Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what makes you middle class?

340 replies

Wantobeareader · 19/02/2024 16:21

I am not from the UK so not very familiar with these class definitions (which personally I cannot stand) but I am curious to understand what people mean with MC. I thought it was a term referred to the fairly wealthy but apparently lots of people and incomes seem to fall into that categories.
So, how would you define Middle Class? Feel free to type a description of a typical MC person you can think of :)

OP posts:
LimeViewer · 22/02/2024 07:42

It's not being French, it's being French but mobile and moving to the UK.

fritaskeeter · 22/02/2024 07:39

As we can see from this thread, the concepts of working class/ middle class are not exactly well defined.

I think it's come to a point where it is just about how people self-identify.

Having said that, I am often surprised that university educated people on high incomes, with professional jobs, who holiday abroad twice a year, own property, send their kids to fancy nurseries/ private schools, go to the theatre and expensive art exhibitions on the weekend, make their own kombucha, identify themselves as working class.

To me, that's about as far from working class as you can get without being royalty, and I would see those people as firmly middle class.

To me, working class is the area where I grew up, where people work largely in unskilled/ manual jobs like factories, on the railways, in a small local shop etc.

I think that you can absolutely move between working class/ middle class as you go through life and social mobility is a thing.

But I can see that's not how everyone sees it - so I think the system and classification is all a bit muddy really!

Ruminate2much · 22/02/2024 07:35

MamaToABeautifulBoy · 22/02/2024 07:29

If your parents are MC, you are.

Otherwise, you’re WC. Doesn’t matter if you went to uni, drive a Volvo XC60, own an Aga or only go on Scott Dunn bespoke holidays, you are firmly WC

You can’t change class just because you want to, just as you can’t change sex, etc.

I respectfully disagree utterly! That's what social mobility is. It's totally different from something like biological sex. Going to uni and entering a profession such as medicine or law absolutely makes you middle class, regardless of origins. It's not a static thing.

fritaskeeter · 22/02/2024 07:31

Wantobeareader · 20/02/2024 12:18

Wow I am amazed by the number of comments this thread has received. Some of the definitions in here make me laugh. Asking people to take off their shoes is WC/MC for some, type of crisps bpugh etc.
I find this whole class system really depressing tbh and sorry people still feel so strongly about all this.
Someone above said being French also makes me MC, we do have blue collar workers in France too, we are not all wealthy in professional
jobs so not sure that the pp meant with that?!

Lol at the idea that being French makes you MC!

I think that just shows how much of it is tied to culture and what we do in our free time, as France and particularly Paris are sometimes held up as examples of arty and cultural places. I wonder if it's to do with that and somebody exoticising the idea of being French.

Could also be the fact that (if you have moved to the UK) you have had the means to move to another country. Travel is an element of it too.

MamaToABeautifulBoy · 22/02/2024 07:29

If your parents are MC, you are.

Otherwise, you’re WC. Doesn’t matter if you went to uni, drive a Volvo XC60, own an Aga or only go on Scott Dunn bespoke holidays, you are firmly WC

You can’t change class just because you want to, just as you can’t change sex, etc.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 22/02/2024 07:22

Dogfisher · 22/02/2024 07:03

Not sure that's true - maybe in an urban setting? Where I am, black labs are more the thing.

That person was probably talking about retriever breeds in general. Labradors, goldens, flat coats etc.

pokebowls · 22/02/2024 07:21

@Lampslights

Yes they working class, their kids are the children of working class parents. Their own class won’t be decided until adults.

It's just not that simple anymore. It used to be simple because people didn't do what the ppl you describe did. But today people have the luxury of choosing whether to go into the same field as their parents or to do what they want. People today have more freedom to partner with who they want. Finances are not set. Some people with working class jobs earn millions and live in a mansion. Some people with MC jobs struggle and live in a modest semi somewhere not so nice.

The old class system of MC, WC doesn't hold anymore which is why there are attempts to create new categories.

Today MC people like Charlotte Tilbury and Lisa Eldridge chose to become makeup artists starting as lowly assistants and working in retail shops but built up empires and are very wealthy.

Chefs like Gordon Ramsey started out WC but built an empire.

Bernie Ecclestone... we all know who he is. Started out very WC. Billionaire. Still WC in manner but loaded.

Trades and jobs that were once WC have attracted MC people. WC people have gone on to university and work in the city.

It's not some straightforward thing anymore

Dogfisher · 22/02/2024 07:03

LoftyTurtle · 21/02/2024 21:47

MC always seem to have dogs that are either poodle mixes or retrievers!

Not sure that's true - maybe in an urban setting? Where I am, black labs are more the thing.

Missamyp · 22/02/2024 06:47

It's funny how people buy into certain elements of social climbing on the one hand and then discredit themselves by claiming to be working class the next.
As for research into classifying people is that a useful endeavour?
No.

Ruminate2much · 22/02/2024 06:31

LittleBearPad · 21/02/2024 19:48

1 the list of people who can so go passports is massively larger than you imply
2 It wasn’t worthiness that allowed professionals to sign documents and passports. It’s that we are traceable by the Law Society, ICAEW etc and held to professional standards. But as I say the list isn’t just professionals.

Thank you for this. It prompted me to look up the current list, as it's over 20 years since I got my first passport, and subsequent versions don't need to be counter-signed.
The list seems much longer and more exhaustive than I remember it. I'd still say it's a middle-class list! Some odd ones, such as professional photographer. You're right that the list is much longer than I thought. But, I do respectfully disagree that it's due to traceability, as some on the list are potentially freelancers. So, I do think classism is a possible explanation. I tried to research this and read that it's because the person signing must be considered an upstanding member of the community - I rest my case.

Ruminate2much · 22/02/2024 06:13

Justifiedcheese · 21/02/2024 22:20

You mean to pretend they're working class when they're not...

Yes, I think it's much more this way round. Both on Mumsnet, and in rl. I've known so many people boasting (which is weird, as it's neither a good or a bad thing) about being working class, when minimal scrutiny proves otherwise. I'd love to know why they do it?!

Justifiedcheese · 21/02/2024 22:20

carbon60 · 21/02/2024 22:16

It's a load of pretentious bullshit really.Only on mumsnet do you get people falling over themselves to prove their middle class credentials.
Meanwhile, in the real world, nobody gives a flying fuck.

You mean to pretend they're working class when they're not...

carbon60 · 21/02/2024 22:16

It's a load of pretentious bullshit really.Only on mumsnet do you get people falling over themselves to prove their middle class credentials.
Meanwhile, in the real world, nobody gives a flying fuck.

LoftyTurtle · 21/02/2024 21:47

MC always seem to have dogs that are either poodle mixes or retrievers!

LoftyTurtle · 21/02/2024 21:32

My experience in baby groups, bear in mind HUGE generalisations, is that:

Middle class women:

  • Breastfeed (or are stubbornly determined to breastfeed at all costs even at the expense of their own mental health & sanity). Judgy if you don't breastfeed
  • Buy their baby clothes either new from Scandi-esque brands like Frugi, Picalilly, Maxomorra, OR everything is secondhand/thrifted
  • Their babies are called names like Theo, Harrison, Olivia and Ottilie. They are sometimes strangely offended if someone else calls their baby the same name, because obviously their baby name choice was just SO ORIGINAL it's absolutely ludicrous anyone else would have the same brilliant idea as them. "There were TWO OTHER babies named Ottilie the night I had my DD! Can you imagine?!" (Actual conversation I've had!)
  • Spend the equivalent to a second mortagage on Waterbabies

Working class women:

  • Bottle feed, and never really considered breastfeeding as an option OR breastfeed/mixed feed but without punishing themselves if it didn't work/they moved on from it. Don't really give a toss how you feed your baby so long as you and baby are happy!
  • Buy their baby clothes new, from brands like Zara, River Island, H&M
  • Their babies are called names like Jenson, Evie-May, Something-Rose or use "nicknames" instead of full names especially for boys (Alfie, Albie etc)
  • Seem to REALLY REALLY like Blade and Rose leggings

Fwiw I'm also a foreigner so don't particularly identify with any class! Although I do like Blade and Rose leggings so maybe I'm WC 🫠

Meowandthen · 21/02/2024 21:05

getitgotitgood · 21/02/2024 10:15

Empirical evidence represents a real-life experience and not just theories. Data collected through empirical research may be less biased because the researcher is there during the collection process.

AKA - your opinion.

ChequeredPastel · 21/02/2024 20:20

CurlewKate · 21/02/2024 20:00

@ChequeredPastel "So ask yourself if class is important to you. If it is, you have your answer"

I disagree. In my experience people are usually incredibly keen to claim working class credentials on the slightest of evidence. Just read this thread!

I think this is further evidence to my theory 😂 it’s mostly middle class people claiming to be working.

actual working class people tend to know they’re working class. They just ARE. They don’t spend ages banging on about it

LittleBearPad · 21/02/2024 20:06

*sign not so go

CurlewKate · 21/02/2024 20:00

@ChequeredPastel "So ask yourself if class is important to you. If it is, you have your answer"

I disagree. In my experience people are usually incredibly keen to claim working class credentials on the slightest of evidence. Just read this thread!

ChequeredPastel · 21/02/2024 19:52

I think generally if you care about what class you are, and frequently refer to your class - then you’re middle class.

So ask yourself if class is important to you. If it is, you have your answer

LittleBearPad · 21/02/2024 19:48

Ruminate2much · 21/02/2024 08:04

Yeah, I think you're right. Countries like Australia that claim to be classless, but actually...
The funny thing about Britain is that people generally want to be seen as working class. The whole working class hero narrative plays into this. But, it's daft, as there's absolutely nothing wrong with being middle class. Nor with being working class. They're just descriptors.
In sociological terms it used to be more useful, for addressing inequalities. But, nowadays many working class people are better off than many middle class people. So, it's less meaningful in that sense.
The only thing is of course that middle class professionals have huge cultural capital. Eg - only certain professionals considered worthy to sign passports 😲
I guess that's why I get slightly upset with middle class professionals not acknowledging their status, as it's not fair on genuinely working class people, who don't have that same unfair advantage. Everyone needs to check their privilege.

1 the list of people who can so go passports is massively larger than you imply
2 It wasn’t worthiness that allowed professionals to sign documents and passports. It’s that we are traceable by the Law Society, ICAEW etc and held to professional standards. But as I say the list isn’t just professionals.

LimeViewer · 21/02/2024 19:33

You have 🤣
Empirical has never meant your own personal subjective ideas and observations. It still doesn't.

getitgotitgood · 21/02/2024 18:12

LimeViewer · 21/02/2024 18:01

Pretty sure you've muddled epistemological with empirical here.
Empirical is directly observable like physics, isolation and control of variables. So behaviourism (conditioning in Psychology) is empirical but cognitive (memory modelling NOT biological) is not empirical. Because you can't directly measure memory only operationalise concepts of models. These can then be potentially confirmed by neuroscience which is empirical as you directly observe the brain.
Most social science aims to be as empirical amd objective as possible unless its from an interpretivist perspective. So eg Smart's personal life theory uses epistemology amd ground up, meanings based research which is what you are describing incorrectly as empiricism.

No, I haven't.

LimeViewer · 21/02/2024 18:01

getitgotitgood · 21/02/2024 11:21

You've never done research have you? Empirical research is used a lot in social science and in other sciences
But please do continue with your laughing emojis

Pretty sure you've muddled epistemological with empirical here.
Empirical is directly observable like physics, isolation and control of variables. So behaviourism (conditioning in Psychology) is empirical but cognitive (memory modelling NOT biological) is not empirical. Because you can't directly measure memory only operationalise concepts of models. These can then be potentially confirmed by neuroscience which is empirical as you directly observe the brain.
Most social science aims to be as empirical amd objective as possible unless its from an interpretivist perspective. So eg Smart's personal life theory uses epistemology amd ground up, meanings based research which is what you are describing incorrectly as empiricism.

Lampslights · 21/02/2024 17:10

GetWhatYouWant · 21/02/2024 17:01

That's interesting. All my family are middle class by profession, education, income, cultural capital, all the markers, and have been for several generations.
However in the extended family there are 2 siblings in a family, one is highly educated, professional qualifications, married a similar type of person, friends are all similar, owns own home, lives a middle class life. The other, who went to the same school, did A levels, decided not to go to university but went to college to train in hair and beauty, which I think is a working class occupation. They work in this area and have a partner who has pretty much had no education, is what you might call a "rough" person, they rent a small house, they have one friend who went to university but all the others seem to have not even gone to sixth form. Have they become working class even though their family background is middle class? What about their child who has lots of contact with extended middle class family, doing plenty of what people on here say are middle class activities, and no contact with other parent's family?

Yes they working class, their kids are the children of working class parents. Their own class won’t be decided until adults.