Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what makes you middle class?

340 replies

Wantobeareader · 19/02/2024 16:21

I am not from the UK so not very familiar with these class definitions (which personally I cannot stand) but I am curious to understand what people mean with MC. I thought it was a term referred to the fairly wealthy but apparently lots of people and incomes seem to fall into that categories.
So, how would you define Middle Class? Feel free to type a description of a typical MC person you can think of :)

OP posts:
Ruminate2much · 20/02/2024 15:47

I think people are just deciding for themselves what it means to be middle class. But in strict sociological terms, if you're a trained professional, on a salary, you're middle-class.

Ruminate2much · 20/02/2024 15:44

Whenwillitgetwarm · 20/02/2024 14:27

If anyone in your household HAS to work, you’re working class. You can wear Boden and buy National Trust membership, watch ITV or watch BBC, drive a banger, read lots of books, have swishy hair in a ponytail, drinks pints of bitter etc. It makes no difference. You’re either a worker or a land owner.

I for one am a high earning worker, as is my DH. We can afford for one of us to lose our jobs but not both. Therefore we live in a working class household.

I respectfully disagree. The vast majority of households couldn't afford to have everyone out of work. That includes teachers, doctors and even lawyers, all of which are middle class professions. Historically the only people who could afford to be ladies and gentlemen of leisure were the upper classes.

Lampslights · 20/02/2024 15:44

Whenwillitgetwarm · 20/02/2024 14:27

If anyone in your household HAS to work, you’re working class. You can wear Boden and buy National Trust membership, watch ITV or watch BBC, drive a banger, read lots of books, have swishy hair in a ponytail, drinks pints of bitter etc. It makes no difference. You’re either a worker or a land owner.

I for one am a high earning worker, as is my DH. We can afford for one of us to lose our jobs but not both. Therefore we live in a working class household.

This is nonsense. If this definition stood there would be no middle class, or very little, it would be made up of the very wealthy or retired, or those solely on benefits.

Samlewis96 · 20/02/2024 14:56

JaninaDuszejko · 20/02/2024 11:48

My middle class children complain when I buy Kettle chips, Tyrrells are much better apparently.

They definitely are lol.

Cordohroys · 20/02/2024 14:39

Whenwillitgetwarm · 20/02/2024 14:27

If anyone in your household HAS to work, you’re working class. You can wear Boden and buy National Trust membership, watch ITV or watch BBC, drive a banger, read lots of books, have swishy hair in a ponytail, drinks pints of bitter etc. It makes no difference. You’re either a worker or a land owner.

I for one am a high earning worker, as is my DH. We can afford for one of us to lose our jobs but not both. Therefore we live in a working class household.

That doesn’t work either - we don’t have to work, (we do though) because we’ve saved enough to retire comfortably but having achieved that goal doesn’t change our class.

Whenwillitgetwarm · 20/02/2024 14:27

If anyone in your household HAS to work, you’re working class. You can wear Boden and buy National Trust membership, watch ITV or watch BBC, drive a banger, read lots of books, have swishy hair in a ponytail, drinks pints of bitter etc. It makes no difference. You’re either a worker or a land owner.

I for one am a high earning worker, as is my DH. We can afford for one of us to lose our jobs but not both. Therefore we live in a working class household.

Cordohroys · 20/02/2024 13:49

pokebowls · 20/02/2024 12:06

@parkinghere

I think it is odd to be in that between place where you don't quite fit in anywhere fully, not even with the "nouveau riche". On paper class is about income and education but in reality if you aren't brought up middle class its apparent to others who were and they will look down on you for it, sorry to those who would deny this but I've experienced it far too many times even from friends and know for a fact it happens.

So do you think Carol Middleton was looked down upon at the school gates? Not by William's lot who teased Kate about her mum being an air hostess but the middle class people they grew up with at their prep school and Marlborough.

Nothing classy about looking down on someone - shows a lack of manners and good breeding but isn't it funny how it seems that the middle classes are seen to have good manners but on this thread - it all seems a bit on the surface. You're all fighting over scraps to feel more important - what a waste of a precious life. I'm better than him because I read books and go to the opera - what a load of guff!

SleepingStandingUp · 20/02/2024 13:25

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 20/02/2024 06:17

There is also an intangible thibgbif just how someone conducts themselves.

Think of the noise levels in a coubtry pub verses a Weatherspoons.

The soft touches of how a house is decorated or a wedding laid out. The classy finish.

Sitting at a table for meal times. Children having table manners and adults using cutlery with proper etiquette.

How someone speaks, their volume, words and phrases as well as accent.

Where they live and what they wear. The more affluent end of working class tends to be highly polished. Ladies with nails done, hair done, little boys with part shaved/ gelled hair wearing a polo shirt. Whereas middle class, particularly coubtry folk are more likely to be in a wooly jumper and jeans with children in shorts and flyaway hair.

Are the children fed on chicken nuggets or fed normal foods the same as the adults.

What are the children called?

Edited

nonsense. all that does it propagate the notion that the working classes are thick, vulgar and trashy.

i prefer a country pub over a wetherspoons. i know how to eat with proper cutlery and proper etiquette, i have a good vocabulary and don't use the local vernacular, none of my boys have ever had gel in their hair, in fact eldest sons is past his shoulders. They also eat "normal" foods the same as us, except the eldest who has feeding issues but genetic anomalies know no class boundaries. I go to the theatre to see ballet and opera, eldest comes along to anything i'll let him and has sat through The Magic Flute to declare he loved the music. We're all well read. I have a degree. I feel perfectly comfortable talking to people in positions of authority. None of that makes me any less working class.

Wantobeareader · 20/02/2024 12:18

Wow I am amazed by the number of comments this thread has received. Some of the definitions in here make me laugh. Asking people to take off their shoes is WC/MC for some, type of crisps bpugh etc.
I find this whole class system really depressing tbh and sorry people still feel so strongly about all this.
Someone above said being French also makes me MC, we do have blue collar workers in France too, we are not all wealthy in professional
jobs so not sure that the pp meant with that?!

OP posts:
pokebowls · 20/02/2024 12:06

@parkinghere

I think it is odd to be in that between place where you don't quite fit in anywhere fully, not even with the "nouveau riche". On paper class is about income and education but in reality if you aren't brought up middle class its apparent to others who were and they will look down on you for it, sorry to those who would deny this but I've experienced it far too many times even from friends and know for a fact it happens.

So do you think Carol Middleton was looked down upon at the school gates? Not by William's lot who teased Kate about her mum being an air hostess but the middle class people they grew up with at their prep school and Marlborough.

Ruminate2much · 20/02/2024 12:03

There are some fascinating cases, where it'd be really difficult to say, even in the days when the class system was much stronger and more clearly defined.
I heard a story on the radio once, about an early 20th century girl from an aristocratic upper class background. As a teenager she fell in love with a working class boy and ran off with him. Her family disinherited her, and I don't think she saw them again. But she was fully accepted into the northern working class community of her husband's humble birth. She ended up working in the local biscuit factory and brought up their children in the area, and lived out her days there. The question is - had she become working class? She definitely wasn't middle class. Upper class birth, but working class life from about 16 years of age. Obviously it was an especially unusual situation.

rosesareorange · 20/02/2024 11:54

there's economic middle class (nice clothes, car, house with a mortgage or paid off, holidays abroad) and educated middle class (has a degree, values education, wants to encourage kids in education and going to University, has cultural interests and pursuits, likes reading, understands politics, has a wide range of views on many different things)

JaninaDuszejko · 20/02/2024 11:48

Bloomingdaffs · 19/02/2024 22:08

Surely the MC eat Kettle chips and would never eat anything as common as Walkers.

My middle class children complain when I buy Kettle chips, Tyrrells are much better apparently.

Cordohroys · 20/02/2024 11:47

Lampslights · 20/02/2024 11:32

Generally a salary is a fixed annual amount, a wage is an hourly rate, or possibly a day, there are exceptions like the self employed or consultants.

but if you think in broad terms someone who works in retail or hospitality is likely to be paid by the hour, where as someone like a teacher is paid a salary.

there are exceptions clearly, too many variances to have one rule fits all. You need to contextualise it with is it skilled work that required further education or is it unskilled or semi skilled that did not.

I think we are back to money. You can pay freelancers anything from minimum wage upwards.

Lampslights · 20/02/2024 11:32

Cordohroys · 20/02/2024 11:27

What's the difference between a wage and a salary? We pay some of our people £300-400 an hour on a zero-hours contract - is that a wage? Does that make them WC?

Generally a salary is a fixed annual amount, a wage is an hourly rate, or possibly a day, there are exceptions like the self employed or consultants.

but if you think in broad terms someone who works in retail or hospitality is likely to be paid by the hour, where as someone like a teacher is paid a salary.

there are exceptions clearly, too many variances to have one rule fits all. You need to contextualise it with is it skilled work that required further education or is it unskilled or semi skilled that did not.

Cordohroys · 20/02/2024 11:27

Lampslights · 20/02/2024 10:41

Yes, this is factually correct. But folks have a lot of emotion round it. Many of the statements on this thread are completely Illogical.

for example. If your parents are working class, you are working class. But illogically this doesn’t apply to your kids who can be middle class. Even though you are working class.

social mobility doesn’t exist, you cannot move class, you are what you were born into.

if you work you’re working class, even though all classes work.

then we have people who are clearly working class, declaring themselves middle class due to their parents. Or people who are firmly middle class declaring themselves working class, again due to their upbringing and deciding their actual adult lives bizzarely don’t count.

we also have people erroneously telling other people what they are, so a firmly middle class person being told they are working class.

class is a very simple set of criteria. It isn’t simply anout money at its core, some middle class folks earn less than working class and vice Versa. It’s about the type of work you do, your educational/skill and if you’re paid a wage or a salary.

What's the difference between a wage and a salary? We pay some of our people £300-400 an hour on a zero-hours contract - is that a wage? Does that make them WC?

ancienticecream · 20/02/2024 11:03

I always find it funny that people tend to think working class equates to having no money. You really must visit Essex 😆 You can be as rich as Bill Gates and still be working class. I was evidently bothered by David Beckham saying "be honest" to Victoria about her class status in regards to what car her dad drove.

But back to the main topic, a sure sign of being MC might include:

  • Having an RHS membership
  • Having a National Trust membership
  • Being a friend of Kew Gardens
😉
parkinghere · 20/02/2024 10:49

apwlgamgo · 20/02/2024 08:58

I’m in the (probably ever increasing) group of people not allowed to declare a class. Grew up working class in terms of financial and cultural capital, or lack of. Always did well at school, went to uni, good career, relatively high household income, a lot of the MC “traits” and activities now. But if I call myself WC I’d get told I was being one of those people ever claiming to be WC despite a MC lifestyle, but if I say I am MC other people would be quick to tell me class doesn’t change etc, I will always be WC. Both sides trying to belittle I find, so weird how sneery this discussion gets and can’t understand why people aren’t just allowed to classify themselves if they so wish. Ultimately, I’m just proud of where I am and live the life I want to live. I drink good wine, go to the theatre regularly, but bloody love a good package holiday too. So brand me as you will!

I think it is odd to be in that between place where you don't quite fit in anywhere fully, not even with the "nouveau riche". On paper class is about income and education but in reality if you aren't brought up middle class its apparent to others who were and they will look down on you for it, sorry to those who would deny this but I've experienced it far too many times even from friends and know for a fact it happens.

LolaSmiles · 20/02/2024 10:46

Lampslights
I think people who have benefited from social mobility end up feeling like they're straddling two worlds, which is how they might feel working class because of their roots, upbringing and outlook whilst living a life that's probably more typical of the middle class.

That's how they feel working class is part of their identity but they know their children are having a different upbringing and different experience so will probably feel more middle class.

Then again I like what a poster said that the more main divides are unemployed/precariat group, people who are employed or self employed to earn their living (most working and middle classes), and those who are wealthy/have independent income streams/lots of intergenerational wealth (upper middle classes and upper classes).

Lampslights · 20/02/2024 10:41

Ruminate2much · 20/02/2024 10:28

I'm afraid I don't think professional, uni-educated, highly paid home owners could be considered working class (in official sociological terms) anymore, even if they have working class roots. To be truly working class you need to be a blue collar worker, in my humble opinion. The professionals with working class roots have been upwardly mobile and become middle class, in every meaningful sociological sense. Class isn't a feeling, it's a a set of facts.

Yes, this is factually correct. But folks have a lot of emotion round it. Many of the statements on this thread are completely Illogical.

for example. If your parents are working class, you are working class. But illogically this doesn’t apply to your kids who can be middle class. Even though you are working class.

social mobility doesn’t exist, you cannot move class, you are what you were born into.

if you work you’re working class, even though all classes work.

then we have people who are clearly working class, declaring themselves middle class due to their parents. Or people who are firmly middle class declaring themselves working class, again due to their upbringing and deciding their actual adult lives bizzarely don’t count.

we also have people erroneously telling other people what they are, so a firmly middle class person being told they are working class.

class is a very simple set of criteria. It isn’t simply anout money at its core, some middle class folks earn less than working class and vice Versa. It’s about the type of work you do, your educational/skill and if you’re paid a wage or a salary.

Ruminate2much · 20/02/2024 10:33

I do think nowadays it's changed so much anyway. Many people can't be neatly boxed into one class anymore. I think most people go up and down a great deal, and are just not easily defined.
I'm not remotely interested in putting people into a class category. All I'm interested in is whether they're a nice person or not 🤷

KimberleyClark · 20/02/2024 10:29

I and my sibling/cousins were the first generation of our family to be born middle class. Our parents came from a poor rural background, got into grammar school, went to university and ended up in professions. I did not go to university however.

Ruminate2much · 20/02/2024 10:28

I'm afraid I don't think professional, uni-educated, highly paid home owners could be considered working class (in official sociological terms) anymore, even if they have working class roots. To be truly working class you need to be a blue collar worker, in my humble opinion. The professionals with working class roots have been upwardly mobile and become middle class, in every meaningful sociological sense. Class isn't a feeling, it's a a set of facts.

dcsp · 20/02/2024 10:23

In my opinion, "working-class" and "middle-class" are typically used as labels for your upbringing, not your current status.

I grew up in a council house, raised by a single mother who could only work limited hours and only in termtime (until I was older), so money was always tight. This means I label myself as working-class.

This is despite the fact that I have been to university, have a well-paid well-respected job, own a detached house with 2 cars outside, etc.... however all of these things mean that my son counts as middle class (or will when he grows up anyway).

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/02/2024 10:08

It’s all down to whether you call the thing you put the car in, a gararzh or a garridge.
Or so a relative of mine would have said - she who had a PhD in ‘U’ and
‘Non-U’. 😉

Swipe left for the next trending thread