 18 and she is already forecasting being in the same situation when she is 30+ unless some (unlucky and stupid) man decides she is worth keeping, because let's be clear here, what she wants is to be put on a pedestal, worshipped and left to waste her income on herself.

It is time for a reality check and if the wife doesn't back you up, she can go too !

Nantescalling · 21/02/2024 23:29

Is she paying the whole gas/electric/water charges?

Nantescalling · 21/02/2024 23:28

BananaSpanner · 20/02/2024 06:59

In all seriousness though, how does it get to the stage where she can almost refuse to pay her way. The late payments need to be addressed if nothing else, it takes seconds to set up a standing order, you and her mum need to sit with her until she does it.

I agree but I think it's more judicious if this gets sorted by her Mum.

breadandroses1992 · 21/02/2024 23:12

stomachamelon · 21/02/2024 20:35

@breadandroses1992 that's ridiculous sorry. £120k 'working poor'?

I would not be surprised. I am comfortable now cos my mortgage is £1020 due to rise to £1256 and also no student loans, and dh only has 4k left on his. Also lived rent free for 3 years and saved 60k plus dh had 10k savings due to bar mitzvah money, tutoring and gap year work. If someone didn't have all that and rent rose more than wage inflation (our flat would rent for 2k now) plus childcare, it may be a little hard esp if wages didn't go up.

We are trying desperately to increase our earnings now and get ahead while we are still comfortable (dh applying to 10 jobs everyday, goal is combined 200k within next 3 years). We wouldn't have state pension by the time we reach our 60s so need to pay off mortgage by the time we are 40 (am 31 now) and build up a pension pot in time to retire at 65 (that is what would be needed without state pension . Plus we would need to pay childcare and I hope for a slightly bigger flat (but yet have to somehow pay off mortgage).

However someone without all our advantages and have to pay for pension and childcare and house deposit and double student loan all by themselves - they could very well find themselves in the same financial precarity than someone on 30-65k is facing today. An asset economy means that what yiu own matters more than what you do unless you earn hundreds of thousands.

SomeCatFromJapan · 21/02/2024 22:48

@Gloriosaford that is a very long game 😂

Gloriosaford · 21/02/2024 22:35

Lolaandbehold · 21/02/2024 21:15

I wish you’d tell my parents this. My sister left uni 5 years ago and she and her boyfriend live with my parents. They earn £150k between them. They don’t give my parents a bean. Thy get their meals served, their heating bills paid (they walk around the house in T-shirts with the heating on full blast). My parents don’t ask for a contribution because they’re saving for a house. 🤯

That is pretty shocking to say the least 😳
.... Or could it be that your parents are playing the long game, they know that your sister and her boyfriend will get complacent, never actually save enough money and then they'll be trapped there forever and will have to be their carers in old age 🤷🏼‍♀️

BruFord · 21/02/2024 22:01

OldPerson · 21/02/2024 19:33

You have a marriage problem. If you're in a relationship with her mother, but paying all the bills and the mortgage, then clearly you need to sort your marriage out. You've decided to be angry with step-daughter directly, instead of being angry with your partner or sitting down with her to discuss your concerns. Why is this? What does your partner/her mum think? What does your partner bring to the relationship/ household? Do you even like SD? Are you both competing for your partner/her mum's attention?

I agree that it’s ultimately a marital problem, @OldPerson , because his DP says that she’s “powerless” to address the situation with her DD, which is ridiculous!

It sounds as if the OP is viewed as the family cash cow who’ll pay the bills that no one else wants to! Some PP’s have suggested that he’s picking on his step-daughter because she’s not his biological child….I wonder whether the OP is actually the unloved one, just a convenient source of money for everyone?

Lolaandbehold · 21/02/2024 21:15

Ponderingwindow · 20/02/2024 05:11

I firmly believe that once a child completes their education, they need to be paying 30% of their income in “rent” if they are living at home. They need to be used to budgeting as if they are living independently. If at all possible, that money should be going into a savings account, not used to run the household.

Parents aren’t powerless to make this happen. You can set up a contract for living in the house. If they aren’t responsible enough to save on their own, then they can actually pay you the rent and you put it into a savings account.

I wish you’d tell my parents this. My sister left uni 5 years ago and she and her boyfriend live with my parents. They earn £150k between them. They don’t give my parents a bean. Thy get their meals served, their heating bills paid (they walk around the house in T-shirts with the heating on full blast). My parents don’t ask for a contribution because they’re saving for a house. 🤯

Jumpers4goalposts · 21/02/2024 20:48

I think she sounds like a typical young person .

stomachamelon · 21/02/2024 20:35

@breadandroses1992 that's ridiculous sorry. £120k 'working poor'?

venus7 · 21/02/2024 20:04

breadandroses1992 · 21/02/2024 07:29

I am not defending the behavior, I am just saying in response to PP who wouldn't want their kids at home is that it would be a more common phenomenon.

Think thanks have reported that in the UK it is the people in the income bracket of £35-60k who face falling into poverty. I would say that is probably the vast majority of people unless they get parental help.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/feb/20/uk-middle-classes-jobs-housing-costs-abrdn-financial-fairness-trust

Some people will take the piss with the help, others wouldn't. Like it or not this is our new reality and if there is no helps for kids between 35k to 60k income bracket and they don't manage to get a partner who earns above that income /has generational wealth, then we can probably expect them to seek help in their 30s (far worse cos they are older) or I suppose they will just struggle in poverty. Would probably get worse too, I suspect it would be people in our income class (£120k combined who would be the new working poor our only saving grace which protects us is our mortgage is currently only 2.3x income but that was facilitated by my MIL letting us stay).

Edited

£120 is 'working poor'? Really........?

OldPerson · 21/02/2024 19:33

You have a marriage problem. If you're in a relationship with her mother, but paying all the bills and the mortgage, then clearly you need to sort your marriage out. You've decided to be angry with step-daughter directly, instead of being angry with your partner or sitting down with her to discuss your concerns. Why is this? What does your partner/her mum think? What does your partner bring to the relationship/ household? Do you even like SD? Are you both competing for your partner/her mum's attention?

angela1952 · 21/02/2024 19:30

PurpleSparkles82 · 20/02/2024 06:49

YANBU.

However when she returns home from her travels, she needs to make alternative living arrangements.

Yes, this. She can't expect this easy ride to continue.

SurroundedByEejits · 21/02/2024 18:46

KnowledgeableMomma · 20/02/2024 05:17

This is definitely something to discuss with DP. Let him know your feelings and that there will need to be a compromise. You've talked about SD and her mother but no mention of what DP says or does anout this? And out of curiosity, if you pay all bills and mortgage, what is DP responsible for?

I think the OP's DP is the biological mother of DS- that's how I read it.

My first thought was that, if DP is happy for DD to remain living in the family home without contributing/ having to be constantly reminded to pay their way, the DP needs to take over that portion of the bill paying so that the OP is not out of pocket or aggravated at her loss of disposable income. That is DP's choice and should not be imposed on OP, who is clearly very unhappy about the situation. If it is hitting the DP in the pocket so they have little to no disposable income themselves, it might change DP's mind about the overall situation. It seems that everyone is happy with the set-up except the person losing out financially so that balance needs to change.

Coyoacan · 21/02/2024 11:59

You can create contented, strong, independent adults who are also close to their family and can rely on them when times get tough

However that is not the case here, so why are you bringing it up?

At no point has the OP or anyone else on this thread suggested abandoning adult children in their hour of need.

DottyLottieLou · 21/02/2024 09:34

Move whilst she's away and don't tell her where

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 21/02/2024 09:01

2in13 · 21/02/2024 08:37

I think some people are seeing this as being solely a financial issue. It's not. Apparently she's not helping to clean or do other household chores.

The combination of these two aspects is probably what makes OP think his DS is being selfish. Perhaps one day he wants to retire alongside DP without running a full time all-inclusive hotel for the adult children.

The question though is whether she is refusing to do it or whether her mum is just automatically doing it. If the second then it’s not really the sd’s fault.

2in13 · 21/02/2024 08:37

I think some people are seeing this as being solely a financial issue. It's not. Apparently she's not helping to clean or do other household chores.

The combination of these two aspects is probably what makes OP think his DS is being selfish. Perhaps one day he wants to retire alongside DP without running a full time all-inclusive hotel for the adult children.

rookiemere · 21/02/2024 08:19

I did an online calculator. At £30k her monthly take home is close to £2k depending on how much she is putting towards her pension. That should be more than enough to give the OP £200-300 per month, and still have at least £1500 disposable income per month.

DH and I are both higher rate earners and we each have £500 a month sole money to pay for holidays, clothes and meals out. It feels like a very generous amount and covers my solo ski trips as well as everything else.

It's ridiculous that DSD is ploughing her way through so much on completely unnecessary procedures- why does a 25 year old need Botox, it will make her look worse not betterwhereas at my age perhaps I should be considering it, but am too mean to pay the hundreds it costs ?

Floofydawg · 21/02/2024 08:02

It's probably from the sheer horror of being forced to pay rent when they could be spending that money on fillers to go with the Botox 🙄