Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ungrateful MIL - absolutely LIVID

388 replies

Lipbalmstrawberry · 19/02/2024 18:38

It’s MIL’s birthday today and we went out for a meal at lunchtime. I gave her her gift which was a blouse from River Island and when she opened it she just was like “Eugh, I don’t think this will suit me. It probably won’t fit me either.” “Have you got the receipt? I’ll go in and change it when go into town on Friday. If not you can keep it I don’t like that.” all with a scowl on her face. I was completely aghast and fuming so I just lied and said I don’t have the receipt and put it back in my bag. Not a word of thanks! I felt even a bit humiliated to be honest.

The rest of the lunch was completely normal and she was talking to me as though nothing happened but inside I was absolutely seething and I still am to be honest. I wished I’d have told her to not be so rude! And she never even said thank you for the cake either!

WIBU to not bother with a cake and present next year? I’m thinking of not bothering after that reaction.

OP posts:
dinkdink · 21/02/2024 19:24

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 18:36

I think you've missed the point. The posters who are saying it's "bizarre" arent saying that from the point of view of whether the clothing is "old fashioned" or "timeless" but from the point of view that buying clothes as a present is bizarre.

No that’s just one of the issues brought up

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 18:36

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 17:39

A blouse could be ageless as I said before it’s hardly a mini skirt 😅

I think you've missed the point. The posters who are saying it's "bizarre" arent saying that from the point of view of whether the clothing is "old fashioned" or "timeless" but from the point of view that buying clothes as a present is bizarre.

Donsyb · 21/02/2024 18:12

MIL bought me a hat for Christmas which I hate. I just smiled and said thank you, put it in in the cupboard and I’ll never wear it. I didn’t tell her I don’t like it as she would be upset, she thought she was doing something nice. I did tell my OH so he can steer her away from similar purchases in the future!

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 17:39

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 15:06

I can't believe how some of you think a comment like that is a hint to buy a random blouse from a random brand.

I'm also puzzled why you think that not buying clothes as a present is "old fashioned". Odd choice of words.

A blouse could be ageless as I said before it’s hardly a mini skirt 😅

TheWildEyeBoyfromafreecloud · 21/02/2024 17:38

Op I think it's quite nice that she felt she could be open with you but obviously.. Not quite that open

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 17:37

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 13:13

The being 68 is irrelevant, but I agree with the rest of your post. Buying clothes is odd unless you've had a clear steer towards a particular item.

Mentioning this thread to my mother, she replied with I almost bought a jumper from there yesterday, good on her and she is 77 👏🏽

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 17:33

zingally · 21/02/2024 10:45

She was very rude, but also... River Island is a strange destination to get a present for a woman who is probably at least in her 50s? That's a shop for teenagers and 20-somethings. I'm nearly 40 and probably haven't bought anything from there in 10 years at least.

But from now on, present buying can be the responsibility of her actual child.

RI doesn’t have an age limit

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 17:29

The audacity 😅 MIL doesn’t deserve a gift, it does not matter if flowers a voucher or clothing was gifted it is the thought that counts, MIL should of appreciated the act of kindness

akasalishsea · 21/02/2024 17:15

I would hold a silent truce and here is why: You were incredibly nice to purchase a present for your MIL and take her out. That alone would of made me grin and bear and be grateful for a gift I did not want. I am a frank person by nature, highly analytical and an introvert so not many people's social cup of tea. I am also super reliable, trustworthy, fair, compassionate and love to great depths without wanting anything back. Best of all I am a constant work in progress as you and your MIL are.

When I have encountered similar behavior first reaction is compassion. My thinking would be she may of been as shocked as you were about an inappropriate gift and her behavior was based on that. She may have felt unheard, dismissed, like you just picked something out to satisfy meeting some expectations around her birthday. She may of felt the invite was insincere. If we do anything for ulterior motives (guilt, making us look good to family, hubs, etc it is insincere and others will feel that because we are not relaxed and in a place of genuine love). DIL relationships are complicated even for women who don't want total control over their domaine. You may not be competing with her and other women and looking for a fight so you can end your part in relationship building in other to build your domaine but you might have had a seething reaction because she is your MIL. Would you have purchased a blouse for a friend without considering it was something they mentioned they wanted? If your own mom hated would she have lied and so you expect her to be like mom? Would you have preferred she lied?

I think her response was less than stellar and you could address it in a light hearted way by bringing the receipt by her home (getting permission of course to stop by) and sharing how you felt but doing it with humble humor. Here is a script you could adapt " Hi- I am pretty embarrassed about the birthday gift but our relationship means a lot to me so I want to apologize if I seemed distracted at your birthday lunch. I was so embarrassed that you had such a strong negative reaction to the gift that I couldn't think straight and was flustered. In hindsight I realize you, just like me, want to pick out your own clothes. I thought it was beautiful and assumed anyone would. Add in that I am not used to frankness and I felt a bit toppled and angry about that. Here is the receipt and now all I need is a hug". Then just shut up. This allows you to let her gently know she was rude, that you value the relationship and your gift giving was inappropriate but done out of love. It is a win win. When you let someone know you value the relationship what you are giving them is not permission to abuse you or expect insta closeness. What you are saying is you value their life enough to want to keep the relationship on a good standing with regards to willingness to work through tough stuff (which all relationships go through) and to bravely communicate feelings and thoughts in gentle, respective ways and to really hear them so you can create closeness.

Your fuming rage eats you and harms your entire family whether you said anything out loud or not.. MILs run the gamut of "Very dear to horrible but we have to make sure we are not looking for a fight when we declare a MIL's behavior as horrible. Interestingly we rarely hear about horrible FILs but we would hear more if DIL complained about all that their FILs fail to do. How many FIL offer to babysit, bring food during illness, try to create holiday memories, buy presents or remember special occasions, just to name a few things we women often do as mothers, sisters, partners, DILs and MILs? Yet FIL are not criticized even when they offer unsolicited advice partially because we females are not competing with them for our hubs love, devotion or time. No household needs to pit a MIL against the family which is what occurs when a DIL is fuming. And for all MIL's out there who ever criticize their DIL, I can only say shame on you and stop it today! ZIP that overbearing, judgemental mouth and get a life outside of the control freaking you feel compelled to do because you've culturally learned that is supposed to be your role and a right of some sort. It is not in this day and age and should never of been a right for a MIL to have any domaine over her own daughters or her DIL's household. Cultural BS that needs to go the way of the dinosaur because not all culture and tradition is positively supporting or uplifting.. If you want a role in your adult children's lives be the most beautifully supportive, compassionate person they are going to meet every time you are around them. Your DIL and her partner are just getting through life best they can and they need the space to do life their way because they belong to a newer culture and different ways of thinking (the exception to non interference would be if physical abuse of a child is occuring, sexual included as well as drug and alcohol addicted parents driving while children are in car, etc-).

When you stop telling others how to live then you have to focus on your own successes and failures and what you want outside of the easy way out which is focusing on the faults of others. Get out of everyone's way and be the happiest person you can be by focusing on your life and helping others, including your own family but without a breath of advice unless specifically asked for and zero criticism or negativity. You sow what you reap- either a sweet garden to relax in or one full of thorny uncomfortable bushes that shuts others out. Your choice- same for DIL's looking for a fight. This MIL was less than gracious and rude depending on how one values complete frankness. She was refreshingly forthright to people like me who value frankness and we'd of had a good laugh and she would of gotten the receipt. She was rude to not thank you for taking her to lunch and buying her a gift. You can move forward in anger or you can move forward with compassion for a woman who may still be working on herself. Your choice. Always leading with compassion for others and yourself brings a lot of love to any relationships.

Bantuchick · 21/02/2024 15:07

JoanThursday · 19/02/2024 19:09

Is that you, SIL? I think we share the same MIL. 🙄

😆😆😆

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 15:06

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 14:32

I can’t believe how many people have old fashioned views I’m with you how can it possibly be classed as bizarre 😅

Edited

I can't believe how some of you think a comment like that is a hint to buy a random blouse from a random brand.

I'm also puzzled why you think that not buying clothes as a present is "old fashioned". Odd choice of words.

Bantuchick · 21/02/2024 15:03

HarrogateHouseSale · 19/02/2024 18:41

Buying your MIL a blouse from River Island is an oddly personal gift
At least she was honest, you can get a refund and your money isnt wasted.
Why dont you have a receipt? Regifting or shoplifting?

Where does the cake come into it?

Bit hostile isn’t it? The put down was unnecessary

Bantuchick · 21/02/2024 14:59

It was the thought that counts. It doesn’t matter that it was a blouse it was the thought you put into it. To not just show gratitude is just rude to me

MrsMarshmellow · 21/02/2024 14:50

Seems like there’s some over reaction to this from the OP as the ‘rest of the lunch went fine’ and was talking as if nothing had happened. ‘Seething inside’ is an unusual reaction and shouldn’t have lied about the receipt - this is a childish response.
How refreshing the MIL ‘said it how it is’ without tip-toeing around the subject. Mind you, if everyone was more honest like the MIL there would be no threads like this and Mumsnet would be a very dull place….

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 14:32

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 21/02/2024 11:06

It's not bizarre at all Confused especially when she'd said she needed some new ones, which I would take as a present hint!

I can’t believe how many people have old fashioned views I’m with you how can it possibly be classed as bizarre 😅

TiredMummma · 21/02/2024 14:16

Rude but I agree with others - don't buy clothes unless you know they want something. It's been hard to hide my disappointment over the years from the bad choices my sister makes.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 13:13

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 21/02/2024 10:55

Didn't your DP realise that his mother would not like nor wear a blouse from River Island, I was going to ask how old she is as there is no way I would buy a MIL anything from R L

I see further down you say she's 68 - good grief what were you thinking of !
it's far too young a shop for her, and far too expensive for what it is for her.

My daughter would be happy in R L but she is less than half my age and I am younger than MIL.

M&S or John Lewis, and always include a gift receipt with clothing gifts.
esp as clothing sizes can very from shop to shop.

She may have been rude or abrupt, she was inwardly thinking wtf am i going to do with this ! and didn't handle it well.

Shame you lied about the receipt.

The being 68 is irrelevant, but I agree with the rest of your post. Buying clothes is odd unless you've had a clear steer towards a particular item.

Dweetfidilove · 21/02/2024 13:09

Her reaction was dreadful!

Do you not get gift receipts, so the receiver can exchange if it doesn’t suit?

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 21/02/2024 13:08

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 21/02/2024 11:05

@rubyredknowsitall it's just not the done thing

Says who? Maybe in your little family but I can assure you, most of the world buys clothes for other people. Confused

Really? For "people" who aren't children?

Mother in law mentioned that she needs a new blouse. Not sure how that translates into buying a random blouse from a random brand.

Other than scarves and gloves, I wouldn't dream of buying clothes for an adult unless it was a brand I knew they loved, and already owned or had said "did you see that blouse in River Island, isn't it great"

The only adult I buy clothes for is my husband - and even then it's limited to knitwear in a style I know he likes. Husband very occasionally has bought clothes as a present for me but only from shops or brands he knows I really like and already own.

Still puzzling why River Island is deemed inappropriate for a 68 year old. The blouses and shirts on their website looked safe and boring to this 64 year old. So, yes, I wouldn't be thrilled by a present from there.

What's the MN acceptable position on politely saying, "thank you dear, but it's not really my thing"? Is that more offensive than letting daughter in law waste her money and it going straight to a charity shop?

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 21/02/2024 13:04

Would you rather she lied?!

She didn’t have to lie outright. She could have just said thank you to acknowledge the gesture, even if the gift wasn’t to her taste. There was nothing to stop her asking for the receipt later in saw it didn’t fit. No one needs to hear “What’s this bloody old tat?”

Lplatecook · 21/02/2024 12:51

Lipbalmstrawberry · 19/02/2024 18:38

It’s MIL’s birthday today and we went out for a meal at lunchtime. I gave her her gift which was a blouse from River Island and when she opened it she just was like “Eugh, I don’t think this will suit me. It probably won’t fit me either.” “Have you got the receipt? I’ll go in and change it when go into town on Friday. If not you can keep it I don’t like that.” all with a scowl on her face. I was completely aghast and fuming so I just lied and said I don’t have the receipt and put it back in my bag. Not a word of thanks! I felt even a bit humiliated to be honest.

The rest of the lunch was completely normal and she was talking to me as though nothing happened but inside I was absolutely seething and I still am to be honest. I wished I’d have told her to not be so rude! And she never even said thank you for the cake either!

WIBU to not bother with a cake and present next year? I’m thinking of not bothering after that reaction.

It seems that your mil did not realise that she was being rude. It is likely that this will be a long term relationship and it would be worthwhile to raise this with her in a reasonable manner.

It would have been better to have done this at the time, to let her know how you feel, that she had unintentionally hurt your feelings.

Now that time had passed, another opportunity could be taken.

This would be best done in person, so that neither party misunderstands tbe other.

If this is not possible, then a short, polite message is needed to her to convey your feelings.

SausageRoll58 · 21/02/2024 12:48

I'd never buy that awful woman anything again, not even a hideous tatty ornament from Poundland! What a horrible brat she is!

Jem57 · 21/02/2024 12:32

MIL here,my daughter in law did exactly the same to me when I gave her a birthday present,she does it all the time,I don’t bother anymore.

angela1952 · 21/02/2024 12:13

My DS and DIL once gave me a top that I really didn't like but I still thanked them and wore it once when I saw them. Later it went to the charity shop.

dinkdink · 21/02/2024 11:41

I’m 45 in a few weeks and as long as I suit them I will buy my clothes from any brand I see fit, a shirt or jumper from river island could be great, I’ve know 80 yr olds buying knitwear from Topshop and they look great then again I am into fashion and fashion is fun, far too many serious people with lack of empathy these days