Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what makes you middle class?

340 replies

Wantobeareader · 19/02/2024 16:21

I am not from the UK so not very familiar with these class definitions (which personally I cannot stand) but I am curious to understand what people mean with MC. I thought it was a term referred to the fairly wealthy but apparently lots of people and incomes seem to fall into that categories.
So, how would you define Middle Class? Feel free to type a description of a typical MC person you can think of :)

OP posts:
Mementomorissons · 19/02/2024 18:10

Lots of technically WC people do very MC things like watch things like Paddington and Strictly Come Dancing, eat smoked salmon and call their kids 'darling'...

SO, I think probably the only fair factor is what parents you grew up with. If you had parents who had manual or service industry jobs growing up then you're WC.

If you had parents who were qualified in something other than manual trade, you're MC.

In my experience even people who say they had a uni-educated parent but they were long term unemployed or abusive or whatever, they usually still have MC ways

BeaRF75 · 19/02/2024 18:09

Folks, you need the works of Dame Jilly Cooper to truly educate you. Yes, some of the ideas are a bit dated but she correctly identifies that middle class includes lower middle, middle middle and upper middle.
Lower middle is cautious, small C conservative and aspirational - very much "shoes off at the door". Upper middle are much more confident and wouldn't give two hoots about shoes.
It's complicated.....

FinallyFeb · 19/02/2024 18:08

I’m from a WC background and my DH is from a MC one, when I first met his large family one Christmas these were the things I noticed.

They liked going out on a lot of walks.

They wore the same clothes often where as I wasn’t used to this and the clothes were in dull colours such as navy or dark grey.

They had good jobs but often said that were poor and didn’t seem to have much fun money.

They were all slim

They had wine at lunch time.

Its funny the things I noticed.

Justifiedcheese · 19/02/2024 18:08

Screamingabdabz · 19/02/2024 16:37

I am all of these but I’m still working class!

In your dreams.

Seriously what is it with clearly now mc people desperate to think of themselves as still working class? It doesn't make you better or more authentic or whatever you think it does. It just makes you dishonest.

WhereIsMyLight · 19/02/2024 18:07

Like didimum said, those are the main indicators. Your parents would have had professional roles and likely your grandparents too. It’s become complicated though now for a number of reasons. A lot of working class people have been given the opportunity to go to university. There are well-paid jobs offering some of the lifestyle of MC are not solely professional jobs anymore - you don’t need to be a doctor, solicitor, teacher, accountant to earn a good salary you can be a senior in communications and marketing or operations. House prices have prices many MC people out of the market.

On paper, DH and I are MC. We are both university educated with a masters and professional qualifications between us. We have jobs paying above the average salary, DH in a professional role and me in one of those not-professional but still pays reasonably roles. We are homeowners (mortgaged) but it’s a large 4 bed detached house, on a nice estate. We enjoy cultural interests of MC (along with some typically WC interests). However, we both grew up WC. My mum was a single parent working in administrative roles, she is degree educated but she did it part time when I was young. My mum’s family have worked in retail, trades, admin. We couldn’t always afford holidays. We couldn’t always afford food. DH was similar, he grew up sharing a room with his brother in a 2 bed council flat. We both went to university and that has given us the opportunity to gain access to a more a MC lifestyle and look MC on paper but we don’t really feel it. A MC person would have had a different upbringing to us and that’s ingrained into you so you’re never fully MC. But we don’t fit in with WC people we grew up with. There are a lot of people in this group which is why you have people saying they are still WC.

The BBC has a tool somewhere that actually has about 9 groups and brings in some of that nuance.

5128gap · 19/02/2024 18:06

Notamum12345577 · 19/02/2024 18:01

I know this is about feeling middle class, but just to point out you cannot be middle class unless your parents were. If they were working class, you may yourself now have all the things that make you middle class, but you will still be working class. Your children though, they will be middle class.

You must see that if your first and second sentences are true, your third cannot be?

Didimum · 19/02/2024 18:06

Notamum12345577 · 19/02/2024 18:01

I know this is about feeling middle class, but just to point out you cannot be middle class unless your parents were. If they were working class, you may yourself now have all the things that make you middle class, but you will still be working class. Your children though, they will be middle class.

This gets very tricky with huge grey areas though.

Didimum · 19/02/2024 18:05

ChevyCamaro · 19/02/2024 18:02

I don’t think it’s that basic Didimum
I think plenty of people are wankers but there aren’t many activities I would describe as wanky. Most things are neutral. It’s maybe the intention behind some of the choices mc people make that can come across as a bit overly concerned with doing the correct thing, as in the things that fit with the ideal of mc taste.

Exactly. My point is that I’m describing a stereotype, just as people here are describing a MC stereotype. You can’t apply something that basic to MC people either.

ChevyCamaro · 19/02/2024 18:02

I don’t think it’s that basic Didimum
I think plenty of people are wankers but there aren’t many activities I would describe as wanky. Most things are neutral. It’s maybe the intention behind some of the choices mc people make that can come across as a bit overly concerned with doing the correct thing, as in the things that fit with the ideal of mc taste.

Notamum12345577 · 19/02/2024 18:01

I know this is about feeling middle class, but just to point out you cannot be middle class unless your parents were. If they were working class, you may yourself now have all the things that make you middle class, but you will still be working class. Your children though, they will be middle class.

Didimum · 19/02/2024 18:00

Megifer · 19/02/2024 17:43

OK great.

Not necessary to get annoyed. A discussion is characterised by people interjecting differing opinions.

2024name · 19/02/2024 17:58

Questions about which social class one may be are usually asked by the middle class or those aspiring to be middle class. The upper class (aristocracy) know what they are, and the 'underclass' (a newer term which describes an age old concept) know what they are.

In British history, there has traditionally been a division between the aristocracy and the rest (those whose service or lands are owned by the aristocracy). Then, somewhere between William the 1st and Queen Victoria, the merchant classes and middle classes (a troublesome lot) began to challenge the order a little. A farmer called Olly really rocked the boat in the 17th century, indeed the Civil War was a class war, and although we got a republic, we found Olly a bit too big for his boots an no-one really liked him, so we get a real king back on the throne. You see, there is something about having a monarch and an aristocracy that keeps everyone else in their place

With Victoria, the working classes (very useful in the Industrial Revolution and as cannon fodder for the Empire) began to gain some nominal power, and some autonomy (what with Chartism and all that). They even began owning houses and attending classes on how to be clever.

The 20th and 21st centuries have brought greater spending power to all classes (except the underclass) and legislation makes it illegal for us not to be equal, but 'class' is, funnily enough, not a protected characteristic (and neither is accent which some people assume is an indicator of 'class').

So, back to the question of 'What the hell is middle class'? I would suggest that today, it is not about what your daddy does (an old measure of class) nor the pedigree if public school educated ancestors. It is all abut money and how rich you are, just as it was when the merchant classes rose.

ginasevern · 19/02/2024 17:58

Things have changed and it's hard to apply the old standards. However, historically if you were middle class you would use the English language correctly, eg not say "we was sat on the bus" although a mild regional accent would be acceptable.

You would know what cutlery to use when dining out and would not be fazed by making polite conversation with a variety of people. Your manners would (generally) be impecable. You would have a higher standard of education and general knowledge than the working classes. You would not read tabloid newspapers or watch programmes like Love Island.

You would be highly unlikely to go on holiday to an all inclusive in Benidorm and you would be more likely to take your children to castles and museums than the nearest water park.

Didimum · 19/02/2024 17:57

bringmorewashing · 19/02/2024 17:48

Perhaps, but it's a pretty common personality type I've encountered exclusively among MC people!

And one could easily put the same judgement on WC people – that they find certain pursuits ‘wanky’ or ‘poncy’, or that they more heavily subscribe to gender-based roles and expectations. Is any of that really true? Is it any better?

BuddhaAtSea · 19/02/2024 17:56

@Wantobeareader you’re ‘forrin’, that’s all 😂 as am I.
Where I come from we don’t have a class system, unless you’re old aristocracy or something, but even then, your kids will still go to the same school as mine.

Took me a long time to get my head around this class system malarkey, but realised it’s totally futile: people are people, the difference is in how much or little of an arsehole you are, basically. I was told it’s very middle class of me to dress DD in Boden and have 2-3 foreign holidays, to go to the theatre and opera, to read and to speak several languages, to be a professional and live in a ‘posh’ area.

I really don’t bother with any of that.
Why do you ask?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 19/02/2024 17:55

I find it difficult to define, but I do know that DH and I are absolutely middle class, me less so than him but still solidly there.

Both privately educated, DH at boarding school, me at an all girls day school. Both his parents were also privately educated and went to uni. My dad went to a secondary modern and left school at 16 but went into an office job. My mum was from a much poorer background but went to grammar school.and then to teacher training college.

DH and I aren't particularly well paid. I'm a social worker and he works for a charity. We have a mortgage. Our dc went to the local comprehensive. But we've given them considerable cultural capital. We've dragged then round museums, nd round NT properties, we've always sat round the table for meals - no screens allowed. Never been on a package holiday but have had holidays walking in the Alps etc.

DS2 has been to uni and is now working in a professional job. So he will also be MC.

DS1 is interesting in that he's had the MC upbringing but chose not to go to uni and went to work instead. He then decided to do an apprenticeship as a mechanic, so very much a traditional WC profession.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 19/02/2024 17:51

@Wantobeareader , it's very nuanced, and as much about previous generations as your current situation. Education, land/house ownership, cultural capital, aspiration.

"Watching the English" by Kate Fox is a good book that investigates, and tries to define, the English class system. Jeremy Paxman's "The English" too, because this obsessing with social class does seem to be particularly English.

Zephyry · 19/02/2024 17:50

It is more about what class your parents were in. I think wc parents might produce dc who have a mc lifestyle, but then if replicating this for their dc, they would then be mc.
There is definitely more social mobility now, which explains the self identified wc, but with the newly acquired trappings of mc. In the past, wc could never really have crossed the divide that easily so I think it was easier to see the group divisions and their characteristics. I'd recommend watching an episode of The Royle Family op, the one where it's Christmas and the son brings his girlfriend and her parents over. The family thinks they are super posh, but they are definitely still wc, however new money. It's funny because the dad looks down on the Royle family, but they are the same really.

midgetastic · 19/02/2024 17:49

Or perhaps you assume that if someone has that personality they are middle class ?

CatamaranViper · 19/02/2024 17:48

Megifer · 19/02/2024 16:56

Middle class or aspiring MC if you instruct visitors to remove their shoes in your home. Lower/working/upper class just want visitors to be comfortable.

For me, if you need to work for "the man" and earn a wage you'll always be WC ).

Hmm I disagree re shoes. I find people on lower wages who often can't afford to buy new carpets as often work harder at keeping them nice. Same with most things. If you can't afford to replace it you take better care of it.

Fionaville · 19/02/2024 17:48

I avoid the whole discussion. I actually chuckle to myself when people refer to themselves as middle class. I'm often told that I'm middle class by other people, but I'm not having it.
Our house, income, cars, lifestyle, cultural memberships and pursuits would put us firmly in middle class. My kids might be middle class and my DH of 25 years probably is. I'm not though.

bringmorewashing · 19/02/2024 17:48

Didimum · 19/02/2024 17:41

You’re describing a personality type. Not a class.

Perhaps, but it's a pretty common personality type I've encountered exclusively among MC people!

Ontopofthesunset · 19/02/2024 17:46

I think working class and middle class are outmoded classifications, as comparatively few people nowadays do the kind of manual, labouring or low skills work that would have been the traditional 'working class'. There is the Approximated Social Grade used by the census, or you could look at the 7 social classifications used in this article: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/britain-now-has-7-social-classes-and-working-class-is-a-dwindling-breed-8557894.html

Class is also not static. You can be born to parents who belong to one group and you yourself can move into another group. Those posters with top degrees and detached houses and interests in theatre and NT properties are no longer members of the 'working class', though they may have been born into a working class family.

My husband's an example - very traditional working class background (father a labourer, mother a part-time shop assistant, no education beyond 14), but he went to a well-known university, got a professional job, married a woman with a different economic but similar educational background and now would fit into the 'elite' category in terms of earnings and interests. But he's still got roots in a very different 'class'.

Britain now has 7 social classes - and working class is a dwindling

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/britain-now-has-7-social-classes-and-working-class-is-a-dwindling-breed-8557894.html

ExpressCheckout · 19/02/2024 17:45

Shower before work = middle class
Shower after work = working class
Shower before and after work = confused class
No shower = filthy rich

Notcontent · 19/02/2024 17:44

Megifer · 19/02/2024 16:56

Middle class or aspiring MC if you instruct visitors to remove their shoes in your home. Lower/working/upper class just want visitors to be comfortable.

For me, if you need to work for "the man" and earn a wage you'll always be WC ).

Or maybe you just live in an area where the pavements are literally smeared with dog poo?

Swipe left for the next trending thread